CBS’s Smith: Stock Rally ‘Vindication’ for Obama Administration

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Harry Smith and Robert Gibbs, CBS On Tuesday’s CBS Early Show co-host Harry Smith talked to White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs about Monday’s stock market rally and wondered: "What was the reaction at the White House yesterday when the stock market closed?...There's been a lot of heat, though, aimed at the White House, aimed at the Treasury Secretary. Was there some degree of vindication?"

Gibbs claimed that the administration does not pay attention to daily stock numbers, but Smith replied: "You have to admit, it's a pretty good day, though, when the stock market goes up 500 points and the AIG executives, at least more than a dozen of them, say ‘we're going to give our money back.’" After Smith’s pressing, Gibbs admitted: "Well, look, Harry. I'll take 500 points and that kind of news any day of the week."

An earlier report by Bloomberg TV anchor Deirdre Bolton credited the White House banking plan for the stock surge: "...yesterday the Dow soared to 6.5%, that was the biggest gain since October. The Obama administration finally giving some -- Wall Street some details on how the bad banks' assets can be treated. Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner put together a plan that some say is the best of both worlds to deal with toxic assets."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Bolton cited chief economist of Global Insight, Nariman Behravesh, who declared Geither’s plan: "...was the missing link. And it's now in place." She also cited Mark Zandi of moody’seconomy.com, who claimed: "It's great. It feels good. And obviously reflects investors' enthusiasm with respect to the plan the administration put forward to help the banking system." Behravesh later added: "I think the proof of the pudding will be in the eating, but nevertheless, I think they came through with a credible, specific plan. So this is very good news for the administration, for Geithner."

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

7:00AM TEASE:

JULIE CHEN: Wall Street's almost 500-point day in response to the Obama administration's plan to buy up bad assets. But as the President prepares to address the nation tonight, can the rally be sustained, and is it time to jump in? Here today, gone tomorrow. AIG execs give back nearly $50 million in bonuses as the company takes its name off its New York headquarters. So what will happen to the rest of the money?

7:02AM SEGMENT:

MAGGIE RODRIGUEZ: But first this morning, it was a monster rally on Wall Street yesterday. Now the big question, will it last? Deirdre Bolton of Bloomberg TV is at the New York Stock Exchange. Deirdre, it's been going strong for a while, so hopefully.

DEIRDRE BOLTON: Hopefully, Maggie, is right. As you just alluded to, yesterday the Dow soared to 6.5%, that was the biggest gain since October. The Obama administration finally giving some -- Wall Street some details on how the bad banks' assets can be treated. Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner put together a plan that some say is the best of both worlds to deal with toxic assets.

TIM GEITHNER: Use public capital to bring in private capital with some government financing to provide a market for these assets.

BOLTON: The program will help take $1 trillion worth of sour securities off banks' balance sheets. The idea is to do so without using more taxpayer money and without nationalizing the banks.

NARIMAN BEHRAVESH: This was the missing link. And it's now in place.

BOLTON: The Dow Jones soared into the triple digits and logged its fifth largest point gain ever.

MARK ZANDI: It's great. It feels good. And obviously reflects investors' enthusiasm with respect to the plan the administration put forward to help the banking system.

BOLTON: Bank stocks rallied on the news, Citigroup up more than 19%, Bank of America, 26%, JP Morgan Chase, 24%, and Wells Fargo, 23%. The execution of this plan is a big test for the Treasury Secretary.

BEHRAVESH: I think the proof of the pudding will be in the eating, but nevertheless, I think they came through with a credible, specific plan. So this is very good news for the administration, for Geithner.

BOLTON: And the President does, Harry, continue to give his full public support to the Treasury Secretary. As you know, he has been in the hot seat. Back to you.

HARRY SMITH: Deirdre Bolton at the New York Stock Exchange, thanks. Looks like the outrage at those bailout bonuses for AIG worked. The government will be getting some of that money back. CBS News senior White House correspondent Bill Plante joins us now with more on that. Good morning, Bill.

BILL PLANTE: Good morning, Harry. The projection is that as much as half of it, about $80 billion, could be returned. But despite all of the anger that you heard here in Washington, it wasn't Congress or Washington that got the money returned.

BARACK OBAMA: People are rightly outraged about these particular bonuses.

PLANTE: President Obama led the populist charge when the public learned that executives at insurance giant AIG received $165 million in bonuses. Despite getting more than $170 billion in federal bailout funds. The anger was evident in a new CBS News poll, which shows 77% of Americans wanted the government to get the bonus money back. The House passed a bill last week that would levy a 90% tax on bonuses over $250,000 for any company receiving more than $5 million from the Fed. But now, as the bill heads to the Senate, there's been a change in tone from President Obama and a word of caution from the Senate.

MITCH MCCONNELL: And we ought to think about the ramifications of what we're doing.

PLANTE: And now that New York Attorney General Cuomo has gotten 15 of the top 20 AIG bonus earners to return the money-

CRAIG GORDON: I would not be surprised if that bill slowed down dramatically in light of both Obama's resistance to it and some of this talk that Andrew Cuomo got the money back from AIG.

PLANTE: And, in fact, the Senate is delaying the bill for maybe six weeks. It's probably dead. And what about getting the rest of that money back? What are the chances? Well, not very good. Because a lot of the remaining money went overseas. No reach, no jurisdiction. Harry.

SMITH: Bill Plante at the White House this morning, thanks. And President Obama will give a news conference tonight at 8:00PM Eastern. You can watch it right here on CBS. Joining us now, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs. Good morning, Mr. Gibbs.

ROBERT GIBBS: Good morning, Harry. How are you?

SMITH: What was the reaction at the White House yesterday when the stock market closed?

GIBBS: Well, look, obviously, we're pleased with what happened in the market yesterday, but Harry, we don't spend a lot of time worrying or looking at what happens each day in the market. Instead, the President wants to feel confident and give the American people confidence that what we're putting in place will bring our economy back long term, create jobs, and lay a path towards prosperity again.

SMITH: There's been a lot of heat, though, aimed at the White House, aimed at the Treasury Secretary. Was there some degree of vindication?

GIBBS: Well, look, Harry. I think we're not going to be judged by what happens yesterday or today in the market, but a year or two from now where people feel like they have a stable job, whether their income is growing, whether they can get a loan to buy a house or a car or send their child to school. I think what the American people are focused on more is this long-term recovery. We don't want to go from bust to -- to bubble to bust economic growth anymore. I think the American people want to get back to sustained, long-term economic growth that provides them a good quality of life and a stable job, and that's what the President's focused on.

SMITH: You have to admit, it's a pretty good day, though, when the stock market goes up 500 points and the AIG executives, at least more than a dozen of them, say 'we're going to give our money back.'

GIBBS: Well, look, Harry. I'll take 500 points and that kind of news any day of the week.

SMITH: Alright. Let's talk some more about the economy, though, because there are still grumblings from the private sector about this idea of controls on executive compensation. How far does the White House want to go with this?

GIBBS: Well, look, Harry. The White House outlined in February -- the President created a plan, it was the strongest plan that had ever been put forward to ensure that executive compensation and bonuses don't get out of whack and out of line. Look, everyone in this country understands rewarding success. But, obviously, excessive executive compensation has unfortunately become the norm, and it's understandable that people get upset about it. What we need to do is have some rationality in that system, understand that we're all in this together, that we all have to give a little. And with that, we can stabilize our economy.

SMITH: Robert Gibbs, we thank you so much for your time this morning. Do appreciate it, sir.

GIBBS: Thanks, Harry.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

They can't call it 

They can't call it  "vindication."

Obama has already said the Dow is just a daily "poll."

Not important.

Oh, wait!  Like other polls, they are significant when they break your way,  unimportant when they don't.

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

Thanks for reminding about Obama's statement . . .

But, of course, since his bots, his thugs and thugettes in the advocacy/adversary media have no ears to hear nor eyes to see, how would they have known he dismissed the Dow so?

Truly, these people are embarrassing.

They're becoming caricatures of themselves.

That's frightening.

The Plan

Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner put together a plan that some say is the best of both worlds to deal with toxic assets.

Cherry pick the right targets to sell at the right price and steal whatever they can.

JDW

DAILY WAVE

The government works for me, not the other way around

OAF.s plunge protection team, shoving a TRILLION at the DOW

Just the smell of the megatons of cash, BETTER bump the market up.

Lets see where the DOW is in a month (without additional cash infusions)?

How is the stock market doing in hugo chavezes peoples paradice?

P.R.I.N.T. Money   30 sec YT 

Dear Harry,

The more Obama gets his way, the lower the P/E expectations...the more downward pressure on the barometer of capitalism...the market.

The market has already priced in near armegeddon/socialism since it became clear he would win and another 3000 points lower when he announced his actual plans.  I know you dont get this, but the markets look FORWARD, not backwards.

The "bounce" was positive, but it was the addition of the word "private" in Treasury's announcment of a Public Private Investment Program was the positive surprise.  imagine that? 

Well, was Harry worried

Well, was Harry worried that the stock market would keep falling until it reached zero?  

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

Harry congragulates Pres Bush?

When the stock market hit its all-time high of over 14,000 during Pres Bush's term, did Harry come out and congragualte President Bush and ask if that didn't validate his policies?

He didn't? Unbelievable. Why wouldn't an unbiased newscaster be consistent? Just more evidence that the MSM is in the tank; has always been in the tank; and will forever be in the tank for liberal democrats. Give me evidence to the contrary, Harry -- I'm waiting. You blowhard.

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

Harry was probably sweating

Harry was probably sweating bullets a couple of weeks ago - it's kind of hard to spin a market going down every day into something positive. Now, he's just giddy with relief. 

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

Market has a 500 point

Market has a 500 point bounce, and Harry the Hack has an Obamagasm.

I wonder what Harry the Useful Idiot is going to say when the markets react to this:

http://hotair.com/archives/2009/03/23/good-news-epa-set-to-shackle-econo...

-Dave

This coup has gone on long enough. The time to put it down is NOW.

More fraud comin' down the

More fraud comin' down the pike. Electricity rates will soar; gasoline will go out of site; and this puts everything -- and I mean everything -- in play as far as "enviornmental lawsuits" go.

You won't even be able to drive snowplows in the blizzards like they're having in the upper midwest today.

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

Harriet The Tap Dancing

Harriet The Tap Dancing Termite... still tap dancing like one of Obama's loyal minstrel troupe. 

So "excessive executive compensation has become the norm"... what about the excessive compensation for Harriet and his MSM sisterhood? Last time I looked, most of the MSM were publicly traded companies.

Harry Smith is a presstitute

If so then obama can take credit for the dow tanking from 14000+ to below 7000 right?

The economy sank once we knew obama had beaten clinton in the primaries


http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=^DJI#chart1:symbol=^dji;range=1y;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined

Harry Smith is a presstitute---

Good one--David

 

Presstitute --one who sells his integrity for ink and space.

"Presstitute." Good One!

Since the market's back to being the Obama Bear Market now, it's safe to assume that Soros money artificially bumped it up, until traders realized nobody real is paying these prices and back down it went.

 Wonder how long ObamaCommie can keep that up?

So, let me ...

So, let me understand Smith's logic. If the stock market goes up, then it is a vindication that Obama's porkulus policies are working. So, shouldn't the reverse be true. If the stock market goes down shouldn't that be a condemnation of Obama's fiscal policies.

Oh, that's right when the market goes up it's because Obama's, "the one's", fiscal policies (the continued bailouts) are working. However, if the market goes down, then it's George Bush's fault and that Bush's fiscal policies did nothing to stop the downward turn.

How can this be true since everything started to really go bad after "the one", "the messiah", "the anointed one", "the savior" got elected? And further, how is it true since it started when the dems took over congress two years ago?

Oh, I know. The liberals are in control, so they can spin what's happening anyway they want. And it appears that is exactly what they are doing. God help us all.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

Harry left out something . . .

When Obamination took over the market was beginning to recover and was up at 8200.

The market then began to steadily tumble down to 6600.

Now we are up to about 7750 - still less than when he took over and caused his own panic on Wall Street.

Duplicate comment removed.

Sorry.

Liberals and leftists using logic? They can't even spell it.

What you've said -- re: "...shouldn't the reverse be true. If the stock market goes down shouldn't that be a condemnation of Obama's fiscal policies" -- is so far over the heads of most journalists, it's pathetic. Actually, they're pathetic.

Throw in that they're liberals and leftists, Demockacrats/Dementocrats, and it's impossible for them to understand.

and your point?

We should all be sad anybody ever said anything that wasn't bad about Obama? Only liberals would think a 500 point stock market gain meant anything good for Obama?

What are you getting it?

Gabby Gibbs was everywhere

Gabby Gibbs was everywhere this morning...it was pathetic...he appeared, I clicked it.

 BT.. Gabby Gibbs... LOL.

 BT.. Gabby Gibbs... LOL. Expect him to say, "Well, Roy, them thar rustlers got another thang coming to 'em." ;+}

"We cannot continue to rely only on our military in order to achieve the national security objectives that we've set. We've got to have a civilian national security that's just as powerful, just as strong, just as well funded

Howdy cel... Glad to know

Howdy cel...

Glad to know you knew where I was coming from...  ;-)

 By the way...did you happen to catch him the other day when he was stammering around for answers and he dissed Chip Reid?

Oh it was delicious as far as I am concerned, one of the few days I have even caught his BS, channel was just left there and he was on when my radio show went off...so I was glad I caught it...he told one of his aides behind him to lend him some change to buy Reid a paper so he could be up on the recent knowledge Reid was asking about....(I'm paraphrasing of course...but still, it was so arrogant...and to another lefty to-boot.)

BT... I missed that but am

BT... I missed that but am not in the least surprised that Obama used the opportunity as a put down. Obama has no class whatsoever, and he seems to be proud of that status.

How's that saying go...pride goeth before the fall. It's coming.

"We cannot continue to rely only on our military in order to achieve the national security objectives that we've set. We've got to have a civilian national security that's just as powerful, just as strong, just as well funded

This is the ignorance of most so-called journalists . . .

. . . and certainly the advocacy/adversary media, in general.

They take one datum and draw a straight line through it.

They make it a trend.

They possess neither the wisdom nor intelligence to understand what they're doing.

But, per usual, they're driven by their seemingly demonic preoccupation with false prophet Obama and suffer the Obama mind-sucked-out syndrome.

Truly, they all are pathetic. To call them childish would be an insult to real children.

To call them idiots and/or morons would require apologies to both types of people.

They define new level of intellectual bankruptcy and robotic, preprogrammed behavior.

They are artificially intelligent--and that ain't no compliment.

AGW Parallels

Do you folks see the parallels with anthropogenic 'global warming'?

Warm weather = evidence of 'global warming'; cold weather = not newsworthy

Good economic news = The messiah is succeeding; bad news = not newsworthy

Thanks for observations. But, really, doesn't . . .

. . . this apply to anything now?

Iraq?

Afghanistan?

Gitmo?

Etc.?

The market is down 115

The market is down 115 today.

What's the reaction of the white house today?

The White House's reaction

The White House's reaction will be that these numbers are just like a daily poll, and the President can't be expected to constantly react to them.

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

 The market is down today,

 The market is down today, one day upswing is not a rally. Besides weren't we told to ignore the market on a daily basis.

Yes we were..that's why I

Yes we were..that's why I commented as I did above.  ;-)

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

At the moment the NYSE is

At the moment the NYSE is down 121 points.  What's that a vindication of, I wonder......

What a buch a tingly-legged, sycophantic, cheerleading bootlickers!

What rally?

The osama obama recession/depression just keeps getting deeper and deeper with no signs of relief. The housing market he and acorn with help from Bawny and Chris destroyed must needs be fixed first and there is no intent or attempt to do so.

How can a one day uptick in

How can a one day uptick in the stock market be "vindication" for anybody?   The market has plummeted since before the election, when it was apparent that Obama was going to win.  It has continued to dive as Obama has attempted to put a stake through the heart of free-market capitalism.  It spikes up for one day and this is "vindication" of Obama's policies?  I think this proves Rush Limbaugh right.  To the leftist media elites, there is no history and there is no future.  The only thing that matters is what is happening right now.  This vindication comment is prima facie evidence of that flawed mindset.

Under GWB, the stock market rallied almost continuously after the 9/11 attacks and the Enron/WorldCom scandals were dealt with.  The market peaked at 14,000 even while most media "experts" were saying it wouldn't touch 13,000 anytime soon.  Bush's policies were never mentioned as a catalyst for this prolonged market expansion.  Yet, we have a one day rally after an abysmal market performance and the media is ready to hail Obama's genius.

 

The most successful war America has ever waged is quickly becoming President Obama's war on capitalism.

"How can a one day uptick

"How can a one day uptick in the stock market be "vindication" for anybody?"

Well, when you are a corrupt, left-wing propagandist like Harry the Hack, you have to grab hold of whatever positive events you can in order to make the DumbMasses think that President FUBAR is actually trying to repair our economy.

-Dave

This coup has gone on long enough. The time to put it down is NOW.

Sooo

Geitner finall does what should have been done a month ago and now Obama is a genius?

 

Nope, no way, no how!

Oh! Vindication .-Smith and collegues.-

Hello! Mr. Drennen, Columnist Thanks.-3/29/09. 3/28/09 9:30 PM. Dozen AIG executives going to back the money..$$. Oh!poor  cowards, demagogue, intimidation and hipocritically."Reading columnist Mr. Jim Meyers date march 18/09" "Wrote".- President   $100.000.00 bonus from AIG.- Another $101.000.00 also for Mr. Obamas.(Sen Dodd "Opensecrets.org.) AIG contributed 18 Democratic members of the Senate Example Mrs.Clinton $35,000.00 - Joe Biden $ 19,000.00 and 34 Democratic House Canditates.

Continue the insurance AIG contributed $ 59,499.00 Presidential canditate Sen John McCain, 14 others GOP Senators and 21 Republican House Candidates.-

President Obama "how do they justify this outrage to taxpayers.who are keeping the company afloat? Actually no one talks the TRUTH  Why so afraid who?  CBS,NBC, PBS etc." Only Column Mr.Jim Meyer is  brave and  the truth.-.

The problem with Socialism,you never see the light of this substance. We are in trouble....  President Barach Obama & Cabinets, Congress.-  Presidential from "our" desk  the $ BUCK   a complete INCOMPETENT. 

Thanks & Cooperation

Charles H. Garrido.

Miami Fla.-

 

 

 

Oh! Vindication .-Smith and collegues.-

Hello! Mr. Drennen, Columnist Thanks.-3/29/09. 3/28/09 9:30 PM. Dozen AIG executives going to back the money..$$. Oh!poor  cowards, demagogue, intimidation and hipocritically."Reading columnist Mr. Jim Meyers date march 18/09" "Wrote".- President   $100.000.00 bonus from AIG.- Another $101.000.00 also for Mr. Obamas.(Sen Dodd "Opensecrets.org.) AIG contributed 18 Democratic members of the Senate Example Mrs.Clinton $35,000.00 - Joe Biden $ 19,000.00 and 34 Democratic House Canditates.

Continue the insurance AIG contributed $ 59,499.00 Presidential canditate Sen John McCain, 14 others GOP Senators and 21 Republican House Candidates.-

President Obama "how do they justify this outrage to taxpayers.who are keeping the company afloat? Actually no one talks the TRUTH  Why so afraid who?  CBS,NBC, PBS etc." Only Column Mr.Jim Meyer is  brave and  the truth.-.

The problem with Socialism,you never see the light of this substance. We are in trouble....  President Barach Obama & Cabinets, Congress.-  Presidential from "our" desk  the $ BUCK   a complete INCOMPETENT. 

Thanks & Cooperation

Charles H. Garrido.

Miami Fla.-

 

 

 

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.