Q. What's weaker than playing the "taken out of context" card?
A. Digging yourself deeper with the supposedly exculpatory explanation.
Mike Barnicle managed the Daily Double today with his mishandling of the flap over the way he described Hillary back in January. Barnicle was on Morning Joe, and discussion turned to a New York Times article, Media Charged With Sexism in Clinton Coverage, that mentioned his remarks.
View video here.
MIKA BRZEZINSKI: The article, Barnicle --
MIKE BARNICLE: Yeah?
BRZEZINSKI: Yeah. It talks about whether there should be a national conversation about sexism, and refers to something you said --
BARNICLE: Yeah.
BRZEZINSKI: Um, "Mrs. Clinton was looking like everyone's first wife standing outside a probate court." I remember that. You said that to us. [Video of original Barnicle remark here, h/t Media Matters]
BARNICLE: You can take anything--listen, I said it. You can't take anything out of con--you can take anything out of context and make it sound the way you want it to sound.
BRZEZINSKI [offering Barnicle the rope with which to hang himself]: Put it back in context.
BARNICLE: [Assortment of hesitant sounds] Put it back into? This was played, I said that after a particular clip of Senator Clinton on the campaign trail, very early in the campaign. When, clearly, from every bit of evidence gathered early in the campaign, she was sometimes shrieking, rather than speaking.
BRZEZINSKI: Right.
BARNICLE: And I said, she sounds like every guy's first wife standing outside probate court, in that particular clip. OK, fine, I said it--
BRZEZINSKI: I remember, it got a good --
BARNICLE: You can blog me to death on it.
And indeed, the left wing blogs did have a field day, as reflected in the search results for "Barnicle Hillary first wife."
But back to Barnicle's claim that his remark was "taken out of context." See, it wasn't meant an insult at all. It's just that, uh, Hillary was "shrieking" rather than speaking. Well, that certainly clears it up. Come on, it was virtually a compliment! No wonder Mike Barnicle's so touchy about those "nitwit" bloggers who think they're real members of the media. Who do they think they are: Mike Barnicle?
By the way, not sure why Barnicle thought it was exculpatory to claim that his comment came "very early in the campaign." But just how early was it? He made the remark more than a year after Hillary entered the race with that chatty video on the comfy couch.
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.





Q. What's weaker than playing the "taken out of context" card?















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Barnicle's foot in mouth disease
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 13:09 ET by allamericangirlI'm sure Barnicle needed extra deodorant today . I noticed that he also kept mentioning that he has a wife and daughters Like that would automatically absolve him from and charge of sexism. I believe Archie Bunker also had a wife and daughter. toooo funny
"He also kept mentioning
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 13:11 ET by Mark Finkelstein"He also kept mentioning that he has a wife and daughters Like that would automatically absolve him from any charge of sexism."
Precisely. Good catch.
I said that after a
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 14:08 ET by motherbeltI said that after a particular clip of Senator Clinton on the campaign trail, very early in the campaign. When, clearly, from every bit of evidence gathered early in the campaign, she was sometimes shrieking, rather than speaking. - Barnicle
In other words, she was, I said it, I meant it.
Thanks for the context, Mike.
Hilarious
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 14:14 ET by SAM-OHIt figures. Scarborough, having returned the show to only medium nutiness, takes off a day and it returns to insanity.
Unfortunately, your mistake is that you needed to start the transcript earlier in the conversation at the point where Mika, Barnicle, and Ford were all fumbling for the editorial from which Mika then did some reading. It was hilarious watching her reluctantly serving the guy up on a platter on national TV.
There Barnicle goes
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 14:23 ET by bigtimerThere Barnicle goes again...trying to worm his way out of something...being the worm that he is.
Too danged funny....
"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson
Isn't it funny, after doing
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 17:05 ET by Chris NormanIsn't it funny, after doing everything they could to get Obama nominated, the liberal media all feel guily about "sexism in politics in America". Of course, the guilt all rests with other people...probably the Republicans...
Give him a break-
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 18:47 ET by VonuAt least it was his own thinking, this time he didn't PLAGIARIZE anyone.
Do you know that for
Fri, 06/13/2008 - 19:14 ET by motherbeltDo you know that for certain? ;-)
Geez Louise......
Sat, 06/14/2008 - 06:48 ET by connmanall this PC madness is making me ill! Archie Bunker? Now there's a blast from the past. By the way, I think there is a visual resemblance between Barnicle and Bunker.
Chris Matthews: Obama's Win a 'Magic Moment,' Like 'Camelot'
This town needs an enema! - The Joker
This is all a ploy
Sat, 06/14/2008 - 17:19 ET by DaieThe MSM talking about sexism against Hillary is just a way for them to get Hillary supporters to support Barack. They are trying to make nice now that Obama is the nominee. Now that Hillary is out of the running it's okay for the media to say people were sexist against Hillary. They want the Hillary supporters to see that they really do care and appease them so they will vote for Obama. Funny how this supposed sexism has been going on for months but only gets mentioned once Hillary is out of the race. Coincidence?? I think not!