Rosa Brooks's Dirty-Harry Doctrine: Al Qaeda 'Got Lucky' on 9/11

Photo of Mark Finkelstein.

Feelin' lucky, punk?

The 9-10 mentality is alive and well and living at the Los Angeles Times. In A really bad case of 'reality', house columnist Rosa Brooks approvingly cites unnamed "experts" thusly:

[Al Qaeda] was little more than an obscure group of extremist thugs, well financed and intermittently lethal but relatively limited in their global and regional political pull. On 9/11, they got lucky — but despite the unexpected success of their attack on the U.S., they did not pose an imminent mortal threat to the nation.

Brooks offers up that analysis in service of her theory that by invading Iraq we have strengthened al Qaeda and transformed it into the threat it hadn't been. Has Brooks forgotten that al Qaeda also "got lucky" everywhere from the U.S. embassy attacks in Africa to the USS Cole to the Khobar towers?

The Dem presidential contenders might want to consider adopting what we might call Rosa Brooks' "Dirty Harry Doctrine." What other terrorist threats are the Dems willing to write off?

Contact Mark at mark@gunhill.net


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Lucky? Wow. How can you

Lucky? Wow. How can you respond to such thoughtless and inane statements like that? 

The New Mantra

So I guess this is the new mantra...Al Queda got lucky. It's the only way for Democrats to win. They know they are weak on securtiy, so they have to downplay the threat. It will be interesting to see how many liberals pick up on this and reiterate it over the next few weeks.

Brooks offers up that analysis in service of her theory that by
invading Iraq we have strengthened al Qaeda and transformed it into the
threat it hadn't been

So is Brooks saying if they "get lucky" again, we should just ignore it in order to not make it worse?

Let's follow the liberal

Let's follow the liberal thought train of the last 5 years:

1.  WTF???  Blow up our Twin Towers will ya???  Kill the b*stards!!! 

2.  Iraq presents a clear and present threat of nuclear weapons and we need to disarm Saddam.

3.  9/11 Commission was right!!! Bush was unprepared!  He should have connected the dots!  It's Bush's fault!   YEEEEARRRGGGHH!

4.  There is no war on terror, it's a bumper sticker.

5.  We need to get out of Iraq because this administration has failed policies. 

6.  Al Qaeda got lucky.

 Forget 911, I dial 9MM.

Rosa

What a blithering idiot..

Really makes you hope the Rove effect is not just a theory, eh?

 

 

What the MSSM doesn't report can kill you.

Rosa says,"If you can just

Rosa says,"If you can just get yer head deep enough into the sand, the terrorists will go away!." And I say, "What this country needs is more chlorine in the gene pool."

Three Monkeys

Rosa has her head buried deep, but it's not in sand... 

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

ROE Effect

My bad, ROE effect...   

 

What the MSSM doesn't report can kill you.

ROE effect SSSpiff, it's

ROE effect SSSpiff, it's been our "dirty" little secret here at VRWC HQ.  Cat's outta the bag now though.  Be interesting now to see if the dems continue "populating" themselves with "illegals" or take it upon themselves to re-popoulate amongst themselves.  Here's their gene pool versus ours.

Men stumble over the truth from time to time, but most pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing happened. -Winston Churchill.

Here's a thought, every

Here's a thought, every time a suicide bomber is successful, the terrorist organization loses the skill to pull off another attack until they find another person skilled or competent enough to be successful.  Hence, the time lags between successful attacks on the US.  Given that the British got lucky with the recent bungled attacks, it stands to reason that most if not all the competent suicide bombers are in Iraq (some were in Pakistan, they were successful).  Sooner or later they are going to run out of competent people to pull off any attack on the US.  But then again, sheer dumb luck does occur.

But as to the growth of al Qaeda since 911, anyone can be a member, the only prerequisit is to be willing to die in a blaze of glory.  As we have seen in Iraq, the entire projection of leadership (fake Iraqi native leader al Baghdadi) and numbers is strictly theater.  They assert their numbers and strength and who is to dispute the assertion?  Any unchallenged assertion becomes truth when accepted by even one idiot.  Unfortunately, we have lots of idiots in this country, they are called liberals.

 

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ran

"they did not pose an

"they did not pose an imminent mortal threat..."

Tell that to one of the "lucky" victims in the twin towers, or on one of those planes.

Oh, yeah, that's right. You can't. They're dead.

 

Reality Check

"...despite the unexpected

"...despite the unexpected success of their attack on the U.S., they did not pose an imminent mortal threat to the nation."

That assinine comment aside - and keeping in mind that I don't agree with the tripe - I would just like to add that while they may not have posed an imminent mortal threat to the nation, we sure as heck posed an imminent mortal threat to their sorry asses - thank you special ops and delta boys and whoever else got to go kick some scrawny sorry cowardly hide-behind-women-and-children butt.  

"Cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war"  - Shakespeare

Amen. All these people

Amen.

All these people blowing themselves up think that they're going to paradise to have sex with virgins...does anyone want to clue them in that they're going to Hell?  Ignorant pyschopaths. 

How is it that most libs

How is it that most libs still don't get it?

This plot was hatch and carried out exposing our weaknesses in, intell gathering, immigration policies and lack of communication among the Law Enforcement and Itell gathering Communities.  These brought about by an attitude of "It is over there, we are safe.  Let us do nothing."While the military screamed "The Threat is real!" and suffered casualty after casualty at Kobar Towers and the USS Cole, the do nothing policies of President Clinton allowed Osama to run amuck in the world.  Our cut and run attitude in Somalia only help boost him in the eyes of Jihadist.  9/11 made him a God. 

WAKE UP LIBS!!!!! 

We are getting back into that attitude that will lead us down that same path.  Keep the pressure on in Iraq.  Screw Pakistan and go into the lawless areas along the Afghan border and kill them in their holes.  Go out and grow a fricking pair!!!!

Lucky is hitting the lottery not killing over 3000 men, women and children.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

Well AF 5_0 you never can

Well AF 5_0 you never can tell with a LA times contributor, she might consider it lucky to see those "rich" people in the towers die. The psychosis IS that deep. The only reason they won't go nuts hitting us right now is Bush. He'll kick their sandy posteriors and they damn well know it. There will be attacks on our soil again, I sadly believe it in my heart. We're too complacent, drug addled, and immoral a nation to stand against the face of true evil in the world.

You can't save the Earth unless You're willing to make other people sacrifice. Dogbert the Green Consultant summing up the elite left.

   Wicked C:  I am

 

 Wicked C:  I am galled to no end how we can't learn.

Example:  The defeat of the John Doe Ammendment.

How the hell is a citizen going to protect themselves from these money hunger greedy SOB's we call Lawyers?  Any LE Officer or Intell man will tell you that the civilian is the greatest source aside the turning of an informant.  They know what's going on.  They see in their community what is not right.What if our boy in NJ had kept his mouth shut?  How many military men and women would be dead right now?

Come on Libs, PULL YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR COLLECTIVE REARENDS!!!!!

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

   "Howthe hell is a

 

 "Howthe hell is a citizen going to protect themselves (sic) from these money hunger greedy SOBs we call lawyers?"  Airforce, I am surprised at you.  The solution has been around for hundreds of years: "The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers."  Shakespeare's Henry VI.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

 MikeB:  The

 MikeB: 

The intelligence of the people of this web site never ceases to amaze me...Bravo!!!

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

I wonder if the words

I wonder if the words "strafe" and "MOAB" can be used together?  If so, they - plus a few awesome B-52s - should pay a visit to the hill country that UBL/OBL calls home. 

So maybe we don't actually get to bring his head back in a box.  At least we'll know we rocked his world :D

"Cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war"  - Shakespeare

HelenS: I say make them

HelenS:

I say make them Mountians flat land.  Easier to plow.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

Or drive a tank over

Or drive a tank over :o)

 "Cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war"  - Shakespeare

The strengthened al Qaeda

The strengthened al Qaeda seems to have less success than when they were an obscure group of extremist thugs. Why is that?

If they were just "lucky",

If they were just "lucky", so what? This is even scarier, because, sooner or later, there will be more terrorist plots, however ineptly planned, that will get "lucky". There doesn't need to be a Dr. Evil running a comprehensive program of destruction to do horrific damage here. If there was, the job of stopping this would actually be easier, it seems to me.

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

I have had a thought

I have had a thought recently,  why we are fighting this war on terror in the conventional manner we are?  If we want to win this battle against radical Islam, and given that these people and this religion have not experienced much change since the 13th century, why are we not fighting this in a manner that would truly affect them?  Stay with me here...  They see it as a great thing to die.  This is one of their goals to become a martyr.  Now of course I can already hear the responses of, well... let's just help them on their way.  Well, that gives them more power in their death to use that to influence another generation of people and the cycle continues.  But, if seen to be "unclean" by their definition, they will not go to paradise and receive their virgins.  So, how do we fight them in a manner that would effect them when they want to die?  Well, I say let's give a new military contract to all the pig farmers in the United States.  A new weapon to be used in this war to really make a difference in the outcome.  If we are to win, don't we want to achieve that goal in the shortest time possible?  After all, the use of the atomic bomb in Japan achieved the desired results and look how horrific that was.  But it did end the war and countrys could rebuild and, for the most part, have enjoyed peace and prosperity.  Now, you can follow this to your own conclusion but visualize an army of pigs marching through the A-Q strongholds, firefighting planes loaded with the blood from the pigs that we can use to help feed our soldiers being dropped on these strongholds.  Now we have truly affected them in a manner that they would understand.  They would be unclean in their minds and if they die would not be martyrs, go to paradise, or receive their virgins.  I could go on and on regarding various strategies about this but please, feel free to talk among yourselves. 

(one can already hear the liberal response to this posting)

Viper

visualize an army of pigs marching through the A-Q strongholds

Viper, thank you!

I'll be in a good mood all day thinking about that.   :-)  I love it!

_______
Fred Thompson and Ann Coulter walk into a bar. The bar is instantly destroyed because that much awesome cannot be contained in one build.

With their unit patch

With their unit patch proudly on display.  The Big Red One??? 

Oh, so much effort.  For a

Oh, so much effort.  For a muslim, the worst thing you can do is burn the body of the dead. Burning the body supposedly bars the soul's entrance to heaven, if I understnd it properly.  So following the line of thinking you mentioned, publicly announce that every al Qaeda and insurgent killed will have their bodies burned.  Hence no more maryters.

 

“The object of life is not to be on the side of the majority but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane"

Speaking of burning, throw

Speaking of burning, throw in a little baking by the enemy, this is the latest I read about yesterday that they are still doing to terrify people who may fight them ect...

Media is mum about this for the most part, heck for all of the msm as far as I have seen anywhere.

I am not familiar with that,

I am not familiar with that, but I'm going to do some research.  If that's true, a public cremation ceremony could be another avenue.  And as you have stated, no more martyrs.  Being viewed as a martyr seems to be a common thread and that may put this on a level that might be understood.