On yesterday’s CBS "Sunday Morning," reporter Steve Hartman demonstrated why illegal immigration is actually a good thing: "Good news about an illegal immigrant...By all accounts this man they call Dr. Q is one of the best up-and-coming neurosurgeons in the country." Interestingly, this story was actually first aired on the May 18 "Evening News." Apparently CBS is really going green, it even recycles its own biased reporting.
The segment began by Hartman actually admitting to the mainstream media’s usual doom and gloom reporting: "Because it never leads the news...because war and scandal and planet melting always make for catchier headlines...It's easy to forget all the good stories that happen every year." Hartman decided to focus on three "good" stories for a change, which included a brief profile of Dr. Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa:
Clinically brilliant, relentlessly charming. His patients say it's almost like he was born to be a doctor. If they only knew...Just 20 years ago this renown neurosurgeon was about as anonymous as a human being can get in America. An illegal immigrant working the fields of California's San Joaquin Valley...after he jumped the U.S.-Mexico border and took up residence in this leaky old trailer, Alfredo says the moon seemed closer than medical school.
Apparently, border enforcement is making it difficult for the future top minds of America to get here. However, last time I checked, Albert Einstein was a legal immigrant to the United States.
It was not until later in the segment that Hartman explained that Dr. Quinones-Hinojosa:
...got his U.S. citizenship and a Harvard Medical School scholarship. Graduated Cum Laude, squeezed in time for a family and is now at Johns Hopkins scrubbing in those same weed-picking hands for brain surgery.
Hartman concluded the segment by demonstrating how silly immigration law really is:
HARTMAN: It's no doubt a remarkable American success story. The fact that it all started with a fence hopping makes it a controversial one too.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: The last thing that I want is people to think that what I have done is justified. And the only thing that I can do is try to pay back every day by every single thing I do.
HARTMAN: To that end, Dr. Q spends much of his free time in the lab trying to find a cure for brain cancer. He hopes it makes amends, but admits he'd cross again in a heartbeat.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: I'm sure I would. You know, to be honest with you, it's human nature to try to find better ways to survive. It's human nature. It's not rocket science.
HARTMAN: It's not even brain surgery.
In other words, illegal immigrants do the jobs Americans will not do, like neurosurgery and curing cancer.
Here is the full transcript of the segment:
9:01AM TEASER:
STEVE HARTMAN: This Sunday, let us give thanks for the good news we've had all year. That's right. I said good news. For a change, we'll show you good news out of New Orleans.
ALFREDO QUINONES-HINOJOSA: All I want to do is come in and say hi to my patient. That's it.
HARTMAN: Good news about an illegal immigrant and good news about an old gillopy and a long ago love. So get ready to be inspired later on "Sunday Morning."
9:08AM INTRO:
CHARLES OSGOOD: The good news is that the phrase good news is not necessarily a contradiction in terms. And when better than Thanksgiving weekend to go in search of proof. Our cover story is from Steve Hartman as reporter for Assignment America on the CBS Evening News, Steve is something of an expert on these matters.
KATIE COURIC: I'm Katie Couric. Tonight an exclusive report about the next terror threat.
BRIAN WILLIAMS: Also, the right to bear arms. What does the Second Amendment really mean about guns?
CHARLES GIBSON: Nightmare scenario. A major storm gathers....
STEVE HARTMAN: Because it never leads the news....
LARA LOGAN: The U.S. Surge is now fully underway.
HARTMAN: Because war and scandal and planet melting always make for catchier headlines.
RUSS MITCHELL: We begin tonight with the most comprehensive report in the worst mass shooting in U.S. History.
HARTMAN: It's easy to forget all the good stories that happen every year.
9:12AM SEGMENT:
HARTMAN: By all accounts this man they call Dr. Q is one of the best up-and-coming neurosurgeons in the country. At 39, he is already Director of Brain Tumor Surgery at Johns Hopkins hospital in Baltimore. Clinically brilliant, relentlessly charming. His patients say it's almost like he was born to be a doctor. If they only knew.
ALFREDO QUINONES-HINOJOSA: My very first job was with the very same hands, the very same hands that do brain surgery nowadays, back then they pulled weeds.
HARTMAN: Just 20 years ago this renown neurosurgeon was about as anonymous as a human being can get in America. An illegal immigrant working the fields of California's San Joaquin Valley. Born Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa, he says as a kid he dreamed of being a doctor. But even after he jumped the U.S.-Mexico border and took up residence in this leaky old trailer, Alfredo says the moon seemed closer than medical school.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: All I wanted to do is just make a little bit of money, send it back to my parents. That's it.
HARTMAN: But he says he had this passion. This passion to learn everything.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: There were a lot of little steps.
HARTMAN: Like you were picking weeds and you got the job on the tractor. And then you were a welder. I'm just trying to get it in order here. And then you went to community college somewhere in there and learned English.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: That's correct. Then University of California --
HARTMAN: Got into Berkeley.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: Berkeley, UC Berkeley.
HARTMAN: And then from Berkeley somehow you got great grades.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: Absolutely, my life began to really take off.
HARTMAN: Next he got his U.S. citizenship and a Harvard Medical School scholarship. Graduated Cum Laude, squeezed in time for a family and is now at Johns Hopkins scrubbing in those same weed-picking hands for brain surgery. It's no doubt a remarkable American success story. The fact that it all started with a fence hopping makes it a controversial one too.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: The last thing that I want is people to think that what I have done is justified. And the only thing that I can do is try to pay back every day by every single thing I do.
HARTMAN: To that end, Dr. Q spends much of his free time in the lab trying to find a cure for brain cancer. He hopes it makes amends, but admits he'd cross again in a heartbeat.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: I'm sure I would. You know, to be honest with you, it's human nature to try to find better ways to survive. It's human nature. It's not rocket science.
HARTMAN: It's not even brain surgery.
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: Looks very good. Thank you, guys.
—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.
















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Future Neurosurgeons
November 26, 2007 - 18:04 ET by iveseenitallThis just in: The future top ten neurosurgeons in the world were aborted yesterday.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
"This just in: The future
November 26, 2007 - 18:34 ET by Sonny Lykos"This just in: The future top ten neurosurgeons in the world were aborted yesterday."
I love it !!!!
How do you know they weren't ten future mass murderers?
November 26, 2007 - 18:38 ET by professor truthI'm waiting for your answer.
They were going to be
November 26, 2007 - 18:44 ET by MightyMouthThey were going to be private schooled. That's how...
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
I thought ALL were innocent
November 26, 2007 - 18:46 ET by JerryI thought ALL were innocent until proven guilty. Ergo, the onus is on you to prove their unrealized potential as mass murderers.
Anyway, I thought the liberal mantra was... "Better for all murderers to be set free than for one innocent to be wrongly punished."
When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).
Many liberals don't believe
November 26, 2007 - 18:51 ET by Chris NormanMany liberals don't believe in the death penalty, unless the inmate is as yet unborn. It's all part of their "Brave New World"...
"How do you know they
November 26, 2007 - 18:49 ET by Jerry"How do you know they weren't ten future mass murderers?"
You do have a point. They could have grown up to become abortionists.
When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).
By default and definition,
November 27, 2007 - 10:02 ET by dmntd1By default and definition, abortionists are NOT mass murderers. They are, however, serial killers.
I really think that questioning others' masculinity is a game probably better left to people who haven't had more cock in and out of them than a Tyson Chicken regional distribution center. AceOfSpades 06162007
Yes but can they become journalist?
November 26, 2007 - 18:26 ET by well99With the msm it probably wouldnt hurt to replace their journalist with illegals.I dont think there would be a noticeable difference.
... and if they can't speak
November 27, 2007 - 11:31 ET by Cortillaen... and if they can't speak english, all the better! Either way, it's still gibberish to me.
www.rhjunior.com Great comics with a hefty dose of Christian and anti-nutjob goodness.
"With your mind as high as Mt. Fuji you can see all things clearly. And you can see all the forces that shape events; not just the things near to you." -Miyamoto Musashi
Good point
November 27, 2007 - 13:01 ET by well99"and if they can't speak english, all the better! Either way, it's still gibberish to me."
I'm sure there are many
November 26, 2007 - 18:55 ET by Chris NormanI'm sure there are many other fine examples of humankind who have entered this country illegally. They're still here illegally. And the media criticized President Reagan for using anecdotal evidence in offering proof of his points...
Not to mention he deprived
November 27, 2007 - 09:52 ET by dscottNot to mention he deprived his home country of his skills. Which points out the flaw in the lib arguments about immigration. What they are really saying here is economic refugees should go to the head of the line, because they want their cheap lettuce and are willing to accept that a few of these illegals will become tokens, professionals to salve their greedy conscience. Of course, the tokens get all the subsidizies they need to go to college because they are poor, hence all the rest of us have to pay for their tokenism. The lib insistence on illegals speaks to their own selfishness as demonstrated here by the brain drain at the expense of other countries. It's all somehow good for America! Did these cretans ever consider this whole deal is bad for the countries these people came from????
When you enable failure by allowing illegal immigration, all you do is give lazy incompetent foreign governments the excuse to continue in their failure. What we have here is the economic equivalent of the Berlin Wall, everyone is attempting to escape the oppression of corruption and incompetence in countries south of the border to come here. If I were a leader of a Latin Country, I would be so embarrassed my fellow countrymen were leaving I wouldn't show my face for the shame.
Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity. dscott's corollary: The line between malice and stupidity is called depraved indifference.
Well, that's a nice story
November 26, 2007 - 18:45 ET by fitzfongWell, that's a nice story and all. But is Steve Hartman actually suggesting that Dr. Quinones-Hinojosa is the rule rather than the exception? Yeah, I'm sure 20 years ago he and his family crossed the border, refused to assimilate or learn English and demanded that a country he was in illegally pay for his healthcare.
I think we know that this
November 26, 2007 - 18:53 ET by ForeverOnTheRightI think we know that this gentleman is the exception not the rule. He should not be the reason to be pro-illegal. The only reason for controversy is because of people who do not see that he is an exception not the rule. You can't make something legal because of the exception. Libs like to cater to the exception and the minority all in the quest to make everything fair, even though life is not fair all the time.
Steve Hartman is one of the
November 26, 2007 - 20:23 ET by FairlightSteve Hartman is one of the weirdest 'reporters' CBS employs. The fake banter between him and katherine couric at the end of his segments have to be seen to be believed. I noticed she stopped touching his legs but that was only because Tonya Reiman probably called and said to knock that fake-friend sh*t off.
I don't have much to add
November 26, 2007 - 20:40 ET by Darth DutchI don't have much to add than to what has been said in this, and many other threads regarding illegal immigration, but it is interesting to see the following exchange (italics mine):
QUINONES-HINOJOSA: The last thing that I want is people to think that what I have done is justified. And the only thing that I can do is try to pay back every day by every single thing I do.
HARTMAN: To that end, Dr. Q spends much of his free time in the lab trying to find a cure for brain cancer. He hopes it makes amends, but admits he'd cross again in a heartbeat.
On one hand, he is saying that what he did was wrong, but on the other he said he would do it again in a heartbeat. Where I come from that is called being a hypocrite. Don't play the contrite card and then follow that up with the "I don't care, I'd do it again card". At least be honest and say what he did IS justified because he's now a neurosurgeon.
Darth Dutch
That's the answer to health care!
November 26, 2007 - 20:49 ET by ArcherBIllegals as surgeons? That's it! That is the answer to rising health care costs. Hear me out.
We all know that one of the main problems causing health care costs is the cost of mal practice insurance. Well, we all know that illegals don't carry insurance! Since they will not be burdoned by the cost of insurance, their costs will be lower and health care costs will drop.
It is the answer to all of our health care problems!
If you hamper the war effort of one side, you automatically help out that of the other. --George Orwell
Hey Numbnuts, I'm still
November 26, 2007 - 22:48 ET by SaseboSailorHey Numbnuts,
I'm still waiting for your answer from four days ago when I pointed out that the lame name "professor truth" was an oxymoron. Are you still trying to find it in the dictionary???
You're out of your league on this website, pal - you'd be much more comfortable with those drooling dysfunctionals over at huffington.
He who hesitates is last.