CBS’s Mitchell to Joint Chiefs Chairman: Do Americans Have ‘Right to be Pessimistic’?

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Still Shot of Russ Mitchell and Michael Mullen, May 26 On Monday’s CBS "Early Show," co-host Russ Mitchell interviewed Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, Admiral Mike Mullen, and asked about Iraq: "When you look at April, last month, 50 American soldiers were killed in Iraq. And a lot of Americans look at that and they're pessimistic, despite what you say about morale and how things are going in Iraq--in Iraq. Does the American public have a right to be pessimistic, in your mind?"

While suggesting Americans are ‘pessimistic’ about the war in Iraq is justified, Mitchell forgets to mention the role CBS News has played in promoting some of that pessimism with its own coverage of the war. In addition, using the phrase ‘right to be pessimistic’ leaves little room for disagreement, as Admiral Mullen pointed out: "The American public obviously gets to choose whether they're optimistic or pessimistic."

Mullen went on to explain: "I think clearly, over the last many months, things have improved fairly dramatically. We always need to be reminded of the sacrifice that these young men and women generate in terms supporting the overall mission."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Mitchell later asked about how soon troops may be coming home:

MITCHELL: Should Americans be optimistic this Memorial Day that our men and women overseas, especially in Iraq, will be coming home soon?

MULLEN: I think Americans can be optimistic that the young men and women who serve us are the best I've ever served with. They continue to serve exceptionally well across the board. And in doing that, we can all be proud of them on this Memorial Day, and their families who support them so well.

MITCHELL: A very eloquent answer, sir. But I ask you again, can Americans be optimistic that they'll be coming home soon?

MULLEN: Well, the decisions on whether or not Americans return--a number of soldiers--returning numbers yet to be made based on the conditions on the ground. We will all assess this fall conditions on the ground there and make decisions accordingly.

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

7:15AM SEGMENT:

RUSS MITCHELL: And welcome back. On this Memorial Day, we remember the fallen heroes from wars past and present. And joining us now from the Pentagon is Admiral Michael Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Admiral, good morning to you.

MIKE MULLEN: Good morning, Russ.

MITCHELL: Admiral, when you look at the landscape across the world now of US troops, how would you compare morale this Memorial Day to last Memorial Day?

MULLEN: Well, in my travels, which have been extensive, morale is exceptionally high. The troops are--know they're on important missions. They're performing exceptionally well and they're serving a noble cause and they feel very strongly about that.

MITCHELL: Admiral, let's talk about Iraq specifically. Again, as you look at the landscape, are things better, worse or about the same for American troops in Iraq?

MULLEN: Things are better in Iraq, and it's principally because the troops have performed so well in the surge. We're at a point now where they've created security so the politicians can move forward, and that's happened. I'm modestly optimistic about what's going on there right now.

MITCHELL: When you look at April, last month, 50 American soldiers were killed in Iraq. And a lot of Americans look at that and they're pessimistic, despite what you say about morale and how things are going in Iraq--in Iraq. Does the American public have a right to be pessimistic, in your mind?

MULLEN: The American public obviously gets to choose whether they're optimistic or pessimistic. I think clearly, over the last many months, things have improved fairly dramatically. We always need to be reminded of the sacrifice that these young men and women generate in terms supporting the overall mission.

MITCHELL: You talked--you testified last week that Iranian influence in Iraq is still very strong. From a military standpoint, what can the US best do to subside that?

MULLEN: Well, I think actually it's more than just the military. It's got to be the full spectrum of national elements of power, economics, finances, diplomacy, politics, as well as military. And I think we need to continue to bring pressure on the Iranians to change their behavior in that part of the world.

MITCHELL: Should Americans be optimistic this Memorial Day that our men and women overseas, especially in Iraq, will be coming home soon?

MULLEN: I think Americans can be optimistic that the young men and women who serve us are the best I've ever served with. They continue to serve exceptionally well across the board. And in doing that, we can all be proud of them on this Memorial Day, and their families who support them so well.

MITCHELL: A very eloquent answer, sir. But I ask you again, can Americans be optimistic that they'll be coming home soon?

MULLEN: Well, the decisions on whether or not Americans return--a number of soldiers--returning numbers yet to be made based on the conditions on the ground. We will all assess this fall conditions on the ground there and make decisions accordingly.

MITCHELL: This is your first Memorial Day as chairman of the joint chiefs. Does this day hold any added significance for you?

MULLEN: This day has always held added significance, but particularly because I'm privileged to serve in this position, spend time with those who serve, spend time with families who's lost--who've lost loved ones and who sacrifice so much, and reminded that we all need to express our gratitude to them and what they've given to our great country.

MITCHELL: Admiral Michael Mullen, we appreciate it. Thank you very much for joining us, sir.

MULLEN: Thank you, Russ.

MITCHELL: You take care.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Terrorists get active when policy decisions are made

The terrorists in Iraq always step up activity when decisions are being made about the war. April was when Gen. Petraeus was reporting to Congress. Look for a spike before election time, trying to insure the Democrat (probably Obama) is elected.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

viking, ...and the

viking,

...and the leftist politicians and msm hand in hand know this and intentionally play it up to the utmost all for the expected outcome they want...more deaths in our military so they can report it as such on our nightly news and the pols can use their pretense with screaming bloody murder towards our President and the repubs...it is as simple as that and has been an obvious pattern for those who pay attention of all of this over the years... talk about aiding and abetting the enemy, I call it also urging them on...with hidden glee for their political outcome with glee.

It is an agenda that all these despicable creatures involved should be tried for IMHO.

Just my two cents... 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

the DNC and AQ work

the DNC and AQ work together

their BDS rhetoric is identical

who said this:

"BUSH IS A DERANGED MANICAL KILLER!"

an elected Democrat, or OBL...?

trick question - they both have...time and time again...

I totally ripped this off

I totally ripped this off from James Taranto's Best of the Web today, but the chart speaks for itself.  There is no reason to be pessimistic unless you are part of the msm who will not report on the great successes of our military, but look for every opportunity to create stories that fit their own pessimistic templates.

From iCasualties.org, here are the numbers of Americans killed in each month since the beginning of last year:

January 2007
83

February 2007
81

March 2007
81

April 2007
104

May 2007
126

June 2007
101

July 2007
79

August 2007
84

September 2007
65

October 2007
38

November 2007
37

December 2007
23

January 2008
40

February 2008
29

March 2008
39

April 2008
52

May 2008 (so far)
18

It is true that the number of U.S. Iraq deaths in 2007 was higher than in any other year. But this is because the numbers were so high in January through September. Petraeus's testimony coincided with the beginning of a sharp decline in the death rate of U.S. servicemen in Iraq.

It is also true that April had the highest number of deaths of any month so far this year. But the April count is below the count for every month between August 2006 and September 2007.

I can't wait to hear what

I can't wait to hear what the press will say when we pass the next benchmark, probably soon to come.  That being, an entire week without a US Iraq Death.

Somehow, it will be presented in some manner to make it bad news (US Troops not as effective as they have been or some such nonsense) or either minimize it, or it will be supressed.

I bet it will be supressed.

I just enjoy the only 18

I just enjoy the only 18 heroes gave the ultimate. That would be the lowest since... ever.

 

This will only be noted on page E12 if at all.

 

 

How long will Obama (if elected) get to do all the change he

absolutely!

We might win this terrorism war through military might. Oh woe is them! The French won't like us any more. Oh no. How depressing, Bush was right all along. [ must find tall building and prepare to jump... ] </sarc>

not to lessen their sacrifice...

but 'cmon, 50?! More people were murdered by gang bangers in LA alone in that time. More died in Detroit from drug deals gone bad.

How many Americans were killed by illegal immigrants and their coyotes in that time? How many LEO's paid the ultimate price here at home from the SAME TYPES OF PEOPLE the Democrats/liberals/Media consider a f**king voting bloc during the same period?

I'm about ready to start advocating withdrawal from Iraq. Which means ten seconds after the last soldier leaves we glass the entire f**king area. If we're supposed to be evil bastards out for control of oil, then maybe we oughta give them what they wished for and fire off the rest of those enhanced radiation warheads.

 

"to call an illegal immigrant an "undocumented alien" is the same as calling a streetcorner drug dealer an "unlicensed pharmacist".

Most dangerous place in America

The abortion mills are still the most dangerous place in America. More Amercians are murdered in these "clinics" than all the wars, disease, accidents, natural disasters, etc. combined. But then, liberals are not against abortions so those don't count.

CBS Weasels

CBS is led by weasels and are now trying to weasel out of their direct responsibility for the death of many of the Americans killed in Iraq. Not only me, but a study by the ultra left wing Harvard Univ study said the media and 'democrats' that bitched from day one are responsible for a lot of the deaths. Supporting the enemies of the U.S. tends to get Americans killed and by any fair law should make several thousand democrats liable as traitors. I volunteer to be the hangman.

Old, Retired and glad of it.

same old, same old

You're right scrapiron. It's the Viet Nam playbook all over again. They hate the President so extremely for taking their favorite toy (absolute power) that they will do anything, and I mean anything, to crash the war and make him look bad. It is beyond disgusting. It is turing us into a third world country with first world living standards. But not for long, as we sink into full socialistic governance and pocket picking. I weep for this country and what my granddaughters will live like.

Scrap... Hear!

Scrap...

Hear! Hear!

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Murder by Abortion.

doug1950 , The democrats have murdered more babies in 5 years than the number of soldiers killed in all wars in the past 100 years. They murder the same number of babies every 3.5 days as the number of troops that have been killed in 6 years in Iraq. That is just by the democrat led Planned Parenthood mafia. Bitching and complaining about an honorable death protecting the country is their way to try and soothe the guilt that will never be soothed. The guilt will go to the grave with them and probably result in suicide by thousands of them. 

Old, Retired and glad of it.

When lefties speak of

When lefties speak of "rights", they actually mean "entitlements". This is just another example of same.