Smith Sad Mumbai Terrorists Missed Americans, Hit Indians?

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Is Harry Smith sad that the Mumbai terrorists missed their intended American and British targets and hit Indians?  Strange as it sounds, it's hard to interpret his remark of this morning otherwise.

Smith was discussing the attacks on the Early Show with CBS terrorism expert Jere Van Dyk when he made his bizarre observation.

HARRY SMITH: When they, as they were perpetrating their attacks in the beginning, they were clearly, they said, were looking for British citizens, were looking for American citizens. Sadly, so many of the people were killed were Indians.
Would Harry have been less sad if more Americans and fewer Indians had been killed?

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"Would Harry have been less

"Would Harry have been less sad if more Americans and fewer Indians had been killed?"

Yes. 

Sometimes you just have to

Sometimes you just have to wonder if they really hear themselves...

To Harry, the lives taken is not a problem, it's that the wrong lives were taken.

This is the classic case of

This is the classic case of the Fraudian Slip.
It speaks volumes in a sentance regarding his world view.

Take that One Back

Harry is as biased as any reporter on television. He is a Democratic flunkie.   His bias is so overwhelming, he is tough to watch.   But I'd like to think Harry "misspoke" and meant only to convery sadness that so many Inidians had been killed. 

That would only be possible..

.. after a thorough examination of previous statements made of similiar situations. This statement by itself, you may be correct. But, given the nature of liberals, and their record, the tendency is to assume the worse.

Bolton/KEYES 2012 

Perhaps. Perhaps not.

You are generous, allanf. More than I am.

Harry is a poor excuse for a human being

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

Harry proves liberalism is a mental disorder

What a MORON!

He needs his @ss kicked! What an idiot!

Alan KEYES 2012 

Can we send them

Can we send them Harry? 

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

Harry is stuck in. . .

this false mentality of "preference for the poor" which permeates not only governments but also churches.  America (and apparently Great Britain) is bad because we are affluent.  Therefore, we deserve to die.  I wonder what nationality Harry Smith thinks he is.  Citizen of the world who obviously isn't rich in his $2000 suit?

Christ came to call ALL men, rich and poor.  Salvation is universally available.  Likewise, our government should serve ALL Americans.  The Nanny state looks to level the playing field, spread the wealth, punish the rich, etc.  We've crossed the threshold from being fooled by these socialists (Carter, Clinton) to embracing them as a political good.  Harry just inadvertently let it slip.

We are so screwed. 

Message to B.A.

I've deleted your comment.  Please tone it down on these threads.

I 2nd the motion!

So very, very sick.

Message to B.A.

Execute plan Delta-One-Zero.

EOM

Alan KEYES 2012 

Kick Me

Yeah B.A.!!! Tone it down. We're conservatives and we lead by example. Now adjust your "Kick Me" sign and get back out there.

FM: do you really think

FM: do you really think that's what I meant?

Lighten' Up Mark!!!

Take it in the lighthearted manner in which it was intended Mark.

Tell me that as a conservative, you don't often feel that way?

If there's one thing less

If there's one thing unlikely to make me lighten up, it's someone instructing me to lighten up.  I have no problem with strong opinions being expressed here.  But I ask that people do so within reasonable bounds of civility.

Thanks Mark

I didn't get to read the deleted remark but if you had to delete it I don't want to.

You hit on one of my Pet peeves. I'm tired of hearing people saying all manner of profanity and lewd remarks in public in the company of women and children.

civility in an uncivil society

what measures civility in our current society of radical left wing screamers who throw profanities and feces at any and all who even marginally disagree with their agenda .. should we always turn the other cheek, shield our children's ears, allow their rants to be the only voices heard ?? are we not morally bound to refute their filth .. and in doing so might we not be forced to adopt some of their tactics in self defense .. do you allow a bomber to infiltrate your home or do you stop him by whatever means necessary ..

never look a gift skunk in the tail

Good News for Harry

Two Americans reported having been killed.

One was 13 years old.

Good job Harry.

Alan KEYES 2012 

AMERICAN IDIOT...

Harry Smith seems to me to be an old 60's counterculture type who has rooted against America ever since. He does'nt know any better. Don't get me wrong, he needs to be exposed for what he is, but he has'nt a clue as to how out of the mainstream he is. The fact that his ratings are in the toilet speak to that. The very fact that the deaths of Americans abroad justifies his viewpoint is offensive on it's face. The idea that this makes him happy makes him hateable.

You suck, Harry, you need to take some time off & drive around the country, you know, places BETWEEN MANHATTEN & HOLLYWOOD. You know, the real America, you might be shocked by how many people would never agree with you on almost anything. They would'nt even hate you for holding different opinions like your little brownshirted leftist freinds would.

 

 

"...it's still We The People, Right?"  Megadeth 

"..Sadly, so many of the

"..Sadly, so many of the people were killed were Indians."

Thanks so much Harry, for adding your thoughtful words to the warmth and charm of this X-mas/Kwanza season. And I hope the tof-urkey and kool-aid tasted wonderful as you and yours gathered 'round the festive 'Indigenous Peoples' Grievances Day' table.

Happy Kwanzaa!

May the blessings of Mother Earth be upon you.

Alan KEYES 2012 

I thought the old "Columbus

I thought the old "Columbus Day" holiday was the one that was changed to "Indigenous Peoples Day."

Well we can't have too many victim holidays!

You're probably right about

You're probably right about that one. I admit, I'm not up to speed with every insult the left wages on the culture.  I figure that the image of American Indians sitting down, breaking bread with European white men is an image that the left despises and holds in contempt equal to Columbus day.  For a politically correct leftist, these holidays are interchangeable.

Too bad that no white, wealthy, American capitalists were killed

Why is anyone surprised that liberals loathe America, and support any cause that seeks to weaken, dilute or destroy traditional American culture.

Smith would certainly be saddened if a group of American homosexual activists were killed. He would have been saddened if a group of American pacifist protesters were killed. He would be saddened if a group of American atheists were killed. He would have been saddened if a group of American radical feminists were killed. He certainly would have been saddened if a group of illegal aliens living in America were killed. 

However, he is saddened that no white, wealthy, American capitalists were killed. What a shame.  

 Smith's slip is a window into the thinking and soul of today's liberals.

Universities Are Churning Out Intellectual But Misinformed Graduates

Harry Smith..

.. will now call for calm by the Israelis, since it's being reported that five Jews were killed.

Bolton/KEYES 2012 

He would be outraged and

He would be outraged and demand that something be done if a reporter had been killed.

Unless of course, it was a FOX reporter. 

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

disclosure

we use to get glasses from shamrock back when gas was 25 cents a gallon .. plastic cups came in our purina chicken feed bags - still have them, too ..

never look a gift skunk in the tail

Yea. I remember

Yea. I remember taking collections from everyone in the car. Coming up with a buck. And buying enough gas to cruise around for the entire evening.

But then 1st class postage was 3 then 4 cents. (I just realized. Computer keyboards don't have the old cent sign. That tells us something. Was it where "^" is?) 

Don't forget the glasses and dishes in boxes of oatmeal, dishes came in boxes of detergent, and jelly and peanut butter were packed in glasses.

Limited Disclosure:  I used to belong to the Sierra Club untill they went crazier. Worse of all, I was bribed by Exxon with free New Orleans Saints glasses with fill ups in the 70's.

I heard they killed 2 Jewish

I heard they killed 2 Jewish Americans, a Father and Son. This should have pacified ol' Harry; they were not only Americans, but they were Jewish too.

It's mind-boggling how stupid the left wingers are. Dumb as a bag of hammers.

Sadly...

Sadly he doesn't listen to himself as he speaks. I understand his point was innocent bystanders were killed. BUT those targeted were innocent as well. It was a bloody attack on unarmed civilians. Everyone killed was an innocent bystanders in a global war on terror. 

I wonder if it's connected to the Indian war with the pirates? Reports are still fuzzy and there needs to be a motive. No crime is committed without a motive.

 

 

Never under estimate the power of stupid people in large groups.

No, this is much more likely

No, this is much more likely going to be linkied to Khashmiri Militants or Pakistanis from the various Madrassah who seek martyrdom through Islamic Fascism.

Someone find Dr Devil Dog for me. Perhaps he can show me how we as Americans are equally at fault for such attacks. After all "We have met the enemy and he is us" under DDD's world view.

Again and again and again

Again and again and again and again, and you still do not grasp their motives, jackie3?

Is it because you assume that their motives have a foundation in rational thought? That is a mistaken assumption.

Their motives are to kill for the glory of Islam.

SADLY

What is most SAD is the fact that this supreme J.O. is still on network television.  What does this fool bring to the table other than a total leftist bias and stupid questions and comments not fit for a cub journalist.  The Abbot and Costello baseball skit makes more sense than anything coming out of Harry the Hack's mouth.

You decide on this one.

     I'm not sure if his words are being taken out of context or not, but I found the whole clip and you can decide. 

watch clip here 

     If what he said is in context then I am thouroghly disgusted with CBS.  Also, I recommend that you watch this whole clip becuase they talk about how Pres. Elect Obama is right on how to deal with Kashmir. 

Perfect Demotivator for the Obama Administration

http://www.despair.com/government.html

What he said is absolutely

What he said is absolutely in context!

His guest talks about the attacks being in Mumbai, the NYC of India, and causing the most psycological damage to India and then Smith makes his observation.

How can that not be in context?

Well, if it makes that a-hole feel any better...

      It's being reported that the American Rabbai are among the hostages that were killed.  Leaving their 2 year old son orphaned.  Personally, I mourn the deaths of all the innocent lives lost and don't care whether they were British, American, or Indian.

Perfect Demotivator for the Obama Administration

http://www.despair.com/government.html

The Trouble With Harry

The Trouble With Harry is that he is constantly reappearing.

"they were clearly, they

"they were clearly, they said, were looking for British citizens,
were looking for American citizens. Sadly, so many of the people were
killed were Indians.
"

So now terrorists think they can take out specific targets without collateral damage by using their same old explosives and automatic gun-fire? Terrorists tend to do one thing very well: blow stuff up. Blowing stuff up isn't rocket science, and they way they make bombs they make them big enough to do the job in a spectacular fashion...which is most certain to produce significant collateral damage. (Their use of automatic weapons is a waste as they usually don't have proper marksmanship skills...spraying automatic gunfire in hopes that it'll hit someone is just a simple waste of ammunition whilst making a lot of noise).

Since when did terrorists think they could set off bombs in an international hotel and hope they would only kill Americans and Britons? I thought terrrorism wasn't about individual victims, but rather the "statement" or message the terrorists want to convey. They don't care about the innocent bystanders...they've never cared about killing innocent bystanders--even if they are their own children

So according to Harry (and the terrorists from their claims) this episode wouldn't be tragic if only the "intended" targets were eliminated? Give me a break! The terrorists are paying lip-service to the "hate America" and "down with the bourgeoisie" crowd.

I hope the terrorists are happy now, they have singlehandedly reduced/dried up the injection of British and American (and other countries) money from the tourists that would have visited there. People that work in the hotel/hospitality/tourism industry will lose their jobs and the area will be poorer as a result. Isn't that the number one things they hate us for (other than being infidels of course)...our being wealthier than they are?

The lessons learned from unintended consequences are a B!tch!

"An armed society is a polite society. Manners are good when one may have to back up his acts with his life." --Robert A. Heinlein, "Beyond This Horizon", 1942

I would pay money to spit

I would pay money to spit on Harry Smith.  Seriously he needs someone to tell him how much of a disgrace he is to Journalism and America. 

 

"If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feed you"

Dear Harry et al...

"We like you. We'll kill you last."

Regards

Ali and Mo

Smith's Comments Echo Michael Moore's Post-9/11 remarks

Never forget this, folks -- this is what Michael Moore wrote on September 12, 2001 about the terror attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon (bold mine):

Many families have been devastated tonight. This just is not right. They did not deserve to die. If someone did this to get back at Bush, then they did so by killing thousands of people who DID NOT VOTE for him! Boston, New York, DC, and the planes' destination of California — these were places that voted AGAINST Bush! Why kill them? Why kill anyone? Such insanity...Let's mourn, let's grieve, and when it's appropriate let's examine our contribution to the unsafe world we live in. 

 

Notice how Moore only got to "Why kill anyone?" only after he implied that if anybody should have been killed, it only should have been people in the red states.  

"Well, I've got nothing against the press...they wouldn't print it if it wasn't true..." -- Joe Jackson, "Sunday Papers"

Wow, L.H., excellent point!

Thanks for including the quote from Mr. Moor(e)!

After seeing how similar the two remarks are, it is a chilling me to the bone to realize how the liberal mind is so limited by walls of hatred presumed to be wisdom on their part that keep them from seeing the world from any other viewpoint than their own petty spitefulness.

How is their viewpoint any different than the KKK, or a Nazi, or even Racist when they seperate the innocent victims into those who asked for it and those who didn't?

For example, the feelings of hatred of Jewish bankers long held by the Germans quickly grew into acceptance of the final solution as a good thing when no one challenged the lie.

Can this media challenge the lies and horror of the actions that spring out of these lies of these thugs when they liberal media themselves hold to the same belief?

Harry -you ignorant SOB

when the young men from GITMO are released, drop them off in Harry's neighborhood, with one semi auto pistol, 100 rounds of ammo, and two hand grenades, and Harry's address.

Thanks for the memories Harry.

 

 allow me to Love America

 

The loony liberal medias

The loony liberal medias worst nightmare. Terrorism
they can't blame on George Bush.

They initially tried to downplay it. A primitive
attack with automatic weapons and a few hand grenades. CNN even marched out the
guest that basically said the poor disenfranchised youth are easy to recruit
because in short WE have done this to them. I'm sure we'll find out that these
guys are middle class well educated dudes. But that doesn't stop the loons from
trying to pin the blame on the USA.

Krazy Keith didn't even deem this terror attack
worthy of much coverage and even warned of the evil GOP using this as part of
there policy of FEAR.

I'm a refugee from the Democratic Party.

 

Harry is a witless

Harry is a witless wonder...just another whiz-bang talking head, whose head is filled with nothing but empty space between those ears

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Well, I would say exactly what I think of Harry Smith...

...but it would be promptly deleted.

-Dave

When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.

Harry's only regret is

Harry's only regret is that, ( sadly, so many that were killed were Indians). You see, in the MSM view, it's never a disaster if only Americans are killed, after , don't those f-----s from the red states deserve it?, the redneck crackers are all probably in the KKK anyway. And then Indians are " people of color " and we all know that " their " lives are intrinsically more valuable than those disgusting caucasians., except for Harry, Katie, Charlie and the well meaning cauc's, they are the "good ones " you know, the rest can go straight to hell, cursed by allah.

Hi nad... Watch the

Hi nad...

Watch the language please...there are plenty of ways to express that word without using the full word here...you know the rules here I assume.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

there are plenty of ways to

there are plenty of ways to express that word without using the full word here - And it is better to express oneself w/o resorting to four letter swear words like "work" and the like.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Actually, Harry, what's most sad about this is ..

... that those killed aren't limited to the terrorists themselves.

"Sadly, so many of the

"Sadly, so many of the people were killed were Indians."

This idot actually said that? So he wished more Americans where killed? These people are bafoons!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

Where is the media outrage

So far I have heard about 15 civilians killed during the counter attacks, and if this had been US forces the media would have been screaming about how evil they were and how innocent civilians were killed not by the terrorist actions, but the US.

Yeah, the media template is

Yeah, the media template is that a terrorist can spray a crowd of innocent victims with an entire drum of 1oo rounds of 7.62mm ammunition. And it is Americas fault.

THen when the US counterattacks and gets blood on the locals from the terrorists head exploding from a single 7.62mm round fired by a sniper - it is all Americas fault as well.

The media PREFERS to use the "Its all the US's, and especially GWB's Fault" mantra.

You know, in a way it reminds me of the scene from Forrest Gump where the SDS thug who hit Jenny attempts to apologize to her near the Bus while Forrest stands near by glaring. Instead of simply telling the truth, the SDS Thug uses the opportunity to blame Lyndon Baines Johnson for his assault of the night before. THe left is AMAZINGLY like that.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.