CBS Reporter Laments Economic Downturn After Fall of Berlin Wall

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Mark Phillips, CBS Reporting for CBS Sunday Morning, correspondent Mark Phillips marked the 20th anniversary of the fall the Berlin Wall by noting the economic difficulty East Germany has faced in the aftermath: “It still isn’t easy for many. East German industry without government subsidy could not compete. The economy shrank by an estimated 50%.”

Phillips mourned the loss of state-run industries after the oppressed nation was freed from decades of communist oppression: “The eastern landscape is littered with the ruins of former state-supported enterprise. A million people have gone west looking for work.”

Earlier in the report, Phillips credited those responsible for the wall’s collapse: “The main players on that night 20 years ago were the people of East Berlin....But it was the behind-the-scenes players who really determined events that night, mostly by doing nothing. Then Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev had refused to back the desperate GDR regime. Then President George Bush refused to gloat as the wall came down. Then German Chancellor Helmut Kohl went on to become the leader of a reunited Germany.” Ronald Reagan slipped Phillips’ mind.

Phillips sounded nearly identical to reporters at the time of the wall’s collapse. On the March 16, 1990 CBS Evening News, correspondent Bob Simon wondered: “...what about East Germany’s eighty symphony orchestras, bound to lose some subsidies, or the whole East German system, which covered everyone in a security blanket from day care to health care, from housing to education?” He concluded: “Some people are beginning to express, if ever so slightly, nostalgia for that Berlin Wall.”

Here is a full transcript of the Sunday Morning segment:

10:13AM

CHARLES OSGOOD: Berlin residents are remembering where they were 20 years ago tomorrow, when the infamous wall began to come down. This picture by journalist Peter Turnley is from a photo essay you can find on our Sunday Morning website. As for Berlin today, here’s Mark Phillips.

MARK PHILLIPS: The anniversary of the fall of the wall may not be until tomorrow but the party has already started. A U2 concert used the Brandenburg Gate as the convenient back drop. When the wall ran through it, the gate sat in the middle of a divided city and was the symbol of a divided world. Now the search lights are merely visual effects piercing the night sky. Not scanning no man’s land for East Germans trying to escape to the west.

The main players on that night 20 years ago were the people of East Berlin who, after months of mounting protests, finally called the bluff of the East German authorities. But it was the behind-the-scenes players who really determined events that night, mostly by doing nothing. Then Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev had refused to back the desperate GDR regime. Then President George Bush refused to gloat as the wall came down. Then German Chancellor Helmut Kohl went on to become the leader of a reunited Germany, an outcome neither he nor any of the others had planned but one they now say could not have happened without them.

GEORGE H.W. BUSH: I might harbor a single hope, it would be that future generations might look back to the moment when mankind really got it right.

BENJAMIN WALTER: I remember my grandma calling. There is a never-ending convoy of cars going to the west side. What is going on?

PHILLIPS: Benjamin Walter was 14 when the wall fell. He didn’t leave. He stayed in East Berlin, where he’s carved out a nice career in IT marketing and marvels at the changes in the life he might have led.

WALTER: Maybe I would have escaped, left the country, leaving, working in some rundown East German company wouldn’t have been easy.

PHILLIPS: It still isn’t easy for many. East German industry without government subsidy could not compete. The economy shrank by an estimated 50%. The eastern landscape is littered with the ruins of former state-supported enterprise. A million people have gone west looking for work. Many of them may have come here this weekend to Berlin’s east side gallery, formally known as the Berlin Wall. Part of the commemoration of the coming down of the wall has been to refurbish the parts of it that are left. Some of the original paintings are being redone for the occasion. An ugly interlude in history literally being painted over. And 20 years later, another party like no other about to be relived.

OSGOOD: CBS News correspondent Mark Phillips in Berlin.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

 The eastern landscape is

 The eastern landscape is littered with the ruins of former state-supported enterprise.

    Oh...  you mean like the road obama is driving us down?

Irony

It is ironic that on this day when we celebrate the fall of communism in Europe, the "liberals" in America celebrate their communist health-care bill. Government demanding that you do as they say. Fines if you don't sign up, jail if you don't pay the fines. Government rationing. A bureaucratic nightmare. Are we nuts?

BTW, Obama did it again. As he spoke to the Germans via satellite he made the moral equivalence between what happened with communism in Europe and the treatment of "Africans" in America. He's such an ignorant jerk.

 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

 

A state run industry?

Yes a far looking car company...Trabant!

NBers  All hail the TRABANT, the latest out of the pre-fallan walled in  Commie nation.

Those captialists  50 miles away are  so unfair !

Ok, ok this gets better milage   how about this

 

State controlled health care ! music video.

Adam ate the apple: News at 11:00.

It's amazing that our liberal institutions still accept the Soviet and Eastern Bloc economic numbers as reliable.  Totalitarians have a way of exagerating their acomplishments, cough, cough.......

"600,000 jobs saved!"

The numbers coming out of the Soviet Union and East Bloc were meaningless.  Another seven years of Obama and a Dem Congress will only hasten our march down that failed path.

Exactly.  A communist

Exactly.  A communist economy can't actually shrink because any of its numbers are based on false value.  Once you end a commie dictatorship, you're at ground zero, with nowhere to go but up.

Sadly, Americans won't learn this until O-bum-a takes us to rock bottom.

Well,

 Sadly, Americans won't learn this until O-bum-a takes us to rock bottom.

 Cant be long now? Right?

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Dumb-a..es

These donkey-ends said "A million people have gone west looking for work.” Well, they could have said "Fifty million people would have gone west looking for FREEDOM!"

With reporter-dolts (but I

With reporter-dolts (but I repeat myself) like Mark Philips running around spouting "what happened", it is little wonder so many people have a false impression of historical events. He might as well have said the East Germans would have been much better off with the barrel of a Kalashnikov aimed at their heads. Citizens, families, whole neighborhoods tried to escape. Those who were caught were shot.

The truth is this: the East German economy was a disaster. People were hungry, the black market was rampant, there was no hope of economic advancement in any way, shape or form unless you were a staunch genossen--a true believer, a radical member of the Communist Party--willing to turn in members of your family, your neighbors and friends who criticized the party. Electricity was limited in most communities, food was often scarce, people ate their pets and horses at times because no meat was available and they were so hungry. Quality of work--manufacturing, crafts-- was abysmal.

I could go on but I won't. I saw all this with my very own eyes. I just cannot abide by the lying media as they continue this ocean of lies about "what it was like" in East Germany. They do not have a clue.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

cel... Thank

cel...

Thank you.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

BT, here a visual that

BT, here a visual that explains it all.

There was a Hilton hotel (still is, I suppose) in West Berlin, not far from the Wall. You could go up to the restaurant on the top floor, and look south. To the left of you was East Berlin--pitch dark after 10 pm. No electricity. No cars. No street lights. Nothing. Period.

Look to the south and right--West Berlin-- and there were lights and cars, and people walking around laughing, and big bright lights everywhere. Restaurants, movies, clubs, bars, streetcars, busses--looked like NYC or London at night. Total black out versus brilliant, bustling FREE city.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

→ celator

As an Army PFC in 1973, we were allowed a visit to East Berlin.  The contrast between West and East was every bit as stark as leaving a technicolor movie and entering a B&W.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Cool...Yep, it was. Were you

Cool...Yep, it was. Were you stationed on the "hill" or at McNair?

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

→ K Town

Kaiserslautern.  We took a long train ride to get there.  Much of the ride was with the shades drawn.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Checkpoints Alpha, Bravo, Charlie

My parents took me on a roadie I would not soon forget, and still haven't.  We went from a little ways south of K-Town on up to Helmstedt the first day, and crossed into Checkpoint Alpha the next morning.  We had to be briefed on exactly how to use Transit West-Berlin as it was called. 

I remember my father trying to do his best to explain to me what Communist propaganda was, as you could see it all over the place (in German).  You could also see the Volkspolizei having stopped cars everywhere.  And they didn't just pull over one car; they would pull them over in bunches.

As we left Checkpoint Alpha's transit briefing, we were told "One more thing.  Do not trade anything with the Soviets.  It isn't authorized.  Yes, they will ask."  Sure enough, everytime my father reported to them with the proper paperwork indicating why he was crossing East Germany, they would try to trade a uniform item for one of his.  He'd laugh about it as we drove off from the Checkpoints Alpha or Bravo.   

Of course we transited the more famous Checkpoint Charlie later on.  My memories of East Berlin were of a drab, gray, concreted over place that didn't look much different from the Wall which cut it off from the Western sectors.  The street signage actually added color to the place, for there was nothing else to do it.

I won't forget that as long as I shall live.  It was one of the more instructive journeys I ever went on.

"CONSUMED DEMOCRACY RETURNS A SOCIALIST REGIME" - Slayer, "Fictional Reality", from Divine Intervention (1994)

→ What I remember

What I remember most about it was the grownups staring silently at the ground as they walked, and the children flipping the peace sign with grins only children can muster.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

We are all East Berliners now

 To the left of you was East Berlin--pitch dark after 10 pm. No electricity. No cars. No street lights. Nothing. Period.

  Obama:   "We can't drive our SUVs and eat as much as we want and keep our homes on 72 degrees at all times ... and then just expect that other countries are going to say OK," Obama said.

"That's not leadership. That's not going to happen," he added

Mid.. it would be a dream

Mid.. it would be a dream come true for Obama.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

cel... Nail on head...and

cel...

Nail on head...and then some.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

cel... Once

cel...

Once again....thank you.

That visual makes one think long and hard.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

BT...As Mid suggested above,

BT...As Mid suggested above, we have to be on high alert that this not happen in our beloved country.

No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.

cel... I know, I

cel...

I know, I agree...and I am.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

If you need a current day

If you need a current day example, just look at North and South Korea.

I remember seeing a satellite photo of the Korean peninsula once and saw how lit up South Korea was, particularly around Seoul. The North, on the other hand, except for maybe a tiny blip around Pyongyang, pitch black. Now granted, an argument could be made that North Korea's communist dictatorship is a lot more brutal than East Germany's ever was (Though that is like saying getting shot in the head with a bazooka is more brutal than getting shot in the head with a regular handgun - you're still dead either way), but it's the same principle - communism did not and still does not provide for its citizens in the way that capitalism.

At least with capitalism, you've got a fighting chance.

"You just don't get it." - Pa Grape, "Veggietales"

Check out my blog.

Opposite view

For an opposite view, I read an account where people in the East German countryside could see West Berlin for many many kilometers away at night just based on the city lights alone.  That account was of West Berlin in the 1950s soon after the uprising.  I can't imagine things changed all that much in later decades. 

These reporters do not have a single clue of what they speak. 

"CONSUMED DEMOCRACY RETURNS A SOCIALIST REGIME" - Slayer, "Fictional Reality", from Divine Intervention (1994)

"nostalgia for that Berlin Wall"?

Our leftist media seems to believe the Communists built the wall to keep the greedy capitalists from coming in and spoiling their worker's paradise.

Wall...armed

Wall...armed guards...barbed wire.

What part of this exactly do these knuckleheads not get?

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.