Today's run-off election for Georgia's Senate between incumbent Republican Saxby Chambliss and Democrat Jim Martin has attracted a lot of attention, especially because it could put the Democratic majority one seat closer to the 60 seats needed for a filibuster-proof Senate. Michael Grunwald of Time magazine has a story up today about the importance of the outcome of the race, but instead of giving a fair-and-balanced look at how both candidates would affect the Senate, Grunwald uses the piece to attack Chambliss for being a "textbook Bush-Cheney Republican" and praise Martin for potentially being a repudiation of Bush and a "candidate of the middle class."
Grunwald starts off by reminding readers that Georgia is still "an extremely conservative state" despite a Time magazine article from June which wondered if Georgia would be "Obama's Ohio" in the election. The writer uses this characterization of Georgia to frame Martin's potential win as "a crowning embarrassment for the GOP" and attacks Republicans by saying it would "rival Obama's own victory as a repudiation of the Bush agenda of tax cuts for the rich, pork for the well-connected, belt-tightening for the working poor, drill-baby-drill, strict-construction judges and military adventurism." That's when the Chambliss-bashing starts, as Grunwald goes on to say, "not to mention the political cynicism that made Chambliss notorious after his ads in 2002 comparing his opponent, triple-amputee Max Cleland, to Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein."
Later in the article, Grunwald goes on to rip Chambliss as a "near-parody of a Bush-Cheney Republican," claiming Chambliss has:
supported Bush on just about everything but its efforts to rein in outrageous farm subsidies. He is so tight with the sugar industry that he attacked a whistleblower who reported safety problems after an explosion at a Georgia mill killed 14 people. He has been an ardent supporter of sending American troops into harm's way even though he avoided serving in Vietnam through student deferments, as well as an allegedly bum knee that hasn't hampered his reputation as one of the best golfers in Congress. On a recent appearance on Fox News, he warned that if he isn't re-elected, "you're going to see an economic stimulus like you won't believe." As if that would be a bad thing!
On the other hand, Grunwald describes Martin as simply "a mild-mannered former state legislator and human resources commissioner who is unusually progressive for a statewide candidate in Georgia."
Grunwald's biggest worry, though, is that a win by Chambliss would "reinforce the dangerous message that recent electoral results have been sending to Republicans" which is that moderates, like Connecticut congressman Christopher Shays and North Carolina gubernatorial candidate Pat McCrory, lose elections while most Republican "survivors" are conservative. Grunwald argues that Chambliss's win would move the party further in his direction, which Grunwald describes as being "even more white, even more to the right, even more eager to fight."
According to Gruwnald, the view by many conservatives that the Republican Party is too moderate is untrue. He claims that Republicans in Washington have not failed to defend traditional values as they "got two conservative justices on the Supreme Court, passed all kinds of laws restricting abortion and stem-cell research, and practically shut down the government to try to save Terri Schiavo." He goes on to say that there is "little evidence that Americans soured on the GOP because of its profligacy" and uses John McCain's "crusade against earmarks" to prove that Americans "don't seem to be crying out for austerity and deregulation." But is McCain the best example of a "conservative" Republican to use? He did support the $700 billion bailout to buy bad mortgages and the debt of large institutions, and that's when his poll numbers really began to go downhill.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Pulling for Saxby
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 11:14 ET by littlemissmuffinSaxby, we are pulling for you to win.
"If we conservatives moved to those seven non-existent States, the government couldn’t find us and tax us to death!"
i voted this morning for the man
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 11:24 ET by bubbatech01God help us if the demorats gain total control of the government. goodbye self-reliance, hello crack-whore welfare subsidies.
I hope Saxby does pull them
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 11:24 ET by ConservativeRexI hope Saxby does pull them to the right. Someone had better!
And then everyone else we elect in 2010 does the same.
Reporting and Opinion
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 11:35 ET by KC MulvilleThis is, so far as I can tell, presented as a political news report. It isn't presented as opinion or advocacy. It's supposed to be an "objective" report.
It's really hard to see how this could be taken as "objective."
Grunwald Is Another Journalistic Disgrace
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 11:40 ET by rammingspeedMichael Grunwald is another "journalist" in the MSM who is boldly coming out even more in unabashedly displaying his extreme left wing bigotry. The Dems are full of themselves for now, but winning elections has always been proven to be a momentary triumph.
Grunwald's whole life is obviously staked to getting his way in politics. That guarantees that he will, once again, be bitterly disappointed, as the pendulum makes it's inevitable swing away from what he wants.
Then I get to watch. I loves me my schadenfreude.
Time isn't worth the paper
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 12:22 ET by exLibIt's printed on.
Even before my conversion I thought Time wasn't very good. That was in the 90s, and I never realized it was a leftist rag, although maybe it wasn't so much back then.
Around 2001 or so some door-to-door college student collecting funds signed me up for a Time subscription and then I started to notice how leftward leanning they were.
Calling Ruth Bader Ginsberg a centrist was the final straw for me. A few years ago they rated all 9 Supremes and couldn't find a liberal in the bunch. Ginsberg and Souter were labeled "centrists" and it went from right of center to lunatic fringe from there. I told them to cancel me.
So this kind of thing doesn't surprise me much. I am sure they though Lincoln Chafee was too far to the right, that's why he lost RI.
From the "battlefield"...
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 12:52 ET by on-the-rocksthis morning, a more astute observer, Neal Boortz, suggested that some Ga. Democrats would vote for Chambliss out of fear that too much control might lead Democrats to "overreach" and trigger a 1994-style voter backlash in 2010.
Before I got to work (and leave the radio), at least one self-identified Democrat caller agreed with him.
The election of Chambliss and the survival of Norm Coleman in Minnesota would preserve at least a shred of "checks-and-balances" in the Senate and help keep Pelosi and Reid under some sort of control.
Dec 06 vs Dec 08
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 12:56 ET by ScrapironSimply ask yourself if the country is in better shape today than it was in Dec 06. We are experiencing the effect of a democrat led congress for the past two years. How much damage can/will they do with total control? I don't think the 'typical' white working American is going to like it. The liberal elitest are also losing their high paying positions (most don't have a job) by the hundreds of thousands. CEO/CFO's, editors and reporters are going to find a world of difference on their new jobs at McDonalds, that is if they can qualify.
I, along with my brothers and sisters, will be planting a large food crop (family use only) next spring. Got enough canned and in the freezer (lots of venison) to last the winter.
Old, Retired and glad of it.
You want to know what's
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 13:16 ET by ConservativeRexYou want to know what's sweet?
My son got stationed to Ft Gordon, in Augusta earlier this year from Ft Hood.
He's been in Georgia long enough to vote for Saxby! LOL And he is telling everyone in his company to do the same!
Dadgum. I did at least one thing right!
Great job, Rex!
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 14:39 ET by littlemissmuffinGlad your son will be able to vote for Saxby.
Next time you talk with your son, please extend my appreciation to him for serving our country!
"If we conservatives moved to those seven non-existent States, the government couldn’t find us and tax us to death!"
I am a Georgia conservative, and Grunwald can jump in the lake.
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 16:27 ET by R D HelmI got to my local polling place today, and was very disappointed that there were only three voters in the place. We were out-numbered by the poll workers. It is being reported that turnout is about 30%.
I hope my fellow Georgians aren't about to hand Barack Hussein Obama a defeat-proof congressional majority.
If you are an eligible voter in Georgia and haven't voted yet, get out there and vote!
-Dave
When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.
RD
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 17:41 ET by littlemissmuffinI have family in Georgia and they voted early. I asked when I talked with them this past Sunday. Maybe other people voted early, too? I sure hope Saxby wins.
"If we conservatives moved to those seven non-existent States, the government couldn’t find us and tax us to death!"
Hey Dave and lmm... I was
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 17:55 ET by bigtimerHey Dave and lmm...
I was going to go to OT to ask if anyone in the state had heard how things are going, just got done listening to Saxby on Hannity, I sure hope he wins, polls close in about an hour I think?
I've heard the latest tactics filthy Franken is doing too in Minn., no matter what, Reid has enough with the RINOs to stop almost all filibusters unfortunately...
I hope I can keep my cool, during the next two years, let alone four!
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Haven't heard anything yet
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 19:17 ET by littlemissmuffinBeen checking Fox News, but nothing yet. Might try World Net Daily.
"If we conservatives moved to those seven non-existent States, the government couldn’t find us and tax us to death!"
Saxby wins. Now we BETTER
Wed, 12/03/2008 - 11:07 ET by HockeyKidSaxby wins. Now we BETTER be electing more genuine conservatives in upcoming cycles! If I hear one more pundit claim W is a real conservative, I'm going to puke. He's been good for national security, but the reach and size of federal government is absolutely out of control.
Hire conservatives! Fire everybody else!
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
Saxby isn't so innocent.
Wed, 12/03/2008 - 11:27 ET by Georgia7What's the GOP's fact-finding crew's take on Chambliss' 2004 victory over Max Cleland? You know, the triple amputee Vietnam vet that Saxby and Rovey declared a terrorist? Of course, Chambliss and Rove sure know all about Vietnam, they readed about it.
So Chambliss is 2 - 0 against veterans.
The fact that Cleland was a
Wed, 12/03/2008 - 11:43 ET by R D HelmThe fact that Cleland was a triple-amputee Vietnam vet doesn't excuse his socialist political leanings.
Cleland was handed the defeat he deserved.
-Dave
When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.