The crisis in Georgia is all Bush's fault, the Republicans offered America a soft-pedaled version of George Wallace's racism, and Obama-voting Southern Democrats are intelligent, defiant people living in occupied territory. I learned all that from just one Newsweek column.
I may have to watch "The View" to earn back some I.Q. points.
Yes, Christopher Dickey enlightened Newsweek readers on "The Defiant Ones," his August 14 Web exclusive, the subheader of which noted that:
The Russia-Georgia conflict is yet another example of why a leader caught up in the romance of resistance should not rely on Washington. What Saakashvili should have learned from history--and the American South.
According to Dickey, the real problem is America and its ally, Georgia, a partner in coalition forces in Iraq, not Vladimir Putin's Russia.
So where does the American South come in? Dickey's thread ran from the nation of Georgia to the Peach State by examining the psychology of defiance (emphasis mine):
After my recent travels through Tennessee, Georgia and the Carolinas to assess the impact of Barack Obama's candidacy on the old Confederacy, my NEWSWEEK colleague John Barry sent me a note about his days reporting on the presidential campaign of George Wallace, the former governor of Alabama, back in 1968. Wallace's race-baiting populism eventually was sanitized and absorbed into the Republican Party's successful "Southern strategy," but Wallace himself was much rougher and more honest in his opinions than his mainstream emulators. He knew that what attracted Southern voters to him was not so much what he stood for, but the many things he stood against. "You got to understand," he told Barry one day as he gazed at the statue of a Confederate soldier in his home town, "All we've had is defiance."
That's it, I thought. That is what Yale professor C. Vann Woodward was saying when he wrote in the 1960s that Southerners were different from other Americans precisely because a century before, in the 1860s, they became the only white people in the United States to be conquered and occupied. All they had left was their attachment to defiance, which lingered for generations and remains among some Southerners to this day.
Defiance has ever been the sustenance of the weak and defeated, the overpowered, the demeaned and the enslaved.
Those overpowered, demeaned and enslaved Southeners of 2008,we find out later, happen to be defiant Southern Democrats who shine like blazing blue beacons in a sea of Southern red (emphasis mine):
In the meantime, a hopeful sign, perhaps, could be another current of defiance I found among Southerners I met on my travels who were proudly living Blue in the Red States. My 82-year-old cousin, Jean Dickey White in Murphy, N.C., said she was raised voting for Democrats, her people had always fared better under them, and, even though it was hard to vote for someone who seemed as different from everyone she knew as Barack Obama, she was going to vote Democratic this time around, too. Jay Srymanske, 58, who runs river trips on the rapids of the Cartecay and what's left of the Coosawatee in north Georgia, says he's "a yellow dog Democrat," who'd just as soon vote for that yellow dog on the porch as for a Republican. When I went up to Kathryn Heath and Sarah George at a Starbucks in a posh suburb of Charlotte, N.C., they had books piled high in front of them, exchanging favorite titles. They said they were Obama supporters. I said I thought that might be the case somehow. "You mean because we read?" said Heath, a corporate leadership consultant.
But one of the most memorable moments came in Spartanburg, S.C., after eating dinner with John Lane and his wife, Betsy Teter, who are pillars of the town's art and culture scene and who dare to put magnetized OBAMA '08 stickers on their cars. It was late. We'd been talking to a young waitress whose boyfriend is dying of cancer, and we were all moved by what she had to say about the need for better health care. And then as Betsy walked toward her car, she said, "It's gone," and we all knew what she meant: the Obama sticker. "Happens all the time," she said. "Wait." She started looking around the parking lot as if she'd dropped her keys. And sure enough, about 20 yards away, there it was on the ground. Somebody had flung it away like a Frisbee. Betsy just put it back on her car, in her quiet way defying the old defiance of the South.
Correction: Earlier posting had references to the Baltic Sea, which have been corrected. Georgia is bordered by the Black Sea.
—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters





















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
a few quick points
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:08 ET by candanceFirst of all, the "posh suburbs" of Charlotte would pass for a middle class neighborhood up north, and secondly to imply that only literate people are voting for Obama only makes those women look like snobs.
There is nothing more ridiculous than southerners sitting around Charlotte, North Kakalacky acting like prissy Yankees.
Second, Dickey seems to be forgetting the detail that Wallace was a Democrat. Third, I find it awfully convenient that a vandal rips the sticker off a car at precisely the moment a journalist is dining with the owner.
And finally, I'm in the south right now, and I can assure you there is nothing "brave" or "scandalous" or "defiant" about being an Obama supporter. If Dickey really wanted to see defiance, let him go to downtown Memphis with a Ron Paul sticker.
This guy actually gets paid to write?
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:31 ET by SickofLibsWhat convoluted logic. If that was an essay in any 10th grade English class, it would get an D at best.
Coosawatee-Bush-Georgia-fried chicken-Wallace-sticker stealers-Confederates-Putin-neuron malfunction-neuron malfunction-neuron malfunction
Everything is Bush's Fault
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 16:59 ET by allanfDid you hear - John Edward's affair was all Bush's fault. (If Gore had one he'd have been VP you see).
Jeane Dickey White
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:39 ET by Cpickering"My 82-year-old cousin, Jean Dickey White in Murphy, N.C., said she was raised voting for Democrats, her people had always fared better under them, and, even though it was hard to vote for someone who seemed as different from everyone she knew as Barack Obama . . ."
I can't believe that Ms White had any more in common with Al Gore or John Kerry than she does with BHO!! She says she is a life-long Democrat.
Balderdash!
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:49 ET by sanergononlibSo the democrat inspired racisim displayed by Wallace was somehow morphed into a Republican strategy? Since the south was run by "yellow dog democrats" since about the beginning of time, it is always baffling to me how the south's historical racism is always associated with republicans. Robert Byrd, anyone?
Indeed. I think this
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:55 ET by JasonCIndeed. I think this phenomenon of transposing historical Southern racism into a Republican thing began in the mid-80s when many of Reagan's domestic policies were construed as racist. Somehow, in the minds of many people, that (mis?)conception retroactively revised 100+ years of Democratically-sanctioned, reconstruction-era racial violence.
"Issue-driven politics in red-and-blue America is like a man whose
appetite for steak is greatly enhanced by his contempt for vegetarians."
Come now...when isn't it
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 15:55 ET by bigtimerCome now...when isn't it President Bush's fault...I just wondered how long it was going to take with the msm...
...then again if you listen to the Washington Journal it has been his fault from minute one...they have some real whiz-bans that call in...and it's spooky these critters vote, let alone had any kind of an education.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Georgia is not in the Baltic region
Thu, 08/14/2008 - 23:13 ET by BinghamtonGeorgia is near the Black Sea area - not the Baltic. Otherwise, this was a good article!
Binghamton, you should know
Fri, 08/15/2008 - 09:03 ET by bassndudeBinghamton, you should know that Newsweek is rather short on reporting real facts. Their reporters are ignorant of history, not to mention geography. They make up their stories to fit their agenda.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
Georgia is on the Black Sea
Fri, 08/15/2008 - 11:26 ET by CTCarbon Credits Smoke'em if you got'em!
correction made.
Fri, 08/15/2008 - 17:22 ET by Ken Shepherdcorrection made.
And all these big thinkers are convinced the Texan is stupid.
Fri, 08/15/2008 - 02:18 ET by CTPutin's playing checkers and the cowboy is playing chess. Poland finally ok'd the Star War missile defense system and got U.S. Troops to man a new Patriot Air Defense System to boot. Think that would have happened in an Obama-Pelosi Administration? Not bloody likely. The Ukraine in NATO is next.