NBC: Birth Control Debate That 'Came Out of Nowhere' Now the 'Third Rail' of Politics
Pretending the Obama administration did not intentionally turn birth control into a campaign issue with the ObamaCare insurance mandate, on Thursday's NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams pleaded ignorance to viewers: "Birth control seems to have become, as one headline writer put it today, 'The Third Rail of American Politics Right Now,' and this happened really out of nowhere."
In the report that followed, correspondent Kelly O'Donnell described the issue as a "political fight over government's place in women's health and reproduction." She touted how discussion of the topic "prompted boos" at Wednesday's Republican debate, while receiving "rare applause at a Democrats-only staged hearing today. Set off by the outrage Democrats vented when Republicans called only men to testify last week on religious institutions and birth control."
After playing a sound bite of Nancy Pelosi leading the left-wing congressional panel, O'Donnell noted particular testimony: "Democrats invited one woman, a Georgetown law student, to talk about hardships for some women who don't have insurance that covers birth control." A clip played of Sandra Fluke pushing the need for contraception: "Without her taking the birth control, a massive cyst the side of a tennis ball had grown on her ovary."
What O'Donnell failed to mention was that Fluke was not simply a "law student," but the former president of the Georgetown University chapter of Law Students For Reproductive Justice, a liberal pro-choice organization.
O'Donnell warned that the contraception fight was expanding, "with some states looking to restrict abortion and funding for women's health programs." She explained: "In Virginia late today, after protests and a national spotlight, legislators changed a controversial bill that would have required an invasive procedure before a woman could have an abortion."
Wrapping up her report, O'Donnell noted that "Some Republican voters want this debate," but quickly added: "Analysts say these social issues are more likely to help Democrats." A sound bite followed from Jennifer Duffy of the Cook Political Report announcing: "This issue has given Democrats at every level an issue to talk to women voters about and particularly independent women."
So, according to NBC, not only did the birth control debate "come out of nowhere," but now the Democrats are winning the argument.
Here is a full transcript of the February 23 report:
7:00PM ET TEASE:
BRIAN WILLIAMS: The politics of birth control. Women, contraception, and a national fight over this issue that came out of nowhere.
7:04PM ET SEGMENT:
WILLIAMS: The price of gas isn't the only contentious campaign issue tonight. Birth control seems to have become, as one headline writer put it today, "The Third Rail of American Politics Right Now," and this happened really out of nowhere. In fact, it was a question about birth control that got the biggest audience response at last night's GOP debate in Arizona. NBC's Kelly O'Donnell has more on the politics of birth control and women's health.
KELLY O'DONNELL: Protests today in Richmond, Virginia.
PROTESTERS: Our bodies! Our lives!
O'DONNELL: A flashpoint in the political fight over government's place in women's health and reproduction. So provocative, the mere mention of birth control prompted boos...
RICK SANTORUM: I don't support that.
O'DONNELL: ...at the Republican debate.
SANTORUM: Just because I'm talking about it doesn't mean I want a government program to fix it.
O'DONNELL: And rare applause at a Democrats-only staged hearing today. Set off by the outrage Democrats vented when Republicans called only men to testify last week on religious institutions and birth control.
NANCY PELOSI: We've heard from over 300,000 people saying we want women's voices to be heard.
O'DONNELL: Democrats invited one woman, a Georgetown law student, to talk about hardships for some women who don't have insurance that covers birth control.
SANDRA FLUKE [GEORGETOWN LAW STUDENT]: Without her taking the birth control, a massive cyst the side of a tennis ball had grown on her ovary.
O'DONNELL: Nearly 11 million women use birth control pills, the most common method of contraception, the political fire is broader, with some states looking to restrict abortion and funding for women's health programs. In Virginia late today, after protests and a national spotlight, legislators changed a controversial bill that would have required an invasive procedure before a woman could have an abortion. Some Republican voters want this debate.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Social issues should play a very high priority in the campaign.
O'DONNELL: Analysts say these social issues are more likely to help Democrats.
JENNIFER DUFFY [THE COOK POLITICAL REPORT]: This issue has given Democrats at every level an issue to talk to women voters about and particularly independent women.
O'DONNELL: Making women without party ties the most sought-after voters this year. Kelly O'Donnell, NBC News, Washington.
- Kyle Drennen's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
came out of nowhere.
Submitted by CarlosS on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:01pm.
This lapdog journolist should not be calling "The Won" "nowhere" He will be re-educated shortly
'birth control debate "come out of nowhere,' "
Submitted by Newsbubba on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:11pm.
No, it came out of George Snuffaluffagus.
Now that I think about it, that is pretty close to nothing and nowhere, I guess.
And things are proceeding
Submitted by motherbelt on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:17pm.
And things are proceeding according to plan..... next it will be the "defining issue" of this election.
What?
Submitted by Maytag on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:16pm.
I have not heard a single person talk about this bulls---. Not at work or when we go for a beer or on facebook. I think the media is losing this issue. east coasties are in to much of a vacuum.
Out of nowhere?
Submitted by Cool Arrow on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:24pm.
Does Press Secretary Williams realize he just insulted Press Secretary Stephanopolis?
Every picture of Williams
Submitted by gregfahey on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:29pm.
Looks like he is either:
1) A bit squirmy from the hemorrhoids?
2) Mesmerized by looking at monitors with his image displaying.
3) Responding to the White House controlled electric-shock-genital-cuff and earpiece telling him what to say.
I'm going with.........3
He got the memo
Submitted by CO2Maker on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 5:50pm.
He's leaning forward so he can squeeze off a silent one.
Is NBC really that clueless?
Submitted by kg on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:33pm.
Is NBC really that clueless? OK, I know. It's obvious.
"DumbAssity of Dope"
No, they're not
Submitted by motherbelt on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:39pm.
No, they're not clueless.
They know exactly what they are doing.
The Dems are outraged when
Submitted by ForeverOnTheRight on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 1:48pm.
The Dems are outraged when their is a men only panel on religion and birth control, but don't even flinch when they have a liberal only panel on anything and everything. Men can know things about birth control, just because they are men does not mean they are clueless about birth control and religion. Besides this controversy started because of a man, Obama. And these libs are purpusly ignoring the fact that this media storm started with Dear Leader.
I thought the real issue was...
Submitted by bigdaddy on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 3:31pm.
...Baracko decreeing that koshers delis start offering BBQ Pork on their menus...
and like fools...
Submitted by FistsforLiberty on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 4:06pm.
The candidates fell in it neck deep!!
Brian Williams
Submitted by dmaley1714 on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 4:10pm.
When you look at him just remember he was an Intern in Jimmy Carter's admin that is all you need to know about Williams objectivity.
CAME OUT OF NOWHERE???
Submitted by rickbren on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 5:42pm.
Brian and NBC, you have got to be KIDDING!!!! Any average idiot knows this came out George Steponallofus' question in a past GOP debate. AND it was doubtless planned and introduced by Barry's regime's lieutenants.
I am so glad to see the All Green Network practicing recycling
Submitted by CO2Maker on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 5:55pm.
Over at NBC News, they don't throw away memes, tropes, and clichés, they recycle them.
"Third rail of American politics" got worn out in the debates about Social Security and Medicare reform (which the AARP demonized so badly no one was able to fix it back when fixing it would have been a lot easier and less expensive).
And "flash point" hasn't been used since Jennifer Gray was wearing leg warmers.
The democrats thought
Submitted by ohio granny on Fri, 02/24/2012 - 9:25pm.
The democrats thought they could trap the republicans by claiming this is about birth control. But look at what has happened. The democrats have stepped into it. It is NOT about contraceptives, it is about the obama administration trying to dictate to churches. Protestant and Catholic Churches abhor abortion and abortion inducing drugs. They will not participate by paying for these drugs. Not by paying for the insurance or by self insuring.
They need
Submitted by nolefan2 on Sat, 02/25/2012 - 12:04pm.
to keep the discussions and debates focused on birth control so they can avoid talking about rising gas prices, loss of jobs, government corruption, etc. They dare not get pulled into a discussion about what Duh One has accomplished (or not) in his first (and hopefully, last) term in office. And, this subject of birth control did not come out of nowhere. It was hatched in the bowels of the DNC or WH, you can bet.