Herbert: Kennedy 'Had to Fight Back After Chappaquiddick'

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

My circle of friends lost a fine man, a husband and father of several children, to brain cancer not long ago. He fought with courage and optimism, and received fine treatment, but the disease simply proved too strong. I sympathize with the plight facing Ted Kennedy, his family and loved ones. I'd add that in the course of the current coverage, I've learned of Kennedy's admirable history of extending kindnesses to many, putting him in something of a different light for me.

That said, I cannot help but comment on Bob Herbert's NY Times column of this morning, Tears for Teddy. The gist is that this is but the latest of many challenges that Kennedy has faced. And it's certainly true that the senator's life has been touched by more than its fair share of tragedy.

Even so, read this line, the one the Times placed on its op-ed web page to promo the column, and see if the same thing doesn't come to your mind as did to mine:

The press will tell you that this is Senator Kennedy’s toughest fight. I don’t even know if that’s true. Who knows what the toughest fight has been for someone named Kennedy?

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

My reaction was to immediately think of Chappaquiddick, and to try to imagine the fight that Mary Jo Kopechne made. And so I was drawn to read the column, to see how Herbert might address the matter. He first made an elliptical reference to it, writing of the Kennedy clan's "tragic failings." But then came these lines, which immediately followed the "toughest fight" one cited above [emphasis added].

This is a guy who has experienced every kind of horror, who went down in a plane, who had to fight back after Chappaquiddick, who has had two kids stricken with cancer, and on and on. So who knows?

That's right. Without a word for the horror Mary Jo Kopechne experienced, or of condemnation of Kennedy, Bob Herbert sees Chappaquiddick as just one more challenge the senator has had to overcome.

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Not just "overcome" though

"Fight back," as though the scandal had been inflicted on poor Teddy by eeeeevil outside forces he had to defeat, instead of his own irresponsible behavior. Amazing bias. Good catch.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

And it was a "horror" that

And it was a "horror" that he "experienced."

Always the passive tone. Nice, Mr. Herbert.

And it was a "horror" that he "experienced."

Not nearly the horror that Mary Jo experienced.

And this is surprising how?

Coming from the apologists for the entire Kennedy clan I don't find this surprising at all.  The entire clan has gotten away with murder, corruption, and a multitude of other crimes starting with the founder, old Joe.  A MAN would have tried to save Mary Jo and not left her to die.  And left she was to slowly asphyxiate in the pocket of air left in the car after it sank.  Who really was fighting at Chappaquiddick, Teddy or Mary Jo?

May God have mercy on his soul.  He is headed for warmer parts otherwise.

CS Lewis' Take on the lake

"A place so small that only God can get in." Hmmm, hope non-believers aren't touchy about close quarters.

Not quite the grand party palace some are hoping for with their buddies. That quote is from "The Divorce."

The Kennedy fiasco..

Expatriot,

I totally agree! All sympathy aside for the senator and his physical condition, this media gushing over his "greatness" is making me puke!

Anyone wanting the lowdown on the whole Chappaquidick mess and it's cover up needs to read Leo Damore's book "Senatorial Privilege". Ronald Kessler's book "Sins of the Father" exposes Joe and his sons for what they really are - left-coast, bleeding-heart, 'do as I say, not as I do', bootlegging, conieving, scheming, hypocritical liberals who have had the idiots who vote for them in Massachesetts in their political hip pocket.

"How can you be in two places at once when you're not anywhere at all?" - Firesign Theater 

who had to fight back after

who had to fight back after Chappaquiddick

   He is a kennedy.  All he had to do was wait for an army of true believers to announce that his period of 'pennance' was over and it was time to allow him to take his rightful place as a leader of all that is right and true.  C'mon.... driving while drunk resulting in a fatal accident and then not reporting it is not as serious as saying 'macaca' in public.

The last sentence in your

The last sentence in your post summed up a lot of what I see wrong with liberal culture, although Kennedy has always struck me as a dishonorable man.

 

------------------------------------------------------------

Grizzly Bear '08

When the chips were down,

When the chips were down, the guy thought only of himself and ran. He lacked nobility and heroism -- and some might say, even the most basic common human decency to help a sister in her hour of need.

His family thought only of themselves and rallied behind him.

That's the irreducible fact of Chappaquiddick. Has Edward Kennedy redeemed himself forty years on?

Who am I to say. (I like to think I would act differently than Kennedy, but who knows.)

That will be for a higher power to decide, whom the Senator would seem to be meeting sooner rather than later.

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

Jackson...

Ahhh, the life lessons Monty Python teaches us...

 

When danger reared its ugly head,
He bravely turned his tail and fled

Yes Brave Sir Teddy turned about
And gallantly he chickened out

Bravely taking to his feet
He beat a very brave retreat

 

Monty Shrubber.. we're all

Monty Shrubber.. we're all individuals... repeat after me...

Actually,  now you mention the lads, isn't Teddy a dead ringer for Mr. Creosote?

Vote 4 change. Vote 4 anything. See Jack & Mr Shy's first campaign ad for the ONLY viable 3rd party candidate.

I am doing this as a public

I am doing this as a public service in case Jackson's reference is more obscure than usual... Mr Creosote.

 

Runaway! Runaway!

Runaway!!

During the hysteria of 3 mile island. Bumper Sticker: "More people died in Ted Kennedy's car than all nuclear accidents combined"

and

"If Ted had been driving a VW he'd be President now"

 

He lacked nobility and heroism . . .

Starting with cheating at Harvard.

He probably cheated his entire life, but only got caught that once.

History revisited

goldenthroat,

One of the problems that we face in this country these days is all of the revisionist history that is daily crammed down our throats.  When you bring up what really happened you are mean spirited and not concerned for the feelings of others.  How dare we talk about Columbus' crew being wiped out after he left for Spain from the carribean?  How dare we talk of the Aztec conquests?  Those people might feel bad.

Same goes for the Kennedys.  Not sure who proclaimed them royalty, oh yeah, the omnscient press.  They know all!

What they're really saying is...

Expatriot,

You have that one right! It's the MSM declaring "our minds are made up. Don't confuse us with the facts!"

They have been doing that with the Kennedys for decades.

"How can you be in two places at once when you're not anywhere at all?" - Firesign Theater

Did you expect better?

Jack,

He is only following in the family footsteps.  The revisionists have the Kennedy clan as squeaky clean crusaders for social justice.  JFK was out for JFK.  How else to explain his private life and multiple out of wedlock liaisons?  Bobby the same.  The dad?  Don't need to get into that with any of you.  It would be nice if the rest of America had even a part of a clue.  The boys did some good things but saints they were not.  Not even close.

A tumor named Mary Jo

I'd hate to lose a loved one to a tragic crime, only to be marginalized by the press. Bob, you are a jerk.

If you think that's bad, in

If you think that's bad, in 2004 this quote won the Medai Research Center's "Quote of the Year" award for liberal media bias:

“If she had lived, Mary Jo Kopechne would be 62 years old. Through his tireless work as a legislator, Edward Kennedy would have brought comfort to her in her old age.”
Charles Pierce in a January 5 Boston Globe Magazine article.

How is that for jaw-dropping?

 

Above reproach

I know I shouldn't talk bad or say negative things about someone in Ted's condition, I should feel pity and sorrow for what Ted and family are going through, just hard for me sometimes. Especially when I think of what the Kennedy's have done to other people and this country. In my opinion, this clan is as corrupt as corrupt can get. I despise the Kennedy's and everything they stand/stood for. This family clan honestly believes they are above reproach, that they represent America and it's values, nothing could be further from the truth. The Kennedy's are always sticking their noses in everything/everyone else's affairs, and no one is allowed to know anything about their business.

Whenever I hear that Kennedy name, I don't think of them as "America's Royalty." Old English sayings come to my mind. "Power tends to corrupt, absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men." "Unlimited power is apt to corrupt the minds of those who possess it."

I guess I don't agree, like, nor share in, the love fest that this country has with the Kennedy family. Just too much similarity with the fake Obama love bandwagon.

 

Elitism

That comment from Herbert demonstrates the conscienceless elitism which permeates modern "liberal" culture. No shame, no soul. Mary Jo means nothing to a jerk like Herbert. How anti-American! She's is not equal to a "Kennedy"; she is simply a rag doll not worth even mentioning. Herbert casts her aside, as did the swimmer himself. And to imply that the poltroon Teddy had to "fight back" to save his reputation from those who would hold him accountable for his actions gives more evidence of the immature ignorance of so-called "journalists" today. Relativism at its worst. What ever happened to the idea that there must be a moral standard if a society is to survive? Much like Barry O., Herbert is a true "liberal"--- a little man with a small mind pretending to lift his audience to ideals, revealing instead his own shallowness, ignorance, and immaturity. It makes one sick to see what has become of a formerly great nation.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

When I heard he had cancer,

When I heard he had cancer, I thought, what is Mary Jo going to tell him when he gets there.  But, I thought too quickly.  He's not going to the same place as Mary Jo.  He'll be a little warmer and less comfortable.

 Marpel, let's really hope

 Marpel, let's really hope and pray he doesn't end up there.  As one who lost my mother to cancer, and one who has sinned very badly, I sincerly hope he doesn't end up spending eternity in Hell.

As Mark posted "I've learned of Kennedy's admirable history of extending kindnesses to many, putting him in something of a different light for me."  I'm sure he has extended kindess and deserves to have the good things done mentioned, but do you think the media would ever fawn over a Republican who likewise has extended kindness to many?  I think Steve Largent is involved with many charities, and gasp he was a Republican congressman.  Wow, I don't recall any fawning over him by the media.   Didn't Elizabeth Dole used to be head of the American Red Cross?  Wow, has the media ever fawned over her charitable work? 

 

 I agree I hope he doesn't

 I agree I hope he doesn't spend an eternity in hell either. But I would like to see him get treated to at least one all expenses paid cruise down  the river Styx before being let go.

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

                               " The Cake is a lie."   

"Horror" that he felt? What

"Horror" that he felt? What about the horror Mary Jo felt as she was left alone in a sinking car. I don't know the details, was she dead as the car sank, was she still alive? Whatever it was, Mary Jo did not get justice. I am sure her family remembers every detail. Sad.

Correct me if I'm wrong

msh,

I read that the coroner stated she died of asphyxiation after she used up all of the oxygen in the bubble traped in the car.  That would make her alive when the car sank.  Alive long enough to use up the useable oxygen that remained.

I believe you are right,

I believe you are right, exp. I remember seeing a drawing of the way the car was situated, and where the last pocket of air would have eventually been, up in a corner.

Does Anyone Recall How Deep the Water Was?

I don't think it was all that deep.  But Mary Jo wouldn't have known that in the dark of the night.  She could just as well have been under 20 feet of water from her perspective.

otr....Exactly. She also

otr....Exactly.

She also had plenty of time to think surely Kennedy was going to come back and get her out..or someone was. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

And the Dems?

And the Dems call waterboarding "torture".

Del... Especially

Del...

Especially Kennedy...if memory serves me he had the audicity to ask Roberts I think it was... what he thought of water-boarding during one of the judicial hearings....I'd look it up but you get my drift.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Hi BT

Here ya go

I oppose Michael Mukasey
by Senator Edward M Kennedy
Thu Nov 01, 2007 at 03:24:20 PM PDT
Waterboarding is torture. Torture is unacceptable. Period.

If Michael Mukasey won't stand up to President Bush and tell him that, then he doesn't deserve to be Attorney General.

Hey thanks Del...that was

Hey thanks Del...that was the one!

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

 Yes, the paragon of the

 Yes, the paragon of the left, the "liberal lion". These are the people the left emulates. People who should have been charged with voluntary manslaughter, perjurers, running a homosexual page boy prostitution ring (in Congress' basement no less), ABSCAM and various other bribes,  innumerable infidelities, and last but not least, an impeached president! Yessireebob, these are upstanding citizens.

But apparently the worst sin imaginable is hypocrisy, or speaking your mind on any racial topic whatsoever. Yeah, I'd say those Kennedy's are model citizens. For Massachusetts, I guess they are.

 Funny I thought his

 Funny I thought his toughest fight was the mile long swim from Chappaquiddick to Edgartown after thirty rum and Cokes.

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

                               " The Cake is a lie."   

Fight back?!?!?!?!

If Joe Sr was not disabled after his stroke, he would have gone into the police station with a briefcase full of money and the story of Chappaquiddick would never have been known!

Bing! Bing! Bing!

TCC,

WE HAVE A WINNER!

"I'd rather go hunting with Dick Cheney than ride in a car with Ted Kennedy!"

What we have seen from he

What we have seen from he msm of all venues since last Saturday is going to be nothing compared to when he does pass away...it makes me ill.

I will be leaving the television off as much as possible.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

I wonder if Herbert and the

I wonder if Herbert and the "NY Times" ever worry about the fight of the S. Vietnamese after Kennedy voted to cut off funding to them.  Here is a link to a movie, that probably won't ever win an Oscar, because it doesn't say Communism is the greatest thing ever. 

 

http://www.journeyfromthefall.com/Synopsis.aspx

 

 

Kennedy is nothing but

 40 odd years of failure, lying and murder. Hell has a special place waiting for this piece of human garbage.

So I take it that you

So I take it that you aren't planning on sending him a get well card, or are planning on joining his fan club.  As far as human garbage, I don't think he ranks up there with the horrible despots of the world, although he may think Ho Chi Minh was a swell guy, and that Ho Chi Minh city is a grand place.  For some strange reason I think Ho Chi Minh city used to be named something else.  I wonder why it doesn't have it's old name anymore.

 

 Wow Ted. 46 yrs. in the

 Wow Ted. 46 yrs. in the Senate, thats a long time to plot America's destruction, only to be foiled time and time again, and again, and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and agian and again and..........................

 

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "

                   - Ben Kenobi on  Liberals, and the MSM.

                               " The Cake is a lie."   

I think sweaty Teddy might

I think sweaty Teddy might be cheered up with a Fudgy the Whale,wouldn't you, Karl?