CBS’s Smith Reviews Harvey Milk Movie: ‘A Must-See’

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Harry Smith and James Franco, CBS On Wednesday’s CBS Early Show, co-host Harry Smith interviewed actor James Franco, who stars opposite Sean Penn in a new movie about gay San Francisco politician Harvey Milk: "Actor James Franco is here to talk about his role in the much-talked-about new movie, 'Milk.' He is amazing in it." At the end of the show, Smith thanked Franco for being a guest and offer this review of the movie: "James Franco in 'Milk,' amazing performance. Sean Penn, off the charts. It's a must-see for everybody."

On November 30, CBS’s Sunday Morning offered a similar glowing description of the film, describing Milk as a "rebel with a cause." In the Wednesday interview, Smith described Franco’s role in the movie as a career-maker: "...there’s this completely other performance here. I mean, there's a part of you that's go to be, ‘this means I have a career,’ and 'I'm not just -- I'm not the pretty face on the Gucci ads, I get a career now.’"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Here is the full transcript of the Wednesday segment,

7:01AM TEASE:

HARRY SMITH: Actor James Franco who's starring in 'Milk' with Sean Penn, getting rave reviews. He'll be here to talk about his big role this morning as well.

8:00AM TEASE:

MAGGIE RODRIGUEZ: Actor James Franco stops by, he's getting Oscar buzz for his latest role in 'Milk.'

[CLIP FROM 'MILK]

JAMES FRANCO: You know, I remember when your birthday's were a little less lavish and a little more intimate.

SEAN PENN: Who invited you in?

[END OF CLIP]

8:01AM TEASE:

SMITH: And actor James Franco is here to talk about his role in the much-talked-about new movie, 'Milk.' He is amazing in it.

8:12AM TEASE:

BRANDY: Up next, James Franco talks about his critically acclaimed new movie, 'Milk.'

8:30AM TEASE:

SMITH: Also ahead, hot young actor -- those are Gucci boots, right? James, don't you do -- don't you do Gucci?

JAMES FRANCO: Yeah, you need some-

SMITH: See, it's a synergy thing.

BRANDY: Amazing.

SMITH: Right, okay. Yeah, he is amazing.

BRANDY: He is.

SMITH: He's here to talk about his brand new movie based on the life of Harvey Milk, so that's what we're going to talk about in a minute.

8:33AM SEGMENT:

HARRY SMITH: Actor James Franco is having a breakout year. This summer, he played a stoner in the hit comedy 'Pineapple Express,' now he is receiving Oscar buzz for his role as Harvey Milk's lover and confidante in the new film 'Milk.'

[CLIP FROM 'MILK']

SEAN PENN: Can I just tell you-

JAMES FRANCO: If you say anything about politics, or the campaign, or what speech you have to give, or anything, I swear to God, I'm going to stab you with this fork.

SEAN PENN: I just wanted to say that this is the most wonderful dinner I have ever had. If we lose this, it'll just be you and me again, I promise.

[END OF CLIP]

SMITH: Right. James Franco is here this morning. Good morning, good to see you, man.

FRANCO: Good to see you.

SMITH: Wow, what a movie.

FRANCO: Yes.

SMITH: For people who don't understand, Harvey Milk was the first openly gay man elected to an important public office in the United States of America.

FRANCO: Yeah.

SMITH: He was subsequently assassinated.

FRANCO: Yes.

SMITH: You play?

FRANCO: I play Scott Smith, his partner, who -- Harvey Milk had to run four times before he was elected to office. And my character helped him with his early campaigns, not knowing anything about politics. You know, they moved out to San Francisco together and-

SMITH: At least in the movie, you very much are the emotional spine to Sean Penn's character.

FRANCO: Yeah. I mean, that was -- I think that was one of the good things about this movie. You know, it's kind of like a bio pic, but not really. It doesn't feel like that to me. And I think one of the ways that they just got around that is he makes it a very personal story and you really get to see that the, you know, the private life of Harvey Milk.

SMITH: Did you and Sean talk about this ahead of time or did you show up on the set and he -- because he -- he goes some place with this.

FRANCO: Correct.

SMITH: I mean this is -- there's a kind of an affectation, but it is -- he makes a serious commitment to this role.

FRANCO: Yeah, yeah.

SMITH: Did you talk about it ahead of time?

FRANCO: Yeah, I mean we had rehearsals and stuff like that as far as like the scenes go. And you know, he's Sean. Everybody that shows up on the set is thinking, like, 'okay I just don't want to, you know, screw up with Sean Penn,' but he -- and you know, he's a guy of such a stature that he could easily intimidate everybody on set. But he was the complete opposite and was very, you know, welcoming and just encouraging and really brought everyone together.

SMITH: What did it mean to you to do this movie? Because people know you from the 'Spiderman' movies. And then they know you, they think they know you, from 'Pineapple Express' and then there's this completely other performance here. I mean, there's a part of you that's go to be, 'this means I have a career,' and 'I'm not just -- I'm not the pretty face on the Gucci ads, I get a career now.'

FRANCO: Well, I was trying to play the character from 'Pineapple Express,' did that not come across?

SMITH: [Laughter] That worked, but you can only make so many of those movies before people say 'oh, that's that guy who does that all the time.'

FRANCO: That's what they say about you.

SMITH: [Laughter] Exactly right. Exactly right.

FRANCO: No I -- no it was an incredible opportunity and I actually -- I actually pursued it. I heard Gus was doing it. I was in London studying and I wrote him an e-mail and just told him, you know, I'd do anything to be a part of this movie. And also just because, you know, because it's such an important movie, but also, you know, he's been one of my favorite directors since I started.

SMITH: That's not a bad troika, the three of you guys working together on a movie?

FRANCO: It was, I mean, truly a dream to -- to work with both those guys.

SMITH: And in the meantime, what people may not know is you're simultaneously studying film at NYU right now and writing at Columbia?

FRANCO: Yes.

SMITH: Right. And making movies.

FRANCO: That's why -- I thought my classes were early. This is pretty early. [Laughter] But I just didn't -- you know, I'm -- I'm in the film program and we had to work on documentaries, so I just did a documentary on the behind the scenes of SNL. And I know that you've, for Biography, you did the same.

SMITH: Did the same, yeah. We'll compare notes.

FRANCO: Yes, we will.

SMITH: You're such a good teacher, that's why I did that, that thing.

FRANCO: You've got it down, what have you been smoking this morning?

SMITH: Just -- just the biscotti that's it. Thanks man, good to see you.

FRANCO: Good to see you.

SMITH: Congratulations.

8:52AM TEASE

SMITH: James Franco in 'Milk,' amazing performance. Sean Penn, off the charts. It's a must-see for everybody. Thanks for stopping by this morning.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

What Harry asked that the cameras missed

SMITH: James Franco in 'Milk,' amazing performance. Sean Penn, off the charts. It's a must-see for everybody. Thanks for stopping by this morning. Oh by the way, do you like Gladiator movies, Franco?

Harry sez:

So Franco, ever seen a grown man naked?

(airplane classic)/off

I'd add

I picked a fine time to give up airplane glue . . .

(but I'd be way off topic.)

ahem.

CBS’s Smith Reviews Harvey Milk Movie: ‘A Must-See’

So? Sometimes I think this site should be called Newsblusters.

Preaching to the choir again

It is amazing to me how movies that preach to the Hollywood choir are oscar material.

Just because it is PC doesn't make it a must see.

Hollywood Rule Of Thumb

If it's about gay people it's Oscar worthy.

Award challenge

If that is true, then I challenge them to be more upfront and change the award statue to a pair. Oscar and Harry for the men, Olive and Harriet for women, and Renne and Richard for men who are now women, and visa-versa.

I have spent a lot of time

Avoiding any movie that Sean Penn is in. Even before I knew his politics. He and Tim Robbins won Oscars for bashing President Bush. I am breathlessly awaiting his return to oblivion.  

Change: When the winds of change blow hard enough, the most trivial of things can become deadly projectiles. From a Poster

Why Watch C-BS News?

The guys and gals over at C-BS news are so predictable in their opinions that it's a total waste of time to even watch it.

<insert sarcasm> 

No way, Harry Smith loves the movie "Milk" and wants every man, woman, and kindergarten class in America to go and see it? Amazing! What will he say next? I can't turn off C-BS news because their analysis is so unique and unpredictable!

<end sarcasm>

I would rather eat glass!

I would rather eat glass than to sit through the misery of watching a movie about Harvey Milk played by the detestable Sean Penn.  An evening with C-Span would be tempting over any movie with Penn.

Jeff Lebowski

www.angrywhitedude.c...

I'd rather eat glass too Jeff! Is he Sam or is he Milk?

Penn looks like he's his I am Sam character trying to be Milk.  The previews look horrible.  I'd never see anything with Penn but this looks especially bad. 

Penn has become the caricature Hollywood star played by Ben Stiller in Tropic Thunder.  He's so bad now.  No more talent just radical admirers.   /p>

I would never see a movie

I would never see a movie Penn is in. 

However, if I were a Hollywood producer I am not sure I'd want to talk about a new release on CBS or frankly, any of the alphabet networks.  They're losing viewers at a record pace. 

If Hollywood doesn't stand for PR it doesn't stand for anything. Appearing on an alphabet network might could doom a movie. 

Just an observation.  I hope they all bomb.

→ Milk Dud

CBS has no choice but plug the movie.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Cool

Milk Dud LOL. That's great. Anyway why a movie about this guy at this time. I mean this guy was killed before John Lennon was and more importantly WGAS. This movie is a sure loser right out of the gate (I recall seeing Dan White was right T-shirts, you can probably go to jail for that stuff now).   

Change: When the winds of change blow hard enough, the most trivial of things can become deadly projectiles. From a Poster

but plug? freudian slip?

but plug? freudian slip?

→ I'm innocent

Anyone who knows me knows I NEVER make use of double entendre.  I probably couldn't even spell it if I tried.

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

In my local carbon-based media...

...they have a recap of 10 critics & newspapers. There were 8 outstanding (4-star) and 2 worth efforts (3-star). That's usually a sign of a 'critically acclaimed' film worth missing. BoxOfficeMojo.com says the film made $4.6 million in 14 days of release. Not exactly a barnburner.

'Milk' reminds me of '30 Rock' - all the critics love it but no viewers. 

Many in Hollywood will never learn.

www.ArmchairEnergist...

I am surprised it

made that much. 1/2 of that was probably in SF the other in NY and DC

Change: When the winds of change blow hard enough, the most trivial of things can become deadly projectiles. From a Poster

 I would say take a film

 I would say take a film class....judge something after you see it...but then again for a website that so proudly proclaimed "An Amereican Carol" (which thankfully I watched online, so as not to lose any money when I couldn't finish it) to be a good movie I don't think "taste" and true understanding of the art form is something most of you really care about. All I can say guys is: Stick to your politics, you're out of your league on this one.

Milk will make it's money over a long period of time because that's what happens in a limited release film of critical acclaim...spreads through word of mouth. Now it's already winning end of year awards...and to the yuppies, a movie isn't worth the time unless it wins a few awards...so expect all involved with this one to get a pat on the back and a pay boost on their next project.

Think Well.

Sorry pal, Americans dont

Sorry pal, Americans dont want to see a preachy movie about an in your face homosexual.

→ Snuggles

An "in your face" homosexual?

EEEWWWW.  (not that there's anything wrong with it)

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

"...so expect all


"...so expect all involved with this one to get a pat on the back"

 

You are probably right, except for the location of the pat.  I have a lower opinion of that than you.

I'll give you 10-1 odds that this is a loser

This movie is DOA. But even W made 28 million (or so I have read). So there is no accounting for taste? 

Change: When the winds of change blow hard enough, the most trivial of things can become deadly projectiles. From a Poster

Give Harry Smith a break. 

Give Harry Smith a break.  The reason he adores this piece of cinematic excrement is because he has eaten too many Twinkies.

Liberal: a power worshipper without power. George Orwell

Twinkies..

Yeah, that white mustache... not milk.

"Bri is with Jesus now, we will meet again, just not right now. We love you Bri!"

LOL

I completely forgot the "Twinkie Defense" 

Change: When the winds of change blow hard enough, the most trivial of things can become deadly projectiles. From a Poster

Giving "Milk" the heave-ho

The thought of seeing "Milk" makes me want to toss my cookies.

I have to wonder if those California cows in the dairy ads are still happy cows after seeing the name of their product co-opted. 

Welcome to the era of unity, you racist!

Harriet Smith's second

Harriet Smith's second favorite movie: Brokeback Mountain.

→ Got Milk?

At his Oscar acceptance, Sean Penn will doubtless say:

Hind sight is hubba-hubba!

  • LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

sean penn is nothing but a

sean penn is nothing but a moronic super-liberal.  Any time I've had the misfortune of accidentally seeing that idiot on TV he's been either severely drunk or high.  Oh yes, great role model.  Yet another lib that just needs to die.  Soon.

 

UGH, Sean Penn

A, I the only one who when they see SP immediately pictures him in his little boat in N.O. trying to rescue people during Katrina? He was down there to "help," Yet ended up making things worse. Typical Hollyweird star. I had a friend that is a FF/EMT that was down there at the time, and they were all cussing SP et al who were actually putting themselves in danger and causing the workers to have to try to rescue them, instead of the residents.

Anti American Values Movies

Oliver Stone Sean Penn Michael Moore, which one will produce the Movie that needs no Script, its title you ask?

"Punch and Pinch how the Grey Lady was raped.."

Obama's last day 1-20-2013