CBS ‘Early Show’ Uses Domino Props to Explain Financial Crisis

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

In case viewers did not understand the concept of a domino effect caused by the financial crisis, on Wednesday’s CBS Early Show, co-host Julie Chen offered a visual representation as she declared: "What happens on Wall Street affects all of us on Main Street. It's the classic domino effect." At that point, six giant dominos where displayed in the studio, each one labeled with a different phase of the economic crisis (see video).

Chen went through each phase, and domino, with financial expert Vera Gibbons. At the end of the segment, Gibbons explained: "It's a domino effect, it all works together." Gibbons then knocked over the giant dominos and declared: "Voila!" Chen replied: "That's depressing." Prior to offering such a dumbed-down explanation of the financial crisis, on Monday, Chen referred to all the comedic material Sarah Palin provided to Saturday Night Live: "Tina Fey has just so much material to work with, this is like, probably a dream come true for her."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

7:03AM SEGMENT:

JULIE CHEN: What happens on Wall Street affects all of us on Main Street. It's the classic domino effect. Joining us is financial journalist and 'Early Show' contributor Vera Gibbons. Vera, good morning.

[SIX GIANT DOMINOS SETUP IN STUDIO, LABELED WITH DIFFERENT PHASES OF THE FINANCIAL CRISIS]

VERA GIBBONS: Good morning, Julie.

CHEN: Can Wall Street fix itself without a bailout?

GIBBONS: No, I mean, we need a bailout package. This is the worst financial crisis we've seen in decades. It's affecting the markets, it's affecting the economy, something needs to be done, it looks like, by all accounts, something will be done soon.

CHEN: It seems like there's no confidence.

GIBBONS: There is no confidence, I mean, confidence has taken a huge hit. These banks made a lot of bad bets on real estate, to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars, lost a lot of money in the process. And in the meantime, too, lost a lot of trust, lost a lot of confidence. And that affects main street. Now there's a credit crunch, a credit freeze. People are going out there, trying to get a mortgage, can't get a loan, can't get a student loan, can't get an auto loan. None of that stuff. So, there is a broader impact on the consumer here.

CHEN: With that, what's happened to the housing market since there -- because of this credit crunch?

GIBBONS: Right, well housing values continuing to go down because desperate sellers can't sell their homes to perspective buyers because buyers can't get the financing. That's pushing prices down even more. In order for the housing market to stabilize, you really need to wipe out some of that inventory. We have over an 11-month supply. A lot of homes on the market right now sitting there. For stuff to stabilize, we have to get rid of some of that and that'll be a while.

CHEN: Okay, why is credit a problem for businesses?

GIBBONS: Right, businesses are having the same problem that the banks just aren't lending to them. They're not lending to them, they're not lending to consumers, they're not lending to businesses. So, we've seen more people lose their jobs. We've had over 600,000 layoffs so far. The unemployment rate is up to 6.1%, a five year high. Could go up to 7-7.5% sometime in 2009. Small businesses in particular, really having a difficult time. They can't get the financing they need to expand their operations to buy new equipment, to hire new employees. And some of them can't even fund their existing payrolls. So more layoffs inevitable.

CHEN: So with more layoffs, people are not spending.

GIBBONS: Well that's the issue. They don't have jobs or they're losing their jobs, their losing their homes. We've had a lot stock market declines. Wages are virtually stagnant. Home costs are going up. The cost of living, everything from gas to groceries is up. Home heating bills are ridiculously high. So there's no money out there to spend, which has called -- caused a panic.

CHEN: Which is the last step [points to giant domino labeled 'Panic'], people are in a panic.

GIBBONS: Right, I mean, look what happened on Monday, over $1 trillion in stock market value gone. Now thankfully, we regained a lot of those losses just yesterday. But people's retirement accounts, their college funds, have been totally wiped out. So there's a wide sense of panic out there. And no one knows how long, how deep this recession is actually going to be. So-

CHEN: Which causes loss in confidence, ends in panic, and it is-

[GIBBONS KNOCKS OVER GIANT DOMINOS]

GIBBONS: It's a domino effect, it all works together. Voila!

CHEN: That's depressing.

GIBBONS: It's depressing. But things will get better, first step is actually get this bill passed and then move on.

CHEN: Vera Gibbons, thanks.

GIBBONS: Thanks, Julie.

CHEN: You're welcome.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Talk about

Talk about awkward.

 Nonetheless, the domino effect is also a perfect representation of CBS's ratings.

come again?

"Now thankfully, we regained a lot of those losses just yesterday.  But people's retirement accounts, their college funds, have been totally wiped out."

Huh?  What am I missing here?

 

And Darkness and Decay and the Red Death held illimitable dominion over all.   -- Edgar Allen Poe

Everyone has been wiped out...

....just like they were in October 1987 (Dow Jones down to 1739)

...just like they were after Iraq invaded Kuwait (Dow Jones down to 2416)

...just like they were following 9/11 (Dow Jones down to 8236)

...just like they were in the run-up to the 2d Iraq war (Dow Jones down to 7286)

Now then, if I remember my math correctly, yesterday's close of 10,850 is anywhere between 31% and 623% higher than all the numbers I just listed.

The MSM has no sense of history and is incapable of rational thought.

You give them far too much

You give them far too much credit for being naive.  They know exactly what they are doing, it's the long con.  They are trying to convince people the government can solve their problems, once they do, our freedoms are gone and they as the propaganda arm of the PC get to tell us what to think and do.

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

Precisely -- there are lots

Precisely -- there are lots of short-term fluctuations superimposed on a longer term positive trend.  Yes, my 401k shares will probably be showing losses from the last quarter (and even forthcoming quarters).  The question is, what will they be worth at retirement age?  And the answer is, probably much more than today.  And anyone near retirement age ought to have their 401k made up of far less volitile investments, and thus also ride this out.

 

 

And Darkness and Decay and the Red Death held illimitable dominion over all.   -- Edgar Allan Poe

We have no voice

If the senate passes this trash it only proves that we don't live in representative democracy. People have been surprisingly attentive to this matter and the Senate decides, "we'll use leadership and pass it in spite of the overwhelming wishes of the voters."

Well whats the use of voting? When push comes to shove, the government just handles us. Its a very scary time we live in. It doesn't matter who wins this election because socialism is already upon us. It crept in sometime in the middle of the night.

I can no longer see bothering to vote in the Presidential election. I never though I'd say that but this utter disregard of the voters wishes has whipped me. Its demoralizing and defeating. We have no voice.

So you're just gonna let it

So you're just gonna let it happen?

I'm not letting anything, I have no voice.

I'm not letting it happen. I have no voice. Anyone who opposes this has no voice. Even the main stream media has reported the unprecedented opposition to this idea. And that's when our representatives decided to ignore us and under the "leadership" euphemism, they decided to ignore the voter and cram it down the voters throat. We *will* opt in. We have no voice. We have no vote. We are being handled.

 

nws... Well, I 've been

nws...

Well, I 've been calling when I can get through...and the Senate is going to cram this down out throats...

Only hope we have now is the House again.

I am furious and sickened by this, they are not listening to us out here...including McCain.

You are right...we matter not...or voices aren't listened to...we are just shoved aside.

I don't know quite yet how I am going to vote now, I thought I did after Palin was named, but this takes the cake,  this is a sad day. 

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

I'm not going to vote

I don't plan on voting any time soon. I do plan on getting in a lot of arguments with people that tell me I have no right to say anything if I don't perform my duty and vote.

Its not a duty, its a facade. Its an illusion to make people feel empowered when they have none.

You have many representatives quite prepared to act contrary to their constituents wishes, and that idea is welcomed in the liberal media, the conservative media, in both houses, and in the White House.

nwahs... Then you are

nwahs...

Then you are part of the problem, not part of the solution!

Palin Is Caught And Her Career Is Over! 

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Yea boy

Yea you ignore rogue senators and put it on me :) Like I care at this point. Business as usual eh? Snipe snipe snipe. Just another day at the office here-eh?

 

If you think voter apathy is the problem, you are incredibly naive, or incredibly stupid. I have the stomach for neither right now.

 

No vote = Obama

No vote = Obama

If there is anything that the phenomenon known as Sarah Palin demonstrates, it's that America is a country where anybody, no matter how humble their beginnings, can rise up and make a difference. 

 

And Darkness and Decay and the Red Death held illimitable dominion over all.   -- Edgar Allan Poe

The Senate is about to vote

Well the Senate is about to vote to bipartisanly screw us, and the cone of silence on the networks continues. Its on Cspan though.

They're poised at FNC.

They're poised at FNC.

 

 

And Darkness and Decay and the Red Death held illimitable dominion over all.   -- Edgar Allan Poe

Still hoping

I see that. I'm still hoping this thing is defeated. They're voting on this procedural thing right now, and its flying through.

Well obviously is wasn't procedural, it was the vote.

I find it so comforting that those who understand this need for this government package confused the procedural vote with the actual vote. Yea, FNC missed the actual vote. They said that vote was just to fill up the "shell bill." No, it was the actual vote. I don't care. Life's sweet if you don't care about politics.

The freaky irony is both my senators voted "no." Still I feel disenfranchised, and absolutely no inclination to vote for a Republican in the near future.

 

McCain had a chance to be a leader and he failed miserably. In no way could I ever vote for him. Huckabee had the guts to come out against this garbage. McCain didn't. He's a typical senator - above the voter. We'll good luck to him. He'll carry my red state, but I sure as hell won't vote for him. How did we wind up with him? We really need to reform the primary system.

 

Lou Dobbs not interested in "congress sandwich"

Lou Dobbs on Imus in the Morning, on the Bail Out Bill. Hint he isn’t interested in a Crap Sandwich, thanks anyway.

http://www.wabcradio.com/Article.asp?id=913480&spid=22807

Yeah the opposition to this 700 Billion Dollar Bail Out is piling
up. Who gets to come back later, and claim they didn’t know any better
when it is being reported every where? Credibility? Forget
Accountability this is the drama driving some politician’s re election
chances or not.

Ifill has a conflict of interest per Moderator

I have been reading she wrote a book or is writing a book about Obama? And Ifill is going to be moderator of the Vice Presidential Debate? Huh did I miss something about neutral unbiased journalism?

 

http://imustimes.wor...

 

Brains

Librals were born without brains.

No no, they just never

No no, they just never learned to use them. and they never will unless they grow up, get a job, or leave the echo chamber that is academia.

Unwelcome players.

I don't want the government to play with my dominos. Or my Risk. Or my Life. Or any of my stuff for that matter. They are the ones who tip things over, lose pieces and break everything.

Exactly Karma... what a

Exactly Karma... what a witty way to put it like you did.

Plus have you seen the other little dominoes they want to add to this bail-out package?

This is from Hot Air.

Started with a 3 page bill, has grown to 450 page one...and still growing...this pork is outrageous. 

We all need to speak out today/this evening before they vote.

Switchboard Number to connect anyone to any congressional office is 202-224-3121

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

They're going to do it anyway.

They already know an overwhelming amount of voters are against it. They're going to pass it anyway, probably in the middle of the night.

nws... Not if it gets

nws...

Not if it gets filibustered...by a real maverick, which is and has been Coburn since he stepped into the Senate.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Well I hope someone steps up

I just wrote to the McCain camp. I doubt it will do any good, but I honestly want them to know, this is one of the few things that could make me sit out the election. Its like a slap in the face. All those voters calling to say "WE DONT WANT THIS" and they're gonna try to ram it down our throats? Why vote?

It would be great to see someone stand up and trust the millions of people who have been following this and expressing their wishes. Obviously, it isn't only Democrats who are elite are above the average American.

The Republicans on Cspan2 are talking like its going to pass.

The Republicans on Cspan2 sound more like Democrats than Republicans. They're more or less saying they'll screw the tax payer in a bipartisan manner. They're calming our fears. They're utterly ignoring our wishes (because we are so dumb we don't understand the free market or capitalism), but they are making it clear, there will be no deadly "golden parachutes!"

They are indeed a confederacy of dunces.

nws... There may be

nws...

There may be plenty of dems who are going to vote against this too...we've got to remember that.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Question?

If this damn thing (which I personally HATE) is so gd good and the only thing that will save our America, as 'they' tell us, .. then why isn't every single member of congress voting yes?  And by the way...I like to be kissed first if ya know what I mean.

 

"I have a bracelet too" ..Barak Obama, Political Sociopath

How cute

Dominos my ass. It's a shell game.

I'm sure CBS will be not be covering that part at the end where Gibbons says "But don't worry, things will get better." 

Perhaps contact the McCain camp?

I wonder if it would do any good contacting the McCain camp? Right now I can't see myself pulling the lever for him. He has been anything but a leader in this. Yea, I get the feeling he's trying to be a deal maker maverick, but I get NO sense he's listening to voters. I am completely disgusted with him right now.

I have

I suggested many of the items that have been discussed here. The Media is killing him on this issue, so I doubt he will do any thing very Maveric like.

 

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

So we have another MSM type

So we have another MSM type telling us we must accept the deal as is, otherwise the trigger on the gun to our heads will be pulled.  Sounds more like a conartist hustling the mark. NO DEAL is better than a BAD DEAL.  The current deal before the Senate is nothing more than a variation of the porked deal the House shot down, that is NOT ACCEPTABLE.  So here's the deal Dems, if there is NO DEAL you are going down with us...  What's it going to be?  A mutual suicide pact or give us a clean bill that actually addresses and solves the problem with no pork and no hidden nasty surprises?

Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.

I get the feeling

As long as it makes Repubs look bad they would comite suicide

 

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Well that would make Repubs

Well that would make Repubs look terrible! How do we get them to see that?

Next CBS will use

Next CBS will use a Monoply board to show people who didnt have the ability to get a loan normally being given property by Barney Frank

The logical chain would have

The logical chain would have been complete if the first domino was labeled "Democrat Policies" or more specifically "Carter & Clinton's Community Reinvestment Act".

Just wait until they do a

Just wait until they do a segment on the "slippery slope" of entitlements...

Care to bet on whether Julie prefers mud, oil, or Jell-O?

Democrats need it broken down Barney style!

BigSpoon65

Keep in mind that the intelligence of your average democrat is barely above their shoe size.  So they need to find these elementary school visual effects so their viewers can understand the depth of the problem.  This is why CBS ratings are dead last as it seems it might be more educational to watch Barney the dinosaur.  I bet they were really impressed with themselves with this demonstration!  What a bunch of morons.  

Conservative.....Because we can't all be on welfare!

Dominoes Falling

The CBS dominoes need to have the faces of Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, Harry Reid, Chuck Schumer, Charles Rangel and last ut not least Nancy Pelosi. Scary indeed! These are the faces that caused those dominoes to fall. Things will change, that's for sure!

Stupid fear mongering propaganda

Gibbons has no common sense. Maybe she can explain why the the markets can't fix themselves? No, she can't because she is a mindless marxist. She says something needs to be done, I'll tell you what needs to be done. First, you need to lose your job as a phony "expert". The marxist palaces of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae should be burned down. The idiots who took out bad loans should lose their homes, poperty, and pay the price for their stupidity. What kind of idiot takes out a loan they can't afford, let alone a loan from a government institution? Frank, Dodd, Raines, Gorelic, Johnson and all the rest of them should be in prison. The CRA should be ripped out of the books and Carter can proudly take it with him to his grave.

Socialism caused this and she thinks more socialism is going to fix it? mindless. The Early Show has the most embarrasing propaganda I have ever seen. Gibbons is a phony "expert" and the domino demonstration is one of the dumbest things I have ever seen. The fear mongering going on with this has reached global warming porportions.

On top of that I have lost nearly all respect for Bush for supporting this folly and joining the effort in trying to shove socialism down our throats.

"Push back the liberal hordes!!" - Mark Levin