Rock the Vote Backs Fight Against Indiana Voter ID Law

Photo of Ken Shepherd.
By Ken Shepherd | January 21, 2008 - 17:58 ET

Update/Clarification (Jan. 24): Ocean MacAdams of MTV News responds (see bottom of post)

Politico's Ben Adler has a story today about Rock the Vote submitting a friend-of-the-court brief in favor of overturning a law requiring voters furnish photo identification before casting a ballot:

Opponents of Indiana’s law requiring voter identification at the polls usually argue it places an unfair burden on the poor, the elderly, minorities, inner-city residents and the disabled.

But some activists predict another group will be affected in November: young people and college students.

A coalition of youth groups including Rock the Vote and the National Black Law Students Association filed an amicus brief to the Indiana state Democratic Party lawsuit urging the Supreme Court to find the law unconstitutional.

“The Indiana case has far-reaching consequences for students and other young people who move frequently, making current ID hard to come by, or who do not possess a driver's license,” wrote Alexandra Acker, executive director of the Young Democrats of America.

“It’s not something that at face value people think is overtly discriminatory,” says Matthew Segal, founder of the Student Association for Voter Empowerment, which also signed the amicus brief, and a senior at Kenyon College in Gambier, Ohio. “They don’t understand the millions of Americans who are poor and don’t have a driver's license.”

Maybe I'm missing something here, but the proliferation of American college kids with fake IDs shows me that your average person in your Rock the Vote demographic isn't exactly hurting for the cash to pay for a real driver's license or state-issued photo ID.

Rock the Vote (RtV) has long maintained its youth-oriented voter drive is unconcerned with whom MTV viewers vote, but that they engage themselves in the political process. It may be strictly non-partisan, but the voter registration drive is hardly non-ideological and no longer confines itself to merely registering new voters.

In 2005, for instance, RtV campaigned against partial privatization of Social Security.

By filing a brief in support of a Democratic lawsuit aimed at striking photo ID requirements, RtV shows a disregard for its ostensible non-partisan mission, as well as disrespect for conservative and Republican MTV viewers who care about guarding the electoral process from abuse by voter fraud.

Update/Clarification (Jan. 24 | 11:49): I received the following from Ocean MacAdams, senior vice president of MTV News:

I'm a fan of your site, but have never had reason to email until today. While I'm sure you have had and will continue to have issues with MTV that don’t concern, "Rock The Vote," I would like to make sure that you know that MTV and Rock The Vote are two separate organizations. We have worked together in the past, especially in the late 90's, on some projects but we really don’t do much, if anything together any more. I think some senior MTV/Viacom folks may be on the board (although I'm not even sure about that anymore), but we really have little to do with them. We've didn't do anything with them in '02 or '04 and have done nothing with them this cycle. It certainly won't be the last time someone makes this mistake, but it drives me to distraction every time I see it.

MacAdams's objections are noted and I do apologize for failing to note the distinction between MTV and the Rock the Vote project.

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Name a College that doesn't issue Photo ID's

Duuude....All College kids have College/Univ. photo ID's.

Not a problem. 

 

"Barack Obama is a Powerful Speaker—And so is My Bose Bass Amp"  Doug Giles

True, although I don't think

True, although I don't think they may constitute valid ID for age verification and address verification under Indiana law.

But like I said, if you can spend $50-100 or more for a fake ID to score booze, you can spend $30 or more for a state-issued identification card which anyone can get from the nearest DMV.

HERE IN INDIANA

The I.D Cards are free of charge to ANYBODY that needs one and can't afford one. 

 

 

MTV just another leftist arm

MTV just another leftist arm of the networks working for the leftist party...it takes a village after-all to cheat early and cheat often.

Here's a thought

“They don’t understand the millions of Americans who are poor and don’t have a driver's license.”

If this is the real objection, then they should be lobbying the state government to make some form of alternate photo ID available to adults who cannot afford, or do not possess, a driver's license.

Shouldn't the greater concern be the integrity of elections, or is that a dumb question?

 

ALREADY DONE

FREE I.D. CARD FROM THE BMV IN INDIANA FOR ANYONE THAT NEEDS IT.

MSM doesn't mention that much, it doesn't help their case.

M-indless-TV

Don't have an ID, or can't find it? How do these people buy their booze or pick up their pharms? 

This is a ruse. Their aim to

This is a ruse. Their aim to facilitate voter fraud, they WANT illegals and dead people to vote for them. Plain & simple.

Too poor?

What are these Indiana drivers licenses made from? Gold? Diamond? Its less than 20 dollars where I am at.

Why does mtv still claim to be music television. It should be LWBTV, Little Whiny Bitch Television.

And besides, most of these "voters" that LWBTV is trying to help will probably end up getting stoned and forget to vote, or not know that voting day is on a Tuesday, ya know being college kids and all, not the brightest group out there.


What doesn’t kill you, only makes you pissed off. -Children of Bodom  

Don't blame them, they're

Don't blame them, they're just trying to recruit new Democrats. ;) ;)

(signature):
You know, people ask me what I like to watch on TV, and I always tell
them that I simply don't watch TV. And I really don't, because TV is a
easy way for others to manipulate how you think. And I would rather not
put up wi

Rock the Vote?!

I thought it was "Rig the Vote"!

MTV

MTV should not be allowed to abbreviate their name for "music" television... they should rename it "liberal TV" or "Lets-shove-gays-down-the-young-peoples-throats TV" or "Money-is-the-only-thing-that-can-make-you-happy TV".  I only watch for the videos or one reality show... and you really don't even get that many videos.  

 

Other than their main station they also run Nickelodeon... has anyone actually watched cartoons nowadays that are meant for young kids?  They have gay characters in these shows.  Trust me, watch it for yourself.  The liberal machine is not only trying to indoctrinate the young voters, which I am one of them, but also our kindergarteners and grades upwards. 

If you don't stand behind our troops; please feel free to stand in front of them!

Ok i ma a dad of an 8 and 4

Ok i ma a dad of an 8 and 4 year old boy and I know "Nicktoons" very well ( I love The Fairly Odd Parents.......I line from that show got me the mom says to the judges of a best garden contest "Thier gonna jusgd my yams....I have great yams!!!" )

 

anyway which cartoon is gay,  

 

 

"Get off the phone you big dope!!!!!!!!!!" Mark Levin

MTV viewers may be the stupidest ever

No, this isn't about those kids and their danged rock 'n' roll.

Remember that Rock the Vote also tried to scare the youngsters into voting against Bush because even though there wasn't a draft, THERE COULD BE.

http://www.dinocrat....

What a dishonest partisan sham.

Rock the Vote

Has MTV also come out against photo ids for admission to bars?

You have to have some id to

You have to have some id to register for college, and then you get one from the college you attend.

You have to have id to cash a check, SS, disability, welfare.

But too much to have one to vote? Hmmmm.

This reminds me of Mr 78 (LBJ who stole the '48 senate election from Coke S). It's about voter fraud. Democrats can't sell their socialist plans to the US, so they have to import votes.

 

If voter ID is required,

If voter ID is required, the democrats can't cart their "designated" voters from precinct to precinct to vote in place of all the the dead people who haven't been removed from the rosters yet.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Oh, and did you get the

Oh, and did you get the profile of the plaintiff in this case Mr Shepherd?

Guarantee the MSM will not detail her circumstances.

 

 

Here in Chicago the line is

Here in Chicago the line is "Vote Early ..Vote Often"

thats Daley Sr. got the mayor spot, and his son has been mayor for 20 years........

 

"Get off the phone you big dope!!!!!!!!!!" Mark Levin