MSNBC's Brewer: Pres. Bush Should Be Ashamed of EPA Ruling

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Contessa Brewer has suggested that Pres. Bush should be ashamed of his administration's decision to exempt the chemical perchlorate from federal regulation.   Speaking with a Republican guest this afternoon, the MNSBC host analogized the decision to Bill Clinton's scandalous last-minute pardons.

Did Brewer ever read the official EPA explanation of its ruling, or had she only looked at articles like this one, "subtly" featuring a huge photo of a baby drinking from its bottle?

View video here.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓


Brewer confronted John Feehery, former head of communications for House Speaker Denny Hastert, with her characterization.

CONTESSA BREWER: John, do you think there should be some shame in a president doing something like this? It reminds me of the big scandal that erupted when Clinton was leaving office with all the pardons.  You know, why are you going to do something in your very last few weeks that just makes you look bad?
Feehery didn't have the specifics on perchlorate, but indicated that the administration employed a careful, lengthy regulatory process, and probably had a good reason for its decision.  Feehery's instincts were apparently right.  From the EPA release [emphasis added]:
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency conducted extensive review of scientific data related to the health effects of exposure to perchlorate from drinking water and other sources and found that in more than 99 percent of public drinking water systems, perchlorate was not at levels of public health concern. Therefore, based on the Safe Water Drinking Act criteria, the agency determined there is not a "meaningful opportunity for health risk reduction" through a national drinking water regulation.
Brewer gave no indication she was familiar with that EPA finding, ending the segment instead by taking a parting shot at the Bush legacy.
BREWER: Will this do anything futher to erode his legacy?

FEEHERY: You know, I don't think so. It depends on what you look at as his legacy.  I think a lot of conservatives will think George Bush did a good job.  A lot of liberals that he did a bad job. And there will be a debate among historians about what his legacy is going to be.

BREWER: "A lot"? A lot might be an overstatement given the current poll numbers.

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

This is a knucklehead

This is a knucklehead alert!!!

These are the very same knuckleheads that pitched a hissy fit when President Bush proposed a change in the arsenic PPM (parts per million) allowed in drinking water, when it was actually a reduction in the PPM that Clinton had allowed to be raised just before he left office!

Nothing to see here folks.....move along. 

MSNBC morally bankrupt....

When will they join the other Lame Stream Media outlets in bankruptcy court?  MSNBC hasn't been on 10 minutes in my home in the past two years.  It's coming, just a matter of when. I doubt there is any fool in congress who would consider bailing out these fools.

Old, Retired and glad of it.

Shouldn't

People be ashamed having voted for a communist?

→ No snooker

I didn't know he was a communist until he bailed out AIG.

I guess when he looked into Putin's soul, that coulda' been something of a tipoff. ;<)

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

What an utter joke

Ph.D. analytical chemist here.  I actually went to a symposium put on by Dionex, the leader in analytical instrumentation needed to analyze for perchlorate.  Among my thoughts in no particular order:

1.  The EPA went from having absolutely no regulation of perchlorate to having a ridiculously tight specification needing a fairly high level of sophistication beyond the normal capabilities of ion chromatography (can't recall the specs. but it is certain an involved method of analysis).

2.  The evidence for regulating perchlorates at all, let alone such a tight level, is pretty flimsy.  I'm inclined to think that someone lobbying the EPA with a direct financial benefit is behind all this.

3.  Kudos to Bush for telling them to F-off.

 

HF

 

A just consequence

Perchlorate sounds like chlorine gas, or chlordane (a poison), or sodium chloride (cause of more heart attacks than anything else in the whole wide world or even UNIVERSE!) That is all we need to know. For her own good, idiots like Brewer should be forced to drink tap water not treated with these perchlorate things.

Contessa the

Contessa the Clueless...

Drink plenty of water from the tap gal, along with your buddies at msnbc....after-all Bush is trying to poison us all again...after-all proof is in the pudding so to speak...besides that, those plastic bottles you get your non-poisonous water from are bad, very bad for the environment ...or haven't you all heard that yet, you brainiac you. 

Golly gee, silly Pres. Bush has been keeping us save from terrorists here so far since 9-11, which means nothing to twits like Brewer, who stuttered before even using the word  perchlorate...yet we had ex-Prez Clinton who pardoned terrorists, including Rich at the last minute...all for a personal agenda for Hill and he.

...and we all know what he didn't do the years beforehand. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

This hissy fit

brought to you by the same twits who probably drink bottled water that is less regulated than tap water, or....pay $8 a gallon for Dasani that is just tap water put into a bottle with a neat label on it.

Hey, I got the wrong "CHANGE"!

Alan Keyes / Sarah Palin - 2012

Pot and Kettle

If Finkelstein is going to suggest that Brewer may have relied "on articles like this one from an environmental activist group," he should look closely enough at the  article he links to recognize that it is from a science blog at "Wired" magazine, not an "environmental activist group."

Fair enough, and I've

Fair enough, and I've changed the description accordingly.   The photo of the baby was so big it kind of crowded out the text ;-)

Local Standards work, why interfere?

I wonder if this woman is aware that every community has it's own standards for the public drinking water it produces? 

Here's what she is omitting in her "report;" Even if the EPA doesn't see the need to add additional regulations to an all ready over regulated country, each community is STILL free to increase the standards as they see fit. Since each community has it's own, separate, sources (for the most part), and since each community has it's own supply systems, it makes perfect sense that each community should be free to set their own standards for the water they supply.

Instead of this woman asking if Bush should be ashamed, we should ask HER if she's ashamed at her complete lack of objectivity, and her lack of knowledge on local drinking water standards and what that actually means.

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

Poll numbers - the new historical measuring tool.

  Hitler was pretty well loved early on in Germany. Yummy! is the common historical opinion.

  Saddam won something like 99% of the vote. Super Duper Awesome says the historians!

  Stalin has gobs and gobs of statues of him all over the former Soviet sphere. Rad! says other historians.

  Accomplishments as a historical measure. Boring!  No longer needed.

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

Dog bites man

For a large segment of the media, President Bush should be ashamed if it rains during a baseball game. Or if the sun comes up. Or if he's breathing. Nothing new here.

Oh, except maybe that Clinton's "last-minute pardons" are now, finally, a "scandal."

'Bout frickin' time.

 

"Meet the new boss, same as the old boss..." - The Who

Contessa Boo/hoo Brewer

How can anyone take this newsreader seriously?  About 2 years ago she was a regular on the Imus show.  (don'tlisten anymore, as he is just a plain mean left wing pandering and depressing radio show host. Besides being an absolute

A_ _ _ _ _E. And this has nothing to do with his Rutgers comments, although they were pretty bad too.) Don't take him off the air just turn him off.

Anyway poor ole Contessa thought she was one of the boys and when they turned on her she ran out crying, just like any big league journalist, and they never saw her again on the Imus radio show.  Some credibility for a woman (journalist).

"Don't let the bastards grind you down."

Red