CBS: Decrease in African-American Military Service Bush’s Fault

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

In what began as a Veterans Day tribute to African-American military veterans, a segment on Sunday’s CBS "Sunday Morning,"soon became a rant against the Bush Administration as reporter Bill Whitaker exclaimed:

The concerned Department of Defense has studied why black enlistment has plummeted and found that many of the so-called "influencers" in the black community, parents, teachers, clergy, feel in general, that Bush Administration policies have hurt African-Americans. And more than any other group, they oppose the war in Iraq.

Whitaker then examined the case of Macio Sheffield, an African-American high school student in Los Angeles who was a member of the Junior ROTC. After Sheffield explained his reason for being in ROTC: "I enjoy learning about respect and discipline. I like the Army. I love America," Whitaker followed with, "But first Macio will have to get past his parents, Macio senior and Terry Craten, who, like the majority of the blacks in the survey, oppose the Bush Administration and this war." Whitaker then talked to Sheffield’s parents:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

MACIO SHEFFIELD SR.: If I was 17 or 18 years old and had that option, I would not go into the service myself.

WHITAKER: Why not?

SHEFFIELD SR.: Because it's not our war.

TERRY CRATEN: Exactly who are we fighting? What are we fighting for? What are we going to get out of this war?

In search of more anti-war sentiment, Whitaker went from parents, to a local teacher: "Other influencers, teachers like Jamal Speaks at L.A.'S Dorsey High....tells his students times have changed and they don't need the military anymore to get an education and a career." No one is being forced into military service. There is no draft and all young Americans have the freedom to choose whatever career path they want. However, showing a young man who would be proud to serve his country but is being keep back by his parents' anti-Bush views is troubling.

Whitaker began the segment at an African-American Marine reunion in Las Vegas and went back to the event at the end of the segment to get the views of veterans. One veteran, Gregory Black, was concerned, "If blacks continue to shun the military and to shun the combat roles and ratings, then there won't be any future leaders of – black leaders in the military." However, that observation did not keep Whitaker from finding more anti-war perspectives. Another veteran, Albert Tims, declared, "The war is very unpopular and it's going to get worse." And yet another, Skip Davis, shared a similar view, "The 'yes' part, the money's good. And the 'no' part is going to Iraq. That's the 'no' part."

Whitaker offered some concluding thoughts, "And that's the attitude Army recruiter Sergeant [Tolsa] Scales does battle with day after day...Talking up the Army's many non-combat jobs." Apparently those in the mainstream media view the military as being nothing more than a government jobs program.

Here is the full transcript of the segment:

CHARLES OSGOOD: Whatever the war in which they served, veterans deserve to be heard about the issues of today. Bill Whitaker has filed this Sunday Journal.

BILL WHITAKER: It's a new tradition for some old leather necks.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN: 40 years.

WHITAKER: The second annual reunion of black Marines.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN B: I did most of my time at Camp Pendleton.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN C: We were just talking, just shooting the breeze about old times.

WHITAKER: Well, not all that old, because there weren't any black Marines before World War II. That's when blacks were first allowed into the Corps but had to train at a segregated base at Montford Point, North Carolina. Some of those old-timers joined younger Marines here in Las Vegas.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN D: You're in the Marine Corps, you're in the Marine Corps. I went through boot camp.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN E: This is the man here. I love this guy. I wasn't even born when he went to boot camp. If he didn't serve I wouldn't have had the opportunity to serve 30 years.

WHITAKER: The fact is American blacks had to fight for the right to fight in segregated units in World War II, not just the Montford Point Marines, but the famed Tuskegee Airmen, and Buffalo Soldiers too, and continued to sign up in great numbers for Korea, Vietnam, and beyond.

GREGORY BLACK: Once we entered the military, when the call went out that we had to fight, we fought. And in most cases, in a lot of cases, we fought above and beyond the call of duty because we had something to prove.

WHITAKER: Retired Commander Gregory Black was a Navy Diver for most of his 21 years in the service. Back home in Maryland, he runs a year-old web site blackmilitaryworld.com chronicling what African-Americans have contributed to the armed services of this country.

BLACK: So what the military got, was a ready source of young, eager, educated Americans who were eager to prove themselves.

WHITAKER: To the point where African-Americans, who make up 13% of the total population.

BLACK: Right, right.

WHITAKER: Made up a full quarter of military service.

BLACK: Right, yeah. African-Americans have been the backbone of the ground forces of the military since World War II.

WHITAKER: And African-Americans have gotten back plenty too.

BLACK: Blacks in the military looked at the military as a source of opportunity, a source of self-improvement, and most importantly as a source of economics.

WHITAKER: And a source of several generations of black leaders and role models.

UNIDENTIFIED Marine Veterans: One nation, under God.

WHITAKER: A theme that ran through the reunion. Master Gunnery Sergeant Robert Council has three tours in Iraq under his belt. What would you say to a young black man or woman today about military service?

ROBERT COUNCIL: I mean, if you don't have no direction right now in life, and your life is at a stand-still and you don't know where you're going. You know, the armed services right now, you know, you need a foundation. And to help you establish that foundation, it helped me establish that foundation.

WHITAKER: And these women Marines agreed. Former Staff Sergeant Benitta Williams.

BENITTA WILLIAMS: If you believe in this country, then you should be willing to go over and fight for it.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINES: I used to wear my faded jeans!

WHITAKER: But lately the message has been falling increasingly on deaf ears. African-Americans aren't signing up like they used to. Just in the last several years enlistment by blacks in the Army, for example, has plunged, down by about half. Which means Army recruiter Sergeant Tolsa Scales has his work cut out for him, burning up shoe leather in the South Los Angeles area.

TOLSA SCALES: Which one's graduated from high school?

UNIDENTIFIED BOY: I just graduated middle school.

SCALES: I was coming back to see y'all.

WHITAKER: Scales is out there reminding African-Americans the Army can be a ticket to a bright future.

SCALES: You say, 'I want to be a truck driver.' He say, 'I want to be infantry.' They say, 'I want a career,' then you talk about a career. If they say, well, I want college money, like myself that wanted college money. That's the thing the recruiter talked to me about, college money.

WHITAKER: The concerned Department of Defense has studied why black enlistment has plummeted and found that many of the so-called influencers in the black community, parents, teachers, clergy, feel in general, that Bush Administration policies have hurt African-Americans. And more than any other group, they oppose the war in Iraq. Take 10th grader Macio Sheffield. He loves his junior ROTC class at L.A.'S Fairfax High School.

MACIO SHEFFIELD: I enjoy learning about respect and discipline. I like the Army. I love America.

WHITAKER: But first Macio will have to get past his parents, Macio senior and Terry Craten, who, like the majority of the blacks in the survey, oppose the Bush Administration and this war.

MACIO SHEFFIELD Sr.: If I was 17 or 18 years old and had that option, I would not go into the service myself.

WHITAKER: Why not?

SHEFFIELD Sr.: Because it's not our war.

TERRY CRATEN: Exactly who are we fighting? What are we fighting for? What are we going to get out of this war?

JAMAL SPEAKS: And why are you going to college?

WHITAKER: Other influencers, teachers like Jamal Speaks at L.A.'S Dorsey High.

SPEAKS: Does everybody know about the job fair on Saturday.

WHITAKER: Speaks tells his students times have changed and they don't need the military anymore to get an education and a career.

SPEAKS: I think that it is my social responsibility as a teacher, as a father, as a mentor, as a person who call themselves a role model, to give those kids that information so they can make a well rounded choice on what they want to do after high school.

UNIDENTIFIED STUDENT: I feel that going to college and becoming somebody, I think that shows a love for my country because I can change something. I can make a difference in my community. I can change my community.

SPEAKS: Who else has family in the military right now?

UNIDENTIFIED STUDENT B: My cousin was one of the fortunate ones that went to the military and came out, you know, with all his body parts.

SPEAKS: A lot of what we're seeing is they're not falling in line with the grandfathers and the uncles, who their only option was the military.

WHITAKER: Back in Las Vegas.

UNIDENTIFIED Marine Veteran F: It's a pretty good representation of six-and-a-half decades of black service in the Marine Corps.

WHITAKER: Some of these grandfathers and uncles who served proudly themselves, worry about the ranks of black officers thinning down the road.

BLACK: If blacks continue to shun the military and to shun the combat roles and ratings, then there won't be any future leaders of... black leaders in the military.

UNIDENTIFIED MARINE VETERAN F: Can I get a hurrah.

WHITAKER: But even here, there are gung-who Marines troubled by this war. Albert Tims retired as a staff sergeant 30 years ago.

ALBERT TIMS: The war is very unpopular and it's going to get worse.

WHITAKER: So if you had to give advice to a young person today, what would you do? What would you say?

TIMS: Well, as long as there is a volunteer Army I'd tell them not to volunteer.

WHITAKER: And an old combat vet who loves the military, Pearl Harbor survivor Skip Davis, ten years in the Navy, 20 in the Marines.

SKIP DAVIS: The 'yes' part, the money's good. And the 'no' part is going to Iraq. That's the 'no' part.

WHITAKER: So what would you tell a kid today?

DAVIS: I wouldn't go. If I didn't have to.

SCALES: They ran back in the house, man.

WHITAKER: And that's the attitude Army recruiter Sergeant Scales does battle with day after day. So he hits the streets and works the phones. Talking up the Army's many non-combat jobs.

SCALES: So, if you didn't have to go to war, then would you join the Army? If the Army could give you a scholarship, or get you a situation so you could have a scholarship...

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

SHEFFIELD Sr.: Because it's

SHEFFIELD Sr.: Because it's not our war.  So this neede a followup of why it is not his war.  We are Americans first and foremost, well Christain for me, as far as politics goes.  We should answer the country's call if she calls.  This attitude pisses me off more tahn anything.  We should shove people who believe that out the door and over the wall.

The fact that we have an all volunteer military is great and the fact that people still join up in the time of conflict knowing they will do in country duty is fantastic.

If you dont think its your war then think this way...Its not your country and you aint welcome.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

blacks are just listening

blacks are just listening to the MSM too much

this proves NB is right

and now just look at how the MSM is harming America's military

is this treason yet?

how much more evidence do we need?

This is exactly right. 

This is exactly right.  But I would add that they are also listening to so-called Black Leaders who have been warning them to "stay out de Bushes" since 1988...

...thus, it's not Bush who is causing this, it's the Left...and they're probably glad about it.

 

is it just me..

or is there something wrong with the fact this boy's "parents" don't share the same last name?

I hate to be prejudiced (sometimes) but did they have to go out of their way to get the boy's parents into the same house at the same time?

Blacks in the Military

The last article I read on African-Americans in the military is there were too many and they were being sent to war zones in numbers far exceeding whites.

 There's no pleasing the left -- they're clearly insane.

You know, this is what

You know, this is what "gets me" most about all of this ...

These same people, often times lead by the likes of Al Sharpton ... but more importantly, Rep. Charlie Rangel, have during the course of the Iraq War, come out and made the statement(s) that "blacks, African-Americans" are the ones being hoodwinked into joining because their lives are so poor and bad (due of course to the failed War On Poverty ... my wisdom), and that they are filling the boots and dying in greater numbers than whites.  And then you have Rangel just itching beyond antihistamine help to get the draft back up and running ... knowing full well blacks/Af-Ams will be drafted in droves ... But the guys complaining in the interview stress NOT enlisting/joining.

So, now there aren't enough blacks/Af-Ams in the military?

Schizophrenia seems to be the new M.O. in this country.

Exactly my first thoughts

Exactly my first thoughts when reading this whining.  It's Bush's fault that there are too many Blacks in the military and now that the false assertion has been numerous times debunked, we now have them whining about too few Blacks in the military.  I know most of us on the Right have long ago dismissed the whining false assertions of the libs.  It's now time for the moderates to acknowledge this and face the fact that absolutely nothing these twerps have to say has any validity. 

These people will say anything to make the sale.  You might as well listen to Joe Iszuzu or Baghdad Bob for the entertainment value because these jerks aren't even funny, it's just pathetic.

The libs stopped whining about the Iraqi's not meeting benchmarks the libs set for them, you know why?  Because the idiots couldn't even meet their own Constitutionally mandated benchmark of October 1 for a new fiscal budget.  BTW - Have any of the 12 budget appropriation bills been passed yet???? It's November 13th, NOOOOO?????  I thought not...  How many more continuing resolutions will you in the Dem leadership be papershuffeling????  Incompetent Morons!!!!!  Leadership means getting stuff done, you have done nothing to speak of but instead wasted taxpayer money engaging in fruitless fishing expeditions against Bush.  INCOMPETENCE!!!!  Now let me tell you how I really feel, sniveling whiners.

Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity. dscott's corollary: The line between malice and stupidity is called depraved indifference.

That is disturbing.  It

That is disturbing.  It sounds to me like the problem lies with the so called "influencers" in the black community who for years have played the victim card and spread a message of unaccountability.  To blame Bush is a tired excuse for wanting to enjoy America without any responsibility.

I thought the problem with

I thought the problem with the military was that they were too full of minorities with not enough white people.  

So, one would think that a decrease of minorities for any reason is a good thing.  But that, apparently, is Bush's fault, but if there were an increase in blacks, it would reinforce their opinion of only minorities joining the military.  You just can't win apparently. 

Plus, many in the media feel that the military is in and of itself a bad thing, so wouldn't any decrease at all be a good thing?

Darth Dutch

...and found that many of

...and found that many of the so-called influencers in the black community, parents, teachers, clergy, feel in general, that Bush Administration policies have hurt African-Americans.

  Blacks, gays, feminists, unions, hollywood types, nutroots.... these are all parts of the democrat party that are under the control of 'influencers'.   Independent thought is not a personal quality encouraged by any of these groups.

OK, maybe I need to read

OK, maybe I need to read the transcript again, but where exactly are the factors contributing to low black enlistment addressed?

Aside from a single throw-away comment about how "Bush Administration policies have hurt African-American" (I say "throw-away" since no attempt is made to back it up), none of the complaints expressed in the story seem particularly unique to the black community.

As far as I could tell, the reasons expressed for not joining the military were "it's not our war", the war is unpopular and if you join up, you might actually have to go to Iraq.

Um, how exactly are these complains different from those that might be given by any person critical of Bush or the war? What makes them particular to backs?

Sounds like a just another story set up to criticize the Bush Administration and the war - thinly veiled as a story about black enlistment.

Blacks in the military

 I spent 30 years in the service and a good portion of the blacks weren't worth the effort, they lived up to the stereotypes and made it difficult for those who were honestly trying, they played the race card just like on the outside. The last four murders involving the US Navy and host Japanese nationals in Japan were all committed by blacks.

 They bring the entitlement/victim mentality with them and they drag down their fellow blacks who are trying to succeed.

 

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.