Slate's Noah: Calling Obama Skinny 'A Coded Discussion of Race'

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.
  • Bookmark and Share

Somebody call the Epidemiology Branch at the NIH.  It's looking as if we're on the verge of a full-fledged epidemic of Obamania.  As we noted here, NYT columnist Bob Herbert suffered an acute bout of the malady on live national TV yesterday, seeing visions of the Leaning Tower of Pisa and the Washington Monument where none existed in the McCain  Obama/Spears/Hilton ad. By yesterday evening, Keith Olbermann had contracted the affliction in aggravated form, claiming, as NewsBuster Brad Wilmouth has noted, to see no fewer than three phallic symbols in the same commercial.

Now, yet another variant of the dread disease can be reported, affecting mental rather than visual acuity. In When "Skinny" Means "Black" at his "Chatterbox" column at Slate, Timothy Noah [file photo] claims to see, yes, racism, in mention of the fact that Barack Obama is thin.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Noah was reacting to a Wall Street Journal article by Amy Chozick, Too Fit to Be President?, which asks whether Obama's svelteness could be a political liability.  Chozick wonders whether in a country "in which 66% of the voting-age population is overweight and 32% is obese," some voters might resent the slender Dem.  Beyond his trim physique per se, Chozick suggests a cultural gap between Obama and many Americans reflected in his fitness-center fanaticism [she recounts a recent day in which he worked out three times for a total of over three hours], his eschewing chewing fattening foods offered on the campaign trail, and his famous question to an Adel, Iowa crowd as to whether they, too, had experienced the horrors of the high price of arugula at their local Whole Foods.

Pretty harmless, nay, funny stuff, and absolutely nothing linked to race. Or so you might think. But you're not Timothy Noah.  You haven't come down with a bad case of Obamania—yet.  Noah sees clear racial overtones in all this.  Excerpts [emphasis added]:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

  • My point is that any discussion of Obama's "skinniness" and its impact on the typical American voter can't avoid being interpreted as a coded discussion of race.
  • Chozick insists that she didn't intend her playful feature about Obama's physique as potential electoral liability to carry any racial subtext . . . But I firmly disagree that a racial reading of Chozick's story is "ridiculous," and I would counter that any failure on Chozick's part to recognize such is just a wee bit clueless.
  • Let's review the basics. Barack Obama is the first African-American to win a major-party nomination for president of the United States. African-Americans are distinguishable from other Americans by their skin color. This physical attribute looms large in our nation's history as a source of prejudice.
  • When white people are invited to think about Obama's physical appearance, the principal attribute they're likely to dwell on is his dark skin. Consequently, any reference to Obama's other physical attributes can't help coming off as a coy walk around the barn.
  • It might be argued that body weight differs from certain other physical characteristics (apart from skin color) in that it has never been associated with racial caricature. Chozick wasn't asking (and, I feel sure, would never ask) whether Americans might think Obama's hair was too kinky or his nose too broad. But it doesn't matter. The sad fact is that any discussion of Obama's physical appearance is going to remind white people of the physical characteristic that's most on their minds . . . In the future, the press would be wise to avoid discussing how ordinary Americans will respond to the size of Obama's ears, the thickness of Obama's eyebrows, and so on.
  • Is that prohibition too inhibiting? I doubt it, unless you happen to be a political cartoonist, and therefore have no choice but to navigate these perilous waters. 

Now all that would be funny, too, but Noah apparently isn't kidding, right down to the self-censorship of the press he proposes. He even misrepresents Chozick's report to fit his narrative.  Thus he ominously notes that Chozick quoted "an unnamed Clinton supporter" saying she wouldn't vote for "a beanpole guy."  But Noah ignores the preceding quote Chozick provided from "Diana Koenig, 42, a housewife in Corpus Christi, Texas" who said Obama "needs to put some meat on his bones."  A more glaring oversight on Noah's part: the only person Chozick directly quotes calling Barack Obama "skinny" is . . . Barack Obama.  She reports Obama having told a San Diego crowd last month: "Listen, I'm skinny but I'm tough."

So who's the racist now?  And who's "clueless"?  

Although no known antidote for Obamania exists, the researchers here at NewsBusters are working feverishly to develop one.  Not sure whether this would constitute torture under the Geneva Code, but I'm thinking that some shock therapy—in the form of being subjected to a 24-hour continuous loop of Olbermann re-runs—might just do the trick.

Note: from JBlog Central:  Timothy Noah, master of self parody: "I kept checking to make sure this wasn’t just something I missed on April 1st, but no."

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

So....Are these white women

So....Are these white women journalists racist ??????

Is this a "coded discussion of race"?

If you play the Berlin speech backwards ...

Mark's examples are simply showing the evidence of the obvious -- these people will concoct any explanation available to excuse their bias, and it doesn't matter whether the explanations are anywhere near the scope of logic.

That's the scary part. As adults, most conservatives simply believe that liberals reason incorrectly. When they're wrong consistently, we suspect that liberals reason poorly. Now our worst fears are being proved true: many liberals don't reason at all.

I am so over this.

The MSM are grasping so hard at these straws their catching fire.

skinny is also "sizest"

skinny is also "sizest" code for thin people

Racist or racism, thanks to

Racist or racism, thanks to the Dems and MSM, means absoultely nothing anymore.

 

www.theholyrosary.org

"There is no problem, I tell you, no matter how difficult it is, that we can not resolve by the prayer of the Holy Rosary." -Sister Lucia

untouchable ninny...

Any debate about anything the untouchable ninny says, does or believes...is racist. So say the MSMr's and his staff.

This is the only way they can try to put down any logical debate on the real issues. Which, of course would immediately make "you know who" look like the incompetent, empty suit liberal ninny that he is.

The secret world of

The secret world of CRACKERDOM is upon us. Save us from the CRACKERS!
They are all in a conspiracy to get THE OBAMANATION. Help! Anyone
criticizing THE OBAMANATION is part of the CRACKER WING RACIST
CONSPIRACY. Help!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA....You poor LEFTY LIBS, is this
what you have been reduced to and it isn't even SEPTEMBER? 

However, the LEFTIES are successfully turning off HOARDS of Conservative Democrats...we'll be sure to send a thank you note in November.

Next Please! If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal.

In my humble opinion...

And from my experiences, people who see 'racism' in the most innocuous places are usually themselves racists who have a large streak of guilt that they are trying to compensate for by projecting their flaw onto the rest of the world so that they see it as widespread and don't feel so isolated.

Remember the immortal words of Dr. Sigmund Freud..."sometimes a cigar is just a cigar."

 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

Another thing

Another thing. Did I mention he's skinny?

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE

Bigot.

Bigot.

i'm starting to feel kinda

i'm starting to feel kinda down about myself 

Everything we say is racist and everything we do causes global warming

and as mean people we suck, and our hate is not a family value

WHAT NEXT IS ASK YOU...?!?!?!

I love how they circle

I love how they circle their wagons around their precious savior, and shoot at every single shadow they see or imagine.

"Look!  Racism!!" (pow!  k-ping!) "Racists all around!!  Fire!  Fire!"

Thank God our real pioneers were made of stronger stuff.

we got yer racism right here

we are the party of Powell, and Rice, and Thomas....

and if any of them were running for prez we would vote for them - even in the deep south

due to the unique fact that, unlike Obama, they are actually qualified to do the job

but that's just nuancing and such, isn't it

silly me

i got a wide stance, etc

And I bet if I call Obama a

And I bet if I call Obama a pro-choice, socialist, tax-o-crat...I'd be called a racist too.

www.theholyrosary.org

"There is no problem, I tell you, no matter how difficult it is, that we can not resolve by the prayer of the Holy Rosary." -Sister Lucia

I knew it

This proves Chubby Checker and Fats Domino were white.

Oprah Winfrey too. 

Don't believe your lying eyes.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE

or fat

or fat Albert..Hey..Hey..Hey.. 

 

Ronald Reagan, 1962: I did not leave the Democratic party, the party left me.

Insert: your name, 2008, and the Republican party.

Romney / Jendal  2012 (if,we survive)

New ways to be racist.

This just in:  If you think Obama's wearing an ugly tie, you're a racist.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

NKV, the way you wrote that

NKV, the way you wrote that looks vaguely reminiscent of Jeff Foxworthy's You might be a Redneck routine.

You may be on to something there... ;-)

"If you think Obama [fill in the blank], you might be a racist."

Then again, I don't suppose there's any "might be" possible. It's a given with this guy and his followers.

Maybe it would be easier,

Maybe it would be easier, and be a time saver, if the RACE INDUSTRY NAZIS made a list for the rest of us?

I'd like to know the few things one is allowed to say about His Hopelessness: The Obama.

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

Doh!

Wait till Olbermann gets wind of this. Amy Chozick, worstest person in the whole wide world!

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Another racist remark

"I'd like to know the few things one is allowed to say about His Hopelessness: The Obama."

You see using the word "hoplessness" is a direct reference to the state of hopelessness the black people have had to endure over the past couple of centuries. That being the case, when we say "hoplessness"  what we are really saying is that the black people are less than white people. It's very racist. So, we cannot use this word in anyway. 

Skinny is beautiful,

Skinny is beautiful, didn’t you know that? There are two kinds of people in the world, those who are skinny and those who want to be. I am totally against a fat person being with a skinny person, it's immoral. O.K. is their any other way to mock this stupidity? If I where to REALLY be racist I'd spread rumors that Obama's favorite foods where chicken and watermelon, and he likes to sit on the porch (Implying he’s a “Porch monkey”. In quotes because I hate the racist term.). But even though I strongly disagree with him, I still will treat him with some dignity, respect and because I feel racism is immoral and repugnant.

Another case of LDS

Looks like just another case of
Liberal/Leftist Derangement Syndrome (LDS)

Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.

Too bad about Leon

Leon would be having an open air lovefest over skinny = black.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE

Liberals

Having worked with so many "liberals" all my life, I'm not surprised at this or Bob Herbert's stupidity yesterday. Most "liberals" are nuts, plain and simple. Some of them actually believe what they are saying. And the most vicious of them combine their other mental disorders with megalomania. Witness Reid and Pelosi. Loony as the day is long, but also hyper- selfish to the detriment of the whole. And they often overreach. They cry wolf so much that people eventually turn them off. It's happening with Barry O. His calls for "change" and his phony act are wearing thin mighty fast.

NEVER, NEVER trust a "liberal"

Most "liberals" are nuts,

Most "liberals" are nuts, plain and simple. Some of them actually believe what they are saying. And the most vicious of them combine their other mental disorders with megalomania.

I have a slightly different take on this. I think that most Liberals, the kinds you and I meet and know in daily life generally, believe what they say because they are “informed” by the media (consistently and from various sources, mind you). These I call media pawns, they are the ones that the media are most interested in targeting and getting to vote for Democrats, so that the “elites” can get their agenda enacted. The elitists are the people in the media and especially college professors, perhaps more properly called leftists, and are prone to be duplicitous and conniving, such as Krugman and Soros. Hollywood types think they are elitists too, which is a laugh. They are much more like the waving bimbos on the parade floats, drawing the spectators’ attention; but it is the elitists that are actually driving the floats.

Nancy Pelosi is definitely an elitist; but as you put it, she has clearly overreached. Now I hear she is quietly and privately selling dispensations to her blue dogs so that they can actually represent their constituencies concerning drilling, and thereby get re-elected this November.

You and I may well be disappointed come November; but it sure looks as if it is going to be an unusually interesting election year.

Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.

Pawns, I like it.

needle, I like your take on why most everyday liberals believe what their sayin; 

believe what they say because they are “informed” by the media
(consistently and from various sources, mind you). These I call media
pawns, they are the ones that the media are most interested in
targeting

I really like the media pawns nomenclature. 

The way I describe it is like this; Instead of media I call them manufactured opinion outlets. People buy(watch/listen/read) a particular opinion(for example Fox News=conservative MSNBC=liberal) from the various outlets based upon which ever one produces the type of opinion(aka the news) they are in the market for. They then spout this manufactured (i.e. heard/saw/read on Rush/ A.C. 360/ Newsbusters :-}) opinion in place of any real thinking they have done themselves about the issues at hand.

I also think that you are spot on about how the elites then have these "pawns" do their bidding. 

However, I will contend that the "elites" are comprised of left, right and middle ideologies. Manipulating the masses is most definitely NOT the sole provence of the left. 

In verbis, non verba sed res et ratio quaerenda est 

If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love youBut if you really make them think, they'll hate you.

Don Marquis 1878-1937

"Kid" and "black hole" are also racist code words

All you need to know - and all the McCain camp needs to point to - is the fact that Bill Clinton was thrown under bus as a "racist" by The Obamamites for referring to Obama as a "kid" and his voting record on Iraq as a "fairy tale". According to them, Clinton was using...drum roll....code words. That's Obama-speak for "we don't have anything on you that's even close to being racist, but race is our trump card and we're going to use it every chance we get (which means anytime anyone criticizes Obama about anything)."

Code

According to Bambi and the Obamacolytes, every other word in the lexicon is code....and racist. 

You nailed it...race is their trump card, which they've begun to grossly overplay.  It's not resonating with anyone other than the dolts in the MsM, is it?

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Any criticism of His

Any criticism of His Hopeyness is "code" for "Uppity Ni***r"

Looking at Most Rappers...

I think it would be more likely to be racist, if I called him "phat".

Other than Tiger Woods, there are few notable blacks out there that I can think of that are skinny.  The trend seems more in the other direction. Even Denzel Washington I would describe as "solid" or "muscular".

Calling someone skinny is

Calling someone skinny is racist???? 

There were large disparities in obesity prevalence by race-ethnic group among women. Non-Hispanic black and Mexican-American women were more likely to be obese than white women. Race/ethnic disparities in obesity were not observed in men.

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db01.pdf

Let's not have facts get in the way of a popular lib trope.

 Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.  

Ahhh: Facts

Thanx for a study.

Skinny is not a code word for black. The tabloids are covered with skinny starlets. That's their slow news day story (skinny starlet/fat starlet).

It was a reach. Maybe the guy at Slatewas kidding?

"Maybe the guy at Slate was

"Maybe the guy at Slate was kidding?"

For his sake, I'd like to think so, but there's no evidence he was.  I did send the item to Noah, and if replies that it was all a joke, I'll be sure to pass it along.

Obamanitis is a viral

Obamanitis is a viral infection caused by the Obama Simplex Virus or OSV and is similar to the herpes simplex virus (HSV) where external physical manifestations and outbreaks occur unpredictably. However, outbreaks caused by OSV have been known to occur more regularly while in the presence of the original host. Another important aspect of the disease is that those infected seem to have a strange, almost metaphysical, affinity with the original host. One observed characteristic of this affinity is a propensity by those infected to bend and twist in whatever direction the host takes. Some researchers speculate that this phenomenon could be related to quantum entanglement.

The good news is that mediacal researchers at the NewsBusters Research Center (NBRC) are working feverishly to find a cure. But one researcher, Dr. Mark Finkelstein, has recently expressed some doubt that a cure could be found in time to prevent the disease from spreading to other nations. In fact, there is evidence emerging which suggests OSV has already escaped our borders.

"Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved, and thy house." Acts 16:31

OSV, good one bradben!.

Btw, how is OSV transmitted? 

 

 

 

If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love youBut if you really make them think, they'll hate you.

Don Marquis 1878-1937

WSJ backtracking on "bean

WSJ backtracking on "bean pole," tea details.

If McCain's staffer doesn't like Honest Tea

He's an idiot.

That stuff's great in all flavors, and someone who is FAR  more fiscally conservative than any McCain staffer likes Honest Tea. A lot (me!). So good shot on the WSJ, Bal, and keep keeping 'em on their toes.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

"...a full-fledged epidemic

"...a full-fledged epidemic of Obamania."

Mark,

"Obamanoia", perhaps?

McNotObama '08

Excellent suggestion!

Excellent suggestion!

Wow...these secret code

Wow...these secret code words seem to be code words only the leftists critters know...guess I need my secret decoder ring. 

First uppity, now skinny.

Give me a break.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Looks like my prediction is

Looks like my prediction is coming to pass. I hope we have a dozen or so of these "racist" articles and talk show discussions each week between now and November. It'll likely be a landslide for McCain.

"Skinny" Means "Black" ?

I'd find their assertion more plausible if they had said "Skinny" is a code word for "Cocaine Addict".

well, if he could just

quit his cigarette habit, he'd lose that "skinny" description real quick-like ;-)

yes, but.....

...there's nothing like a good cigarette after a hard workout, is there?

Be careful!

If you say Obama is skinny and has big ears there may be some sort of fatwa issued against you for insulting The Prophet.

almost as bad as global warming

No matter what you say about the Obomination, it's racist. It almost as bad as global warming causing [ fill in the blank with your favorite ]. It is only the welfare plantation blacks and Dims that keep howling "racism" at every turn. It shows how weak their candidate really is. They smell defeat all over him.

Fat Albert

So Fat Albert wasn't African-American because he was fat?

Hey Hey Hey!

Thomas Jefferson once said, 'We should never judge a president by his age, only by his works.' And ever since he told me that, I stopped worrying. 

- Ronald Reagan

In the same mold

National Review Online has a whole column along the same lines.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.