Republicans aren't racist per se, but they'll use the law to disenfranchise black voters who overwhemingly cast their ballots for Democrats.
That according to Newsweek's Jonathan Alter in a September 11 article on "Jim Crawford Republicans." Crawford was the losing party in a Supreme Court case earlier this year upholding Indiana's Voter ID law.
[W]ith the help of a 2008 Supreme Court decision, Crawford vs. Marion County (Indiana) Election Board, white Republicans in some areas will keep eligible blacks from voting by requiring driver's licenses. Not only is this new-fangled discrimination constitutional, it's spreading.
GOP proponents of the move say they are merely trying to reduce voter fraud. But while occasional efforts to stuff ballot boxes through phony absentee voting still surface, the incidence of individual vote fraud—voting when you aren't eligible—is virtually non-existent, as "The Truth About Vote Fraud," a study by the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University, clearly shows. In other words, the problem Republicans claim they want to combat with increased ID requirements doesn't exist. Meanwhile, those ID hurdles facing individuals do nothing to stop the organized insiders who still try to game the system.
The motive here is political, not racial. Republicans aren't bigots like the Jim Crow segregationists. But they know that increased turnout in poor, black neighborhoods is good for Democrats. In that sense, the effort to suppress voting still amounts to the practical equivalent of racism.
[...]
So about the only thing we know for sure this year is that with the Crawford decision we are seeing a return to the days when one political party saw a huge advantage in preventing as many poor people as possible from voting. That's understandable politically, but also un-American.
Of course, Alter is presuming an ID check will automatically result in a downturn in voting, rather than an uptick in eligible voters obtaining free state-issued ID. Yes, Alter neglected to mention that the Hoosier State will give voters such IDs free of charge:
If you do not possess an ID that is acceptable for voting purposes, Public Law 109-2005 requires the BMV to issue an Indiana State ID Card free.
Alter also neglected to mention that Indiana permits provisional balloting whereby people without IDs may cast ballots and have 10 days to go back with proper identification for the ballots to count.:
If you are unable or unwilling to present ID meeting these requirements, you may cast a provisional ballot. If you cast a provisional ballot, you have until noon 10 days after the election to follow up with the county election board and either provide the necessary documentation or affirm one of the law's exemptions applies to you.
—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Dammit! All you guys have are FACTS!
September 12, 2008 - 00:13 ET by Scout FinchWe cannot change public perception of 'overly strict' voter laws if you keep posting laws that are 180º different than our lies!
My thought was "Damn those
September 12, 2008 - 05:54 ET by motherbeltMy thought was "Damn those "new-fangled" laws!! LOL
But Alter is being disingenuous. He says:
keep eligible blacks from voting by requiring driver's licenses. Not
only is this new-fangled discrimination constitutional, it's spreading.
However, the law only requires official identification, not specifically a driver's license!
Anyone who can get themelves to the polls to vote can get themselves to the BMV or wherever to get an ID!
WOW! Bet you didn't know THIS
September 12, 2008 - 07:30 ET by AJBEvery non-black voter has ID! Only black voters are affected! Only democrats get votes from blacks! There is NO election fraud (read Chicago, Ohio, Florida) by spendocrats, uh, democrats! Jesse Jackson is only working to improve life for blacks. Al Sharpton is not a racist. Please mark these down. You will be tested later.
we're trying to inhibit the black vote...?
September 12, 2008 - 13:39 ET by TruthMongerwe're trying to inhibit the black vote...?
they've lost a third of their population to roe-v-wade
http://www.city-data...
leave the DNC plantation, my black friends
walk towards the RNC light!
Stuffing ballot
September 12, 2008 - 00:13 ET by jkwtradingStuffing ballot boxes..Let's see Lyndon Johnson and Jack Kennedy are masters of it..
for those whom like to play what if...what if Nixon contested the 60 election Ike told him in no uncertain terms, "get those two" and won
Would we have all the social legislation we have today? Would we have had vietnam, and the now far left from the 60's coming to the forefront now in the likes of Pelosi, Obama, and all the rest.
would there be Newsbusters or any need for it?
IDs
September 12, 2008 - 00:14 ET by SchnikeysI was gonna say...I'm not sure about Indiana, but my state offers ID cards for non-drivers to carry around.
<sarc>What's that? Alter was reading too much into the issue? Nahh....</sarc>
------------------------------------------------------------
"My morality is your morality."
There are only 2 counties
September 12, 2008 - 00:16 ET by jkwtradingThere are only 2 counties in indiana where all out fraud can exist, Marion and also Lake counties..
Of course 90% of the blacks live in those two counties.
Response
September 12, 2008 - 00:49 ET by SchnikeysSo Alter's answer is, without considering any other possibilities, to assume that any effort to combat this fraud, especially in these two counties, is based on racist foundations.
In conclusion: you want to vote in Indiana? Get a free ID and take it with you to the polls on Election Day. Requiring people to ID themselves and have the brains to use ID for its purpose is not a crime. Racism's got nothing to do with it.
------------------------------------------------------------
"My morality is your morality."
Why does the black culture have any respect for liberals?
September 12, 2008 - 00:22 ET by JWFOnce again, we have a liberal looking down on a culture. Black people are too poor and stupid to get a free ID card. So they must be given special favors to help their downtrodden selves. Special favors and treatment that can only come from caring loving giving tearful liberals.
Jefferson Parish where I
September 12, 2008 - 00:31 ET by cocodrieJefferson Parish where I live requires a picture ID to vote. New Orleans is fighting tooth and nail against this. It is too difficult for the dead people and those in vacant lots and non existant houses to get a picture ID. Without these voters Mary Landrieu will never be reelected. Mayor Willy-Wonka Nagin and Refrigerator Jefferson owe a lot to these voters.
»→ Respect for Liberals
September 12, 2008 - 00:47 ET by Cool ArrowBut if the slave plainly says, ‘I love my master, my wife, and my children; I
will not go out free,’ 6 then his
master shall bring him to God, and he shall bring him to the door or the
doorpost. And his master shall bore his ear through with an awl, and he shall be
his slave forever. Gen. 21: 5,6
I'm beginning to believe we have no business questioning the choices (individually, or en masse) that have been made voluntarily. Who are we to demand others step out of their own private comfort zones.
"that was the trip of a lifetime to visit our troops in Kuwait and stop and visit our injured soldiers in Germany" - Sarah Palin
As a person who lives in S. IN
September 12, 2008 - 01:51 ET by tomnkiki...which is heavily DEMOCRAT, and where most people vote DEMOCRAT, I, as a Republican am required to show my Driver's License every single time I vote. Is it wrong of those Democrat's in this area to force me to show my ID? BTW, when you get your license in IN, you can also sign up to vote at the same time. Are people so brainless that they can't manage to do that?
Hold on to your
September 12, 2008 - 01:59 ET by mastersofdeceitHold on to your seat
Because this tactic is just getting started. This one is the hot one on AA just starting today. Expect it to show up on a major media channel near you. Expect new "scandals" we will have to hear about the rest of our lives.
I'm sorry Alter, which party invented black (and white,catholic republican) voter suppression? And exactly how did the vote in poor black neighborhood's become "good for democrats"? I'm curious. What's that? Which party? That's what I thought.
This sounds like a job
September 12, 2008 - 02:04 ET by MrSnugglesThis sounds like a job for... a community organizer!!!!!
Found! Community Organise
September 12, 2008 - 02:16 ET by mastersofdeceitFound!
Community Organiser's!
a.k.a, Tire Slashers.
September 12, 2008 - 05:37 ET by Crasha.k.a., Tire Slashers.
Requiring Is Discrimination?
September 12, 2008 - 02:27 ET by Intellectual Honesty[W]ith the help of a 2008 Supreme Court decision, Crawford vs. Marion County Indiana Election Board, white Republicans in some areas will keep eligible blacks from voting by requiring driver's licenses. Not only is this new-fangled discrimination constitutional, it's spreading.
Hello? The law doesn't just require blacks to have licenses but whites also ie. all voters. And what does "white Republicans in some areas" mean? And one doesn't have to have a driver's license but a state-issued ID.
If the requirement to have a state-issued ID is repressive because blacks are less likely to have the time to get them (they are free, if I understand it correctly, so cost isn't an issue) then why isn't it discrimination that rural voters have further to travel and need to provide their own transportation to get to their voting locations when most blacks live in areas with multiple public transportation options?
Just guessing,
September 12, 2008 - 04:04 ET by IamTinmanBut I think illegal immigrants are going to have the most trouble with this law. Tough!
They just like to use words that begin with "Dis"
September 12, 2008 - 05:36 ET by CrashNext thing you know democrats will want felons to vote.
Crash
September 12, 2008 - 05:51 ET by Cool ArrowI'm in favor of felons voting if they have completed their sentence.
"that was the trip of a lifetime to visit our troops in Kuwait and stop and visit our injured soldiers in Germany" - Sarah Palin
I guess the Republicans. . .
September 12, 2008 - 06:22 ET by WingletDriverare trying to prevent Blacks from flying on an airline. Every time I do it, someone asks me for a danged ID.
I hear ya, WingletDriver
September 12, 2008 - 07:00 ET by Mica the MagnificentAnd I hear that republicans require blacks to be at least 62 years old before they can collect social security.
The b**tards!
Don't forget. . .
September 12, 2008 - 15:04 ET by WingletDriverthat those dastardly Republicans must also be preventing them from buying alcohol or getting speeding tickets.
the incidence of individual
September 12, 2008 - 11:24 ET by dscottthe incidence of individual vote fraud—voting when you aren't eligible—is virtually non-existent
Folks you missed the nuanced point being made by Alter, he parsed that phrase very specifically in order to distract from the real issue. It's groups who commit voter fraud, i.e. Democrat Political Machine, ACORN, etc. When individuals accept walking money to vote a under an proxy name, it's not personal, it's their civic duty to give a vicarious voice to the dead and future voters of America. So of course Democrats have to vote twice, once for themselves and once vicariously for the others. In the event there aren't enough to vote only twice, then vote as many times as needed so no one is disenfranchised. <sarcasm>
Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, starving the poor one gallon of ethanol at a time. Fill your tank with E85 and cull a village.
Democrat's Standard Play Book
September 12, 2008 - 07:35 ET by Kirk TurnerHere we go--the election is finally on. When the democrats begin deploying their standard playbook, you know it's the final stretch--and make no mistake, Alter is a democract strategist as are many if not all of the MSM. Next come these chestnuts: (1) the Republicans are trying to starve children, (2) kill older Americans, and (3) bring about a theocracy.
How dumb are democrats who have believed these groundless talking points for, at least, the last twenty-eight years despite reams of evidence to the contrary? How sad is it that the semi-intelligent dumb masses go running to the polls to vote democrat every four years in panic because of unsubstantiated assertions like those of Jonathan Alter and his ilk?
Every time I hear someone extoll the intelligence of the American people, I just have to laugh.
Why is it that the author thinks that blacks have no IDs?
September 12, 2008 - 07:50 ET by c5thenHe automatically assumes that Blacks are unproportionally ID-less in Indiana, Whay is that? Why does he maintian that the requirement to show proof of ID before voting will keep just Blacks from voting? Could he be implying that Blacks are the only 'group' that regularly commits voter fraud? I don't think so. So what is behind this specious argumnet.
Could he be using Blacks as a cover when he really means illegal aliens? That is the 'group' most likely not to have the required ID. Is it that he wants the illegaly present foreigners to have the ability to influence who is elected to public office? Ah... That makes more sense.
Here is the key point:
Illegal voting is apparently good for Democrats. Therefore it is in the interest of democrats to impede the enforcing of voting laws so as to help their supporters illegaly elect them.
Now I understand.
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.
Vote Fraud?
September 12, 2008 - 09:05 ET by Copperhead RidgeFrom time-to-time I have lunch in a small cafe' in a small Kentucky town with a retired "vote fixer." Surprise! He's a Democrat.
He's told me dozens of stories of how he and his cronies stuffed ballot boxes, distributed alcohol and "election day money" (they'd have bags full of five dollar bills), and how they connected with people willing to cast multiple votes (unions).
He told me he retired because of two things. First, poll workers started checking ID's more closely. Second, most county clerks went to an electronic, touch pad voting booth.
Kentucky is going back to a computer scan ballot and now people can just swear an oath that they are who they are without showing an ID.
My vote fixer friend told me that he's thinking about coming out of retirement. He's salivating over the changes.
corruption is the norm
September 12, 2008 - 13:23 ET by ZuccoZoidVote-fixing is the norm for Democrats, from Chicago to JFK to Tammany Hall. It is the only way they can win.
I am not "preaching to a choir" - Democrats work hand in glove with the mafia, communists and now Islamists to control nearly all aspects of government and other institutions with brute force, with the goal of creating [as John Edwards admitted] "Two Americas" - one for them, one for us.
Proper ID
September 12, 2008 - 10:04 ET by NorthCoasteronly disenfranchises liers and cheats. Ohio has restrictions and sends out a reminder card 2 monthes ahead of the election to remind voters what to bring.
It would be wonderful if a FREE ID CARD were available for anyone without a drivers license because then the proper papers could be taken to the Election Board for confirmation of eligibility.
NorthCoaster,
September 13, 2008 - 17:15 ET by Indiana JoeNot sure if you missed it, or just forgot the <sarc>, but free photo IDs are available here in Hoosierland. Then just take it to the polling place.
Just covering the bases.
"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall
Not again...!
September 12, 2008 - 12:31 ET by ZuccoZoid"Not only is this new-fangled discrimination constitutional, it's spreading...."
Please, not THIS argument again - the old James Byrd-black-churches-will-burn scare tactic.
Providing an ID to vote is now discrimination? Support ID's to vote? You're a Jim Crow racist!
Should we be cynical and say blacks vote Democrat no matter who's on
the ticket? Does Barry Hussein have a lock on the black vote simply
because he's black? Why not put O.J. Simpson on the Democrat ballot?
Blacks will vote the party line anyway.
A vote is still an individual right as a responsible citizen - anyone who can't even manage to acquire a driver's license shouldn't be given the opportunity to alter the political course of our nation, even by one vote.
Well, actually....
September 12, 2008 - 13:49 ET by Heather RadishThe (black) folks getting paid to vote multiple times in multiple precincts under fictional and other people's names? Darn right I'm trying to disenfranchise them. One warm body = one vote. Period.
Annnnd... they'reoff!
September 13, 2008 - 17:51 ET by Indiana JoeHere we go again, folks! Stupid coastal liberals moaning about how bigoted and myopic us fly-over folks are. (Btw, I just want to take a bow for Indiana pushing McCain ahead of Obama in the EC count today... for now, at least)
This has been a non-issue to everyone but the Democrats since this law was first proposed.
Normal person: "Uh, make people prove who they are before they vote? Yeah, that makes sense."
Dem pol: "Now hold on there! You're just trying to disenfranchise our little friends, our helpless little ones who don't have the means or the wherewithal to meet these heinous conditions! What's next, bring back the Poll Tax? Or an Intelligence Test? You are continuing to trample on the rights of these poor helpless, incompetent folks. They need a friend against all you picky racist reactionaries, but I'll be their friend. I will protect them. I will take this to the highest court in the land, and THAT will settle it!"
NP: "The Supreme Court upheld it."
Dem pol: "This ain't over!"
I just am flabbergasted that Dems can be so obviously condescending to blacks, even to the point of insulting their intelligence and ability, and still pull in about 90% of the black vote. What did Baba Wawa say the other day? "Us white folks will protect you???" No wonder they hate teaching true American history in schools. How many HS seniors, do you suppose, know that Lincoln was a Republican? How many know that the Party was founded on the anti-slavery principle? How many know that the KKK was a thoroughly Democrat organization? Sure, they know Jesse Helms was a "bigot," but how many know Robert Byrd was a "Grand Dragon," or whatever?
This has gotten so blatant, it's all going to come tumbling down around their ears. And it can't be soon enough for me.
"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall
IJ.. I absolutely
September 13, 2008 - 18:01 ET by bigtimerIJ..
I absolutely agree...like you say, look what the kids are intentionally taught or not taught...it is all an agenda as we know..the Dept. of Education needs to go back to the states...YESTERDAY! The power of the teachers union needs to be diminished swiftly if possible...which I know that is a dream.
Plus..it can't come down around their ears fast enough is right, but at least until the election, and for some days afterward, I am going to enjoy watching the slow burn.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Oh yeah!
September 13, 2008 - 18:27 ET by Indiana Joe"Do you smell that?"
"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall
Jonathan Alger and Racism
September 14, 2008 - 04:49 ET by holmesauthorLet's See!
Jonathan Alter's political leanings are with the party that began slavery, formed the Klu Klux Kan, enacted Jim Crow, and openly lynched blacks that tried to vote. The Republican Party was formed as the anit-slavery party.
Who is the rascist!
MSNBC anti-republican
September 14, 2008 - 06:06 ET by nicksmith112MSNBC anti-republican correspondent Alter already laying the groundwork for ..."Them Republicans stole another election!"
and the day after the election we will hear about the long lines at the polls or people didn't know where to go to vote screwed the "good guys" again.
I'm a refugee from the Democratic Party.
altered states
September 14, 2008 - 15:35 ET by sawing battathis dude is one of the reasons newsweek is a dying brand. he's over the top in an msdnc kind of way and trying to create news to fit his 'republicans are evil' theme, not honestly report on or analyze facts. His name if fitting for the tasks at hand...
Note to Newsweek mgmt: this flimsy, slanted reporting from one of your top names is of no real surprise anymore. Tell me, how are the financials of your company? Things going well? renewals and ad rates trending upwards are they? See any connection?
bigot
September 14, 2008 - 19:53 ET by paulnashtn"Republicans aren't bigots like the Jim Crow segregationists."
No they are not but you ARE --- you assume that most low-income blacks are too stupid to get a drivers liscense or state ID -- I work in the polls on election day and actually the ONLY trouble I have had in 5 years concerning IDs were 2 young white guys and 1 drunken white woman -- there have, of course, been many other problems but not IDs
VOTE REPUBLICAN