Time's Joe Klein: Ahmadinejad the Iranian Version of George W. Bush

Photo of Ken Shepherd.
  • Bookmark and Share

If beating dead horses were an Olympic event, Joe Klein would have more medals gracing his neck than Michael Phelps.

On his magazine's Swampland blog, the Time columnist returned to his latest overwrought left-wing pandering point: labeling hardliner President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as the Iranian version of George W. Bush:

The protesters admire our freedom, but they are appalled--and insulted--by our neocolonialist condescension over the past 50 years. The reformers, and even some conservatives, consider Ahmadinejad the George W. Bush of Iran--a crude, unsophisticated demagogue, who puts a strong Potemkin face to the world without very much knowledge of what the rest of the world is about. This was an anology [sic] that came up in interview after interview, with reformers and conservatives alike.

Klein doesn't explicitly reference the "axis of evil" remarks  in then-President Bush's 2002 State of the Union address as an offense, although he quite probably has it in mind. Yet a review of the relevant passage from that speech shows Bush was dead-on and arguably eerily prophetic about the iron-fisted repression that the world is witness to presently on the streets of Tehran (portion in bold is my emphasis):

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Our second goal is to prevent regimes that sponsor terror from threatening America or our friends and allies with weapons of mass destruction.

[...]

Iran aggressively pursues these weapons and exports terror, while an unelected few repress the Iranian people's hope for freedom.

[...]

States like these, and their terrorist allies, constitute an axis of evil, arming to threaten the peace of the world. By seeking weapons of mass destruction, these regimes pose a grave and growing danger. They could provide these arms to terrorists, giving them the means to match their hatred. They could attack our allies or attempt to blackmail the United States. In any of these cases, the price of indifference would be catastrophic.

Although Klein won't admit it, he partially agrees with former President Bush -- the Iranian people want greater freedom -- although the Time columnist also insisted that the Iranian protesters are content with the Islamic "revolution" that is denying them said freedom (emphasis mine):

They do not believe they live in an Evil Empire. They still support their revolution. They shout "Allahu Akbar" in the streets, which was the rallying cry of 1979. They are proud of their nuclear program, even if many have doubts about the efficacy of weaponizing the enriched uraniam that is being produced. They want greater freedom, to be sure. And they believe that the Khamenei-Ahmadinejad forces--and the militarized regime they have empowered, the millions of basiji and revolutionary guards--is a profound perversion of that revolution. They are right. They deserve our prayers and support. But they don't need grandstanding from an American President, and they certainly don't need histrionics from blustery old John McCain.

It seems Klein is the one that has bought the Iranian mullahs' "Potemkin face to the world." After all, the basij and the Revolutionary Guard are not perversions of the Islamic Revolution of 1979, they are a fundamental component of it, the armed enforcement mechanism and thought police, as it were, of the "revolution" which Klein insists the intelligent, sophisticated, and world-wise Iranian protesters support.

What's more, contrary to Klein's insistence, there is evidence that there are at least some protesters now publicly long for Ayatollah Khameini's death and perhaps with it fundamental change to the regime's theocratic structure. As the Associated Press reported on Saturday (emphasis mine):

On the streets, witnesses said some protesters also shouted "Death to Khamenei!" — another sign of once unthinkable challenges to the authority of the successor of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the father of the Islamic Revolution. 

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Wow, BDS must be a terminal

Wow, BDS must be a terminal illness: It stays with you to the end.

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

BDS

I agree wholeheartedly!!!!  Its strictly contagious among MSM.  Is Obama going to be on tv every

day he is in office?   It appears that way.   Today a

news conference and tomorrow, non-stop coverage

of healthcare by ABC.   I won't watch any of it

today or tomorrow.  I'll wait for FOX news to give

the feedback of what was covered today and

tomorrow. 

 

They cannot just get over

They cannot just get over Bush or let him go. Their self inflicted wounds must really run deep.   

"DumbAssity of Dope"

No impeachment has really cut them to bone

they pinned all their happiness on it.  They got their One in office and it still isn't good enough.

Klein Needs to Clarify

My understanding is that he thinks Bush is worse than Ahmadinajad and the turmoil in Iran is just a redux of Florida 2000.

Well then, he should pay up his life insurance policy and  take to the streets of Tehran.

This is the problem I have

This is the problem I have with commentary "based on reports from on the ground" - it is skewed by all the craziness, hatred, and chaos from that same ground. Guys like Klein are more sympathetic to these crazy zealots and trusts them far more than the president of his own country. What good does such warped commentary do for anybody reading it?

The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.

The NYT is the Newspaper

The NYT is the Newspaper that only prints hate. Time and again they spew their hatred -- untouched, and unvarnished by rationale editors or even the scent of decency. What really irritates me is that this paper knows many of its readers take the NYT as gospel -- and so the NYT is confident that their hatred and outright lies are spread as The Truth by their subscribers. Thank God for sites like NB -- where at least some people can be rightfully informed of these tactics being perpretated by a once-great, but now totally useless rag.

___________________________________ 

Liberals constantly demand that we accept a glaring falsehood as truth; Obama's elimination of the word "terror" will make terrorist acts less terrifying

Hey.. Baghdad Bob is the

Hey.. Baghdad Bob is the Iraqi version of Joe W.D.* Klein...

(*That's short for Walter Duranty for those familiar with the Slimes long history of shameful so-called  journalism

“For God's sake, somebody tell Obama that a TRILLION is one MILLION MILLION!!!!

I beg to differ...

Bob had more journalistic integrity.

Ah, yes...

the people who were counting the days until we were all rid of W cannot shut up about him now that he is out of office.

They are really scared of their messiah's amateurism showing before the entire world.

Comparisons

Let's see, The Great Obama just said that Iran is having an "extraordinary debate" recently. He must be talking about the killings of protesters by the government. What a debate! Then Klein compares Ahmadinejad to Bush. What recent U.S. President used a military style attack to quell men, women, and children protesting the government? How many were killed at Waco without leaving their home, without marching in the street? How many died whose only offense was they would not surrender fast enough?

Well, to be fair, in the

Well, to be fair, in the U.S., liberals debate Ann Coulter by throwing a pie in her face.....

The most poignant thing I always remember when I hear these socialist/communist/marxists compare Ahmadinejad to Bush is that it was the communists that branded the fascists as 'right-wing'. And they never paid any attention to the similarities of Fascism and Communism. 

WE THE PEOPLE of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare,

Bush is totally the American

Bush is totally the American version of Ahmadinejad in that half the country supported him, the other half didn't.

Other than that, I don't get this.

It's a pretty big stretch. 

And, I'm-inna-jar

was invited to an ivy league university and treated with respect.

We all know the treatment W would have received.

Bush actually spoke at the

Bush actually spoke at the Yale commencement in 2001.  No problems were reported.

"Bush actually spoke at

"Bush actually spoke at the Yale commencement in 2001.  No problems were reported."

You are incorrect.

  1. CNN
  2. FOXNews
  3. Yale Daily News

Bush is totally the

Bush is totally the American version of Ahmadinejad

In what way and with what reasoning do you conclude this?  Im-A-Dinner-Jacket is more like Obama in that he wants to keep oppressing the people, he believes in the state controlling and owning all big enterprise.  In short both are oppressors of the people and lie about their intentions.

Ohh ya both also cheat on elections and use thugs to control the election results.  Obama has not gotten his brown shirts/hezbellah up yet so he relies on ACORN and Black panthers to do his dirty work.  Both believe they should control the press.

Yep Im-A-Dinner-Jacket and Duh One are eriely similar. 

Bush is totally the American

Bush is totally the American version of Ahmadinejad in that half the country supported him, the other half didn't.

What don't you understand about this sentence? 

The part about Bush being

The part about Bush being Im-A-Dinner-Jacket, its a false assumption.  Also Im-A-Dinner-Jacket got way more than 1/2 of Iranians.  Other than that, what dont you understand about my comment?

In that case, Bush got less

In that case, Bush got less than half of the American votes in the 2000 election.  He simply won the electoral.  Do you want to keep throwing facts back and forth?  Can you spell Ahmadinejad?  The I'm-A-Dinner-Jacket thingy was funny when the first guy posted it.

What I get from your comments is that you either misunderstood my simple statement, or you're reading something else into it in hopes of starting a fight.  If you want to read it again, slowly this time, I simply stated that about half of the country in each candidate's case supported the candidate.  Other than that there's no link.  Get it?  Or do you still want to fight about it? 

Bush is totally the

Bush is totally the American version of Ahmadinejad

You are being disingenous as you compare President Bush to I'm-A-Dinner-Jacket and then say hey look can you read.  Yes I can and I see exactly what you meant and I don't think I misunderstood your intent.

It was not to srtart a fight but to set the record straight that I'm-A-Dinner-Jacket and President Bush are nothing alike.

I have one question about this statement "If you want to read it again, slowly this time..."  Do you have that much trouble that I have to read it to you slowly?

And I am through with this matter as I have made my point.

Are you kidding me!!! It was

Are you kidding me!!!

It was not to srtart a fight but to set the record straight that I'm-A-Dinner-Jacket and President Bush are nothing alike. 

That is exactly what I was saying with my first post.  Everyone else here seemed to get it, why can't you?  I posted the only similarity that I could come up with, and left it at that.  What's the problem?

Joe Klein is not

Joe Klein is not important...at all.

Useless idiot deluxe.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

who rates the losers?

How is TIME---in partnership with CNN---magazine doing in the ratings? Are magazines given weekly ratings like news programs? Does some agency rate TIME's weekly newstand sales against Newsweek's weekly sales?

Is Joe Klein any less relevant than say, Michael Isikoff? Does anyone actually care?

 

 

Interesting Choice of Words

Demagogue: 1 : a leader who makes use of popular prejudices and false claims and promises in order to gain power

All together now, HOPE!  CHANGE!  BAD OIL COMPANIES! That lying Bush!

And of course there is the similarity of federal agents attacking US civilians with many casualties ie Waco.  That killing Bush!

Oh. . . wait a minute. . .

Someone Left Home Without His Straitjacket

I thought Bush Derangement Syndrome would die hard. I didn't think it would never die. The 8 years of Bush's presidency drove Klein and his ilk completely out of their minds. They'll never recover. Klein's comparison of Ahmadinejad to Bush is literally insane. What the hell is the matter with these people on the Left? They've got no credibility whatsoever with regular people, and the regular people still run the country. Klein is unwittingly lining people up against Democrats.

As long as Klein works for Time magazine, I will not only...

never buy the rag, I will never even touch it with my fingers.  Truth be told, this will not be a hard vow to keep.  It is the equivalent of saying, I will never score a point in an NBA playoff game.  The difference is, I'd LOVE to score a basket in an NBA playoff game.  Jim Webster

Prozac, Zyprexa, Lamictal? Something's gotta work.

I simply do not understand BDS.  It appears to be an obsession bordering insanity.  I'm currently sporting a rather attractive and notable bruise on my right knee after being decked by an overly friendly Great Dane I met while walking yesterday evening.  (Do you have any idea how TALL these dogs are when they rise up to put their front paws on your shoulders?!)  This is clearly Mr. Bush's fault.  Isn't it lovely to have someone to blame rather than taking responsibility for oneself?

Of course, we now have ODS wherein every media outlet is bowing and scraping before Mr. Obama.  He's charismatic and his family is lovely.  If he doesn't get his dog trained ASAP I'm going to seriously disdain him.  It's not difficult, but demands daily attention.  Perhaps he could take a break from rushing in front of a camera and have a trainer train him to train the dog.

anneftx

Time's Joe Klein: Ahmadinejad the Iranian Version of George W. B

Klein is a cretinous idiot working for a joke of a "news magazine." Frankly, who cares what that clown thinks?