NewsBusters is holding a 5th anniversary happy hour in Washington, and you're invited! Click here for details.

A Tale of Two Leaks: NYT Bashed Palin, But Won't Touch ClimateGate

  • Bookmark and Share

The ClimateGate email leak has demonstrated in full force a glaring double standard in the mainstream media's coverage of leaked information. Too often, liberal media outlets jump at the chance to damage conservative figures by publishing sensitive information, but refuse to publish such information if it discredits or hinders the left's efforts.

As Clay Waters reported yesterday, Andew Revkin, who writes for the New York Times's Dot Earth blog, refused to publish emails from Britain's East Anglia Climate Research Unit showing efforts to manipulate climate data and marginalize global warming skeptics.

Said Revkin, "The documents appear to have been acquired illegally and contain all manner of private information and statements that were never intended for the public eye, so they won’t be posted here."

Revkin is correct that the emails were never intended for the public eye, contained private communications, and were released by hackers who violated the law in obtaining them. But apparently this standard for publication of such documents does not apply to information about Sarah Palin.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The Times's Caucus Blog reported on September 17 of last year:

Computer hackers broke into the private Yahoo e-mail account of Gov. Sarah Palin, the Republican vice presidential candidate, and posted some of her messages and a long list of contacts on the Internet.

The Web site Wikileaks posted screen shots of Ms. Palin’s inbox displaying her username, gov.palin@yahoo.com, and messages that were reportedly obtained by a group of hackers on Tuesday night.

The e-mails include an exchange between Ms. Palin and Alaska’s lieutenant governor, Sean Parnell, as well as an associate, Amy McCorkell, who Ms. Palin appointed to a state drug and alcohol advisory board last year. Wired Magazine reported on its Internet privacy blog, Threat Level, that it obtained confirmation from Ms. McCorkell that she did, in fact, send the message to Governor Palin.

On Wednesday, the McCain campaign acknowledged the breach in a statement from campaign manager, Rick Davis: “This is a shocking invasion of the governor’s privacy and a violation of law. The matter has been turned over to the appropriate authorities and we hope that anyone in possession of these emails will destroy them. We will have no further comment.”

Governor Palin has faced criticism for reportedly using her private address to conduct government business.

When hackers posted screenshots of the then-Vice Presidential nominee on Wikileaks, the Times rushed to publish the information. It even included a link directly to a page displaying the screenshots, disclosing private communications and making available her personal email address and contact list. This is "private information" in every sense of the term.

Guy Benson at National Review extrapolates that at the Times, "it's unacceptable to direct readers to hacked private emails that fundamentally disrupt a lefty meme-of-the-decade, but it's totally cool to direct readers to hacked private emails of the lefty bete noire-of-the-year."

Revkin's statement displays a profound double standard in the Times's reporting on leaked information. It managed, in the last sentence of the Caucus Blog post, to turn Palin's email leak into an attack.

Yet in the case of the ClimateGate emails, which were obtained in a near-identical manner and contain similarly sensitive and personal communications, the Times suddenly finds ethical misgivings in publishing the information. The paper's reservations appear to be a veiled attempt to shield the left's global warming narrative from criticism.

—Lachlan Markay is an associate with Dialog New Media. You can follow him on Twitter and Facebook.

NewsBusters is turning 5. Enter our free t-shirt contest to help us celebrate!


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Morally Bankrupt

Once again we see selective moral indigation is a hallmark of the statist.  The Valerie Plame leak was a crime.   Exposing the names of CIA interrogators is justice.    The exposure of ACORN is ignored and the exposers are attacked. Palin's hacked emails are applauded. 

The principle seems to be the left has no principles.

The left has the principles

The left has the principles extolled in the Koran, in that it is okay to lie if the lie is to advance the truth.  I'm a little shaky on that logic, but I know Hasan had taken an oath but apparently didn't mean it. The 'journalists' in question supposedly subscribe to standards but it looks like they don't mean that either.

The Palin yahoo hacking is the perfect foil

and reveals the fools amongst us!

Pentagon Papers

Let's not forget Daniel Ellsberg's funneling of information to the NYT in 1971.

Good thing they had the sense to withhold the classified documents from publica. . . What's that?  They printed them?

I refuse to believe the NYT would do such a thing.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Step into the Looking Glass

This isn't even Bizarro World....it's just downright weird!!

These are 4 headline/links on the Drudge Report right now:

Climategate: 'Greatest scandal in modern science'...

Call for Congressional investigation...


Paper: Junk science exposed among climate-change believers.

And then we have:

Obama: 'Step closer' to climate deal...

 

What's wrong with this picture????

 

LOL...just as I finished this, I turned on the radio, and Rush is talking about Obama 's speech saying that we are continuing to work on solving this crisis.

 

What universe is this guy living in?????

 

He just doesn't know how to operate outside the realm of his rhetoric!

 

mb... I'm listening as

mb...

I'm listening as too, he's saying how 'O' was saying all the progress we have made regarding climate change...blah blah blah..I loved it, when he said 'stick it where the sun doesn't shine' as well.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

I once read about a man

I once read about a man whose pre-school daughter asked  "How does Santa get in the house if we don't have a chimney?"

Sensing a "teaching moment," he spent a long time telling her about
Santa being a story, not real, the spirit of Christmas, the whole nine
yards. At the end he said, OK? You see now?

And she said "Yes, but how does he get in the house if we don't have a chimney???"

Obama is the same.  No matter the evidence to the contrary, he's going to continue to work on solving the crisis of "climate change."

 

mb... Your prime example

mb...

Your prime example here couldn't get any better regarding the O-Team tactics to achieve their agenda.

Priceless.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

  He is doing Pre-Damage

 

He is doing Pre-Damage control.    He wants to make sure the American people KNOW how much work has been done,  then these e-mail will be these e-mails will be tossed aside because we have so much more work to do.    The sheelple will eat it up

 

this is just like the Rev Wright stuff....Dear Leader's supporters all said "He wasn't there that day!!!! Get Over it!!!!!"    even though there were many different videos and Rev Wright was wareing different clothes on each video....

Even the Bible argees  Psalm 109:8 "Let his days be few; and let another take office."

I laughed when I saw

I laughed when I saw that.

It's above the pay grade of the savior of the free world.

"You lie!"  Rep. Joe Wilson R-(SC)

I disagree Obama knows

I disagree Obama knows exactly what he's doing. This is politics right now and especially for all of the Democrats and many Republicans. Don't you believe for a minute they weren't prepared for some set backs. And if there's a major clitch as there is now, well they'll just ignore it and the news media will help them. They have every reason to believe if they stick to the narrative on Climate Change, or Healthcare, they'll accomplish their goals. The nasty distraction's like the truth, and Teaparties will just go away as long as there existence isn't acknowledged. There won't be any accountability if they stone wall long enough most of us we'll lose interest and forget in time. Well we better wake up, the hard left's running the government, politicians, the communications media now. They're not nice they don't play by any rules and they're not interested in the welfare of America or it's people, it's not their priority.

This is right out of George Orwell's world.

The NYT also forgets that it is

 

the son of DEMOCRAT Tennessee State Represenattive Mike Kernell that is under federal indictment for hacking Palin's passowrd.

 

Don't Tax Me, Bro.

 

Debate is over ....settled Morality

The Global Warming debate is over and it is settled morality. No honest scientist could possibly advance this scheme futher without publicly providing all sensor information and data streams and computer models to public scrutiny similar to open source computer programs. No scientist should expect the public to pay for the expensive implications of the laws being proposed by governments. In fact, Obama  should apologize to the world for the sins of these phony scientists on which he has based his threat to skyrocket our enegy prices. He needs to offer reparations for the psychic damage he has done to all of us to whom paying the yearly heating and electric bill is a serious thing much more so than some phony temperature changes.

rfp....the challenge before

rfp....the challenge before us now is to undo all that "global warming" legislation around the world which was based on that phony data generated by the "global warming" scam science.

In this country, we probably ought to look at RICO laws to begin investigating who is involved in this mess, and bring them to justice.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

Follow the BBC wailing & gnashing over ClimateGate

NBers who want a good summary and commentary on what's happening in the UK over CLIMATEFRAUDGATE, should check out

BiasedBBC Blog

The state controlled leftist media are just a bunch of DOUCHE BAGGERS (D-BAGGERS)

Rush is on a dad gummed

Rush is on a dad gummed roll!!  He says..you do CAN buy that big SUV, you CAN buy incandescent light bulbs and on and on...I am LMAO.  He is right as rain as usual.  All the houses of cards are falling now.  Like we knew they would.  Nothing about global warming is or has been true.  Only the idiots or folks with evil intentions believed in this crap.

Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum

CRex... I've loved every

CRex...

I've loved every minute of it myself!

Love how he's bringing up Ted Dansen and his ilk as well.

Cover-up and try to weather the storm, frauds, held up for public ridicule ect...it just doesn't get any better.

They ought to be hung-up, drawn and quartered etc... it doesn't get any better than this.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

Contact Michael Mann

I am embarrased to say that one of the reserchers, Michael Mann
teaches at my alma mater, Penn State.  Please join me in sending him an
email to tell him exactly what you think of him.  I will also be
sending anotehr email to the PSU department of Earth and Mineral
Sciences demanding his removal and a full investigation. 

 

Contact him at  mann@psu.edu

Don't stop there

Make sure you write in to the Penn Stater and write to Graham Spanier too.  I'd say to write to the Daily Collegian as well but they're probably pulling out all the stops to defend him.

I'm wondering if any of our fellow alumni have started an online petition or something.  We need this to go viral just like the Van Jones situation.

If you're not outraged at the media, you haven't been paying attention.

The gift that keeps giving.

The gift that keeps giving. Ya gotta love this. From:

Today, on behalf of the Competitive Enterprise Institute, I filed three Notices of Intent to File Suit against NASA and its Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS), for those bodies’ refusal – for nearly three years – to provide documents requested under the Freedom of Information Act.

The information sought is directly relevant to the exploding “ClimateGate” scandal revealing document destruction, coordinated efforts in the U.S. and UK to avoid complying with both countries’ freedom of information laws, and apparent and widespread intent to defraud at the highest levels of international climate science bodies.

"You lie!"  Rep. Joe Wilson R-(SC)

Re 'Hacker'

Re "Revkin is correct that the emails were never intended for the public
eye, contained private communications, and were released by hackers who
violated the law in obtaining them."

I'm disappointed that a website meant to identify liberal bias has entirely accepted the liberals' claim that this is the work of a 'hacker'. The heroic whistleblower that exposed the emails and other documents is in all likelihood an employee of the organization that took some data home one day. There is no more evidence for the notion of a 'hacker' than there is that of an employee that decided to expose criminal behavior.

 The left will twist the

 The left will twist the story into an issue about internet privacy and the right will fall in line and the real global warming issue will be forgotten and the left will be able to pass the fairness act. Meanwhile the right will stand there licking their fingers after removing them from their rectums and wonder what happened. Notice how you don't hear anyone on the right taking up this issue except Rush. Everytime the left hands the conservative a gift they piss it away.

 

GSP---

You are entirely too correct.

What I mean by that is, I wish that what you stated were a little less true, because the truth is sometimes a stinger, a stunner, or as in this case, can produce sadness.

Every time the Left serves up a ball that could or should be hit right out of the park, the Right generally looks it right into the catchers mitt for a called strike three.

If only they could at least go down swinging.

Someone on NewsBusters has a tag line, "Swing hard in case you hit it."

Damn.

If only.

MD

'There is no distinctly American criminal class - except Congress."

Mark Twain (1835-1910)

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.