CBS Praises Obama Tax Cuts, Slammed Bush’s

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Stimulus Bill, CBS On Thursday’s CBS Evening News, anchor Katie Couric introduced a report on the Democrats’ so-called "stimulus" plan about to pass Congress: "And we'll tell you what's in it for you, including tax breaks...It's designed, in part, to get you spending again by giving you the money to do it." However, in July of 2001, when President Bush was trying to get tax cut legislation passed, then Evening News anchor Dan Rather warned: "...new worries that his big tax cuts, along with a shrinking budget surplus, are re-shaping the political and fiscal landscape of the country."

Following Couric, Correspondent Nancy Cordes touted the benefits of the tax cuts: "For restaurant owner Tom Glascow, and for most Americans, the new stimulus package serves up a variety of tax cuts...The biggest bit is a $400 credit for almost all workers. That comes out to about $13 a week, which may not sound like much, but consider this-" Glascow explained: "The bottom line is, is every little bit will help...Basically, what does my business good is people with disposable income that can spend a little extra on lunch on a daily basis."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Cordes went on to declare: "But the biggest winners may be low-income workers like Glascow's eight employees. The bill gives workers making as little as $3,000 a year, a check of $1,000 per child and gives a one-time payout of $250 to social security beneficiaries." The report featured Roberton Williams of the Tax Policy Center, who further defended the tax breaks: "The poor spend almost any additional money they have coming in. They have lots and lots of needs relative to their incomes. They need every dollar they can have, and a new dollar in the door goes out pretty quickly."

Back in 2001, Katie Couric, then co-host of NBC’s Today, asked Bush advisor Karen Hughes if tax cuts should be "put on hold" due to budget deficits: "...the Bush administration is relying on a $5.6 trillion surplus over the next ten years. But there is no guarantee of that...So if that money, you know, for some reason isn't there and the debt isn't being paid down that the tax cut would be put on hold. What's wrong with that notion?"

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

6:30PM TEASE:

KATIE COURIC: That package will be approved just the same. And we'll tell you what's in it for you, including tax breaks.

6:34PM SEGMENT:

KATIE COURIC: Congress is expected to approve the economic stimulus plan by tomorrow. It's designed, in part, to get you spending again by giving you the money to do it. Nancy Cordes has details.

TOM GLASCOW: Cheeseburger, American, all the way, to go!

NANCY CORDES: For restaurant owner Tom Glascow, and for most Americans, the new stimulus package serves up a variety of tax cuts.

GLASCOW: The bottom line is, is every little bit will help.

CORDES: The biggest bit is a $400 credit for almost all workers. That comes out to about $13 a week, which may not sound like much, but consider this-

GLASCOW: Basically, what does my business good is people with disposable income that can spend a little extra on lunch on a daily basis.

CORDES: Americans will also get more tax breaks for making big purchases, up to $8,000 for first-time home buyers, while new car buyers can deduct the sales tax, and the college tax credit jumps from $1,800 a year to $2,500.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Two orders of fries?

CORDES: But the biggest winners may be low-income workers like Glascow's eight employees. The bill gives workers making as little as $3,000 a year, a check of $1,000 per child and gives a one-time payout of $250 to social security beneficiaries.

ROBERTON WILLIAMS [TAX POLICY CENTER]: The poor spend almost any additional money they have coming in. They have lots and lots of needs relative to their incomes. They need every dollar they can have, and a new dollar in the door goes out pretty quickly.

CORDES: The stimulus bill does little, however, to spur small business owners, like Glascow, to add to their payroll.

WILLIAMS: President Obama, during the campaign, proposed a $3,000 refundable tax credit for any business that hired an additional worker.

BARACK OBAMA: You are going to get a tax break.

WILLIAMS: But that's been dropped. That's not part of the stimulus package.

CORDES: And in today's tough environment, it's going to take a lot to convince employers to start hiring again. Americans could start to see that extra money in their pockets within a couple of months, but the big question is will the tax breaks continue once the economy improves? Congress could find it difficult to take those tax breaks back, Katie, once they've given them out.

COURIC: Alright, Nancy Cordes on Capitol Hill tonight. Nancy, thank you.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Amazing, how by

Amazing, how by just carefully picking the right words and characterizations, a reporter can make a full glass seem empty and an empty glass seem full...

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

more like diabolical

more like diabolical

Darn, my baby is due in July

Darn, my baby is due in July so it looks like I will miss out on the $1000 freebie. Oh well.

What do you expect from the

What do you expect from the Constant Barak Syndrome network?

Katie Cupcake and her minions are clueless as to how our economy works. All they are looking to do is spin whatever is in the current news cycle to make and even more clueless Barky Obama look good.

Wow, $13. whole dollars a week

About enough for 2 gallons of gas in July when its' expected to kick in. But you shouldn't get too ecstatic, it drops to $8/week in 2010 and then goes away, such largess. For us retirees, who have seen our mutual funds go in the tank since Jan. 20th, a whole $250.00. But Wait! only if you qualify, and from what I've read so far if you took the Bush $600. last year you dont qualify for the $250. Have to wait and see. But in any case, as Michelle pointed out the $600. Bush sent might buy some ear-rings. I guess the Obama $250. is for nose rings. Too bad I'm old. I'd get a minimum wage job, have 10 or 12 kids and live like a king.

It's not YOUR money!

Any liberal will tell you that. So, you should enjoy the government's charity no matter how insignificant.

"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason

Bolton/KEYES 2012 

There are no tax cuts in

There are no tax cuts in the Socialist Takeover of America Act of 2009, only welfare payments.

-Dave

Our clueless political leaders are about to drive us all over a cliff. The time to HITM is now-before we go over.

$13 a week

WOW.....where's the line to kiss BHO's ass (or ring)

$1.86/day

I'm not sure how many jobs are going to be created for $1.86/day. However, I paid more than $50K in taxes this year. Give me back 10%, and I'm going to go buy something. When I do, here's what happens with my $5,000 tax return:

The sales clerk gets paid
The store makes a profit,,,,
   from which, the town/state gets taxes
The company/people who delivered the product get paid
The people who put the product together get paid
The people who built the equipment/factory for the product get paid
The people who shipped the refined material to the product-makers get paid
The people who extracted/refined the raw material get paid
Inventories get reduced,,,,, which means that
  additional materials are ordered,,,, which means that
     all the manufacturing plants are expanded, and more people are hired.

Now that's stimulus. Unrestricted, and triggered from a person that makes more than average. Stimulus is not triggered when the lowest-paid people are targeted with $1.86/day so someone can order fries with that burger.

Congress, and the president, should be required to work in the real world before they get elected. And then they should hold office only for a limited time. That's the only way they are going to really understand economics.

___________________________________ 

The challenge is to follow a consistent plan despite inconsistent prices - Sarah Palin, State of the State of Alaska speech

Hey TnT, Obama ...

Hey TnT, Obama claims that he worked in the real world when he was a community organizer. Of course, we know exactly what he was doing. Going into an office from 10 to 2, claiming he was there for 8 so that he could get his $10 per hour.

Obama has never worked a real job in his life. I'm talking hard labor here, not walking or riding around a neighborhood looking for 3 or 4 people in a group so that you can BS with them for an hour or so.

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

$399.99 TV

I'll be happy to spend $399.95 of the $400 rebate on a TV made in China. Don't need another TV since I have 5-6 but will buy one to help the Chinese economy using the debt Hussein is putting on everyone's great-grandchildred and beyond.

 

Old, Retired and glad of it.

Very patriotic Scrapiron

Since the Chinese hold the mortgage on our country, I guess it's best to learn how to kiss up to them.

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Stimulus passed the

Stimulus passed the House.

...as Nancy smiles...

Yep

Per C-SPAN: 

246 - 183

Seven Democrats voted against it.

One Democrat voted present.

One Democrat did not vote.

Zero Republicans voted for it.

Two Republicans did not vote.

A Democrat voted

A Democrat voted present?

I didn't know that Obama was allowed to vote on this?

Scuba... LOL! He's

Scuba...

LOL!

He's Everywhere...after-all...he is The One.

"He's

"He's Everywhere...after-all...he is The One."

Cue Scary Music.    :  )

57 ayes so far...

Looks like The One is going to get his television coverage to sign the porkulus bill Monday or Tuesday...the 3 RINOs stuck to their guns...they have 57 ayes so far, waiting on three dems somewhere to vote yet...maybe Sherrod Brown hasn't arrived yet...don't know who else is missing...but they wil get 'er done whoever it is missing for the votes, I haven't kept that close of tabs on the dem votes.

Precious isn' it?

This really sucks watching

This really sucks watching Obama steal from my granddaughter. Bastard!

Angry American II

 

 Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

→ Clear

I have three grandkids.

All I can hope for is that I amass a good sized pile of money, and pass away from a quick heart attack, without hospital bills, leaving them with the money and the apology I've already given them.

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Amen! I'm not going down

Amen!

I'm not going down without a fight. Somehow, someway, I will let them know they owe my granddaughter. Why do I feel we have totally lost control of our country?

Angry American II

 

 Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

→ Me neither

Why do I see, in my mind, a dissident standing in front of a tank in Tiananmem Square?

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Ct...Cool... Well...it is

Ct...Cool...

Well...it is over now...they are just waiting for Brown to soar in like an eagle with his vote...

Freedom, free market, ...don't make me laugh...more to come with upcoming bills at the ready...socialism, here we come big time.

Btw, we have 13 grandchildren...great-grand child not long making his/her way into this mess.

Lord help us all...

Dude!

 
LOL!  Good one Dude! Knowing Barry, he did vote! LOL!

 

Gary


Sorry Al, I've used up my allotment of "give a crap!"

They love tax cuts when

They love tax cuts when they aren't actually tax cuts...

You know what ...

You know what really ticks me off, these holier-than-thou democrats claiming that Clinton left President Bush with a budget surplus and that Bush blew it.

First off, Clinton didn't leave a budget surplus. A surplus means that more came in than you spent. That may be true as long as you don't have a debt. However, this country had a rather large debt when Clinton left office, so any surplus would have had to be sued to pay on the national debt. With all the surplus going to the debt, how could Clinton have left this so called surplus?

The dems favor saying is "Oh what a tangled web we weave when we practice to deceive."

Remember folks, Freedom isn't Free. It was bought with the blood and sacrifice of the men and women who are serving and who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For those who fought for it, Freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.

Also remember folks, that the way to SUPPORT THE TROOPS is to support their mission. Anyone who says that they support the troops but don't support their mission is lying about supporting the troops. And if you want to know, yes I do have a dog in the fight, he is a United States Marine.

 

They can try to put a positive

spin on this tax cut all they want but I predict that the ones that are going to complain the loudest are their own constituants.  They have been spoiled with Bush's lump sum payments.  What good is extra money in your paycheck if you don't have a paycheck???? LOL.  Most of them do not know how to fill out their w4 to get all their money now or even advanced earned income credits.  They will reject the advanced EIC because it is just a few more dollars in their paycheck.  I speak from experience.

$13 a week??

What am I missing? $400 over a 52 week period is $7.69 a week.

$13 a week for 52 weeks is  $676.

 

$13.00 dollars a week.

It has been adjusted to allow for the fact that it won't start untill mid year.  The government isn't very efficient ( duh) it will take that long to gear up for it.  It will involve paperwork changes for employers reporting withholdings etc.  Next year it will start in January, therefore the $8.00 dollar figure for that period.

Thanks Pokerface. I knew it

Thanks Pokerface. I knew it had to be something I was overlooking.

You're forgetting they used Hussein's math....

No matter what they send out it will all go to China, other than what the druggie democrats spend on drugs (also imported) and booze, some produced in the U.S.

Old, Retired and glad of it.

→ Hussein's math

Hussein's math would have yielded votes from 57 States today.

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

..remember back when Bush's tax cuts were being debated

...and one Senator brought in a muffler as a prop to show that the money saved wasn't much at all? I think that was Little Dick Gephart.

 The MSM spin: 2001/2003 tax cuts (real reduction in rates) "THE MONEY SAVED HERE IS NOT MUCH IF ANYTHING!"

The MSM spin 2009: "13 DOLLARS A WEEK IS HELPFUL TO ANYONE AND BETTER THAN NOTHING!!"

→ No fair Jnoble

I don't refer to the President as Big Ears Obama.

Please don't call him Little Dick Gephart

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

→ Gillibrand holding out????

I'm seeing Gillibrand (D - NY) as not having voted yet.

57 of 60 AYES already cast.

Come on!!!  Somebody's gotta have some guts.

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Cool... I also just posted

Cool... I also just posted about the vote...I have since seen the four not voted yet...Brown we know about, he is supposed to have been flown in by now... maybe Gillibrand is in NY because of the plane crash? ..but where is Bayh? Now That is strange...
maybe two defectors....or as Reid likes to call our 3 RINOs...patriotic americans.

Sorry about the jumble here...in a hurry.

Martinez finally voted...NO...big whoop though, we need the dems to defect.

→ Gillibrand and Reid

Then Harry Reid took Kirsten Gillibrand to a high pinnacle and said

"All of this will I give unto thee if you will just bow down and worship me"

 

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Cool.. Looks like they

Cool..

Looks like they are going to keep this vote open until the water-boarding is done,

→ No kidding bt

Can you imagine the pressure little Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), and NRA member is under right now?

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

→ D@mmit

So she caved in.

Gillibrand- AYE

No doubt what Bayh and Brown will do.

  • When Liberals raise the bar, expect The Limbo

Her torture session is

Her torture session is over..she just voted Aye.

They may have to fly in Kennedy before the night is over.

seriously...I am surprised at Bayh.

Btw..if he is up for

Btw..if he is up for reelection, I haven't looked, will in a minute if he doesn't vote soon...he may be doing the right thing when it comes to ND.

I know the phone calls are 100-1 against this bill to their offices.

Talk about making the Sunday talk show rounds...lol.

Nah...can't see him doing it...voting against this.

Obama raids Social Security, hears crickets

When Bush proposed allowing us the option to use a portion of our payroll taxes to invest in the stock market in an attempt to improve on the return we get from Social Security, you'd have sworn we were going to throw old people naked into the street.  But let Obama give a "payroll tax credit" which should decrease the amount of money available for Social Security, it's nothing but the sound of crickets.  What happened to the "third rail of politics"?  Why can Obama steal from Social Security without a peep? 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

I don't think tax cuts will

I don't think tax cuts will work now.  Under a more stable economy, they obviously did.  The problem is the credit freeze and more recently this pork garbage...scaring the hell out of potential investors and lenders.

Actually, the solution is to find (or plant) a sour apple tree in the vicinity of the Capitol.

(Just a satirical metaphor, for you government types lurking out there).

One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

HMMMMM

 

 The liberal propaganda machine at it's best 

Hmmmm

 

 Remember people the same thing happend in Germany in the 30's 

CBS News is comedy, isn't

CBS News is comedy, isn't it?

Liberalism is a convenient lie.