Christianity Today: ABC Spells Sloppy Reporting on Wheaton College

Photo of Ken Shepherd.
By Ken Shepherd | May 5, 2008 - 15:45 ET

This is a much more serious sin than the folly I noted earlier today from ABCNews.com coverage of a Bill Clinton visit to a "Pentacostal" church.

On May 1, Christianity Today's Sarah Pulliam took to her magazine's Liveblog to address ABCNews.com's numerous errors in reporting on a faculty matter at evangelical Wheaton College:

ABC's report of Wheaton College professor Kent Gramm's resignation was an example of sloppy journalism and weak analysis.

Screencap of ABCNews.com via ChristianityToday.com The original headline was simply false: "Professor Fired for Getting a Divorce." Gramm was not fired. He resigned because he declined to talk with the college about his divorce. (The image to the right is a screen shot of an earlier version)

Later today, ABC changed the headline to "Professor Loses Job Over Divorce." The headline is still not quite accurate. To lose your job generally indicates that someone took it away from you. However, Gramm voluntarily resigned. And according to the Chicago Tribune, the college offered him another year of employment while he searched for another job.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Also, student Emma Vanhoozer's name was misspelled. Most journalists are extremely careful about getting basic facts like these correct. But reporter Russell Goldman bypassed whatever fact-checking system ABC has set up, if they have one.

Not only are there factual errors, but Goldman imposes his own strange analysis on the situation.

"If the school is free to impose its beliefs on divorced family members where does the law draw the line? Could the school just as easily impose arranged marriages?" Goldman writes.

Yes, that's the big looming threat here: forcibly arranged marriages. Someone has been reading too much coverage of the raid on the polygamist sect's ranch in Texas.

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

what????

How on earth did he make a leap from questioning divorce to arranging marriages?

Oh, wait, I keep forgetting...since Christianity is such a popular and controlling force in America, it's fair game for criticism, and no need to fact check because those dumb evangelicals don't matter.

*rolls eyes*

No suprise here. When was

No suprise here. When was the last time a reporter was familiar with the subject they were writing about? Their job is to impart their personal feelings into a story, and hope nobody is smart enough to see it.

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

and never ever

let the facts get in the way of  getting "the message" out! 

Question: Why did he have

Question: Why did he have to talk to the college about his divorce? And what were his options if he didn't resign? I'd imagine it was getting fired.

And I'd imagine that, if

And I'd imagine that, if that were the case, he was aware of the policy when he took the job. He should have fought it then.

Lots of questions here, mb.

Lots of questions here, mb. IF there's a stipulation in his contract that says conditions surrounding a divorce are to be discussed, then the teacher screwed up. But if he said, "Nope, not gonna talk about it." and the school said "Talk about it or get fired, or you can resign," that's another thing.

Lots of questions.

If you follow the link to

If you follow the link to Christianity Today's original story you find this:

Wheaton’s faculty handbook states that the college will consider
employee retention “when there is reasonable evidence that the
circumstances that led to the final dissolution of the marriage related
to desertion or adultery on the part of the other partner."

 



Is the question...

...what led to the story, or the reporting of the story itself. I didn't realize NB had become such a thinktank.

The story was from May 1. I

The story was from May 1. I hadn't noticed it til May 5, but thought I'd note it since it was a semi-major story on the news nets last week and because Pulliam had something to offer that I thought our audience was not aware of.

divorce

The college's policy is to accept divorce only in acceptable perimeters of adultery or abuse. Pretty standard stuff for any Christian school or private company. Even so, just because he got a divorce does not automatically mean he'd get fired.

Here's one we might see:

ABC Fires Reporter for Insisting on Accuracy

Isn't that what happened to

Isn't that what happened to Brit Hume?