CBS: Hillary’s Mom is ‘Secret Weapon,’ Plays on ‘Primal Fear’ of Voters

Photo of Kyle Drennen.

On Wednesday’s CBS "Early Show," co-host Harry Smith played a clip of a recent Hillary Clinton campaign ad featuring her mother and asked Political Correspondent Jeff Greenfield: "Is Hillary's mom the real secret weapon in the campaign?" Greenfield responded by describing the ad’s brilliance:

I very rarely look at ads these days and one line just jumps out at me. Hillary's mom lives with her, not mother, mom. Why? Women outlive men. Wives outlive their husbands. Primal fear: 'I will spend the rest of my life alone or in a home.' And the idea that this prototypical career woman, who her enemies see as driven and cold, has taken her mom in to live with her, I think that packs a powerful emotional wallop. And in Iowa, women vote in caucuses more than men and older people do more than younger.

Smith agreed with Greenfield’s assessment, "Right. And older women especially. Yeah this is -- boy -- talk about right to the heart."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Smith and Greenfield went on to discuss John McCain, who’s mother had recently joined him on the campaign trail, and Greenfield offered kind analysis of the "maverick" Senator:

Right, first of all, it looks like he's had a B-1 injection. He looks ten years younger, he's on the 'Straight Talk Express.' He's doing the same thing he did in 2000. He's -- everything's on the record, he's juiced. Why? One, the debates. Just as they helped Mike Huckabee, they reminded people of why they liked him in the first place...the dissatisfaction of all the Republicans, means that a lot of Republicans who don't like McCain on immigration, campaign reform -- finance reform, he was against the Bush tax cuts, he's a maverick, but now their saying 'well, all of these other people we're unhappy with in one way or another, this guy actually has some -- some chops.'

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

7:15AM TEASER:

JULIE CHEN: Well, ahead in this half-hour of the broadcast, the emergence of the candidates moms on the campaign trail. The new 'Mommy Factor.'

7:18AM SEGMENT:

HARRY SMITH: Good morning again, I'm Harry Smith. This is "The Early Show" on CBS. Today we look at Hillary Clinton's latest family member on the campaign trail. Her mother, Dorothy, who lives with the Clintons and is now in the latest campaign ad.

DOROTHY RODHAM: What I would like people to know about Hillary is what a good person she is. She never was envious of anybody. She was helpful, and she's continued that with her adult life, with helping other women. She has --

SMITH: Here's CBS News Senior Political Analyst Jeff Greenfield. Jeff, good morning.

GREENFIELD: Hi.

SMITH: Is Hillary's mom the real secret weapon in the campaign?

JEFF GREENFIELD: I very rarely look at ads these days and one line just jumps out at me. Hillary's mom lives with her, not mother, mom. Why? Women outlive men. Wives outlive their husbands. Primal fear: 'I will spend the rest of my life alone or in a home.' And the idea that this prototypical career woman, who her enemies see as driven and cold, has taken her mom in to live with her, I think that packs a powerful emotional wallop. And in Iowa, women vote in caucuses more than men and older people do more than younger.

SMITH: Right. And older women especially. Yeah this is -- boy -- talk about right to the heart. And how interesting is this in contrast to yesterday we saw the pictures. They've got Magic Johnson out there, they've got Bill Clinton out there. We've asked this question for a couple of days. Is he helping more than hurting because he goes out into a crowd and everybody rushes to the former President of the United States, she's left holding a cup of coffee.

GREENFIELD: Right, is he helping or hurting? The answer's yes. Democrats do like him, first only two-term Democrat since Roosevelt, but Dems don't like them, that reminds them. But it reminds me a little of 92' when Clinton was the effective nominee and they suddenly realized people don't know who he is, and they put him on Arsenio Hall playing the saxophone.

SMITH: Sure.

GREENFIELD: Yeah, that's what's going on here. It looks like -- if you try to guess what's going to happen in the caucuses, be my guest.

SMITH: You be my guest. Alright, speaking of the 'Mother Factor,' it was just a month or two ago that John McCain was out campaigning with his mother who is --

GREENFIELD: Yeah, true. In her 90s.

SMITH: In her 90s, no less. Just to show what?

GREENFIELD: Well he's the oldest -- he would be the oldest president ever and he's trying to so -- say genetically I'll be ready to do this job for a while.

SMITH: Right, now you just came off the campaign trail with him.

GREENFIELD: Yeah.

SMITH: Talk to me a little bit about what's going on there, because this guy was politically left in the ash heap four months ago.

GREENFIELD: Right, first of all, it looks like he's had a B-1 injection. He looks ten years younger, he's on the 'Straight Talk Express.' He's doing the same thing he did in 2000. He's -- everything's on the record, he's juiced. Why? One, the debates. Just as they helped Mike Huckabee, they reminded people of why they liked him in the first place. The Petraeus strategy in Iraq seems to have vindicated McCain, saying 'we've got to change and I know better than anybody else in this race how to win this -- this effort.' And third, the dissatisfaction of all the Republicans, means that a lot of Republicans who don't like McCain on immigration, campaign reform -- finance reform, he was against the Bush tax cuts, he's a maverick, but now their saying 'well, all of these other people we're unhappy with in one way or another, this guy actually has some -- some chops.' He's still well behind in New Hampshire, he's running on fumes.

SMITH: And he's not really running in Iowa.

GREENFIELD: No, he's basically said 'okay I'm on the ballot.' But it's a very simple strategy for him, if he can catch up and beat Romney, who has spent millions of dollars and is a neighboring state governor, sling shot to Michigan, where independents vote, he thinks he has a shot.

SMITH: Wow, very interesting to watch. I'm not sure it's ever been quite this interesting.

GREENFIELD: This one, I'm telling you, if you -- whoever called it political science, had no idea what they were talking about.

SMITH: Jeff GREENFIELD, thank you so much.

GREENFIELD: Okay.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hill's mom mudwrestles

Hill's mom mudwrestles McCain's mom.

Film at 11.

This is nothing but fear

This is nothing but fear and desperation on Shrillary's part...almost everyone knows that except the leftist talking heads that are either being black-mailed by her or have a vested interest in her....

Too bad they can't see through those silly la-la land rose-colored glasses they all wear...then again it is going to be fun to watch those glasses shatter right before our eyes as they pass the kleenex to one another...boo-hoo!

I'd love to know with whom

"mom" resides...him and his "visitors" in NY or her in D.C.??  Like this is supposed to tell the world she is a "fine" woman...her "mom" lives with her.  Now I understand...all that we have been observing the past 15 years is a moot point...she has her "mom" living with her.  Forget all the knives in the back, bullying of lady friends of Bill, files mysteriously found in the WH residence, and oh yes, let's not forget that famous lack of memory when testifying before Congress!

What I would like people to

What I would like people to know about Hillary is what a good person
she is. She never was envious of anybody. She was helpful, and she's
continued that with her adult life, with helping other women.

<GAG>

Yeah, she sure helped all those "bimbos" back in Arkansas, didn't she?

On a side note: Greenfield says about Bill Clinton:

But it reminds me a little of 92' when Clinton was the effective
nominee and they suddenly realized people don't know who he is, and
they put him on Arsenio Hall playing the saxophone.

Uh, Jeff, that was because, as you yourself said, people didn't know who Clinton was before that, and people looked at him and thought he was maybe kind of cool, someone they could relate to.

The problem now is that everyone already knows who Hillary is; some more than they ever wanted to. So this has "strategy" written all over it, and people know that. When reporters are writing that you brought out your mother and that your campaign started a website to you can be likeable, I'd say you've missed any chance of a "secret weapon." And when a WaPo headline advertises that Magic Johnson and Bill Clinton are providing you with "charisma," I'd say that sublety is out the window too.

Oh, for the love of Mike.

Oh, for the love of Mike. Even hardened criminals' mothers testify on their behalf. Anyone else, and this would be hooted down as hokey.

Oh, for the love of Mike.

Oh, for the love of Mike. Even hardened criminals' mothers testify on their behalf. -Chris Norman

LOL, Chris, I didn't think of that! That is so true! Jeez, if your own mother can't say something good about you, you might as well just slit your wrists and get it over with.

As for having her mother live with her, big, fat, hairy deal. Why are we always supposed to be soooo impressed when famous people do what millions of ordinary Americans do every day? (It's like the tabloids that tell us of so-and-so's "brave" fight against cancer, as if ordinary people are cowards about it.)

 

 

The term "obsequiously

The term "obsequiously fawning dweebs" comes to mind. Along with Girly Men and BEYOTCHES but that's just me.

Hey, now, Jeff --

Betty Currie took the freakin' cat, but taking Hillary's mom was just too much to ask.

derv...LMOA...Good

derv...

LMAO...

Good zing there....still chucklin' here.

I always felt sorry for Socks...when Hill would hold that cat for photo-ops you could tell that cat did not like her one iota...anymore than she liked that cat.

Glad Socks finally got a loving home...and didn't go the way poor ol' Buddy did. 

Yeah, RIP Buddy...

Mama better think twice about going her own way.

This mommy stuff is just

This mommy stuff is just dumb.

All the momma warthogs are certain that their little baby is beautiful.

But they're all a bunch of ugly f-ing warthogs...

 

 

Hey, not over yet...

The election is not over yet, remember they dumped the kitty after they were out of the limelight. Who knows where her mother will be after (I hope) she loses. Bet it is still not living with Hill.

ROTFLMAO!!!!

Hillary gets her mommy to ask people to vote for her.

LOL.

Reminds me of the "Raymond" episode where the mother writes a letter to the FBI to "help" her son Robert get a job with them.

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

hehe

I love that show. We could all probably learn more life lessons from raymond. Robert didnt get the FBI job if i remember correctly. Hopefully hillary wont get it either

hehe

I love that show. We could all probably learn more life lessons from raymond. Robert didnt get the FBI job if i remember correctly. Hopefully hillary wont get it either

Speaking of the Rodham Clan, Where are they hiding the brothers?

 

Where are the accolades for Hillary from her brothers, Tony and Hugh?

Both should be heaping praises on Hillary, and brother-in-law, Bill, for the favors done to them by granting presidential pardons to their criminal business associates.

 

Rodham's mom lives at the

Rodham's mom lives at the house? As if Rodham has enough trouble getting her "husband" to come home at night.

Big Freakin Deal

Her mommy lives with her - so what! That doesn't make her a saint or better presidential material than the other candidates. It's not like she's busting her butt taking care of dear old ma.

Maybe the crowd she runs with thinks this makes her something special. Not like people I know, who all believe that family should be taken care of. If grandma, grandpa, mom, dad, etc. needs care, then we do what needs to be done to make sure they are happy and healthy.

Sorry, but I have a difficult time believing that she's doing this because she loves her mom.

For Smith to have said

For Smith to have said this, "Yeah this is -- boy -- talk about right to the heart",  in regards to a woman who is STILL trying to convince the American people after all this time that she HAS a "warm side" is the height of media lying BIAS. It completely IGNORES the last umpteen years during which this woman has been struggling to convince us that she has a pulse! M. Dowd captures it perfectly.

DOWD---""Hillary doesn't have to worry about her face. She has to worry about her mask. Back in the '92 race, Clinton pollsters devised strategies to humanize her and make her seem more warm and maternal. Fifteen years later, her campaign is devising strategies to humanize her and make her seem more warm and maternal."

The story would much more appropriately be, "Why haven't voters seen her as "human" after all this time and why is it necessary to drag out her mom to say so? And wouldn't even Saddam's MOM say something nice about him, so how does this help?"

But when you're a lying deceitful IN THE BAG piece of crap, this is what you say when the opposition does the very same "humanizing" thing..

SMITH: Right. Harry, you've got to wonder if beating voters over the head with how likable you are is really a good idea. 

Disgusting.