CBS: People Stealing Manhole Covers In Tough Economy

Photo of Kyle Drennen.

Priya David, CBS If any further evidence was needed to prove that the country is in a recession, the CBS Early Show found it, as co-host Maggie Rodriguez declared: "Coming up this morning, during hard times in some U.S. cities, they're as good as gold. Manhole covers being stolen and sold for scrap." Co-host Harry Smith later introduced the segment on this desperate trend: "Across the country thieves are stealing metal objects like manhole covers because the price of scrap metal has sky rocketed."

Correspondent Priya David reported on the problem: "That's right, thieves are literally stealing the street right out from under you. One area of the nation hardest hit by these thefts is Philadelphia. Typically they'd lose about a hundred manhole covers or grates a year to theft. But in the past year, 2,000 have gone missing." She went to describe how: "When you look at this street, you probably see a manhole cover. But to a thief, this looks like free money." As David later mentioned, that "free money" isn’t much: "Each cover nets a thief a grand total of about $10."

David detailed how the crime wave was starting to take it’s toll: "In Philadelphia, this girl is one of two children who suffered minor injuries from falling into open holes." She then turned to Democratic Mayor of Philadelphia, Michael Nutter: "That can be a very dangerous situation. But, you know, you can never be too surprised at the creativity and the lengths that people will go, you know, when facing, you know, a financial challenge, trying to take care of themselves."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

David concluded her report with some proposed solutions: "It's a public safety problem and an expensive one. In a year, Philadelphia replaced 2,000 manhole covers at the cost of $150 each. Then these two employees came up with a cheaper solution. Simply chain the covers down...Philadelphia is also looking at other creative solutions to protect its 140,000 covers. In the coming months it'll be testing plastic covers, such as this one." It is unclear how people dependent upon scrap metal from manhole covers as a source of income will be able to survive these new measures in a struggling economy.

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

7:15AM TEASER:

MAGGIE RODRIGUEZ: Coming up this morning, during hard times in some U.S. cities, they're as good as gold. Manhole covers being stolen and sold for scrap.

7:19AM SEGMENT:

HARRY SMITH: Across the country thieves are stealing metal objects like manhole covers because the price of scrap metal has sky rocketed. CBS News correspondent Priya David is back with the story. Good morning, Priya.

PRIYA DAVID: Harry, good morning. That's right, thieves are literally stealing the street right out from under you. One area of the nation hardest hit by these thefts is Philadelphia. Typically they'd lose about a hundred manhole covers or grates a year to theft. But in the past year, 2,000 have gone missing. When you look at this street, you probably see a manhole cover. But to a thief, this looks like free money. Nationwide, manhole and sewer covers are vanishing and leaving gaping holes in streets from Phoenix, Arizona, to Flint, Michigan. Thieves are turning the heavy metal covers into cold, hard cash. In the United States, the price of scrap iron has sky rocketed 300% in just the past five years. In 2003, one ton of metal scrap, such as sewer grates, sold for $125. Six months ago, $300. Today they're worth $600 a ton. Each cover nets a thief a grand total of about $10. That's if the scrap metal yard doesn't turn the seller into police. As yard owner David Richman now does.

DAVID RICHMAN: Because no responsible yard will take one. If someone steals a manhole cover, somebody else can fall in it.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: The whole top was off.

DAVID: In Philadelphia, this girl is one of two children who suffered minor injuries from falling into open holes.

UNIDENTIFIED GIRL: I was scared. And I hurt myself.

MICHAEL NUTTER: That can be a very dangerous situation. But, you know, you can never be too surprised at the creativity and the lengths that people will go, you know, when facing, you know, a financial challenge, trying to take care of themselves.

DAVID: It's a public safety problem and an expensive one. In a year, Philadelphia replaced 2,000 manhole covers at the cost of $150 each. Then these two employees came up with a cheaper solution. Simply chain the covers down.

RINA CUTLER: They could easily get them up off the ground but they can't actually take them away. It's just not that easy to steal the chain. We've got about 300 of them which we've done so far. Not one of them has been stolen.

DAVID: Philadelphia is also looking at other creative solutions to protect its 140,000 covers. In the coming months it'll be testing plastic covers, such as this one.

CUTLER: This is in fact, a prototype. They have no metal in them, so they have no metal value for salvage.

DAVID: Valuable to the city, but worthless to thieves. Now worthless to thieves because they're just made of plastic. Take a look at this, it's about 35-40 pounds. Look at Harry doing his weightlifting this morning. The city of Philadelphia hopes that these will foil future thieves. What do you think?

SMITH: Priya, thanks very much. Very impressive.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I saw this once

in a Scooby Doo episode.

Not only does it earn you cash for scrap metal, but it also helps trap the bad guy monsters.

<insert witty signature here>

Sincere or Calculating?

What I want to know is the following:

Do the editors and producers really believe all is going to economic hell?

Or do they simply want to look for another reason to paint the economy as hell because we have a GOP administration in an election cycle?  And do they get some cheap thrills doing stories like this?

My guess is the latter.  Having worked with the press in a previous life it was amazing just how far they would go to spin a story to achieve the narrative they wanted.  Crazily, they got a good chuckle over the ridiculousness of their spin over drinks after airing.

I would think most scrap

I would think most scrap yards would be able to I.D. stolen manhole covers.  One scrap yard in my area recently caught people trying to sell stolen copper.

This is just another "depression" story designed to get everyone thinking we're doomed so they'll elect the big 0.  (At which point we will be doomed)

Darwin award candidate

They have found many of nuts dead in a power stations.  Trying to steal the live copper wires

Darwin award candidate

Gosh, are they trotting

Gosh, are they trotting this one out again?

manhole covers as leading indicator

its ye olde "manhole cover theft is a leading economic indicator" statistic!

<insert witty signature here>

just nod and wave

we get it 

it hasn't been this bad since the dust bowl, the great depression, and hoovervilles

Journalism is the opium of the liberals

Conclusion

To sum it up:

"This is a public safety issue and it's the GOP's fault."

 

------------------------------------------------------------

"It could be the answer to our age-old, philosophical question, 'Why are we here?' PLASTIC!"

I thought Leon said he had a

I thought Leon said he had a good job? If it isn't for the money, doesn't he know obese people won't fit through his trap?

We haven't even had one

We haven't even had one quarter of GDP loss! What are they talking about!?

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

Having been out in teh

Having been out in teh field and moved a few manhole covers the math in teh article pains me.  An industry standard 24" Cast Iron MH cover wieghs about 300 pounds.  A larger 40" type weighs even more.  Now they are in addition to weighing a lot they are quite unwieldy.  It would take quite an effort to steal them.  And how dod they only get $10 from 300 pounds of iron if it sells for 600 a ton.

My math says they would get about $90.  The way to protect the covers is by bolting the covers to their frames.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Dan,

I believe that $600/ton is what industry pays for scrap. What you get for it at a scrapyard would be a different story.

Still, 10 bucks does sound low. This is an old story, maybe they're using old pricing data. They're interested in the paradigm, don't confuse them with facts!

But she said "they're as

But she said "they're as good as gold."

300 lbs = 4,800 oz x $811/oz.

There you have your $3,892,800 manhole cover.

→ Scrap Iron

J ust got back from the scrap yard with $51 extra in my pocket.

A kid was getting arrested for his pickup bed full of A/C window units.

Bad news when you have to work at stealing, huh? 

I ♣ my seal

Air Conditioners

The kid probably got arrested for illegally carrying around freon rather than actual theft.

<insert witty signature here>

Maybe

This guy was an obvious meth head.

I ♣ my seal

Drugs okay...

but despoiling the environment... that's a different story.

 <insert witty signature here>

Making the news?

"Typically they'd lose about a hundred manhole covers or grates a year to theft. But in the past year, 2,000 have gone missing."

Hmm. Maybe the MSM has been inflating those numbers by stealing a few themselves. "All the news that fits our agenda."

Anyone know where Dan Rather was during all this? 

They have their facts

They have their facts wrong.  I work with governmental entities in California.  The theft of these items started about 15 years ago.  Actually recent thefts are down.

CBS memo: Hey, let's not

CBS memo:

Hey, let's not worry about the murder rate in the Murder Capital Of Pennsylvania, lets write up this 'human interest' story about manhole covers.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

If the economy is so bad,

If the economy is so bad, why would scrap metal be so valuable?  That stuff is only valuable when demand for raw materials exceeds the supply.  It's really an indication of economic growth.

Lefties know nothing of real economics.

Here's my take: the cost of

Here's my take: the cost of mined minerals has gone up and will continue to go up because the extreme environmental movement in this country has tied the hands of those who supply us with minerals.  Copper and other metals are the new gold.  It's NOT the economy, its environmental extremism.

mine your own business

absolutely correct, watch this trailer for this documentary about how rich western environmentalists are preventing poor people around globe from bettering their lives :

http://www.mineyourownbusiness.org/ 

manhole covers

 

They have to steal them. The cost of drugs have gone up 

Absolutely

Absolutely.

No one is paying the house payment or then next meal with stolen manhole covers or stolen copper pipes and wires from the foreclosed house all for scrap. It all goes to drugs and the premature death. '

Actually

China's demand for scrap metal has made its recovery a very lucrative enterprise.

It's like Meth and scrap metal were made for each other.

I ♣ my seal

Excuse me???

 "It is unclear how people dependent upon scrap metal from manhole covers as a source of income will be able to survive these new measures in a struggling economy."

OMG you have GOT to be kidding me!  How about this as a way to survive, GO TO JAIL!  (along with all the illegal aliens)

 

P.S. Around here, Joe Blow gets $7 per 100 pounds at the local scrap yard.  So the math is still wrong.

Faux concern

"Across the country thieves are stealing metal objects like manhole covers because the price of scrap metal has sky rocketed."

Come on, CBS. People have been stealing things since, well, FOREVER! Theft rate increases can not be considered a reliable indication as to the declining prosperity of any particular society.

As a matter of fact, one would expect that the incidences of theft should increase as a society prospers, as thieves need things to steal. Only a prosperous society will generate the economy necessary to create the things that thieves steal. Poor societies don’t have much to steal, do they? If anything, this supposed increase in theft rates indicates an expanding economy in America, and not a contracting one.

Right. It's a sign of

Right. It's a sign of declining morals, not a declining economy.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Don't want to offend your base Mayor Nutter?

"But, you know, you can never be too surprised at the creativity and the lengths that people will go, you know, when facing, you know, a financial challenge, trying to take care of themselves."

It's amazing how much these idiots bend over backwards to justify and excuse criminal behavior.

The things people will say

I can here the excuses already:

The accused: "Your honor, I stole those manhole covers so I can sell them and feed my starving children."

The Judge: "Are you telling me that you stole them because you're TOO PROUD to accept charity? Well, I suggest you visit the local food shelves the next time your children are 'starving.' OK? Your sentence is six months incarceration, courtesy of the county who made those manhole covers. Bailiff, please call the next case."

Egg-zactly! The only time

Egg-zactly! The only time the MSM doesn't excuse bad behavior is if they can somehow tie an (R) to it, or a Christian label.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Actually, they are stealing

Actually, they are stealing them to build fortifications from the coming shellfish invasion.

Its okay to steal if your wife has cancer

Or was that its okay to cheat?


John McCain 2008 Protect Traditional Marriage

Traditional Marriage is not "Divisive" Obama.

Wait, you mean there is

Wait, you mean there is crime in Philadelphia? I'm stunned, stunned I say! Given all the other problems that city is having (their ever-growing homicide rate and all), is this really the sign of the Apocalypse for which the media has been waiting?

And the media is clearly off their own template. According to my 15-year-old AP Style Guide, the correct name for the objects in question is "utility hole cover." Call the PC police immediately!

Bassakwards as usual

People aren't stealing manhole covers because the economy is bad, they're stealing them because the economy has been so good the price of steel/iron has skyrocketed. They have crushed thousands of old vehicles in this area because the steel brings so much. As a fact you can have a running older model vehicle and it will scrap out for more that it will sell for as a used vehicle in fairly good shape. Every day more and more people prove their education in 'liberal' school is a total failure.

 

 Old, Retired and glad of it.

→ Scrappy

I made the same observation above.

It's a silly conclusion the MSM makes in deducing a rising demand for scrap metal indicates a poor economy.

I ♣ my seal