Religion Blog: NYT Reviewer Didn't Bother to Do Homework on 'Veggie Tales'

Photo of Ken Shepherd.
  • Bookmark and Share

A new "Veggie Tales" movie is hitting the silver screen and, as may well be expected, the New York Times doesn't like it much.

That's not so surprising coming from the hallowed pages of the broadsheet bible of the secular left. But as Jeffrey Weiss of the Dallas Morning News's Religion Blog notes, it appears the hostile NYT reviewer is wholly unfamiliar with the Veggie Tales franchise and so may hardly have been the best reviewer for the assignment in the first place:

The New York Times has a bad review today of the new VeggieTales film, "The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything." It's a bad review, in the sense that it slams the movie. But it's also a badly written review in that it seems to be written by someone who has never heard of or seen any of the VeggieTales previous cartoons or movies. Here's the top of the review, by Neil Genzlinger:

You don’t have to go far into the press material for “The Pirates Who Don’t Do Anything: A VeggieTales Movie” before you hit the phrase “faith-and-values-based property.” It is used to describe this and earlier offerings from the VeggieTales franchise, but the “faith” component of this rather ordinary film for children doesn’t make itself readily apparent.

I suppose there is some value in offering a review for people who don't know about the previous work. But like the Simpsons, LOTR, Compass, Spider-Man etc etc films, VeggieTales comes with an automatic audience who understands the context and knows the characters. And for whom this review will seem curious at best.

Here's the link.

Update (17:32): By contrast, reviewer Kevin Crust with the L.A. Times had a very different take on the children's flick, finding it an entertaining spoof with a "worthwhile message."

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

My children and I love the

My children and I love the Veggie Tales.  They are well done with a great message of morality and faith.  They are also very funny. 

The NYT actually getting it is like asking Stevie Wonder to spot the eagle in the sky.  Not going to happen.

Gee an editor and a reporter commenting on something

Gee an editor and a reporter commenting on something they have never heard of, read, or know anything about.....

Sounds almost like the featured bloggers on HuffPo.

 

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

They review children's

They review children's movies?! WHY would someone waste their time doing that? Children don't care about plot integrity, the cinematography, or the artisticness (is that even a word?)...they just want to be entertained.

Parents will take their kids to this BECAUSE it is a VeggieTales film...and kids will want to see it for the same reason. I let my kids watch the VeggieTales because it is wholesome entertainment that they enjoy.

But really, reviewing a children's movie of this type is kind of a waste of time.

I was happy to...

...Read the reviews of Golden Compass. Knowing the sort of tripe it was saved me some hard-earned dough, and helped me to make a statement that that sort of thing isn't welcome in my sphere of influence.

Does anyone know how it fared at the box office?

 

 

Looks like about 61

Looks like about 61 million, well below I'm sure what they hoped for. Reviews were pretty one-sided that this movie wasn't that good, a little too intense for young kids, and not good enough to entertain adults.

The Golden Compass wasn't

The Golden Compass wasn't focused solely on children like VeggieTales is.

Reviewing something intended to suit the tastes of young children is like reviewing a Muppet Movie, kind of an excercise in futility. I go in to any and all kid's movies expecting to not to see a great work, but I know that my kids will be entertained (or sit quiet or even sleep for 1.5 hours) and that is worth every cent of the ticket price.

I like 3-2-1 Penguins

I like 3-2-1 Penguins better, but some of the Vegitale work is pretty funny.  The Vegi books are really good too.

taking the family to see it

taking the family to see it tomorrow.

We will have to rent it, but

We will have to rent it, but we will.  Closest theater that is playing is 40 miles away.

One Little Clue

Allow me to give the NYT one small clue here: the Veggie Tales predate Disney's Jack Sparrow and the pirates who don't do anything have been around for years. I remember watching them in the movie about Jonah back in 02.

This is truly like a movie critic stumbling on Superman Returns and saying "wow this guy kinda sounds like Spiderman."