Continuing the sky-is-falling mantra about lead laden toys, on Tuesday’s CBS "Early Show," co-host Hannah Storm asked Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) spokeswoman, Julie Vallese:
...you are standing there, Julie, among a whole group of toys, 61 recalls, a third of those because of lead paint. Why don't you tell us as parents, why we just shouldn't buy books and clothes and pets this Christmas? Why even buy toys?
Of course that followed Julie Chen’s assertion on October 31 that Halloween and Christmas had been "ruined" because of the CPSC. It also complimented Lesley Stahl’s rant against the fast food industry on Sunday’s "60 Minutes." Not to be out done in alarmism, Storm began the segment by warning, "Millions of toys tainted with lead have been recalled so far this year, so it's tough to know what toys are actually safe to buy this holiday season."
Storm then assumed the role of toy safety expert with her first question to Vallese, "You guys have issued your top five toy hazards, but lead is not on the list. Why not, with all the lead recalls this year?"
After Vallese explained that toys that could cause choking were more likely "hazards that do injure and sometimes even kill kids," Storm brushed the safety tips aside and again focused on the recalls:
But Julie, with all these recalls, over 60 recalls, it's so tough for parents to keep track of what's safe and what's not. You mentioned you have a family, what are you buying the kids in your family for Christmas?
Who would ask a parent to announce what they are buying their children for Christmas on national television?
Finally, Storm ended the segment by condemning the CPSC for doing its job:
Okay so, how many of the toys that are on the shelves right now when we go shopping, how many of those have you tested? Can you assure us that everything on the shelves right now is safe?...But, Julie, how do they get on the shelves in the first place? I mean why isn't there a mechanism in place to not have these toys get here in the first place, instead of us trying to keep track of millions of recalls and you guys back pedaling and trying to get these things off the shelves? How are they getting here in the first place?
As Vallese then pointed out, "It's not back pedaling. It's a commitment and it is our authority to pull products, hazardous products, off the shelf."
Here is the full transcript of the segment:
HANNAH STORM: Millions of toys tainted with lead have been recalled so far this year, so it's tough to know what toys are actually safe to buy this holiday season. But the "Early Show Moms Against Lead" are on the case. Joining us is Julie Vallese, spokeswoman for the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Good morning, Julie.
JULIE VALLESE: Good morning. Nice to see you, Hannah.
STORM: Nice to see you. You guys have issued your top five toy hazards, but lead is not on the list. Why not with all the lead recalls this year?
VALLESE: Lead is an important issue. It's one to keep out of a child's environment, but I think that a lot of parents, while they may be focused on lead, are forgetting about the true risks. You know, its not your child's dollhouse, when it comes to lead, that's going to actually be an injury. It is your own house, and that's where parents should be focused if they want to really tackle the issue of lead. Now, taking lead out of a child's environment is important, but when you're shopping for toys, when you're bringing toys into your home, you really do need to know the hazards that do injure and sometimes even kill kids.
STORM: So, we're looking at ride-on toys, toys with small parts, magnets, projectile toys, and toys with chargers and adapters. And you are standing there, Julie, among a whole group of toys, 61 recalls, a third of those because of lead paint. Why don't you tell us as parents, why we just shouldn't buy books and clothes and pets this Christmas? Why even buy toys?
VALLESE: Well, if those are on your kids' lists, by all means, go ahead and buy those. Those are absolutely wonderful gifts. But let's have a little bit of a reality check, and we know children will be asking for toys. In my house, Christmas wouldn't be the same without them. And so, we want parents to really focus on where is the risk for their child. And we do know that it's choking, inhaling small parts, that children do go on riding toys and get hit by cars. And so, we want parents to choose the appropriate gifts, the age-appropriate gifts, interest and skill level for their kids. And that's really a great way to end up protecting them.
STORM: But Julie, with all these recalls, over 60 recalls, it's so tough for parents to keep track of what's safe and what's not. You mentioned you have a family, what are you buying the kids in your family for Christmas?
VALLESE: Well, my kids have quite a long list, but we will decide, you know, when we go shopping what we really feel is appropriate for our kids. And my kids do have toys on their list, but we don't want to make it all about the toys in my house. So, when you talk act these 61 recalls, we want parents to understand that earlier this year when we realized that there was a violation of lead paint in the system, we did a top-to-bottom real inspection and scrutinization of the toys on the shelves. And the toys that are on the shelves this year have been more heavily investigated and scrutinized than any year in the past.
STORM: Okay so, how many of the toys that are on the shelves right now when we go shopping, how many of those have you tested? Can you assure us that everything on the shelves right now is safe?
VALLESE: Well, I don't think we can say we have inspected everything that's in the market place. What we have done, the CPSC, as well as industry, have reassured -- gone back, and made a commitment to do a top-to-bottom inventory of those shelves. You know, since the CPSC opened it's doors, we've announced recalls, every year since 1973, recalls have been announced. That is part of our responsibility, to remove products that are in violation of the law and --
STORM: But, Julie, how do they get on the shelves in the first place? I mean why isn't there a mechanism in place to not have these toys get here in the first place, instead of us trying to keep track of millions of recalls and you guys back pedaling and trying to get these things off the shelves? How are they getting here in the first place?
VALLESE: Well, it's our responsibility and that's the authority that we have. It's not back pedaling. It's a commitment and it is our authority to pull products, hazardous products, off the shelf. And I think that there's really two different things. There's violation of laws and there's defects, that in the manufacturing process, those defects are not always well-known. But the CPSC does investigate and find those toys and pull them off the shelves. Parents need --
STORM: All right, Julie. We want to tell people at home they can find the CPSC toy alerts by going on to our web site at cbsnews.com. That's Julie Vallese, we'll be right back.
—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.















Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Tough for MSM to know
November 20, 2007 - 13:50 ET by JayTee"Tough to know what toys to buy" ?
Buy the Toys that are not in the Recall Bin........
Buy clothes, Buy Games, Buy PC's, Buy Ipods, Buy footballs, baseballs, Soccer balls, but don't Buy the MSM Baloney.
It's the one thing is wrong, so everything is a piece of S.....t syndrome. The Iraq War reporting applied to Toys.
The MSM is going to really piss off China.......they may dry up Hillary's Campaign contributions if they don't watch out.
What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ? David Foote GoE
it's tough for liberals -
November 20, 2007 - 14:07 ET by TruthMongerit's tough for liberals - everything is tough for liberals...
so when did this fax go out to the MSM about depressing everyone for the holidays?
what a rotten country we live in. Christmas is ruined. America is runied. The world is ruined...
But thank-you God for the tons of blessings we ignore every year! It must feel so great for you to keep giving us these gifts of modern living only to see the MSM bitch about it all...
As a parent this Christmas I hope to get the same reaction from my kid when he opens his gifts...
His life is "ruined" now too isn't it:)?
hey CBS why don't you take a "poll" and see how everyone's feeling now after watching your pissing and moaning extraveganzas...good stuff - really...bravo...
of course it's the "truth" right - there is only negative truth in the world - no positive truth this "thanksgiving" season to be thankful for right MSM ingrates?
what a sh*tty world we do live in, what a crappy country this is, curse all this freakin food, clothing, housing, schooling, technology, peace, prosperity, entertainment, liesure activity at my disposal - really bums me out, it's awful, why go on? what's the point? why can't we go back to the good old days of my great grandparents living on a farm with no electricity, tv, mini-vans, health club, pro-sports, mega-grocery stores, pizza delivery, yadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayadayada
curse my spoiled modern life dammit all
"It's the one thing is
November 20, 2007 - 15:15 ET by zf"It's the one thing is wrong, so everything is a piece of S.....t syndrome."
You've summed up the MSM mentality nicely. That's also their favorite way of viewing the economy.
Lead Fears Are Stupid
November 20, 2007 - 13:55 ET by deerjerkydaveBig media fears over lead have been causing my cool-aid drinking alarms to go off. A quick search at junkscience.com reveals that people are way too concerned about lead, that the science behind the fear is dubious and questionable. I guarantee you that somebody is making a lot money as long as people remain overly afraid of lead. Big media are more than happy to oblige.
http://www.junkscience.com/foxnews/fn031601.html
Not to detract from the
November 20, 2007 - 14:06 ET by BruzillaNot to detract from the Christmas spirit, but I think first and foremost, any kid who ever had their Christmas hopes crushed by opening a beautifully wrapped Christmas gift only to find a book or clothes, should be allowed to smack Hannah Storm across the face.
Secondly, when I think back to all the lead-painted, projectile-wielding, feed the small parts to your kid sister, toys that I grew up with, it's hard to get too worried about a Thomas the Train set with a skosh of lead in it. I used to make and play with lead soldiers, painted in lead paint! Maybe if Dan Akroyd came out on the set with his old Maimway Toys character, I would be more worried.
Lastly, I think it's about time that folks like Storm wake up to the fact that they are the ones who are causing all these problems. A basic black replica of an AR-15 assault rifle has no issues with lead paint. Most kids can grab it up, and run around the backyard playing war for hours without the need for any dangerous colorization. The move away from war toys, and towards bright, colorful, happy-faced, toys is the root cause of all this evil. When is the CPSC going to wake up and ban them?
I think I'm going to buy my
November 20, 2007 - 14:13 ET by Hero SquadI think I'm going to buy my kid "Lead Man" and "Magnet Boy" action hero toys this Christmas.
*****
"The empty wagon makes the most noise." - Derrick Mason
It's times like this that I'm happy I'm old.
November 20, 2007 - 14:16 ET by Dave in TexasMan, I remember the good old days when I was a kid. Buying things like lawn darts and metal drag racers that shot sparks out the back when you pushed them across the floor. You could go into a quick shop and buy candy cigarettes that had the ends dyed red so it looked like they were burning. Kids these days don't know what they're missing.
and now...
November 20, 2007 - 14:50 ET by UndercoverConservative...that we don't have those things, has life gotten "better", safer, or anything? Or have things gotten more repressive, dumber, and even more dangerous?
It's been over 20 years now with the bright green and yellow squirtguns, the removal of spring missile firing toys, no more spark shooting push alongs, gone are bright colored and stinky marker pens, banned are the lawn darts. Haven't seen candy cigarettes since I was ten. Has this stopped homeplace tragic accidents? Have kids quit smoking or simply moved on to more lethal inhalants? When did magnets become a problem?-when they didn't have plastic missiles to swallow. Now instead of sniffing markers, preteens grab cans of spraypaint.
And instead of fun dangerous toys, kids have to go elsewhere for their thrills. Gangs, fights, pregnancy, drugs. Thanks a lot, Nanny State. You've done a great job. Keep it up and things can get even worse! Grr.
The *least* dangerous thing a ten year old should have in his closet is a nice single shot bolt action .22. Right next to the skateboard, toolbox with real metal saws and hammers, a set of walkie-talkies, a slingshot or bow and arrow, a pair of six shooter cap guns, baseball and bat-the list goes on. According to Nanny State folks, there's no statistical way I should have survived childhood. My father, growing up around farm equipment, even less so. How about early pioneer families? Is this what really happened to Jamestown Colony? No properly approved toys? :P
Why don't you tell us as
November 20, 2007 - 14:27 ET by fitzfongWhy don't you tell us as parents, why we just shouldn't buy books and clothes and pets this Christmas
So you have your answer, dummy. If you're so afraid to buy toys, buy your spoiled little brats something else this Christmas. If they don't like the books and clothes, perhaps it's time for them to come to terms with the concept of "disappointment". Life has ups and downs, better to get them started early. Getting them a pet might familiarize them with the idea of responsibility...though I'm not sure that's such a great idea as pets deserve to be placed in loving, responsible homes...not picked up as window dressing and pawned off on a Betty Curry-type when it's outlived its "utility".
My compliments on the folded arm angry mob photo. No doubt manufacturers everywhere are duly frightened.
easy choices
November 20, 2007 - 14:37 ET by UndercoverConservativebuy them a big roll of bubble wrap, and a helmet. make sure they're protected from any and all sharp edges, blunt edges, middling edges, scary stuff, boring stuff, controversial stuff-anything that they might learn from-err..be "traumatized" by.
Raise another milquetoast pantywaist who has no problems with cradle-to-grave government.
I love her asinine suggestion-another case of "unintended consequences"-pets? Isn't that why the shelters are crowded cuz morons buy pets their children are unable to handle or are intolerant of? Or that the pet can scratch or bite or have fleas or cause allergies, which gets them sent to be slaughtered when they're too old to be "cute" anymore, or have been raised so badly by selfish abusive kids that they're violent and crazy?
You watch, next week this shill will have a big article on the "dangers" of pet ownership, or some sort of piece on evil Americans killing unwanted puppies and kittens after the Holidays, or how feral cats are causing Global Warming.
Brilliant!
November 20, 2007 - 14:46 ET by fitzfongBrilliant!
My holiday wish would be to
November 20, 2007 - 14:48 ET by BruzillaMy holiday wish would be to be the department store Santa who hears the wishes of Hannah Storms' kids. I could go all Al Bundy on them...
Me: "How about I get you a beautiful pony for Christmas?"
Storm kids: "A real one? That we can ride?"
Me: "Of course a real one that you can ride!"
Storm kids; "Yeah!!!"
Me: "I'll tie him up right to your Christmas tree, and if he's not there on Christmas morning it'll only be because your mother took it out back and killed it. Next kid."
Honestly, working in rescue
November 20, 2007 - 16:19 ET by nnptcgradHonestly, working in rescue I'd rather people didn't get pets for Christmas. It a very busy time of the year, family visiting, door opening, going places, etc. that a new pet can get lost in the shuffle. It's very easy for a new puppy to get out a door when you're helping your grandmother in and a person not to notice until the puppy is long gone.
Then there's the whole present aspect. A toy a kid gets bored with gets tossed in the closet, dogs and cats end up in rescue. We're getting a dog back tomorrow that a family adopted from us over a year ago. They just suddenly decided they don't want the dog anymore. I guess the "newness" has worn off.
Our rescue doesn't adopt out at all from Dec.1 through Jan 31 to avoid the whole problem.
Mother nature is a bitch - Ninth Corollary of Murphy's Law
Nanny State T.V.
November 20, 2007 - 14:56 ET by greenfairieMaybe I was weird, but I liked getting books and clothes for Christmas. Unless they're like me, Hannah Storm's kids are in for a lame Christmas morning ;).
These silly women "journalists." They're such hardcore careerists either they have no children of their own or if they do, the tots are basically being raised by nannies and au pairs. So they act like your mommy and my mommy instead, the irritatingly overprotective kind who raise hypochondriacs and neurotics because everything is too dangerous.
Who Died?
November 20, 2007 - 15:27 ET by coffee260Has anyone died from lead poisoning lately?
It's hard to die-from
November 20, 2007 - 15:30 ET by sarcasmoBut lead exposure is proven to make people even-dumber, and that we obviously don't-need.
JMR
Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.
I think Leon played in his
November 20, 2007 - 15:33 ET by MightyMouthI think Leon played in his daddy's tackle box when he was a tike. Could explain alot.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Why Buy Toys?
November 20, 2007 - 17:41 ET by merlin61Truth Monger is absolutely right - lets ruin even
out children's Christmas. CBS rules. What a bunch
of despondent idiots. Now even Sesame Street
videos have to have warnings on them. Just heard
this today, its bad for kids. They had all sorts of
moronic reasons why that make absolutely no
sense. Anything fun is going to be banned. I
think the Taliban are here already and taking over.
Don't you sometimes wonder
November 20, 2007 - 20:43 ET by Chaitealoverhow so many of us managed to reach adulthood before we had the MSM & nanny state to protect us?
Personally, I spent a large part of my childhood playing on the roofs of our and our neighbor's garages [jumping back and forth between the two]. And my favorite place to read my latest book was high in our apple tree, where the branches came together just right. My brother had a chemistry set when you still could do something with it, and a BB gun before he was 10. We stayed out after dark, too.
Chai
In explaining any puzzling Washington phenomenon, always choose stupidity over conspiracy, incompetence over cunning. Anything else gives them too much credit. Charles Krauthammer
Smells like ManagementThnk™
November 20, 2007 - 21:28 ET by dlombardHannah Storm sounds like middle managers I've had to answer to in the past--completely empty on facts, overloaded on hyperbole. Totally full of bullcrazy.
"I want answers, and I want them right now, damn it! But I've got no time for lengthy explanations. It just better be short, and I had damn well better like it!"
Meanwhile, in the real world...
*rolls eyes*
"Speak not in the ears of a fool: for he will despise the wisdom of thy words." Proverbs 23:9
My mom and dad were born in
November 21, 2007 - 13:59 ET by misterbee241My mom and dad were born in the early part of the last century. I remember them many times saying that most Christmas' they got a couple of oranges and maybe some walnuts or hard candy, and felt very fortunate to get that. Kids today have too much.
There is none so blind as they that won’t see. Jonathan Swift 1667-1745