CBS: Obama’s Berlin Speech ‘Confirmed His Rock Star Status’

Photo of Kyle Drennen.

Mark Phillips, CBS A report by correspondent Mark Phillips on Friday’s CBS "Early Show" gave a glowing review of Barack Obama’s speech in Berlin on Thursday: "...there is a bit of a morning after feeling here in Berlin after what they're calling the 'Obama show.' But if the intent of this trip was to raise Barack Obama's foreign profile, it could hardly have been raised any higher...The stage could not have been bigger. The 200,000-plus crowd confirmed his rock star status, and his more cooperative sounding rhetoric was what the crowd wanted to hear."

On Thursday’s "Early Show" Phillips previewed the upcoming speech with the same fawning: "...preparations have been underway for a crowd that may number in the tens of thousands. Such is the anticipation of this Obama visit...Barack Obama of course isn't running for office here, but he may wish he were. Opinion polls across Europe, unofficial ones in newspapers, show that he would have a lead somewhere in the range of 80%. He has extremely high popularity in Europe and extremely high expectations." During that same report, Phillips quoted one German citizen who explained: "I have the feeling that with Obama there's something new. And we need it. Especially in Europe." Phillips then added: "Something new meaning he's not George W. Bush, whose war in Iraq drove a wedge between U.S. and European public opinion."

On Friday’s show, Phillips observed: "This was a speech about tone, not specifics. But mostly it was about showing up and being seen." He then went on to describe John McCain’s "bitterness" toward Obama’s media coverage: "Being seen too much, according to John McCain, who has complained bitterly about the coverage his opponent has received. McCain's response to Obama's Berlin mega-event was to go to a German restaurant in Columbus, Ohio."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Phillips concluded his report by discussing how Obama had "passed" a risky test: "This trip had its risks, just not the Berlin speech, but the Middle Eastern swing and the Iraq and Afghanistan visits as well. It was a test, one, the prevailing view here at least, would say he passed."

Following the report by Phillips, co-host Harry Smith talked to political analyst Jeff Greenfield about Obama’s speech: "We watch these images over the last 24 hours, 200,000 people out there. He's giving a speech to the people there... The images though, are stunning." Greenfield explained that Obama was really speaking to American voters:

And I think what he's trying to say, one of the messages that I heard was, 'look, I'm not some wooly-headed liberal lefty that thinks we should all sing Cumbaiya together. I'm here to tell them that we need international cooperation to beat the terrorists, to beat the extremists, to win the war in Afghanistan.'...But I think for the American voter he was saying, 'look, I'm here speaking for our national security interests...My metaphor is the wall that Reagan used, not John Kennedy's metaphor.

Obama certainly was not trying to sing Cumbaiya when he declared: "Tonight, I speak to you not as a candidate for President, but as a citizen - a proud citizen of the United States, and a fellow citizen of the world....People of Berlin - people of the world - this is our moment. This is our time." And he certainly was standing for national security interests when he asked: "Will we reject torture and stand for the rule of law? Will we welcome immigrants from different lands, and shun discrimination against those who don't look like us or worship like we do, and keep the promise of equality and opportunity for all of our people?" Read Obama’s full speech here.

Smith went on to compare Obama’s speech to McCain’s campaign events: "You're John McCain...you're eating a bratwurst, you're at a German restaurant...you're trying to make the best of an odd situation at best." Greenfield replied: "It is. And I think the message coming from Obama's opponents will -- McCain's message is 'this is overreaching. I'd rather go there as president. You're not the president yet.' And there's a certain theme of arrogance, overreaching, that the Republicans are trying to put on Obama." Greenfield added: "I do think that after, you know, after four years of the war, an American being cheered in Europe is probably not politically harmful."

However, Greenfield did conclude the segment by poking fun at all the coverage Obama has received:

You have this obsessive over covering of every single thing that Obama's doing. 'Did he pronounce this word right? Did he eat the right food? He made a three-point shot, he's going to win Ohio.' Meanwhile, it's July. And what I think is, yes, some of the polls in the battleground states are tightening. An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll seemed to show that people have doubts about Obama. They think he's the riskier candidate...Because they don't know him. So we've got to wait a while.

Here are the full transcripts of the Thursday and Friday "Early Show" segments on Obama’s speech:

07/24/08

7:07AM SEGMENT:

RUSS MITCHELL: Barack Obama is in Germany this morning. The beginning of the European leg of his nine-day overseas trip. Early this morning he made his last stop in Israel, a surprise visit to Jerusalem's Western Wall. And later today Obama meets with German leaders and he will deliver a speech on U.S.-European relations in front of one of Berlin's most famous back drops. CBS News correspondent Mark Phillips is in Berlin. Mark, good morning to you.

MARK PHILLIPS: Good morning, Russ. Well, that Barack Obama chose Berlin to make the major address of this foreign trip is no accident, presidents Kennedy and Reagan, of course, made famous speeches here during the Cold War and they did so right on the front line of that war, the Brandenburg Gate. Barack Obama is still running for president and he's been relegated to a spot a little further down the road. It's been a political juggling act for the Germans as to where Barack Obama would give this speech. In the end, the site of the Victory Column, built after a war in the mid-1800's, was chosen. And preparations have been underway for a crowd that may number in the tens of thousands. Such is the anticipation of this Obama visit.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: I have the feeling that with Obama there's something new. And we need it. Especially in Europe.

PHILLIPS: Something new meaning he's not George W. Bush, whose war in Iraq drove a wedge between U.S. and European public opinion. Berliners, though, have other fond memories of major American political figures and what they've said here.

JOHN KENNEDY: Ich bin ein Berliner.

RONALD REAGAN: Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.

BARACK OBAMA: I've never been to Berlin, so this will be -- I would love to tootle around a little bit.

PHILLIPS: And Barack Obama has a delicate task ahead of him.

CONSTANZE STELZENMUELLER: He obviously can't afford back home to be seen as somebody who panders to Europeans. And at the same time he is trying to convince those in America who care deeply about the repairing of America's image in the world that this is something he can do.

PHILLIPS: Barack Obama of course isn't running for office here, but he may wish he were. Opinion polls across Europe, unofficial ones in newspapers, show that he would have a lead somewhere in the range of 80%. He has extremely high popularity in Europe and extremely high expectations. Russ.

MITCHELL: Mark Phillips in Berlin, thank you very much.

 

07/25/08

7:07AM SEGMENT:

HARRY SMITH: Now back to Barack Obama's foreign trip. The Democratic presidential hopeful arrives in Paris this morning. Yesterday he delivered a major speech in Berlin. CBS News correspondent Mark Phillips is there. Good morning, Mark.

MARK PHILLIPS: Good morning, Harry. Well, there is a bit of a morning after feeling here in Berlin after what they're calling the 'Obama show.' But if the intent of this trip was to raise Barack Obama's foreign profile, it could hardly have been raised any higher. Barack Obama had two objectives on this, the most public leg of his overseas trip, to demonstrate he could perform on a grand world stage and to show that his hands across the water approach to major issues could work. The stage could not have been bigger. The 200,000-plus crowd confirmed his rock star status, and his more cooperative sounding rhetoric was what the crowd wanted to hear.

BARACK OBAMA: True partnership and true progress requires constant work and sustained sacrifice. They require sharing the burdens of development and diplomacy, of peace and progress. They require allies who will listen to each other, learn from each other, and most of all, trust each other.

PHILLIPS: This was a speech about tone, not specifics. But mostly it was about showing up and being seen. Being seen too much, according to John McCain, who has complained bitterly about the coverage his opponent has received. McCain's response to Obama's Berlin mega-event was to go to a German restaurant in Columbus, Ohio.

JOHN MCCAIN: I'd love to give a speech in Germany too, a political speech, or a speech that may be the German people would be interested in, but I'd much prefer to do it as President of the United States.

OBAMA: Thank you, Berlin.

PHILLIPS: This trip had its risks, just not the Berlin speech but the Middle Eastern swing and the Iraq and Afghanistan visits as well. It was a test, one, the prevailing view here at least, would say he passed. Barack Obama had said before this trip that he was coming overseas to listen, which in politician speak of course means to talk. Harry.

SMITH: Mark Phillips in Berlin this morning, thank you very much. Joining me now is CBS News senior political correspondent Jeff Greenfield. Good morning, Jeff.

JEFF GREENFIELD: Howdy.

SMITH: We watch these images over the last 24 hours, 200,000 people out there. He's giving a speech to the people there.

GREENFIELD: No, he's not.

SMITH: He's not giving a speech to the 200,000? Who's he speaking to?

GREENFIELD: He's speaking to the American voter. And I think what he's trying to say, one of the messages that I heard was, 'look, I'm not some wooly-headed liberal lefty that thinks we should all sing Cumbaiya together. I'm here to tell them that we need international cooperation to beat the terrorists, to beat the extremists, to win the war in Afghanistan.' There were a lot of other stuff, global warming and human rights-

SMITH: Right.

GREENFIELD: -But I think for the American voter he was saying, 'look, I'm here speaking for our national security interests.

SMITH: Right.

GREENFIELD: My metaphor is the wall that Reagan used, not John Kennedy's metaphor.

SMITH: So interesting, yes-

GREENFIELD: Yeah, I think that's what he was up to.

SMITH: Yeah. There was a lot of stuff in there about the environment and sort of bones to throw to the audience about nuclear weapons and stuff like that.

GREENFIELD: I think this was about 'I'm here speaking for what we need from Europe.'

SMITH: Very interesting. The images though, are stunning. We'll get to the images in a second. You're John McCain-

GREENFIELD: Right.

SMITH: -you're eating a bratwurst, you're at a German restaurant-

GREENFIELD: Yeah. I thought that was kind of cute.

SMITH: -you're trying to make the best of an odd situation at best.

GREENFIELD: It is. And I think the message coming from Obama's opponents will -- McCain's message is 'this is overreaching. I'd rather go there as president. You're not the president yet.' And there's a certain theme of arrogance, overreaching, that the Republicans are trying to put on Obama. The other thing I think is there's always a danger if the Democrat is seen as Europe's candidate, which happens to be what the National Review, a conservative magazine, put in its website yesterday.

SMITH: Yes.

GREENFIELD: You know, 'He's a brie-eating, Chablis-sipping, snail-eating elitist, not like us guys,' that's always the danger. I do think that after, you know, after four years of the war, an American being cheered in Europe is probably not politically harmful.

SMITH: Interesting also, though, what's going on, if you look at the polls this week-

GREENFIELD: Yeah.

SMITH: -numbers are very tight, especially in these swing states.

GREENFIELD: This is what I love about this time of year. You have this obsessive over covering of every single thing that Obama's doing. 'Did he pronounce this word right? Did he eat the right food? He made a three-point shot, he's going to win Ohio.' Meanwhile, it's July. And what I think is, yes, some of the polls in the battleground states are tightening. An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll seemed to show that people have doubts about Obama. They think he's the riskier candidate.

SMITH: Right.

GREENFIELD: Because they don't know him. So we've got to wait a while.

SMITH: We do have to wait a while. Thanks so much Jeff, always a pleasure to see you.

GREENFIELD: You're welcome.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

"....confirmed his rock star

"....confirmed his rock star status"

Gee, no mention of the fact that Obama was the third rock act that day.

"...there is a bit of a morning after feeling here in Berlin."

That statement reminds me of Jim Carrey in 'Fun With Dick and Jane' when he wakes up hammered the next morning in the motel room next to Rene Zellweger, and there's a 'sex device' lying on the sheets. He says to her "Did you have fun with that?" She says "No, that was for you, and you did."

Germans shmermans...

Who the heck cares about a "campaign stop?!?" in GERMANY.

Maybe someone should tell their messiah that Germans cannot vote in the election.Why on earth is this not discussed by the National Barack Compnay, or the American Barack System, or the Communist Barack System???

I have often noticed that the "lead band" often outshines the "main event". Poor Barack...

Rock Star status is fleeting

Ask any Rockstar, that "rock star" status is very fleeting.  That mindset always has, following close behind it, the mentality of "what have you done lately" and so the rockstar is forced to one-up what they did previously and sooner or later they just can't do it (ask Brittany Spears of recent fame, now infamy).  Sooner or later Obama is not going to be able to one-up his previous ___________ (whatever he is currently doing).

Yup.

JOHN KENNEDY: Ich bin ein Berliner.

RONALD REAGAN: Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.

BARACK OBAMA: I've never been to Berlin, so this will be -- I would love to tootle around a little bit.

 

That about sums it up right there.

Ich Bin Ein Beginner!

BHO Ich Bin Ein Beginner!

ROCK STAR MY @$$...

This Obama is no headlining act, he does'nt know how to work a crowd, & cannot say it if Axelrod did'nt write it. This backbencher should be booed off stage, he has no buisiness doing what he is doing.

 

"...it's still We The People, Right?"  Megadeth 

"The 200,000-plus crowd" ????

"The 200,000-plus crowd" ????

Democrats are adding zeros again.

"Berlin studio chief Peter Frey added, "We
do estimate that 20,000 [literally, "a couple of ten thousand"] people
have turned out."

http://www.worldpoli...

 

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

Verbal Photoshop.

Verbal Photoshop.

You only hear what you want

Thanks for the link.  One guy did say a couple of ten thousands, but if you bothered to watch a bit later the anchor was saying over 100,000 people were there.  German news seems to agree on over 200,000 in later reports:

http://www.morgenpos...

http://www.heute.de/...

 

 

". . . .his more

". . . .his more cooperative sounding rhetoric was what the crowd wanted to hear."

So the Europeans want another wimpy (Chamberlain) appeaser they can push around.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Catch Fuhrer Feavuh!

Germany has already traipsed down that road ... did you say "free" concert? 

  I guess if you are a

 

I guess if you are a left wing over the hill hippy having a presidential candidate with "rock star status" actually means something. I know that libs make a big deal out of pleasing europe. Honestly, having rock star status and pleasing europe has nothing to do with being the number one super power.

Not surprizing that socialist Obama would be leading in Europe

The fact that socialist Europeans like socialist Obama by 80/20 is to be expected. That alone should give many Obama supporters pause (but it won't). 

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

I am so sick of the Rock

I am so sick of the Rock star analogy.It sounds so lame coming from the MSM. 

HEY TAZZ...

I agree with you about the "rock star" analogy, but if the MSM were honest, & we know they are not, they will do the follow up "Behind The Music" for Obama. It will detail the highs & lows of the Obama campaign, & how he had all of the MSM patting him on the back telling him he can do no wrong. It ends with what went wrong, why, & why nobody involved saw it coming.

 

 "...it's still We The People, Right?"  Megadeth 

 So Chairman O had a

 So Chairman O had a speech that was liked by throngs of supporters. Is there a surprise contained in that? Marxist of a feather..and so on.

The left in this country just has to be adored by Europeans. They live for acceptence by them. To leftists in this country, a rebuttal by Europeans is the one signal that you are not sophisticated and backwards. That is why the biggest insult a leftist uses (especially against President Bush) is that he doesn't act European. In my circles, not acting European is a badge of honor.

Seriously, if you were German ...

JFK spoke to show solidarity with Berlin. Everyone knew what he was threatening: JFK was telling the Soviets that if they moved on Berlin, the US would fight back. Reagan challenged the Soviets to tear down the wall, which were great words, but they had all the more impact because Reagan was bringing missiles to Europe to back up what he said. He was telling the Germans that we were going to fight for them. JFK and Reagan were speaking to the Soviets, but they were also promising the Germans that America would fight and die to protect them. Damn right they appreciated it.

Obama came to lecture them. Together, he declared, we have to protect the Iranian blogger. Sorry, but why in hell would a German give a crap about that?

a little sourkraut with your coolaid

Yea Smith and the rest of the MSM are eating Baracks Bratwurst.

They're all waiting for the next spatzel of brilliant thought to fall from his plate.

 

BTW does anyone else thing that Phillips look like Captain Kangaroo  http://timstvshowcase.com/kangaroo.html

Or is it just me? 

 

Where's Mr. Greenjeans?? LOL

"If a man does his best, what else is there"?

General George S. Patton Jr.

BARAKWURST!!

Now that sounds yummy doesn't it?

What kind of rock star?

The Amy Winehouse or Keith Richards type? Maybe more like an incoherent Bob Dylan?

Let's put McCain in the

Let's put McCain in the largest venue in the most conservative state and see how big a crowd he draws. Any guesses?

 

Do we need to judge a

Do we need to judge a candidate by how many people show up at his/her speech?  I say no.  We don't need more speeches.  We need plans/agendas/solutions, not sound-bites.

well gee goldbar

By that logic we should elect Hannah Montana to be president - she can draw a bigger crowd than any of them.

And lefties wonder why we call them superficial.

Why? The people that would show up

don't need to hear another speech by McCain to vote for him - they are already onboard.  Plus, conservatives would like to CONSERVE gasoline and not drive to another speech.  Democrats on the other hand seem to need constant re-affirmation and the cost of fuel is insignificant.

So you support the candidate who draws the most?

Let's see,  who of the following do you think would be the best leader of the most powerful country in the world and the leader of the free nations:

Amy Winehouse,

Bono,

Jessica Simpson,

Brittany Spears,

Hanna Montanna?

They all command large audiences and in point of fact would blow Obambi out of the water.

 

What say you?????????????????????????

expatriot, you left out

expatriot, you left out Reba, Vince Gill and the grand champion Garth (Low Places) Brooks!

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

The fact that even report on

The fact that even report on him like he is a serious candidate should be something that they are just putting under the table because it is simply to ugly to look at.

Passed the Test or GIVEN a PASS?

"Phillips concluded his report by discussing how Obama had "passed" a risky test: "This trip had its risks, just not the Berlin speech, but the Middle Eastern swing and the Iraq and Afghanistan visits as well. It was a test, one, the prevailing view here at least, would say he passed.""

BHO didn't pass any thest, he was simply given a Pass by the adoring press corps!

Sieg Heil Barak!

Third Rock Star Act that day and

Free Beer.

Just like any other date he probably had.

Cheap!

Bush is President of USA - But he is NOT a ROCK STAR

Thank you President Bush for your Courage and Your Leadership !!!!
Obama can do a left handed Jumpshot from outside the 3 pt line, in a War Zone secured by Bush and the Military..I'm not sure if that is a job Requirement for a Pres ?
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised

JayTee

Amen to what you just said.

President Bush would never use our Military as pawns or photo props. Not ever.

Thank you for your thoughts.

Delsa....Actually I have thatT-shirt

I ordered a McCain shirt from a Republican site...I was sent the "Thank you President Bush" shirt by Mistake.....They must have these shirts left over...Lets all order one "Intentionally"
The Republican Revolution will not be Televised

slight difference

One is an elected sitting president who is actually the Commander in Chief, whose policies, for better or worse, have gotten the military in the situation it is today.

The other, is a "presumptive nominee"who is campaigning for an office he has never held, who has opposed almost all policies and decisions that, for better or worse, gotten the military where it is today.

basically, you have the CEO who drives the Company Car. The other is the kid who just started in the copy room standing around the Company Car and posing like it's his.

 

"to call an illegal immigrant an "undocumented alien" is the same as calling a streetcorner drug dealer an "unlicensed pharmacist".

"You spend your money anyway you want and respect other's rights to do the same'