HuffPo Blogger Fired for Using Press Creds to Abet Union Protesters
Just because the site was founded by an alleged plagiarist doesn't mean it's totally devoid of ethical clout. Though you do have to wonder: from where does the Huffington Post recruit its bloggers?
The site reportedly informed one of its unpaid contributors last week that he was being let go. The offense: he had used his press credentials as a HuffPo blogger to get labor union demonstrators access to a Mortgage Bankers Association event, where they staged a rowdy protest.
Yahoo News reporter Joe Pompeo wrote of the event on Monday:
The commotion attracted a fair amount of media attention -- even CNBC gave it some airtime that afternoon. But what didn't make it into the news reports was how the union members gained access into the conference -- held at Washington's posh JW Marriott -- in the first place.
As it turns out, they were abetted by Mike Elk, a 24-year-old freelance labor journalist who secured press credentials to the event through his affiliation as a blogger with the Huffington Post, and who then passed those credentials off to one of the union organizers.
That move cost Elk, well, his unpaid gig as a Huffington Post blogger.
"I'm sorry to say we are revoking your access to our blog and ending our association," Peter Goodman, HuffPo's business editor, wrote to Elk in a Jan. 20 email obtained by The Cutline. "I appreciate that what happened yesterday was a poor decision on your part, one made on the spur of the moment, but it was simply over the line from an ethical standpoint and it would compromise our integrity to have you continue to write for us or represent us in any way."
Elk, who said he has contributed more than 100 posts since being recruited as a blogger in 2009 by the website's national editor, Nico Pitney, sees it differently.
"I never lied to anybody at any step in this process," he told The Cutline on Friday. "There is a tradition in labor journalism to be active participant journalists," he added, citing Michael Moore, who also blogs for HuffPo. "This is a tactic union organizers use all the time."
Perhaps Elk's problem has to do with his invocation of Michael Moore and union organizers as exemplars of journalistic integrity. Again, it is refreshing to see HuffPo do the right thing in this instance, but one has to wonder how a person with such a skewed perception of honest journalistic practices got the gig in the first place.
As Pompeo reminded us, this is not the first time the site's contributors have demonstrated a considerable lack of basic ethics in their reporting. HuffPo has not always been as proactive as it was in this instance:
Indeed, it's not the first time one of HuffPo's unpaid contributors acted outside the realm of traditional journalistic standards. Most famously, there was Mayhill Fowler, the former HuffPo blogger who in the lead-up to the 2008 election taped a conversation with Bill Clinton without his knowledge that he was either speaking to a journalist or being recorded.
Fowler, of course, was allowed to keep writing until she eventually severed her own ties with the website because it refused to pay her for her posts.
For his part, Elk slammed HuffPo for buying into a "corporatist" model of journalism.
- Lachlan Markay's blog
- Login to post comments















Comments
He thought what he was doing IS honest Journalism.
Submitted by Ashrak on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 8:14pm.
"There is a tradition in labor journalism to be active participant journalists,"
Yeah, that "tradition" is far from limited to labor.....and it has almost grown beyond the ability to hide it anymore.
Ashrak, I'm Sure You're Right
Submitted by Boil It Down on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 9:49pm.
Elk's actions preclude objectivity which is vital to any real journalist. HuffPo and apparently many other media outlets should probably review their policies on vetting who gets press credentials and precisely how they are to be used.
If labor leaders commonly use the press as a tool for their message the press violates the Journalist Code of Ethics. That would be a huge story on it's own.
He must of been an unpaid" Blogger Author"..
Submitted by jorae on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 9:58pm.
Anyone can blogg at their site. Only a few people have been given the rights to start threads. I assume he was one of them.
The offense: he had used his press credentials as a HuffPo blogger to get labor union demonstrators access to a Mortgage Bankers Association event, where they staged a rowdy protest.
Actually, what he did is wrong. And Huffpo caught him doing it, and let hime go...
Where's the beef?
Mike Elk? Palin is behind this, mark my words
Submitted by SickofLibs on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 8:15pm.
.
Nevermind
Submitted by Dave. on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 10:17pm.
-Dave
Vote for the American in November
As it turns out, they were
Submitted by bkeyser on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 9:02pm.
As it turns out, they were abetted by Mike Elk, a 24-year-old freelance labor journalist who secured press credentials to the event through his affiliation as a blogger with the Huffington Post, and who then passed those credentials off to one of the union organizers.
Okay, with apologies to all of you 20-somethings- what is a 24 y.o. doing blogging for HuffPo anyway? In most cases, a mid-20-something knows next to nothing about the world and the way it works, and surely a lib labor union writer knows less than half of the depiction just described. Did Zsa Zsa put the pool boy to work over the winter?
Secondly, ethics and bad press are not necessarily synonymous though one is likely the result of the other.
And finally, doesn't this smack of James O'Keefe-like antics? Wouldn't this be covered differently if the character was O'Keefe, the activists Tea Partiers, and the demonstration led by Al Sharpton?
Internet experience comes before age...
Submitted by jorae on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 10:27pm.
Noah Kristula-Green is a Web Intern at The New Republic. and now does Blog Thread titles...He looks like he is in his 20's...
Internet Experience before age..
jorae
Submitted by bkeyser on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 10:37pm.
Being able to type and understanding the world and how it works are not the same thing. I'm sure there are exceptions, but in general, I see too many young journalists today with nothing more than a college degree and penchant for parroting their professors.
No offense intended if you're a 20-something -I was once myself- but I'm wise enough to know what I didn't know at that time. Internet experience is no substitute for life experience.
I'm not saying it is
Submitted by jorae on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 10:50pm.
I'm not saying it is right...in fact, I completely agree with you. But pandering to the youth is a selling tool. Do we know the different ages of the thread writers on NB?
Sometimes, the subject matter seems pretty immature to me...but who's to say what appels to the internet crowd. I think a lot of people who make decisions, feel they tare he majority on political blogs... so, get a staff that thinks like them.
jorae
Submitted by bkeyser on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 11:10pm.
Well, that depends on your business model. If you want to include a "younger crowd" section in your blog, newspaper, television programming, etc, then by all means you should have people who appeal to that demographic. But if you're looking for serious dialog or in-depth reporting on subjects such as the labor movement, you don't rely on a 20-something with less than 2 years work experience. He or she can read up on it all they want, but they end up parroting someone else's words rather than reporting on their own experiences.
This is not to say that there aren't talented young journalists -as I indicated above- but it is my view that they "make their bones" before they are to be taken too seriously on issues with which they have little to no real-world experience. Opinion pieces, natch, notwithstanding.
I'd be careful about the use of the term pandering, however. Some of us older folks are completely aware when it's being done, even when the panderer is trying to keep it under wraps.
times change...
Submitted by jorae on Tue, 01/25/2011 - 5:45am.
I meant the first one...but appeals to readers...who are voters...
Pandering may refer to:
What a douche bag
Submitted by hbnolikeee on Mon, 01/24/2011 - 11:08pm.
"This is a tactic union organizers use all the time."
You point at others doing wrong as a pass for you doing wrong? You must be kidding? There's no pass for finding other lowlifes that do as you do.
This Guy Now Wears the Albatross
Submitted by Tenebrous on Tue, 01/25/2011 - 1:52am.
Good luck on getting a job now, dude. *shakes head* Outside of the government and other hate-America groups, that is. No-one else will touch you with a ten foot pole.
P.S. Advocacy is not the same as journalism. Your typical liberal lack of morality is showing.
Visions and Principles blog
I'm NOT surprised.
Submitted by tinydancer on Tue, 01/25/2011 - 5:32am.
This is CLASSIC and TYPICAL Rules For Radicals procedure. Obama was using it in Chicago.
Nothing NEW here.
ACORN used it. Midwest Academy of Chicago trains people to use it. And Obama used, supported, and defended those who use it.