Carroll's Cri de Coeur: Globe Columnist Anguished, and It's All America's Fault

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

I don't know James Carroll, but if I were a friend or family member I might truly be concerned. His Boston Globe column of this morning, American Disconnection, is a disjointed lament about the state of the world and his feeling of disconnectedness, invoking the anomie of his youth. What makes it interesting for present purposes is the way in which Carroll, the prototypical MSM liberal, looks at the world, sees a litany of wrongs, and naturally concludes . . . It's All America's Fault.

Carroll seeks to reassure us, and no doubt himself, that "my adult connections are strong, and ever more interesting . . . My friendships are intact. Boredom is a word of absolutely no relevance in my life, nor has youthful moodiness left a stamp on me." He even claims that "I was part of a large, happy family." This from someone whose alienation from his Air Force general father was so intense he famously wrote a book about it: An American Requiem: God, My Father, and the War That Came Between Us.

Carroll recites his bona fides of psychic health as a prelude to admitting:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

I am feeling ambushed by a sensation, exactly, of ineffectual isolation. The endless midafternoon of an August summer day seems all at once the whole of life. Disconnectedness is the heart of it.

And what is the cause of Carroll's angst?

The largest experience of being cut off from what matters of which I am aware involves the American crisis in the Middle East.

The former Roman Catholic priest then ticks off a laundry list of international woe: Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, the West Bank and Gaza. Claims Carroll: "one can fault feuding Iraqi factions, Iranian fantasies of dominance, Pakistani duplicity, Taliban ruthlessness, Hamas intransigence, or Israeli belligerence." But that wouldn't be any fun. No, oh-so-predictably, Carroll looks at all that is wrong in the world and concludes that it is "tied to the behavior of the US government."

Carroll then plunges into serious downer mode, speaking of "a vast population of shamed US citizens" [a bit of projection, perhaps?]. He writes that "private brooding desperately seeks a mode of public action, yet is thwarted." He asks "why shouldn't youthful summer doldrums open into massive civic anguish?"

He concludes with this jeremiad of a final sentence:

"The war has become a god apart, for which now it will really punish everyone."

Gadzooks!

While Carroll's story is clearly a troubled personal one, I'd suggest that in many ways he epitomizes the liberal condition. He looks at the world, sees all its wrongs, feels helpless, anguished and disconnected, and concludes that America is to blame. What a way to go through life.

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net

—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Typical liberal -- a study

Typical liberal -- a study in self-contradiction, and self-loathing projected onto the world around him.

Lee T.

U.S. Navy (ret.) / Vancouver, Washington

The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain

One word James C...........

Medication>

You need some serious help there Mr. Carroll.

 

Good catch Mark.

 

...And joins the growing

...And joins the growing liberal trend. And, moves to Canada. 

“Eppur si muove!" (And yet it moves!) Galileo Galilei

Globe - James Carrol

This self loathing worm is very well known up here in MA.  My group of people (that I will keep secret for fear of their houses being burned down, or shot to death by the radical left) know him for what he is.  A snivelling little troll that is so rediculoulsy borded that he has to contemplate his very existence.  It's a shame, really.  I wonder if it's the huge salary, secure job, or lack of debt that does it? 

What the MSSM doesn't report can kill you.

Is it that bad up there? I

Is it that bad up there? I know the ELF has been burning down new homes and Torching SUV's. But are they doing that up there?  

“Eppur si muove!" (And yet it moves!) Galileo Galilei

He clearly must feel that

He clearly must feel that his success is not earned and he must atone for it.  He sounds like he's searching for something or someone to take the blame for whatever wealth he has when so many are less well off.  Well, I'm one of those less well off Americans and guess what...I think I have a GREAT LIFE.  I am married to my high school sweetheart (38 years next June), I have two beautiful daughters and five wonderful grandchildren, I have more real friends than I can count and I live in the greatest country in the world.  What in the world is there to complain about???

You and Me Both EvilRoy

that makes two of us.  I certainly don't lead any relaxed lifestyle, that's for sure.  My wife and I just moved into our first apartment together, and the utilities are a shocker to say the least.  Then we look around at all the homeboys, hooligans, and general delinquints, and wonder "What the hell are we doing wrong?"  Why am I driving a 97 sh*tbox Lumina, scratching to stay alive, while multiple spanish families walks by us with numerous baby carriages, and wearing the latest fashionably trendy clothes?  what really pisses me off is when they are carting out a big screen TV from Best Buy into their Lincoln Navigator.  You can't tell me they are all superbly skilled, and here legally.  It cant be

 

What the MSSM doesn't report can kill you.

sixstring--

As one who grew up in MA. I suspect he went to a religious school and suffered extreme pangs of guilt as he masturbated in his bathroom, then went to confession and said his mea culpas. Years later, after his first non-solo sexual experience, again he felt sullied and yet, "damn, that was good", kept hitting him in the face. As he moved into a more secular life--the next step was to blame the church (RC) for all his troubled emotions and then finally, blame his dad because James does not have a set and his dad does.

He has not yet reached the stage in his life where he can accept responsibility for his own actions and decisions, thus he must blame someone or something else.

God works in mysterious ways. This drone has been given all the wheels to be a positive life force for himself and those around him, Instead he chooses to whine and try to have everyone feel as hateful and confused as he.

A vast population of shamed

A vast population of shamed US citizens

Yeah, James, ole boy, you have a disconnect alright.  What a load of emotional claptrap. 

And shame on any American that is shamed. 

 

I'd advise this guy to get

I'd advise this guy to get of his house and enjoy the country he has the priviledge of living in.  If he is so ashamed of being an American, perhaps he should move somewhere else and let one of the millions of other people on this planet who so desperately want to be apart of this country and all it stands for take his place.

I think he's one of the

I think he's one of the Kool-Aid glass is half-empty types.

Raspberry Berets And All That Jazz

Someone should inform Mr. Carroll that he is no Henry David Thoreau.  Please stop trying to impersonate him. But Karl Marx called and said thank you.

This self-loathing horse's patoot's comments dovetail nicely with another self-loathing jackass, Terry Moran, who detailed the birth of a terrorist is modernity.  I wouldn't be surprised if Carroll read Moran's suicide note to the world and decided to hop on board the Lib train to nowhere as well.  Their brand of teenage-tinged middle aged man angst should be relegated to coffee shops of yore with the beatniks and the bongos where they would get plenty of finger snaps no doubt.

There is not enough soap nor psychotherapy in all the world to wash their hides or souls of all their wallowing in the mud and self-pity.

We're talking major self-esteem issues here people.

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.

James Carroll,,,another

James Carroll,,,another aging, balding hippy longing for the "good old days" of the `60s.

Smoking Banana Peels

If ever there was a case of an LSD flashback, Mr. Carroll's comments would surely qualify.

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.

First, thanks for the

First, thanks for the "Gadzooks"... it's been years since I've heard that word, and it has been missed.

 I think that people like Carroll are excellent representatives of the closeted life of many Liberals.  They live in their own little worlds, orbiting a small cadre of like-minded folks who agree with their every word, and cringe at the thought of experiencing the real world.  Life is black & white, cause & effect being a game of "one-on-one" and not the confluence of hundreds of different events.

My first trip to Saudi Arabia was the first time that I got to experience a true open press... as odd as that sounds.  Granted, the papers can't write anything anti-Saud or anti-Islam, but other than that the presses are wide open.  What really amazed me was I had no idea how screwed up a world we live in until I read the daily Saudi English paper.  Countries that you rarely ever heard about were strewn with the dead bodies of political adversairies, religious non-believers, cheating spouses, suspected AIDS carriers, and on and on.  Living in America, we have no clue just how many totally screwed-up groups and individuals there are out there, just waiting for a chance to kill this person or that in the name of some personal agenda. 

The US isn't breeding evil or violence in all the places Carroll whines about... it's already there.  It's already thriving.  It's just that most of us in the US don't read, see, or hear about it until someone in the "evil" United States decides to do something about it.    

Delusion, thy name is Mark

I'm wondering if Mark is so completely bubble-wrapped as to not have noticed that the majority of Americans appear to be of the same sentiment as Carroll's so eloquently worded essay? Yes, the MAJORITY. 

Conversely, the Bush/GOP's War appeasers in America who struggle with logic and reality fit snugly somewhere between 26-29% . That would be a MINORITY of Americans who ascribe to the happy gas Bush is currently selling regarding our middle east misadventures. 

Too bad that the deadly folly Bush and his GOP handmaidens have wrought (with the 28%-ers sociopathically cheerleading them on) continues to take lives, destroying a country and diverting attention away from the real culprits of 9/11 and the dangers that face our country. 

And let's not forget that the ungodly amount of money and resources being fed into this war shows at home, with our infrastructure is falling in around us. 

The deadly collapse of a bridge in Minnesota shows our GOP's tax cuts at work, and the misdirection of our tax payer dollars to this war (and we won't even go into the debt that is mounting).

And BTW, the title of this site would give one the impression that it's main reason for existing is "exposing" liberal bias in the media. How does this include opinion and op ed, as in the case of Carroll's piece? After all, Carroll's only writing his opinion - as do David Brooks and Thomas Sowell - but with considerable more plausibility in his work than the rightwing counterparts. (My opinion of course, but I AM part of the MAJORITY these days) 

Try again, "truthsayer"

Want to try that again, "truthsayer", without relying on insults and shallow rhetoric?  

Grow up.

"And let's not forget that

"And let's not forget that the ungodly amount of money and resources being fed into this war shows at home, with our infrastructure is falling in around us."

The frames on my glasses broke last night. If only we had`nt gone into Iraq, and Bush had signed Kyoto, it never would have happened. 

I stopped reading when the

I stopped reading when the poster lost all credibility with this illogical and factually innacurate statement:

The deadly collapse of a bridge in Minnesota shows our GOP's tax cuts at work

 

It was Rove! Rove did it!

Next, the conspiricy theorists will come out saying that the bridge was
demolished intentionally. Hundreds of workers secretly placed
demolition charges on the bridge at night - when no one was
watching.  Moonbat Video will post their latest and "greatest" on
Youtube . . .

(sigh) :-(

Something about people with

Something about people with 3% credability lecturing someone who only has 28%. 

“Eppur si muove!" (And yet it moves!) Galileo Galilei

free---it was---

free---it was---a rather foolish statement! This dude is a hater!

Skew You

1)  The statistics you quote are biased in that the question asked of people gave no room for alternate answers.  Everyone wants the US out of Iraq, but, it's the timing of such a move that people disagree on.  What if the question in the poll had been "Would you support the rapid redeployment of troops out of Iraq now if that meant leaving that country a safehaven for terrorists and an Iranian ally satellite, necessitating a future larger scale, deadlier and costlier battle against an entrenched enemy?"  That is what a majority in the country think but avoid discussing, at least by the Democrats and the Media.  Your "majority" is based upon an incomplete, and therefore false, premise.

2)  The poor state of the Minneapolis bridge has been known for dozens of years.  Multiple Democrat administrations at the local, state and federal levels had every opportunity to "fix" the bridge.  It remains to be seen who was responsible for this fiasco if anyone at all.  Sometimes bad things happen and it is no one's fault.  Then again, there have been billions available to Minnesota over the years for infrastructure repair and development.  Follow the money of the Democrats in that state to see whether it was misappropriated or not before you go off on taxes and out of state individuals and events.  I'll bet dollars to doughnuts plenty was siphoned off for pet projects and individuals on the state and local levels.

3)  Carroll's mewings being printed exemplify the liberal bias in the media.  His self-loathing diatribe isn't fit to be printed in my once a week local paper.  He would, however, be a hit as a pamphlet at the neighboring city's revolutionary bookshop where Marx, Lenin, Che and all the other "darlings" of the "revolution" are celebrated.  Detail how many conservative opine's and colorized "news" stories are given such prominence in The Globe.

4)  Plausibility does not confer nor explicitly mean fact.  Plausability is in the eye of the beholder and subject to all the bias of assumption.  It was plausible that the Sun rotated around the Earth.  Plausibility is why people by lottery tickets and gamble in Las Vegas - afterall, they could win!  Sadly the vast majority just keep losing money. 

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.

What makes you think

What makes you think "everyone" wants us out of Iraq?  What would have happened to post-WWII Europe and Japan if we had pulled out of those areas immediately after WWII?  What would have stopped the Soviets from finishing what Hitler started? 

I don't understand the logic of the rush to leave Iraq, even if things were going swimmingly out there.  Once Iraq is stabilized, we'll have a pro-democracy country in a sea of kingdoms and dictatorships.  Does anyone really believe that these folks will behave themselves in the future?  Even with the heavy US presence in post-war Europe, it wasn't a year before Greece had involved the US and Britain in it's civil war.  If the Allies had completely withdrawn the continent would have been enbroiled in conflict well before North Korea became an issue.

I think we need to stay in Iraq for the next 40-50 years, just as we are still in Europe and Japan, until the people who have known nothing but armed conflict all their lives die and people raised in peace take over.

Explanation

I should not have discounted the handful of psychologically unfit that enjoy conflict.  As such, "everyone" was hyperbole.  I stand corrected.

But I think you have misinterpretateed my comment, and, in reality, we are both on the same page.

I do believe the overwhelming majority of Americans would like to have our military out of everywhere and return them home to America.  Unfortunately, wishes are not horses and beggars still do not ride.  Reality dictates we cannot bring them home from the various places around the globe because of the instability within those regions.  It is imperative to keep an American military presence in Iraq and other places until those places/regions are stable, peaceful, self-reliant for their own security and no longer a threat to the United States, the last being the key issue.

I have said for several years to the "get out of Iraq now" crowd that following WWII, American military occupied Japan for seven years, and that was with a compliant and gregarious population no longer at war where the Japanese toiled greatly in unison to repair their country.  To this day, America still has troops present in Japan by the "invitation" of the Japanese government, even though we all know it is bourne (correctly) out of fear of their aggressive and avaricious neighbors (eg North Korea, China).  Similar statements can be said about post war Germany as well.

Iraq is not a compliant population nor is the region pacified yet.  Oceans that separated continents once were enough of a deterent to prevent attack.  That no longer applies.  The cumulative result is that America will be involved in Iraq and the Middle East for generations.  That's if we have the desire to preserve our way of life. 

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.

Truthsayer trashed

Where to begin?

"I'm wondering if Mark is so completely bubble-wrapped as to not have noticed that the majority of Americans appear to be of the same sentiment as Carroll's so eloquently worded essay? Yes, the MAJORITY. 

Uh oh.  He used caps for 'majority'.  It must be true then.  I'm sure there is a link that we can't see to back up his claim...

Conversely, the Bush/GOP's War appeasers in America who struggle with logic and reality fit snugly somewhere between 26-29% . That would be a MINORITY of Americans who ascribe to the happy gas Bush is currently selling regarding our middle east misadventures. 

Bear with him, folks.  Evidently he is familiarizing himself at with the definitions of 'majority' and 'minority'.  Let's also continue to ignore the fact that Bin laden was handed to Clinton and he refused.  I believe something was distracting the country..?  Something about cheating on ones Wife and then lying to a grand Jury..?  Anywho....

Too bad that the deadly folly Bush and his GOP handmaidens have wrought (with the 28%-ers sociopathically cheerleading them on) continues to take lives, destroying a country and diverting attention away from the real culprits of 9/11 and the dangers that face our country.

I'm sorry.  I though AQ were the ones responisbly for 9/11?  Wouldn't they be the same primatives we are fighting in Iraq?

Let's not kid ourselves truth..  Iraq has never been built up enough to consider anything that's happened to it as 'destroying'. 

And let's not forget that the ungodly amount of money and resources being fed into this war shows at home, with our infrastructure is falling in around us.

Oh God...   BDS.  The lastest talking point reverberating as wildly as anything elese you morons can try to pin on the Bush Administration.  It's called STATE LEVEL RESPONSIBILTY.  I know you libtards like to have government babysit everything, but some people prefer the grown up method.  BTW  How nice of you to also use the victims of that horrible tradgedy as another political stone to throw.  You disgust me.

   

The deadly collapse of a bridge in Minnesota shows our GOP's tax cuts at work, and the misdirection of our tax payer dollars to this war (and we won't even go into the debt that is mounting).

Ah yes...   The hypocritical spending argument.  the Dems are the KINGS of spending.  Let's not get started on the heaps of cash that could have gone to better things besides entitlement programs.   You just don't win that one.  As an aside, I'd rather spend what it takes on a war that is about our very survival, than to sit around and be proud of 'diversity in the workplace' while we sit and wait for the next attack. 

And BTW, the title of this site would give one the impression that it's main reason for existing is "exposing" liberal bias in the media. How does this include opinion and op ed, as in the case of Carroll's piece? After all, Carroll's only writing his opinion - as do David Brooks and Thomas Sowell - but with considerable more plausibility in his work than the rightwing counterparts. (My opinion of course, but I AM part of the MAJORITY these days) 

 And that statement you just made is also an opinion.  Congratulations.  Our website is chock full'o leftwing bias.  Please don't cherry pick the fact that we chose and op-ed from one of the most leftwing biased papers.  That's just pathetic.

The American Revolution Continued  

Coherance or not coherance that is the question

I know that Six String Spiff is trying to say something. Can someone who knows him please translate his meanderings into some form of coherance. Thank you.

Pocomoco

I was responding to "truthsayer"...  I copied his post in Italicsa and gave my replies in bold.  However, the formatting did not keep my spacing.  I don't know why. 

 

 

The American Revolution Continued

LOL! Brilliant satire. BTW,

LOL! Brilliant satire.

BTW, you only THINK you're in the majority. Wake up.

James

Sadly, James Carroll has joined Bill Maher and Rosie in the growing group of self-loathing sickos in the MSM. They need more help than is offered by pop psychologists. And those who hire them for their own profit while ignoring the sicknesses are despicable. Even more digraceful is that so many of these types are teachers in America's classrooms. The same bilious nonsense as Carroll is writing is being pushed on our kids every day, most of the time leaving no room for dissent. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a liberal

Carroll then plunges into

Carroll then plunges into serious downer mode, speaking of "a vast population of shamed US citizens" [a bit of projection, perhaps?]. He writes that "private brooding desperately seeks a mode of public action, yet is thwarted." He asks "why shouldn't youthful summer doldrums open into massive civic anguish?"

 

I charge that the leftist talking heads and politicians, with the eager aid of the MSM, have emotionally and mentally abused the people of this country, much the way a bad parent would a child, by constant berating, accusations of you're horrible selfish people, incessant degradation, ridicule, unfounded blame ... just to name a few.

It would appear Carroll not only was part of inflicting the abuse, but in the process has fallen victim of it himself ... much like self-mutilation.

I have no sympathy for this man ... or any of the others.

Carroll

"While Carroll's story is clearly a troubled personal one, I'd suggest that in many ways he epitomizes the liberal condition. He looks at the world, sees all its wrongs, feels helpless, anguished and disconnected, and concludes that America is to blame. What a way to go through life."

Mark, you stole my thunder. As I read your article some of the same thoughts crossed my mind.

Sigmund Freud would have a field day, or year, with Carroll.

Mark. Carroll, in 1997

Mark, without any doubt, Carroll is liberal and a pacifist thru and thru, and in fact to the best of my recollection, he was quite outspoken, in much the same manner during the 90's with Kosovo, etc.  However, I suspect back then, as with so many (Carter and Mandela condemned the NATO action in Kosovo - not Bill Clinton, by name) Carroll, when distressed as to the role, or lack of a role, of the US abroad, did it by saying, "we." When "we" do this. What "we" have done.  It always seems more partisan, when the "we" involves conservatives, does it not?

And to the point. Carroll should reflect back a bit, as a quick search illustrates that he well understood the nature of the beast - them, not us. But even then, where was he going? 

An Enemy Within The Us Military  Source: Boston Globe | Date: Nov 18, 1997 | By: James Carroll Imagine children being used by soldiers as literal shields, old people forced in front of an enemy by a threatened military elite. Such cowardice is on display in Iraq now, as Saddam Hussein conscripts civilians to encamp at the command posts, missile sites, weapons factories, and communications bunkers likely to be attacked by American bombers and cruise missiles. A nation's armed forces exist as protection for its civilian population -- or as nothing. Saddam's reversal of this order is yet another epiphany of his cynicism.

Face Reality

If all you have to do is sit around and philosophize all day - at government expense (the guy is a professor, right?), you can come up with all kinds of flowery tripe - it doesn't do anyone any good.

While the libs are worrying themselves over the sad condition of the human race, which they refuse to admit as evidence of the sinfulness of man, the people they ridicule are actually doing something to stop the evil.

Libs will never figure it out unless and until they face the reality that evil exists and needs to be resisted.  The cause of good never started a war, but whenever the right side wins a war, humanity benefits.

If you really care about people, and want peace, then you should fight against those who would use force to gain dominance over civilization.  If you stand around with a "Build Bridges, Not Bombs" sign...you're actually helping the people who want you dead.  Wake up!

 

Come to mommy!

Aaah, my poor Jimmy. It's okay. It's okay. That mean Georgie Bush is going away soon and will hurt you no longer. Now here, have a cookie. Alright baby?

Gadzooks! The horror! I love what you say and how you say it

A little gushy I know but I can't help it. Great memory or reasearch also in coming up with that book he wrote that so discredits him.

He is like most liberals, who often pretend to be something they are not because they don't know how else to make their theory sound more plausible. Like the liberals who come on here pretending to be soldiers to try and make their war stance seem more credible or others who claim to be in a profession or religion that they aren't to gain respect on their financial or religious beliefs. He tries to claim a carefree happy life so that the only explanation for his disconnectedness is the government. The sad thing is, other liberals actually believe these people when they imbelish or make things up.

Is Carroll spiritually adrift and scared?

He concludes with this jeremiad of a final sentence:  "The war has become a god apart, for which now it will really punish everyone."

As a young man, Carroll obviously sought spiritual meaning and relevence by earning an ordination in the Catholic Church.  Presumeably, he didn't find it there, and having removed his collar years ago to pursue life's answers in the dogma of the secular Left, it's possible that Carroll is suddenly realizing that he's lost -- that he suffers from a spiritual emptiness -- the kind described by Camille Paglia in this morning's Washington Post.

Consequently, lacking any spiritual frame of reference such a Good v. Evil, he substitutes an earthly entity -- the US -- for all the Evil in the world.  Hence, his reference to "the war has become a god apart."  But that still won't answer his questions or relieve his anxiety.

Or he's just ... well, nuts.

Or he's just ... well, nuts.