Actual op-ed column, or parody of MSM mockery of Middle America? You be the judge of today's p.p.v. opus by Gail Collins, New York Times columnist turned Editorial Page Editor now returned to her column-writing roots. We'll begin with the title, Republicans in the Straw, and proceed to these excerpts:
- Today 40,000 Republicans are expected to make a pilgrimage to a large tent in Ames, Iowa, where they will eat an enormous amount of free food and vote for a presidential candidate. Mitt Romney is going to serve barbecue, and one of his sons has just visited all 99 counties. I don’t think we need say more.
- Romney moves around with so many photogenic sons, daughters-in-law and grandchildren that they look like one of those singing families that were so popular in the ’70s.
- The Iowa State Fair is not actually about politics so much as about finding new things to deep-fry.
Story Continues Below Ad ↓- [T]he line of people waiting to see Harry Potter carved in butter snaked around the Agriculture Building. Since the statue itself is behind glass for climate-control reasons, the scene strongly resembled the viewing of the Pietà in the Vatican.
- [T]he traditional Butter Cow which has to be there whether it really fits the theme or not. This was all the work of Sarah Doyle Pratt, a 30-year-old elementary school teacher, who apprenticed under the legendary Norma “Duffy” Lyon, creator of the never-to-be-forgotten all-butter Last Supper.
- Truly, if you are into art forms based on dairy products, you have to go to Iowa.
- Personally, I’m only in Iowa for the butter sculpture, and I’d be happy to be diverted if, say, Arkansas challenged its voters to pile up watermelons for their favorite Republican, or Kansas did a Candidate Winnowing. Winners will be judged on originality and public participation.
- Extra points for carving things out of local produce.
I don't know if Collins is an aficionado of the Hamptons, Nantucket or perhaps Martha's Vineyard. But whatever the venue, it's not hard to imagine the Times columnist regaling her sophisticated friends with tales of those amusing bumpkins of the heartland.
Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Ahhh, yes ...
August 11, 2007 - 17:36 ET by drillanwrWe knuckle-dragging, Bible-thumping, Jesus-weeping, brother-sister-marrying, cow-and-sheep-humping, barefoot-and-pregnant, chickenhawk-military-breeders.
Thanks for reminding us, Mzzzz. Collins.
Now, please pass the butter.
She criticizes butter carving "art", but I'll bet she loved Piss Christ and Elephant Dung Virgin Mary.
come on now - we flyover
August 11, 2007 - 17:55 ET by TruthMongercome on now - we flyover serfs are truly fortunate to enjoy any east coast patronage and condescension here...
Know your place people:)
People see what they're looking for
August 12, 2007 - 13:06 ET by Carbon SasquatchJust as the cop sees everyone as a crook and the fireman sees potential
conflagration everywhere, this political writer sees everything as
political. Now she finds herself in Iowa and truly is baffled
that regular people live there and continue to do regular things,
despite her august presence. I wonder if she has ever attended
the New York state fair. I also wonder if, in her visit,
she ever left the midway and commercial exhibition halls. Perhaps
the livestock barns and 4-H displays were too terminally quaint.
It's amazing to read this
August 11, 2007 - 17:38 ET by fitzfongIt's amazing to read this woman mocking middle Americans and her perception of their "habits"...especially since it doesn't look like she's too acquainted with the toothbrush.
LOL @ 'all 90 counties'
August 11, 2007 - 18:15 ET by ChrisNHWell, the same can't be said for how many TV networks Democratic presidential candidates appear on. It certainly isn't 'all of them.'
I've got two words for
August 11, 2007 - 19:39 ET by HypocriteHaterI've got two words for Gail...
Crest Whitestrips.
Think about it, honey!
He's real cheap
August 11, 2007 - 20:09 ET by drillanwrMaybe she could use Mookie's dentist?
http://patdollard.com/2007/08/10/colonel-al-sadr-back-in-iran/
A Beauty Contest Reject
August 11, 2007 - 17:48 ET by Guy Arthur ThomasComing from a woman that looks like a Minnesota Lutheran Beauty Contest reject and the certain winner of a Garrison Keilor look-alike contest...I would say she has little room for complaining about that which appears DROLL.
Shut up and blog! If you claim to be a conservative, please don't disgrace yourself and conservatism by thinking and arguing like a liberal. Go Rudy!
I agree with you that she is
August 11, 2007 - 18:10 ET by fitzfongI agree with you that she is putrid looking and obnoxious, but I wonder if using one regional stereotype to dispel another regional stereotype is the way to go.
A Minnesotan Lutheran Takes offense
August 11, 2007 - 19:12 ET by Lame CherryYou know I almost took offense at your comment and then I though, You know I am not Minnesotan.........and you are right lol.
I don't know how you know what those Swede, Norski and Kraut people of women look like but I remember allot of them........especially their cooking which consisted of a scoop of Crisco of Fluffo with "that good recipe" which amounted to Cream of Chicken soup dumped into everything from soup to noodles......always followed by dessert which was always jello.
Oh for the good olde days of Rose Marie who could fist fight a bully for you or win a beauty contest lol.
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
What a snob, is the Iowa
August 11, 2007 - 17:52 ET by general companyWhat a snob, is the Iowa fair any different then any other states? Pure meanness just for the sake of being mean.
Actually, she's spent a lot
August 11, 2007 - 17:54 ET by Del DolemonteActually, she's spent a lot of time along the "Gold Coast" of Connecticut (Ned Lamont-land). And her husband Dan Collins is a senior producer for (surprise surprise) CBS News.
Typical elitist liberal attitude...
August 11, 2007 - 18:05 ET by Army BratThose commoners in Iowa are bringing down the average I.Q. Can't we do something? Jeez...what next? Happy Trails...
There's no way she's
August 12, 2007 - 00:57 ET by Johnnye BThere's no way she's married! He's either vision impaired or has a very serious drinking problem and I don't think there's enough liquor to get anybody that drunk!
Fortunately
August 11, 2007 - 18:10 ET by botgthe article in full is behind the subscrition firewall 'Times Select' is this a selection of snobs?
Supreme Court, National Security, Borders, Fiscal Restraint, my litmus test for President.
Does The New York Times have a dental plan?
August 11, 2007 - 18:18 ET by ChrisNHJudging from this homely woman, I'd say 'No.'
Chopped Liver
August 11, 2007 - 18:37 ET by P.J. GladnickMeanwhile it would surprise me a bit if the New York Times hosts a company party featuring a bust of Pinch Sulzberger sculpted out of chopped liver. First person to take a bit off for his/her sandwich gets fired.
Gail Collins
August 11, 2007 - 19:04 ET by pocomocoA snob is as a snob does! (Forrest Gump)
August 11, 2007 - 19:10 ET by MidAmericaHer problem is obviously that we are too white. I can't imagine her report would have the same tone if she went to a barrio, a black community or a homosexual dominated area.
Oh Gaild...Don't worry
August 11, 2007 - 19:21 ET by bigtimerOh Gail...
Don't worry you're sort of pretty little head about it all....
Your Soros leftists little trolls of the dem party are going to be crying in their bibs before this is over...along with you and the rest of the msm leftist press.
Romney did great today....Tancredo had the fire in his belly today for once with his speech.....Hunter made a great speech but needs that fire in his belly like Tancredo had....
I enjoyed it immensely along with Laura Ingram (sp).
Gail Collins don't throw Stones in yellow Tooth Houses
August 11, 2007 - 19:25 ET by Lame CherryBuilding on the above comments, you got to understand the midwest people really. See Gail does look like a Minnesota beauty contest reject.......everyone in the midwest detests Minnesotans. All you hear about is Vikings, Twins, Timberwolves, Wild and how they are more caring, more concerned and more American than Americans.
Iowans probably mistook Gail for a milkmaid escaped off the farm or a Paul Wellstone educational associate on vacation and were just politely ignoring her. Gail's yellow teeth are sure sign she is from Minnesota to an Iowan as the state animal is the golden gopher and shows up on their state signs with big yellow teeth.
If she showed up in South Dakota they probably would have given her wrong directions with a smile to get rid of her and North Dakota probably would have "gifan dat purdy yallo tooth gurl a looksee" and Nebraskans would have just spit snoose on her shoes.
So don't talk down about us midwestern types Gail as we is right proud of the them uppity tulip growers as they are our sophisticated folk and weed people like you out quick as Minnesota types.
Just wait till you get to Missouri Gail as they will all be propsin mearage to ya cuz you got all yer tooths.
God, literally God, I love the Redlands People. Amen to them wonderful Americans which produced me and let me call all of them home yet. I wouldn't want them any other way as they are perfect!
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
NYTimes Writer
August 11, 2007 - 21:25 ET by SR71 555Looks like she needs to pay for a good tooth whitening !!!!!
She's waiting for Hillary to
August 11, 2007 - 21:27 ET by drillanwrShe's waiting for Hillary to get into office and that Universal Health Care to kick in.
NYTimes Bigotry... Again
August 11, 2007 - 21:42 ET by stratmanBigotry from an effete elitist.
Shocking.
Killing them with kindness isn't working. Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.
While you're at the Iowa State Fair, Gail...
August 11, 2007 - 23:00 ET by nkviking75Hey, Gail, while you're at the Iowa State Fair, check out the cow chip throwing contest. I hear they need catchers.
For the life of me, I can't figure out why my home state fights so hard to be first in the nation when we're rewarded every four years with these stuck up Eastern snots. Even the candidates like Jean Francois Kerry had to backtrack after being overheard complaining about having to go to places like Dubuque. Just do one national primary in June and get it over with.
When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.
}}---> Good clean fun
August 12, 2007 - 05:14 ET by Cool ArrowSo they weren't playing "Pin the hair on Brittney Spears", or something so avant garde as taking in a Hillary hosted "A Chorus Line"
Republicans engaged in downhome meet and greet without the barkers and the transwhatever's for the prurient Ms. Collins to admire for "inclusiveness" appearances.
A Republican fair versus a Democrat freak show.
Oh, and did you hear Mitt had his whole family campaigning? Shocking!
they look like one of those singing families that were so popular in the ’70s. . .Oooohh I get it...The Osmonds...Mormons. You almost flew that one right over my head Ms. Collins.
I am from Iowa and have
August 12, 2007 - 08:09 ET by NortonalecI am from Iowa and have lived in South Florida for 20 + years. Its always the same thing from New Yorkers-Idaho? Most people from the North East don't even know where Iowa is, much less what the people are like. I wonder if Snaggletooth has ever been the the New York State Fair and seen what people outside of Manhattan look like.
Nortonalec
I find it so perfectly
August 12, 2007 - 08:29 ET by USA4freedomI find it so perfectly typical of the standard North East
liberal. I just have one thought in my mind. Don’t go. You make fun of us in
the South, and then retire, and bring your sorry liberal ass down here. Make
fun of anyone that is not in your little group (the party of tolerance). Then
demand the NYT’s, and good bagels. Hey if I’m not mistaken, the bagels and the
NYT are back home. Stay home. Don’t go.
Hey after all, with all this Global warming gong on, the
North East will be like Miami in a few weeks.
It reminds me of John F.. Kerry when he tells the guy at the
gun shop, “I want to get “me” a hunting license.”
If we are so.. back woods.. hill jacks.. rednecks.. DON’T GO.
Remember if you sit on your horn behind my pickup truck just
as the light turns green, My back wood, hill jack, redneck ass might get out
and explain some southern manners to you.
These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day
Iowa - Ohio - Idaho
August 12, 2007 - 15:45 ET by River CityI can't tell you how many times people have said "Do you spell that O-H-I-O?" Idiots.
“You don’t understand. I am a queen, and I demand to be treated like a queen.” Representative Sheila Jackson Lee D-TX
Photogenic?
August 12, 2007 - 08:45 ET by ecarlwhiteIf this were a Kennedy offspring she'd be gushing over how charming and regal the sons look. But no, she only cuts one way. Her sarcasm, err... reporting, is not transparent. Thank you Gail for your political discourse contribution. I'll be sure to file this article, right after I delete my browser cache.
'Truly, if you are into art
August 12, 2007 - 08:55 ET by kg'Truly, if you are into art forms based on dairy products, you have to go to Iowa.'
The art forms preferred by the 'enlightened elite' of the two left coasts are based on dung and piss.
The only ones making art out of dung in Iowa are the 1 year olds who manage to shed their diapers.
}}---> Parkay
August 12, 2007 - 09:23 ET by Cool ArrowDems have got to be miffed that Butter is back in and that French invention, margarine is out.
As for Democrap art, one has to wonder why they decided to stay within that freudian stage.
I lived in North Jersey
August 12, 2007 - 09:38 ET by USA4freedomI lived in North Jersey for about 15 years. I once stopped
to help an elderly woman in her late 70’s. She had a flat on a main street. I
stop my truck and got out, she jumped in her car rolled up the windows and
locked the door. I think it was one of those moments where I said to my self
“what am I doing here?”
I still changed her tire, after she calmed down. While walking away it occurred to me
that she did not even thank me. I
turned around and said “your welcome”. She just turned around, and got in her
car.
My point to this is every where except the North East/ west
coast corridor people, (for the most part) look out for each other, they go to
church, they don’t march in Gay Pride parades. They stop and offer help when
you break down, they love our military, (as well as their mission). They grow
the food that you pick up on the shelves. They don’t talk about the cruel treatment of animals by hunter’s as
they scoff down a porterhouse. Liberals see no problem with abortion but have a
real problem executing a mass murder.
So with all that in mind, I’ll take the all butter last
supper, over a crucifix in urine, (paid with taxpayer money). In a New York minute!
These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day
USA.... ....ain't that
August 12, 2007 - 15:46 ET by bigtimerUSA....
....ain't that the truth!
You said it all.
What would you call it when
August 12, 2007 - 10:27 ET by buddycWhat would you call it when some praises evil, hates something that is attractive, dislikes good, thinks she is superior to hard working people, has reached the lofty level in life of working for the New York times and looks like this woman(?) looks?
It is pure and simple jealousy.
She will never reach Romney's success level, have a family like Romney, be as attractive as Romney, or contribute as much to society as Romey has or will.
Hate is a difficult character flaw to overcome.
Deep-rooted hate of Republicans
August 12, 2007 - 12:48 ET by ThisnThatI decided to look up this Collins gal, and noticed this highlight: "One of those politicians was Alfonse D'Amato, the former U.S. Senator from New York. Once Collins asked him to name the last five books he had read. When he said 'The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich,' she mocked him every chance she got."
Frankly, I don't get it:
I think this just shows what kind of a "I'm more sophisticated than you" attitude this person has, which explains why her current article is very much in character.
The old Republicans-as-Nazis meme
August 12, 2007 - 14:28 ET by nkviking75My guess would be that a liberal loon would say D'Amato was reading the book for inspiration for more Republican e-e-e-e-vil-l-l-l. There is nothing wrong with the book. It's just the old Republicans-as-Nazis meme.
When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.
TnT -- here's the
August 12, 2007 - 14:42 ET by Jack BauerTnT -- here's the thing.
The book was published in the 1950s. Now I suppose it is possible that that would be one of the last fives books you read.
But it does smack of saying the last five books you read are: War & Peace, Little Women, The Complete Works of Shakespeare, Huck Finn, and Chaucer's Canterbury Tales.
So while I am not defending this twit of a women, it could sound a little hokey.
So what? That's like
August 12, 2007 - 14:49 ET by fitzfongSo what? That's like claiming it's hokey to say that the last movie you've seen is The Godfather: Part II.
What's the alternative? Oceans 21?
C'mon Gail, your heart may
August 12, 2007 - 14:48 ET by BlazerC'mon Gail, your heart may not be in Iowa, but your teeth are definitely in West Virginia.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
The Butter Cow and All Things Iowan
August 12, 2007 - 15:40 ET by River CityDear Gail of the NY Times:
Those of us in Iowa don't really care if you like our butter cow sculpture or not. We don't do it to please you. The Iowa State Fair is the best state fair in the country. We think so and to those of us that live here that's all that matters. Stay in NY next caucus season. We can vote for president without you.
“You don’t understand. I am a queen, and I demand to be treated like a queen.” Representative Sheila Jackson Lee D-TX
Good post River City. For
August 12, 2007 - 15:46 ET by BlazerGood post River City. For someone who comes off as being so elitist, and bourgeois, in her above pic she looks like an Amishmans wife. Speaking of butter, when I look at her teeth, I cant' believe it's not.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
Here is the break-down of
August 12, 2007 - 15:48 ET by bigtimerHere is the break-down of the votes from last night for those interested that may not know...
Now pass the butter....
LOL!
Common liberalism: ignore
August 12, 2007 - 17:45 ET by AJCommon liberalism: ignore the small people and call them fools for their petty attempts. Wish she'd read some books on economics. If states like Iowa didn't exist, neither would she.
What a snotty, elitist snob she is.
August 12, 2007 - 23:57 ET by Dave RGeez, I hope she doesn't come down here to Georgia during our primary. Wonder what the hyper-sophisticated (in her own mind) Gail Collins would think of the Stone Mountain Carving? Or the Big Chicken?
Gail Collins actually
August 13, 2007 - 00:58 ET by daveinbocaGail Collins actually graduated from my alma mater, Marquette U. in Milwaukee, and appears to have drunk too much near beer in her mis-spent undergrad days. Seriously, plain Jane pseudos like Gail proliferate in these urban midwestern environments---Minneapolis is another place I've lived chock-full of phony lib broads who are okay in the sack, but empty between the ears. Ditto St. Louis. Chicago is a bit of an exception, as the University of Chicago is a conservative institution and Northwestern ain't as lame-brained as U. of Wisc or U of Ill/Champaign. I also went to the U. of Michigan, along with Chicago the best two schools in the Midwest, and better than any Ivy schools except Penn.
Gail Collins lost her job as Op-Ed editor because she was out of her depth, and her columns now are one level above Robin Given's monstrosities in the Wash Post.
USA4freedom does make some
August 13, 2007 - 01:09 ET by daveinbocaUSA4freedom does make some good points. NJ is full of psychos, as is NYC & environs. Some moron from California named Bainbridge is wondering why people from Iowa, NH & SC are having primaries instead of the airhead elites of LA/Tinseltown, Pelosi/Cindy City on the Bay, and the Mendocino dope farms.
Someone tipped the USA and everything loose and unbalanced slid into Californicator-land. Keep your two ding-bat senators & myriad head-case congress-people and let the USA's leadership be decided by people who value hard work, traditional values, and pay their taxes. After those three states weigh in, places with plug-ugly victims of snobbish academicide like Gail Collins, and the make-over capital of the world in Lotus-Eater land can vote in their own primaries; not that most Americans will be impressed.
I like Giuliani because he tamed the animals allowed to run loose by Dhimmi-crat administrations in NYC.
Even though I’m more of a
August 13, 2007 - 08:37 ET by USA4freedomEven though I’m more of a Fred fan, you have to see the
difference that Giuliani made in NYC. Times square was a drug infested, street
walking hell hole. Now its really nice (if you like big citys).
These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day
Droll
August 14, 2007 - 22:11 ET by botgsorry