CBS’s Storm Quotes Barbara Boxer, Who Blamed Wildfires on Iraq

Photo of Kyle Drennen.
  • Bookmark and Share

Wednesday’s CBS ‘Early Show’ had a recurring theme in its coverage of the Southern California wildfires: the federal government failed to provide resources. Co-host Harry Smith opened the show by exclaiming that "...a fire chief says it's "the absolute truth," with more air resources, we would have been able to control this." In a later segment of the show, co-host Hannah Storm asked FEMA Administrator David Paulison, "Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer of California complained the ability of the state's National Guard has been compromised because too much of their equipment and personnel is in Iraq. Is that true?"

In addition to Smith’s blame-the-government show intro, he later observed in a report from the fire line that "I'll tell you, resources is a big part of this story...There are just not enough planes, there's not enough people, there's not enough equipment." Smith then sent the coverage to CBS reporter Bill Whitaker, who asked a firefighter if the wildfires could be brought under control, to which the firefighter responded "...if we get the resources..." Whitaker then remarked, " Now, considering how stretched resources are all across Southern California, that is a big "if."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Then came Storm’s interview with Paulison, which she began by declaring that "This massive evacuation is putting a heavy burden on emergency workers..." Storm then went on to accuse FEMA of not providing enough resources to deal with the disaster, "Well, as we've heard, the Chief Chip Prather of the Orange County Fire Authority said it's an "absolute fact" that if we had more air resources we would've been able to control this fire. Why weren't those resources available?"

Paulison explained that water planes were available, but that strong winds made the planes useless, "...when they disperse the fire retardant and the water, it dissipates so quickly that it doesn't, it's not effective." An undeterred Storm brushed aside that fact and pressed Paulison, "But he's actually saying that there were resources that were not made available to them in quick enough time. What's your response to that?"

At that point, Storm decided it was best to quote left-wing Senator Barbara Boxer’s ridiculous claim that, "...the ability of the state's National Guard has been compromised because too much of their equipment and personnel is in Iraq." Paulison’s response to the statement rejected the premise, if ever so politely, "I have not seen that at all, quite frankly, and I know she's right on top of issues, but -- and she does a great job for California. But I've not seen that at all."

At the end of the segment, Storm turned to "Early Show" weatherman, Dave Price, who reported from San Diego’s Qualcomm Stadium. She asked Price, "And Dave, you remember back a couple of years, you were at the Superdome in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. How does it compare?" Unlike his colleagues, Price had some good news, "Well, you can't help but compare those two circumstances, but Hannah, much more organized, certainly, and actually, this arena has an air of a mix of social services, a community gathering, and a street fair."

Credit to Dave Price for actually acknowledging the government’s successful response to the wildfires.

Here is the transcript of excerpt’s from this morning’s coverage:

7:00AM TEASER

HARRY SMITH: And a fire chief says it's 'the absolute truth. With more air resources, we would have been able to control this. Early this Wednesday morning, October 24th, 2007.

7:03AM REPORT

SMITH: 7,000 firefighters working round the clock are overwhelmed. Virtually every fire engine in the state, some from 800 miles away, are on hand to do battle. And with all that, there's still not enough help.

FIRE CHIEF CHIP PRATHER: It is an absolute fact, had we had more air resources, we would have been able to control this fire.

CRYING WOMAN: We did what we could, there's just no fire engines here. There's no fire engines. We've got lots of friends, but no fire engines. There's the flames, really big, big flames.

7:05AM REPORT

SMITH: After a special request from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Department of Defense sent six Air Force and Air National Guard planes to help with the fight. Most of these planes carry about 3,000 gallons of water. A new supertanker, one that carries 21,000 gallons and distributes it over a much wider area, is currently being tested. It's also faster and safer. But it won't be certified in time to fight these devastating wildfires. I'll tell you, resources is a big part of this story as we were with firefighters all night last night. We heard the radio crackling all night long. We need more help over here, we need more help over there. People were trying to take a nap. They woke people up and said we need more help over here. There are just not enough planes, there's not enough people, there's not enough equipment. That's how big this story is. Now, let's go to Bill Whitaker who's in Lake Arrowhead, another place where the fire is burning out of control. Good morning, Bill.

7:08AM REPORT

BILL WHITAKER: Despite the devastation, firefighters were optimistic they can win this battle.

FIREFIGHTER: It's got a lot of potential, but if we get the resources, we'll be able to put it to bed.

WHITAKER: Now, considering how stretched resources are all across Southern California, that is a big if. And this is what they're trying to prevent. It's not just this house here, but down the block, one house after another, after another have been destroyed, and they're trying to keep this from happening throughout this whole area.

7:11AM SEGMENT

HANNAH STORM: This massive evacuation is putting a heavy burden on emergency workers who offer food, supplies, and shelter to evacuees. FEMA Administrator David Paulison is in Los Angeles leading the effort. Good morning.

DAVID PAULISON: Good morning.

STORM: Well, as we've heard, the Chief Chip Prather of the Orange County Fire Authority said it's an absolute fact that if we had more air resources we would've been able to control this fire. Why weren't those resources available?

PAULISON: There is quite a bit of resources on the ground right now. Part of the issue is the winds. The airplanes can fly in the winds, but when they disperse the fire retardant and the water, it dissipates so quickly that it doesn't, it's not effective. We have quite a few air tankers on the ground. There's six more coming in from the National Guard from Northcom. So, we feel like we have a lot of air resources on the ground right now. And hopefully, if this wind will die down this afternoon, we can get those in the air and get these fires under control.

STORM: But he's actually saying that there were resources that were not made available to them in quick enough time. What's your response to that?

PAULISON: Well, I'm not aware of that, obviously, but, you know, California has the best wildland firefighters actually in the world. And they know what they're doing. They will get a handle on this fire. It's just a matter of dealing with the weather right now. The winds are horrendous. The humidity is down in single digits in some cases, and we just need a break with the weather and we can get all the air tankers that are actually on the ground right now, up in the air and get this fire under control.

STORM: Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer of California complained the ability of the state's National Guard has been compromised because too much of their equipment and personnel is in Iraq. Is that true?

PAULISON: I have not seen that at all, quite frankly, and I know she's right on top of issues, but -- and she does a great job for California. But I've not seen that at all. I was just at Qualcomm yesterday and last night, actually. Things are under control. There's plenty of food, there's plenty of water. There's lots of security. I have not seen an issue with the Guard. In fact, they're moving a lot of National Guard on the ground working with Northcom and others to make sure we have the right people here to do the job.

STORM: Alright, FEMA Administrator David PAULISON, you have a huge task. Good luck.

PAULISON: Thank you.

STORM: And time now for our first check of the weather. Dave Price is at Qualcomm stadium in San Diego, that's the largest shelter for fire evacuees. And Dave, you remember back a couple of years, you were at the Superdome in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. How does it compare?

DAVE PRICE: Well, you can't help but compare those two circumstances, but Hannah, much more organized, certainly, and actually, this arena has an air of a mix of social services, a community gathering, and a street fair. As you took a look yesterday as people began to gather in, community organizations came together, the place was filled with baby food and diapers, toys and books, blankets and tents and entertainers alike. In fact, there's even a meditation area here, Southern California style. But keep in mind, people here are worried. They are concerned. They don't know whether when they leave here they're going to go home and find that they have a home or they have lost everything.

—Kyle Drennen is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

It's all Iraq, all the time

It makes me wonder. Do these guys just look at every single news item and think to themselves, "how can I relate this to Iraq?"

 

Well, to be fair, some ask themselves, "how can I releate this to Global Warming?"

So I guess I just answered my own question.

 

 

If you hamper the war effort of one side, you automatically help out that of the other. --George Orwell

It sure is, Archer

Let me see if I have this straight for the sake of logic-

1. US Army in Iraq= Bad
2. US Army in California < US Army in Iraq
3. Fires in California= Bad
Therefore:  US Army in California= Good?

These same people who bad-mouth our military all day every day are now saying how much they need them back to help the poor people of S. Cal.  Aren't they scared that these people will terrorize innocent Californian women and children in the dark of night?

 

 

 

When will they make up their little minds?

It is either Bush's fault or Global Warming. Please make up your minds.

The lack of intelligence of these morons on the left really just  makes me want to puke. I am getting to the point where I just cannot watch them anymore because it is nothing but the same old dribble that spews from their mouths day after day. It's getting really old.

Governor Terminator

Governor Terminator said they had plenty of planes. They could not fly because of the high winds which were caused God. He chewed out  Claire Shipmann about the same thing.  

Southern by birth, Tarheel by the grace of God!

Arnold should be blasting

Arnold should be blasting these dispicable political hacks who are using their own political self-interest without a shred of facts or knowledge - at a time of a major disaster.

He should immediately start with his own Lieutenant Governor and then go onto Boxer and Feinstein.

He's a Republican in the

He's a Republican in the Democrat stronghold of the nation. He's surroounded by virtual enemies, including his own wife. He has done quite a few things I can't even come close to agreeing with, but it makes one wonder how much is Arnold's personal choice, and how much the whacko lefties force on him? At least he clarified about the planes... 

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

MSM Theme Song

Funny. I always thought

Funny.

I always thought they sounded a lot like the Beatles.

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

Hannah Storm is a moron and

Hannah Storm is a moron and so is Babs Boxhead.  Where was her overcoiffed heinie?  Safely back in D.C. while the governor and local officials were doing all of the heavy lifting.  

Barbara Boxer scheduled to make an appearance...

Local news from Qualcomm Stadium is that Barbara Boxer will be making an appearance with a number of other politicians for a press conference from the "Q". I hope somebody calls her out for her comments about the National Guard. The equipment that they keep talking about isn't in Iraq! And the weather conditions have kept everyone grounded. I'm about 7 miles from an airstrip in Ramona where they stage the firefighting planes and they have been showing the conditions there for several days. The pilots have been chomping at the bit to fly, but, have been grounded from the wind. The political BS has got to stop. I've been in the middle of it all and the politician's don't know sh!t! (excuse my exclamation!!!)
I'm ducking fisgusted...

That woman makes Nancy

That woman makes Nancy Pelosi look like a conservative.

I hope Arnold puts on his Terminator sunglasses and goes to the press conference with her.

She KNOWS her comments about the National Guard are flat out wrong, but she can't resist passing up the opportunity to slam the President.

Despicable in the midst of all that tradgedy.

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

Boxer is a moron

Saw Boxers press conference. Now blames lies that she told about the National Guard on a letter from the Pentagon. Says that she talked to General in charge of Ca. National guard and now believes that they can handle their responsibility. Wonder why she did not talk too general first?

Anyone that uses a disaster to gain political points is evil.

Punch a Lib

Everytime I see something like this, it makes me want to punch a liberal in the face.  I know that is not civil but man would it feel good.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

Airforce_5_0 I am with

Airforce_5_0

I am with you on that.

I love your slogan also! 

 

Thanks Voodoo.  I read

Thanks Voodoo.  I read this crap they spew and I just think back to something my dad use to say.

"Son, some people won't understand what is going on without your foot in their a$$."

That is the piont I am at with Liberals in the media and our government.

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

The North Carolina Air Guard

The North Carolina Air Guard sent 4 C-130's  from the 145th Airlift Wing to help. Two of those planes are equiped with equipment to spread the retardant and the other two are to move men/equipment. I didn't think that the air guard had many planes in the Iraq theater. Most of them fly over, drop their cargo and return to their home base.

Southern by birth, Tarheel by the grace of God!

Rick, it is just ashame

Rick, it is just ashame that the MSM can't bring themselves to cover anything good that is happening.  Show me where in the MSM, ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, and any other Main stream network.

Pitiful. 

The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.

 

A minor point, but a misuse of rhetoric

There are a lot of questions about this tragedy, but it's still early and the initial reports are always wrong. But we can spot rhetoric-gone-wrong as it happens, as it did here: 

“It’s an absolute fact.”

Ask professors of philosophy what a “fact” is – they’ll tell you it means nothing. To assert that something is a fact merely asserts that you agree it’s true. But whenever you assert anything, logically, you're already claiming that what you assert is true. Calling it a fact adds nothing.

  • As Quine said, to claim that ‘snow is white is a fact’ is just another way of saying ‘snow is white.’
  • All you’re really doing is adding an exclamation point, but it doesn’t prove anything.

When the media then runs with the phrase, ‘absolute fact,’ they’re trying to score an empty rhetorical point. The local fire chief believes that if they had more resources, they could have controlled the fire. Well, that’s his opinion, but his opinion has been debated elsewhere (i.e., Schwarzenegger explained that the wind was keeping the planes grounded, but that doesn’t mean they don’t have enough planes). Nevertheless, it’s simply his opinion – calling it a fact doesn’t change anything.

I'm not even going to

I'm not even going to attempt to get into how friggin ridiculous this entire diatribe is. But one thing little Missy Storm said pissed me off: 

She asked Price, "And Dave, you remember back a couple of years, you were at the Superdome in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. How does it compare?"

Uh Hannah, how about this for a comparison:

New Orleans - water

Malibu - fire

New Orleans - poor

Malibu - rich

New Orleans - incompetent government

Malibu - (relatively) competent government

New Orleans - gimme, gimme, gimme nanny state

Malibu - some degree of self-sufficiency

And finally, yes, the Gov of Kansas tried to play the National Guard in Iraq card, and got biatch-slapped for such a stupid, ignorant, lying statement. Should Hannah be next? I vote a resounding YES!

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

Boxer


Boxer is an idiot, she has no intelligent thoughts of her own so she needs someone to tell her what to say. That person is also an idiot.

She is also 1 of 2 reasons why I have often said that SoCal has no representation in the US senate. you can bet if the fires were in Berkeley [which has happened in the past], all she would be talking about is how much money to send the people.

Side point: People who have evacuated to Qualcomm stadium come from
San Diego, not Malibu, which is something like 120+ miles north. Otherwise, your points are valid.

Surprise!

Boxer, the bemoaner, was just on FoxNews basically retracting everything negative she said yesterday. No apology. No "I was wrong." No "I was mistaken."

Typical hater.

"After speaking with the Governor...."

Maybe Boxer should have waited to speak with the Governor first, huh?

Leftists don't apologize....

Leftists don't apologize....

It Sure Seems That Way

But, confoundedly, I continue to hope that little bit of "good" inside everyone, even the blackhearted Liberal haters, will come to the surface. Pipedream? Yeah, I know.

Hi BPB... I'm an optimist

Hi BPB...

I'm an optimist by nature...but not that much of one in this instance...

ROFL!

Newbusters will grow.

 These stories have to be a good feeling for Newsbusters.  Talk about job security! The media isn't even bothering to research any of this stuff, they just ask the leading questions (no doubt supplied by their friends at the DNC) and move on.  You'd think they would check on the National Guard or why the planes weren't being used (too windy), but no, they just continue to act like the media wing for the Democrats. 

Democrats: Specializing in "high tech lynching" since 1987.

Over the last few years,

Over the last few years, they have grown so accustomed to being completely unchallenged on anything they say, it is coming as a severe shock when now their veracity is questioned and they are forced to actually come up with facts to back up their rhetoric. Even worse (for them) is that they seldom have any facts to back them up. This is almost as good as watching a real circus...

The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers

Drive By Media

That's why they call it the "drive-by" media. They swoop in, wreak havoc and confusion, then flee before they have to account for the damage.

It's like "Jurassic Park." You see these large footprints in the mud, and you just follow the trail of wreckage. They're the Jurassic Press.