Honor Killing Omitted in Weinstein Movie at Iranian-American Group's Insistence


According to London's Guardian and a press release issued by the National Iranian American Council, the NIAC forced significant changes in the upcoming movie “Crossing Over.” The movie's plot featured an Iranian family, and all scenes relating to an honor killing and the phrase “family honor” were removed after “ongoing conversations” with the director.

If “significant changes” were not made, the NIAC threatened that the film would “generate serious backlash against the Iranian American community.”

After the complaint, the producer “immediately contacted” the NIAC and “agreed to take its concerns into consideration.” Even more surprising was how much access and influence the NIAC had over the Weinstein film starring Sean Penn and Harrison Ford (my emphasis throughout):

NIAC later submitted its analysis and suggestions to the production team, which changed elements of the script and even re-shot certain scenes. The final product, the director says, does not include any reference to "family honor" and does not depict an honor killing.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

That is a lot of influence. The Guardian expanded why the NIAC was upset:

"Honour killings are accepted in some Middle Eastern cultures but not accepted in Iranian culture," NIAC president Trita Parsi said. "They sometimes happen in remote areas of Iran, but there are no cases of Iranians doing this in the US."

"While we believe strongly in freedom of expression, we also believe in the importance of constructive dialogue between artists and the communities they seek to portray," a Weinstein Company spokeswoman said. Crossing Over opens in the US later in the year.

Really? Weinstein believes in “constructive dialog” with the communities they portray? Where was this “dialog” when Weinstein made “Dogma,” a movie critical of Catholicism (but funny nonetheless)? Other ethnic/religious groups are not given the same consideration in Hollywood and have accepted movie inaccuracies. The IRA kept the violence out of the US, but that didn't deter Hollywood, as with “Blown Away's” IRA bombings in Boston.

Rather than address the honor killings and violence against Muslim women, the NIAC worried about PR and their “true achievements” at the close of their press release:

 

NIAC president, Dr. Trita Parsi, attributed the success to the power of outreach and dialogue. "The Iranian-American community should engage in dialogue with directors and producers in Hollywood to ensure that the depiction of Iranian Americans reflect the community's true achievements," he said.

Notice the similar wording to Weinstein's comment. I'm sure he'll have “constructive dialog” to ensure “Dogma” director Kevin Smith's upcoming horror movie set among Christian fundamentalism, “Red State,” will “reflect the community's true achievements.”

Of course, that won't happen, and that's not necessarily a bad thing. Hollywood screams about artistic integrity until the “right” group complains, then they bend over backwards to appease. Although it would be nice for a non-liberal slant in a movie now and then, Smith should be able to make his movie the way he wishes, poetic license intact, unless, of course he casts Ben Affleck—then all bets are off. No justice, no peace.

 

**Image by Jason Decrow/AP

Contact Lynn with tips or even complaints at tvisgoodforyou2 AT yahoo DOT com


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

NIAC sounds like first cousins to the CAIR crowd.

"The Iranian-American community should engage in dialogue with
directors and producers in Hollywood to ensure that the depiction of
Iranian Americans reflect the community's true achievements,"

So, when do we get to see the movie about Iranian Americans who secretly support Iran building nukes for the express purpose of blowing Israel off the face of the Earth?

Once again, Western Society caves in to the "demands" of the Islamists. How sad.

I guess that since they

I guess that since they removed the scenes from the movie that must mean that honor killings just don't happen in real life.

Disclaimer

All they would have had to do was put a disclaimer in the opening credits.  The fact that they went to such lengths to censor their own work means they're afraid of something... reprisals, perhaps?

Exactly!  Besides,

Exactly!  Besides, wouldn't the controversy surrounding the movie translate into a greater number of people seeing the movie?  The only reason they caved was due to reprisals, or the desire to be politically correct, neither of which is the case when they make movies about Christians or other groups.

Dutch

Repraisals? Let's not

Repraisals? Let's not sugar-coat it.

They were in imminent danger of being killed by not cooperating with these islamofascists.

Just TRY to make a movie based strictly on the Koran's depictions of Mohammad.

You'll be dead before the ink on the screenplay is dry.

The Truth About Islam....

shall not be heard if the Muzzies have their way...  Their real goals...not the ones they let you hear, will astound the uninitiated. CAIR...the enemy within. Happy Trails...

Couple of thoughts: there's

Couple of thoughts: there's a difference between a drama (this movie) and a comedy (Dogma). Inaccuracies are often part of the equation in a comedy. If Iranians don't believe in honor killings, then perhaps they shouldn't be in the movie, especially considering how tense relations are between us and the Middle East. 

If Iranians don't believe

If Iranians don't believe in honor killings (actually, they do), then perhaps they
shouldn't be in the movie, especially considering how tense relations
are between us and the Middle East.

Yeah, who wants to increase tensions. I guess we should also cover up all our women, take away their right to vote, drive, work, divorce, etc.

While we are appeasing the radical islamofascists, we should also ban the bible, burn down all churches and synagogs and chase all the pigs and dogs out of the country.

Wouldn't want to offend anyone.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Thank goodness you didn't

Thank goodness you didn't go overboard.

}}---> Our last defenders

Our last line of defense may be PETA as the Muzzlies drive pigs and dogs to extinction.

And Iran, Iran So Far Away...(Flock Of Seagulls)

The Guardian article says that an Iranian-American NOT invovled with the film read the screenplay and complained to NIAR.  (Look, you're either Iranian or you're an American.  It's time to stop with the half-assed monikers)  NIAR then approached the director and an unnamed actor to get the honor killing scene out of the movie.  Wonder who that unnamed actor was (cough, sean pennis) and why it is so secret?

Another interesting development, from http://www.niacouncil.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=859&Itemid=2 :

"the Bay Area Iranian-American Democrats (BAIAD), a small grassroots political organization based in northern California", have convinced "the California Democratic Party to pressure Congress to oppose unprovoked military action against Iran and the use of sanctions as a ‘tool of escalation’…and instead support direct talks between the United States and Iran without preconditions.”

"The resolution comes in the wake of the Assembly’s approval of legislation last month that would compel the state’s public employees' and school teachers' retirement funds to divest from any business with ties to Iran’s defense or petroleum sectors. The California Public Divest from Iran Act would prohibit the California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers Retirement System (CalSTRS) from putting money into companies that have $20 million or more invested in Iran’s defense, petroleum development, or nuclear sectors. The bill would also compel CalPERS and CalSTRS to withdraw funding from all companies that have business operations in Iran."

That's two big coups for Iranians/Iranian-American special interest groups in 3 weeks.

Isn't that special.

Killing them with kindness isn't working.  Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.