CNN Frets Bill Clinton Was Too Conservative

  • Bookmark and Share

Christine Romans, CNN American Morning | NewsBusters.orgThursday's edition of CNN's "American Morning" featured a "fact checking" segment on the claims former President Bill Clinton made about his accomplishments as president during his speech to the Democratic National Convention. The segment wasn't much of a "fact check" as CNN Business Correspondent Christine Romans mostly reminisced about the "glory days" of the '90's. But what she did find was that the worst part of Clinton's presidency was one of his more conservative actions: "He also signed into law a historic deregulation of the financial system, dismantling laws from the Great Depression that many say would have protected us against the current mortgage crisis."

Other problems the correspondent found with Clinton's presidency include: "the go-go days of the '90s also gave us the dotcom boom. And when that went bust, Allan Greenspan and the Federal Reserve lowered the interest rates to ease the pain. Dropping them so low, many now see the roots of the current housing mess way back in the dotcom boom. Plus, the '90s gave us this obsession with record home ownership with Clinton as a principal cheerleader."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Romans, of course, included praise of Clinton in her report, saying "Well, you know, Bill Clinton is and rightfully credited with being the president who resided over the longest economic expansion in American history." She also reminisced about the "incredible" '90's, claiming, "But you can't really argue with some of these job creation and poverty numbers from the '90s. It was an incredible period."

However, Romans failed to investigate Clinton's statements about the current Bush administration in which he argued, "They took us from record surpluses to an exploding debt. From over 22 million new jobs to just five million. From increasing working families' incomes to nearly $7,500 a year to a decline of more than $2,000 a year. For almost eight million Americans lifted out of poverty to more than 5.5 million driven into poverty and millions more losing their health insurance." It is possible to argue that a good number of the more than 5 million people "driven into poverty" Clinton noted are actually illegal immigrants who have entered the country in the past eight years.

A transcript of the August 28 segment follows:

7:34 a.m.
KIRAN CHETRY: Well, former President Bill Clinton gave Barack Obama one huge endorsement last night saying he is ready to lead. His campaign coined the phrase "it's the economy, stupid." Clinton supporters say that his policies led to unprecedented gains, but his critics argue that the housing crisis really has its roots in the '90s when Clinton was in charge. Business correspondent Christine Romans is here with a little bit of fact check for us about this. I guess, there's two ways to look at this. There's different sides.

CHRISTINE ROMANS, CNN BUSINESS CORRESPONDENT: Sure. Well, you know, Bill Clinton is and rightfully credited with being the president who resided over the longest economic expansion in American history. And he used that part of his legacy to slam the Bush administration and the Republicans.

PRES. BILL CLINTON, FMR. U.S. PRESIDENT: They took us from record surpluses to an exploding debt. From over 22 million new jobs to just five million. From increasing working families' incomes to nearly $7,500 a year to a decline of more than $2,000 a year. For almost eight million Americans lifted out of poverty to more than 5.5 million driven into poverty and millions more losing their health insurance.

ROMANS: So, quick fact check. Let's look at some of those numbers over the eight years. 22 million jobs, the lowest jobless rate in 30 years. From record deficit to record surplus, average family income rose, poverty fell.

But Kiran, the go-go days of the '90s also gave us the dotcom boom. And when that went bust, Allan Greenspan and the Federal Reserve lowered the interest rates to ease the pain. Dropping them so low, many now see the roots of the current housing mess way back in the dotcom boom. Plus, the '90s gave us this obsession with record home ownership with Clinton as a principal cheerleader. He also signed into law a historic deregulation of the financial system, dismantling laws from the Great Depression that many say would have protected us against the current mortgage crisis.

Now, here we are. Hindsight is always 20/20. But some people are looking back and saying, wow, maybe some of the moves that we made way back then kind of led, started us on the path to where we are here today. But you know, a lot of folks say presidents get too much credit and too much blame for the economy. But you can't really argue with some of these job creation and poverty numbers from the '90s. It was an incredible period.

CHETRY: Very interesting. Christine, thanks.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

If and when Obama loses,

If and when Obama loses, Bill Clinton will have the last laugh. While I have no use for him, he was at least smart enough to move an inch or two in our direction during his administartion. 

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

Right Nbb... He and Hill

Right Nbb...

He and Hill both did what they had to do to save their political butts and retain power while they are seething behind the scenes and their smiles...they will have the last laugh...

Obamamessiah is getting past old and very wearing on all of the normal people in this world...over-saturation by the msm has been our best friend...maddening yes, frustrating yes...but they have dug a deep hole of their own making and Obama is going to go down into it along with all of them in Nov.

I can't wait!

Shovel anyone?

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Ah, no Christine, they

Ah, no Christine, they would not have, but the finger of blame you point at the Clintons is still justified given that the morons he appointed to run Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac lowered lending standards for their quasi-government organization to buy mortgages.  It was their incompetence allowing people who had no business buying a house to get loans under the failed liberal policy of Equality of Outcome.  In lowering those lending standards they created a free for all environment sparking housing speculation thus driving up prices and creating the insentive to over build the market.  All bubbles must burst and of course just like with Clinton's incompetence responding to terrorism causing 911, Bush got stuck cleaning up that mess too.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

Operation Destroy America

Should Biden be blamed for the foreclosures in CA?

Why isn't Obama being identified as the major ACORN supporter?

How did the F Mae/F Mac benefit a prospering housing market?

GDP just came in at more than a 3% yet all future expectations continue to be negative?

Biden wanted to split Iraq into three sections yet the war was a total success. And Biden wants to pull out?

Nobody wants to drill, all want increased taxes and free health care.

Clinton left Bush with an economic depression which nobody will admit. Sick of predicted surpluses being shoved into your face?

Last night the argument was who in society has the privilege to pursue opportunity. Certainly the wealthy must be punished. Imagine all of the middle class being debated, should they be given a chance at a better life? Doesn't jive with the above.

JDW


DAILY WAVE

How did the F Mae/F Mac

How did the F Mae/F Mac benefit a prospering housing market?

Don't eat before you read otherwise you will have a mess to clean up...

Political appointees to the companies’ boards pocket millions in stock options to bolster support on Capitol Hill. Clinton-appointed board members at Fannie Mae include Marc Rich lawyer Jack Quinn and Janet Reno’s lieutenant at the Justice Department, Jamie Gorelick. At the helm of Fannie Mae is another Clinton appointee, Franklin Raines, who was paid more than $4 million and had almost $6 million in unexercised stock options in his first year at the helm. http://michellemalkin.com/2006/12/19/crackdown-on-fannie-mae-corruptocrats/ 

Revving the housing market made these crooks rich, when the market crashed, the suckers who bought after them got screwed.  What the heck did they care when they undermined the entire housing industry, banks and bond funds using derivatives based on their unsound loans????  Another sucker, the US taxpayer, will have to clean up the mess.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

Understood

We are on the same side.

Questions reflect the title, incessant lib effort to destroy America. Tonight culminates in a fictional Greek god yes-we-can. Blue Oyster Cult will sing Don't Fear The Reaper (RNC). The entire convention is a joke. It trashes capitalism and freedom. What are we going to hear about his leftist objectives? I listed questions about them.

JDW


DAILY WAVE

I figured it was

Views of the Clinton economic legacy.. left and right..

More views of the Clinton economic legacy..from the left and the right..

 I'd suggest that CNN should just put them out for public dialog and discussion; this constant pandering of the Dems and their associates, the MSM of "Sure. Well, you know, Bill Clinton is and rightfully credited with being the president who resided over the longest economic expansion in American history.." bla bla bla - what a white wash.

From the left:

Dean Baker, CEPR (loved by the mainstream media - notably PBS and the LA Times):

 March 16, 2000 - "The main feature of the 'new economy' is a stock market bubble of unprecedented magnitude. When the bubble bursts, the new economy will just be a bad memory....  What are you going to tell people who lose much of their retirement savings in their 401K when there's a downturn?"

March, 2001 - "the nation's political leaders chose to ignore the stock market bubble" -- and "as a result, millions of families have seen their dreams of a secure retirement or their children's college education vanish.,, As a result, millions of families have seen their dreams of a secure retirement or their children's college education vanish with the stock market bubble. The level of negligence of the nation's political leaders in ignoring the stock bubble exceeds anything since the days of Herbert Hoover."

For another good read from Baker; one that the MSM kept from the Democrat voters, see: Bursting Bubbles

Funny  - I didn't hear any of that at the convention!

More from the left (this one is current):

The Legacy of the Clinton Bubble, By Timothy A. Canova. Oh, once again, we find that many of our current woes - as viewed from the liberal side of the isle - find their roots firmly planted in the Clinton administration. A few excerpts:

THE CONVENTIONAL wisdom has held that economic policy was a great success under Bill Clinton in the 1990s and a failure ever since. Hillary Clinton has made the comparison often, promising to end “the seven year detour” and “attack poverty by making the economy work again.” In January, in response to the president’s State of the Union Address, Barack Obama stated that it was “George Bush’s Washington that let the banks and financial institutions run amok and take our economy down this dangerous road.”

Perhaps this reading of history makes for good politics in an election year, and it is certainly better for the Clintons than for anyone else. The only problem is that the story line is flawed. One could even say that it’s a bit of a fairy tale.

[..]

The trade deficit increased most dramatically at the end of the Clinton years. In 1999, the U.S. merchandise trade deficit surpassed $338 billion, a 53 percent increase from $220 billion in 1998

[..]

Predatory lending was not an invention of the Bush administration. High-interest payday loans and subprime mortgages took off under Clinton. The morals of the marketplace were once again, “Buyer beware.” Many loans, tellingly referred to as “teaser loans,” were structured so that the monthly mortgage payments would start off low and rise significantly in the future, even while the overall loan amount—the outstanding principal—would also rise. The borrower would end up worse off several years into the mortgage than when the loan began.

But none of this was considered overly problematic by the Clinton White House.

[..] -- and my favorite...

Chickens Come Home to Roost - HISTORY SHOULD deal harshly with Bill Clinton

And.. from the right:

May, 2007 - Bush's Real Record On The Economy

Bizarrely, polls show that many people think the economy has fallen into a recession. Or that we never left the slump that began in March 2001, a bare month and a half after Bush entered office, and that ended in November of the same year.

Last summer, a national poll taken by American Research Group showed 38% of Americans thought the economy was in a recession. By last month that had fallen to 28%, but it's still a big share. Of course, we weren't in a recession. Nor is it the case, as also has been asserted, that "things got worse" under Bush.

What factually is true is Bush faced the greatest economic challenge of any incoming president since President Reagan. Like Reagan, Bush met the challenge — something for which the media and his foes refuse to give him credit.
It's hard to overemphasize how nasty things were. But the media were too busy penning loving tributes to President Clinton to note that the economy was falling apart as he left office. ..

..which includes this tremendously revealing graphic:

The Greatest Destruction of Wealth in U.S History

Now, as we reflect back on the views of the left and the right, and comtemplate Tom Blumer's presentation of the more of the good economic news that the MSM just happened to forget to inform the voters of today, we are reminded of one sad fact: the MSM is completely managing to keep the news and views the  voters deserve, censored from the voters. Every aspect of the MSM's presentation is focused on simply putting and keeping Democrats in power. 

Now they have a new

Now they have a new dreamboat - Obama, they talk trash about their ex- highschool sweetheart hunk -  Bill Clinton. These girls are sooo fickle.

McNotObama '08