Now that David Shuster has returned from MSNBC exile after the Clinton campaign complained about his comments on Chelsea, will Tucker Carlson's be the next head Camp Hillary hunts?
Senior Clinton advisor Kiki McClean comprehensively rapped Carlson's knuckles this evening over comments Tucker made about Clinton campaign spokesman Phil Singer.
View video here.
The jumping-off point was an astounding Dana Milbank piece in today's WaPo: Team Clinton: Down, and Out of Touch, which described the frayed nerves within Hillary's camp. Milbank singled out Singer for particularly tough treatment, painting the picture of a man on the verge. Tucker had the temerity to raise the matter.
TUCKER CARLSON: Phil Singer, who is the Clinton spokesman, was also quoted by Dana Milbank in this piece in the Washington Post today, and he described his own mindset as this, and I'm quoting: "Sixteen months into this, I'm just angry."
That one quote doesn't do justice to just how beside himself Singer appeared to be, per the Milbank column.
KIKI MCLEAN: You know what? Phil Singer's a great guy. He's been working really hard --CARLSONL: He's an angry guy.
MCLEAN: He's a guy who's been working really hard for something and somebody he believes in.
CARLSON: Right.
MCLEAN: And you know what? Let's be honest: you said it in your own coverage. Senator Clinton and her campaign have taken a pounding, sometimes not always fairly. And you had a moment, you had a very human moment there, and I think we can all appreciate that.
CARLSON: Should the Hillary Clinton campaign continue to employ an emotionally troubled spokesman? Is that wise?
That set McLean off.
MCLEAN: I think you're totally out of line to make a comment like that.CARLSON: He said he's angry. He said "I am angry."
MCLEAN: Tucker, Tucker.
CARLSON: You want a spokesman who is angry? Come on.
MCLEAN: You and I have always had a good relationship, but I think for you to use a phrase like that about a member of our staff is totally inappropriate.
CARLSON: He's describing himself this way.
MCLEAN: You used the phrase "emotionally troubled." And what I'm telling you is that this is a staff person who believes in what he's been fighting for, believes in the senator's plans for the country and the vision for the future, and he had a very human moment yesterday, and I think you probably have human moments too. I think the way you're characterizing that is really inappropriate.
CARLSON: I think it's exactly what the guy just said, and moreover I think it's counter-productive to have people who are out who are enraged and whose dealings with the press reflect that rage.
MCLEAN: You know what, I think we're talking about what's been a long race. Both teams are tired.
The conversation moved on, but a bit later Tucker had one of those classic message-in-the-earpiece moments.
CARLSON: I just heard that Phil Singer has just called apparently MSNBC, he's upset about what I said . . . oh, I'm sorry, I totally misunderstood [MSNBC source informs me it was internal, not from Singer]. I did not mean in any way to imply that Phil Singer was crazy, I'm just saying, he described himself as distraught, and that's the point I was hoping to make.
MCLEAN: You used a phrase that was inappropriate and that's what I challenged.
CARLSON: I don't believe it was inappropriate. I did not mean to say the guy was crazy. I just mean to say he described himself as distraught and is that an effective spokesman? That's the point I'm making.
MCLEAN: And what I'm telling you is that, that's a very human person yesterday in one moment.
CARLSON: OK, OK.
Will the forces of Hillary call for the head of Carlson as they did in Shuster's case, and if so, will MSNBC again cave?
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
And they say the Bush
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 19:51 ET by Chris NormanAnd they say the Bush Administration wants to limit free speech...
No one is saying Tucker
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 19:57 ET by motherbeltNo one is saying Tucker shouldn't be "allowed" to say it...she is just saying that it was a low blow. And I think she's right. Saying someone is "emotionally troubled" implies way more than anger...it implies almost a mental illness...or at least, instability.
Perhaps he shouldn't have
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:02 ET by Chris NormanPerhaps he shouldn't have said it - he should have higher standards. Still, I've heard much worse on these shows that went unchallenged and unpunished. It's the punishment part that's chilling - and it was done in Shuster's case. If they're going to punish "inappropriate" comments, it should be applied in even handed way - and not because the Clinton camp demands it.
I agree, Chris, worse has
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:05 ET by motherbeltI agree, Chris, worse has been said. But that doesn't mean he was right. And unless he left out part of Singer's quote, I didn't hear Singer describe himself as "distraught" (another loaded term) either, which Carlson said he did.
And he's only been chastised by Kiki McLean....he hasn't been punished. Time will tell on that one.
These types of shows, by
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:26 ET by Chris NormanThese types of shows, by their very design, raise the temperature of rhetoric. Carlson made a bad choice of words, but I would guess he didn't set out to accuse a campaign functionary of being insane. I wonder if this woman would have been so offended if the discussion had been about McCain's "explosive" temper - which has been quietly hinted at suggesting instability. How long before Chris Mouthews brings it up? Will he be reprimanded? I rather doubt it. The Clintonistas and the Obamaists(Are you implying we're communists? We're offended!)just seem a little too ready to be offended - and I think someone should call them on it.
and...?
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:02 ET by Skypilot4808and...?
Chaplain Lee M. Thompson
I agree that emotionally
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:34 ET by balboaI agree that emotionally troubled is a little more suggestive than angry.
Well, of course you would.
Wed, 02/27/2008 - 11:04 ET by Chris NormanWell, of course you would.
delete
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 19:57 ET by motherbeltdelete
From the picture, I see that
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:28 ET by Chris NormanFrom the picture, I see that yet another Clintonista has "the wagging finger of doom" move down pat.
Get a life
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:31 ET by paulnashtnYou are talking about a
campaign flunky here, MSNBC hosts have called the President crazy -- which is worse
VOTE REPUBLICAN
OK... if you don't like emotionally troubled
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 20:36 ET by c5thenHow about reason challenged? A tinder box?
a headline waiting to happen?
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.
c5, all he said was "16
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:15 ET by motherbeltc5, all he said was "16 months into this, I'm just angry."
I hardly think that qualifies for the treatment Carlson gave him. I'd love to be high-fiving Tucker, but I can't. He even said Singer described himself as "distraught" which Singer did not, and suggested he wasn't fit to be on the campaign because of it.
He doesn't need to stoop that low. If anger is a disqualifier for just a staffer, John McCain had better quit right now.
Good points all.
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:30 ET by c5thenI just thought that as a "journalist" on MSNBC in the mold of Matthews and Olberman, it was Carlson's job to tweak his "guest" and really get her going.
I agree, that the anger statement was nothing. After all, anyone working with Hillary for 16 months straight ought to be angry at least.
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.
I just thought that as a
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:48 ET by motherbeltI just thought that as a "journalist" on MSNBC in the mold of Matthews
and Olberman, it was Carlson's job to tweak his "guest" and really get
her going.
Well, he certainly did that! LOL
???
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:21 ET by seaniepisn't tucker a bit of a pushover any way since jon stewart made fun of his bowtie and he no longer wears one?
but I say screw hillary and her campaign, they just can't accept that someone may not be in love with them!!!!!! who cares, if someone doesn't like me, I deal with it
I suggest some of these people deal with it
Screw 'em
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:35 ET by Mica the MagnificentHere we go again - as conservatives - wringing our hands and breaking out in a cold sweat over-analysing our behavior. Was Tucker fair, was he too mean, was he insulting, etc.
SCREW THEM!
The dems didn't worry about putting the lives of our troops in danger by declaring the WAR IS LOST or calling interrogation of terrorists 'torture' etc etc
So Tucker upset the fat chick! Screw her!
Mica... Hear! Hear! I
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 22:02 ET by bigtimerMica...
Hear! Hear!
I Second that Motion all the way!
isn't tucker a bit of a
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:46 ET by motherbeltisn't tucker a bit of a pushover any way......
Well, that's why he's trying to "make his bones" by going after Kiki.
LOL
"Lighten up Kiki"
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 21:33 ET by CapeCodScottTucker, Mr. Singer was not "Angry". People who are angry do things like throw ashtrays and lamps at their spouses, scream publicly about the shame they feel about people they where "Proud to be with" only days before, they wear pant-suites!
He's not the Angry one....
Two words
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 22:06 ET by JJVTwo words are missing from media people, and pundits anymore....THICK SKIN. I'm so tired of everyone getting offended. Stop with all the nonsense, and then the insincere apologies. GET OVER IT! You said it you meant it. Even if you didn't, so what.
Frankly, I'm offended.
And I demand an apology.
You see ...
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 22:06 ET by drillanwrTHIS is the eventual problem with Teflon ...
Yeah, when it's new and shiny things easily roll and flip off of it. Amazing stuff.
But as it wears to the constant exposure to heat and scraping it weakens and scratches and begins to infiltrate whatever it comes into contact with ... with concerns that it just might not be good for your health ...
So, you throw the Teflon thing ... out.
When you men get home and face an anti-war protestor, look him in the eyes and shake his hand. Then, wink at his girlfriend because she knows she’s dating a pussy… ~ Attributed to General Tommy Franks
Tucker is eally skating on
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 23:42 ET by bigtimerTucker is eally skating on thin ice...what has it been twice now in about two days he is seeming to not give a rats rear here about what msnbc has to be unhappy about with the way he is doing his show...he knows more than we may ever know anyway of what goes on behind the scenes or he is fed up..whatever....time will tell...
Go Tucker Go!
Tucker
Wed, 02/27/2008 - 00:27 ET by scoopaI have always liked Tucker, except for his foolish anti-war stance. I've never understood that one. But, he is SO CUTE!
I had my picture taken with him at McCain's NH primary victory party, and I told him that he should move to Fox. He said "they probably wouldn't have me"!!! He's so cute.
That victory party was a blast, I have a pin, a flag and pictures and can say when McCain wins the White House that I was there when it all began, because it truly began in NH. The USA, USA chant was very cool too.
I live in Maine, and went with my Repub buddy. McCain was my #4 at the time, but who's counting! There was so much free food, it was incredible. And, all the media people that I see on cable TV every day - I felt like a kid in a candy store.
Had my picture taken with Carl Cameron too. And, got interviewed by USA Today and the BBC (can you believe it?). Of course it never saw the light of day because I wasn't from NH, haha!
Something in the water over at MSNBC
Tue, 02/26/2008 - 23:47 ET by Jonah JohansenHardly a day goes by when one of them Matthews, Tucker, Shuster, etc doesn't shoot from the hip, engage their tongue before their brain and say something moronic.
Olberman is whole other story. Listening to him is like signing up for a college course on post WWII European History and having the professor try to connect UFO's with all the important events of the time period.
Comrade Tucker
Wed, 02/27/2008 - 07:34 ET by ArchConservativeSounds like the KGB got to ol' Tuck. Time for your re-education camp. I just love seeing the MSM get the slap down day after day. I hope this never ends. Hopefully the powers-that-be go after Olbermann next.
The Set Up
Wed, 02/27/2008 - 10:55 ET by CellaIf anyone should be emotionally troubled, it is Tucker for having to deal so often with the undisputed queen of spin, Kiki McClean.
Which producer is scheduling this woman week after week?
If the truth be told, I am certain the word has gone out to all Clintonistas appearing on TV, to be listening for any comment that they can spin into an insult to the eternal victim, Hillary Clinton.
I don't know how Tucker can resist reaching over and whacking KiKi upside the head. Oh, wait......that would be inappropriate.