Rich Rumbas on Republican Grave

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Frank Rich has apparently figured out that after January 20, it's not going to be as much fun for him.  True, the Times columnist will surely disinter W as necessary to explain away Obama's missteps. But the buck for whatever post-inauguration problems the country faces will land ever more resoundingly on the new president's desk.

And so, like a vaudevillian tapping as fast as he can while anticipating the hook, Rich seems determined to spend these last few weeks of the Bush administration dancing on GOP graves and luxuriating in Republicans' perceived pain.  You might say Frank is making hatred while the sun shines.

As we discussed last week in Have Fun For Now, Frank, Rich's immediate post-election column was one long poke in the Republican eye.  The Timester is back at it again this morning, outdoing himself in sheer vitriol as he pour buckets of salt, generously seasoned with schadenfreude, into Republican wounds.

Annotated excerpts from The Moose Stops Here:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The conservative crackup may be ugly, but as entertainment, it’s two thumbs up!

At least Rich is frank here.  This really is all about reveling in his rivals' defeat.

Celebrating the internecine warfare into which conservatives have allegedly descended, Rich notes that Ross Douthat labelled Doug Kmiec a "useful idiot." 

Rich doesn't bother informing readers that  Kmiec . . formally endorsed Obama.  "Useful idiot" would be high praise compared to some of the things Democrats have called Joe Lieberman.

Rich suggests that U.S News & World Report is on the road to extinction, and implies that its Michael Barone, a conservative of encylopedic electoral knowledge, is responsible for the magazine's decline. 

People in shaky financial houses shouldn't throw stones.  I hear there could be a gig available at Daily Kos, just in case the Times continues to founder.

The GOP . . . is now more representative of 20th-century South Africa during apartheid than 21st-century America.

Frank, Frank: you were so close.  Just a little extra effort and I'm sure you could have found a parallel to Kristallnacht.

There were as many Republican prejudices as candidates. In primary season, the whispered antipathy among some conservative evangelicals toward Mormons grew so loud that Mitt Romney felt compelled to give a speech defending his faith.

Yes, and let's not forget those angry, ugly demonstrations by anti-Romney Republicans staged outside Mormon places of worship. Oh, wait, those were gay rights activists demonstrating in the wake of Prop 8's passage. Some of the same folks who have used the n-word to condemn black Californians who voted overwhelmingly in favor of Prop 8. Sorry for the confusion.

Rich criticizes McCain for having "strenuously sought the endorsement of the Rev. John Hagee." 

Does Rich really want to go down this road?  Does he actually want to consider which candidate had the longer, closer relationship with a controversial pastor?

[GOP] leaders once again believe they can bamboozle the public into thinking they’re the “party of Lincoln” by pushing forward a few minority front men or women. The reason why they are promoting Palin and the recently elected Indian-American governor of Louisiana, Bobby Jindal.

Why doesn't Rich just come out and call Jindal "clean and articulate"? Nobody needs to push the brilliant Jindal forward.  He ran for and won the governorship of Louisiana based on a record of real accomplishment.

Rich finishes on a fittingly ugly note, referring to Republicans as "brain dead."  Keep dancing, Frank. We'll see you next year.

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

That's rich, Frank

[GOP] leaders once again believe they can bamboozle the public into
thinking they’re the “party of Lincoln” by pushing forward a few
minority front men or women.

Of course, you won't see Obama making the mistake of hiring minorities. He's sticking with the tried and true, the mighty white Clinton adminstration. Can you say 'retread'?

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

As I said so many times before

it would be extremely dangerous and premature to write off the GOP, they will survive and you know who is going to save the GOP...Obama himself...sounds crazy? Wait until the American people get a load of his policies once his backside hits that chair.

"9 out of 10 doctors agree that flag burning is the number one killer of liberals."

Hi HC... I wished it

Hi HC...

I wished it would be that way, I fear not though, no matter what he does the msm critters like Rich, Krugman ect will defend him to suit their agenda, we thought the msm protected, spun, omitted real facts, lied for the Clinton Team, we ain't seen nothing yet...

Remember in the words of Matthews, it is his job to make sure this President succeeds...

No filthy outright bias/hypocrisy there...the majority of the rest will be the same.

Look what Congress is already planning to use regarding fast-tracking laws already passed...this is going to hurt us all..so this is the only way I can possibly see anybody seeing the light, given enough time, and their jobs disappearing, let alone this hurting us in the pocket-books...big time. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

No arguments BT

and hello right back at ya! but hell even with all this protection even the most harden lemming has to stop and say "wait a minute I'm being financially hurt by this guy why are the media still protecting him!

Back in my Democratic days (Bill Clinton) when I thought Clinton and the Democrats could do no wrong there were plenty of times where even I said "wait that's not very ethical, moral, or safe for our country." 

Basically what I'm saying is that maybe -just maybe- even the most Obamafied loyalist will say "damn Obama I like you and all but even I can't agree with that." 

"9 out of 10 doctors agree that flag burning is the number one killer of liberals."

It is the Republican party that is navel gazing.

   Conservatives are doing fine. The core of conservatism is the principles found in the Constitution and Declaration of Independence. Last time I checked, those documents are still the same.

   There was no conservative candidate in the just finished election. Sorry.

  I will take you word that Rich is a boob. Not following the link. They get money for the advertisements that will display.

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

Response to brain-dead FRich

Nice article Mark!  I just posted this on NYT site under Rich's article this morning;

November 16, 2008 7:20 amThanks FRich, for an article showing once again how clueless you are. The opposition party is "brain-dead" ? If you'd paid attention, you'd have heard that the Repubs' message was: Slow or freeze the growth of fed govt, keep Bush tax cuts and reduce corporate tax rates (2nd highest in the world), produce more of our own energy in offshore Continential shelf within 100 miles, and in ANWR where the oil is, and do NOT raise taxes for highest 5% of earners who, as you know are the job-creators. Now, if you elected Obama, pray tell how his economic faux "plans" will help the economy. The NYT lead editorial last month endorsing Obama couldn't even come up with anything. You guys20are clueless, and you have the nerve to call Repubs brain-dead. Pathetic. Give it up, oh, and stop trashing Palin. You all did that very successfully in Aug/Sep/Oct, and your guy's going to the White House. Be careful what you wish for. You got it and it's gonna be a disaster with Pelosi and Reid. Hope you don't have kids looking for jobs in the next few years, b/c we're economic toast. I do, and that's another reason I voted against Obama.      — steve Bourg, Maryland

 

Your comment isnt there. Are

Your comment isnt there. Are they filtering out any comments that Frank Rich would disagree with? A few are getting through, but it seems that 99 percent are mostly agreeing with Frank Rich.

Maybe they don't get posted

Maybe they don't get posted right away...might not show up until tomorrow.

The GOP . . . is now more

The GOP . . . is now more representative of 20th-century South Africa during apartheid than 21st-century America.

[GOP] leaders once again believe they can bamboozle the public into
thinking they’re the “party of Lincoln” by pushing forward a few
minority front men or women..

OK, Frank, let's stipulate that there are few black Republicans (among voters). Why is that?

The Republican party stands for less government, lower taxes and personal responsibity coupled with the freedom to achieve, and rewards for that achievement.

If blacks prefer the Democrats' promises of cradle-to-grave government caretaking, income redistribution and a culture of entitlements, what should Republicans do?  Yeah, I know....be more like Democrats. 

There's only one problem...Republicans will never be able to out-pander Democrats.

GREAT, MB !!!!

"Republicans will never be able to out-pander Democrats."

:) 

You're the next contestant on...
THE MESSIAH IS... LEFT !!

 

Right MB and Shy

Republicans will never be able to out-pander Democrats.

Just remember Bill Clinton's shameful campaigning in black churches and labeling himself "the first black President".

It's the dem party that needs a casket

The dems just elected a far-left liberal with no management experience to the top executive position in our country. They'll also for sure push forward their anti-growth legislative agenda through Congress. Their policies are also anti-national security, anti-military. Voter anger is going to be high in 2012 for what they've done to our country and when they finally have only themselves to blame. It's going to be a sweeping victory for the Republicans in 2012. Nothing wisens an electorate so well as giving a bad platform time to govern.

   The dems and the media

   The dems and the media are making a mistake in building up people's expectations of what it means to have democrats in control.  There is a lot of talk about how will the Republicans ever regroup and recover.  Republicans only have to find a decent candidate for the next election.  Whether that candidate is successful is up to the democrats.  In politics it's your own failures that bring you down and your opponants failures that bring you back up.  So the dems have three years to make the country better and (more importantly) happier.  If they fail, the Republican Party will automatically be raised up.  It is doubtful that had jimmie carter been presiding over a contented country that there would have ever been a President Reagan. 

Frank, look down,

 

 that's the highly varnished deck of Titanic beneath your loafers.

 

 

 

Anyone who has ever heard Santayana's famous quote about History repeating itself is condemned to repeat it.

Unity???

Frank Rich and his ilk are the reason the call for "unity" is such a farce. The media continues to divide the nation. Hatred is high and the "jounalists" love it. Typical "liberal" hypocrisy. Call for unity, while expecting those who disagree with you to simply sit by and take your crap. Ain't gonna' happen, Rich  boy, Obama boy, Emanuel boy, Reid boy, Pelosi girl. Ain't gonna' happen. Until the lefties in politics and the media admit what haters they are, they will get nothing but hatred back in return. Until the lefies admit what racists they are, they will get nothing but racism back. And, unfortunately, like radical Islam, until they stop their own violence, the libs will get nothing but violence back at them. Radical lefties like Rich are, first and foremost, ignorant beyond belief. But until intelligent, informed people stop being apathetic and get involved, our nation will continue to be under the thumb of the fascists from the left. The recent election proves that the left is winning, because people of good will and common sense have sat this out far too long. The lefties are not people of good will, as Rich's words prove, as the attacks on Sarah, and Joe the plumber prove. It is more than simply that they disagree with you; they want to eliminate all your disagreement and create their own America. "Unity" to them means one Godless, valueless, communist/socialist/ fascist state in which they are in charge and you have nothing to say. It is happening, particularly in our schools, our government, and our media. Re-read books like 1984, Fahrenheit 451, Brave New World, Animal Farm, etc. and then look around you. The pigs are in charge and they'll soon begin to "change" the rules. Big Brother just took a trillion dollars of your hard-earned money to give it to his pals, like those at NBC and GE who just got a 139 billion dollar "loan". Every other commercial on t.v. is pushing some kind of drug. T.V. "news" is now an entertaining, mind-numbing propaganda machine. Don't trust any of them; they are the enemy within. Open your eyes and do the very thing they don't want you to do---THINK!  The America our founders envisioned, the America which has become so great by following their principles, is slowly but surely dying. Lambs to slaughter, due to our own apathy and ignorance, and left-wing haters like Frank Rich and company.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

And Rich is wrong?

How is Rich wrong? The GOP claims to be opposed to affirmative action, yet it trots out affirmative action politicians like Jindal, Steele, and Palin.

None of these three quacks would be so heavily promoted if they weren't minorities or female.

I am a conservative who is willing to think for himself.

Fallacies

Rich uses every logical fallacy he can to make his case: false analogies, either/or, false cause, circular reasoning, bandwagon, ad hominems, red herrings, biased language... to name a few. Just as Barry; he is a sly fox, the enemy within. Don't be fooled!

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

You Sir, or Madam, are no

You Sir, or Madam, are no conservative.

Only a liberal would claim that most conservatives don't think for themselves.

Hey guys..

don't start drinking the kool-aid just because they have an (R) after their name.   Sure Bush has maybe staved off another terror attack, which he should get a 100%  kudos for...BUT... HE HAS NOT BEEN A CONSERVATIVE!!!  If 'we' conservatives start making excuses for the Bush presidency We start sounding like Clintonistas.  Sure Bush has done a GREAT job on terror..BUT an AWFUL job on a war that we should have won 3 years ago, maybe 4 or 5 yrs ago. And lest we forget, it was his daddy that produced this anti-discrimination(sic) policy that is the reason were in the (pickle) that were in now;  vis-a-vis people stomping on crosses for gay 'marriages' etc.

My point is, Bush is hardly a conservative. I'll stand up for him about the war, but not much else.  Illegal immigrants, SPENDING out of control...THIS BAIL OUT!!  hardly a conservative.

I'm just saying, I'll stick up for Bush where and when it's warranted...but, unlike Democrats...Just because he's got an (R) behind his name doesnt make him God. He was better than the alternative, but again, that's why 'most' of us held their noses voting for McCain, we had no choice. WE need a REAGAN REAGAN REAGAN or now a PALIN PALIN PALIN

Public

We can, and do, disagree with things President Bush did. But I'm sure many Dems disagree with what other Dems do. However, they don't make it public.Their public face is always one of unity. I cringed every time I saw McCain bash others in his party. And in the end, he lost. As a matter of strategy, Republicans have to keep their disagreements private and unify in public. If not, they will continue to lose. Remember Reagan's 11th Commandment? Don't ever knock another Republican in public.The enemy loves nothing more than to see public division in the Republican party. The main reason for McCain's loss was, ironically, that he is a "maverick" on the public stage. That is what turned off so many of his own. Unfortunately, politics is a "game". And, as in all games, strategy counts. Know your enemy and don't make mistakes. President Bush and John McCain did not understand their enemy, and they made too many mistakes.

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

I'm not disagreeing with you

BUT, what do republicans 'fight' about in public? Senate pages? If an (R) touched the foot next to him in a bathroom?  We do look and sound stupid. We and I mean "WE' got to start keeping these our elected officials accountable for 'MAJOR' policy 'gaffes'. And not be 'mind numbed robots' and stick up for 'em just because they have an (R) behind their name.

I'm just saying , We cant sound like a democrat. sticking up for and making excuses for everything that happens just because they have an (R) behind their name.

Frank Rich is an idiot...but he does have points.

If it's a 'public' fight...so be it.  Let the MSM have a field day, but if it's for the best for America, let the MSM have their red meat, But, and we are now, having a 'fight' within our Republican party which way to go. 'We' at NB have our way of thinking...If we close our eyes...the problem doesnt go away

Dear MotherBelt and BMovies:

You're right  -  the "Comment-Interns" at the NYT deleted my polite but total skewering of FRich.  It was up for 15-30 mins early after posting, then they saw it and deleted it.  I've done this to Dowd and Krugman, and it's a hoot when it's the early posting right near the top.  Then they delete it, and keep the positive Comments.  

Fatuous = MDowd = FRich

Dowd's article this morning was equally fatuous, and also impossible (and pointless) to read in its entirety.  I wrote this Comment that stayed near the top in the early hour this morning, 7am, then they deleted it off the public comments for her article:

MDowd:   It's a "cool" idea -- Hillary as Sec'y of State?  And "at long last, the feminist icon".... would have accomplished something on her own, without Bill?    Do you HAVE a left-side in your brain? Do you actually look for "cool" in your political-opinion-formulating process? And, how can she be a feminist icon when, as you admit, she hasn't done anything without her husband's coattails?  You make ZERO sense. A few sentences of an article of yours is all I can handle. You can't expect a sensible person to read more than a few of your sentences.  It's painful.  I have a double or triple non-sequitur limit.   But that's all it takes to get a kick out of your lunacy. You should be an unpaid intern, b/c if you're not, you're being paid WAY too much per brain cell.   -SBourg, Ellicott City MD

sb.... LMAO...that post

sb....

LMAO...that post of yours is deliciously spot-on!

...and of course all of the leftists in all venues conveniently over-look little matters like this.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.