Editor & Publisher has a tally of presidential endorsements by college newspapers that puts the count at 63-1 in favor of Democrat Barack Obama. The only paper to endorse Republican John McCain: the Daily Mississippian at the University of Missippi.
On the one hand, the overwhelming pro-Obama majority tracks with the long-running media narrative that Obama is king among young voters. If even young people who have no votes are going for Obama, then it makes perfect sense that college papers are going publicly for the candidate Oprah Winfrey dubbed "The One."
On the other hand, are we really supposed to believe that there are only 64 daily and weekly college papers in a country that has 50 states?
The first thing I noticed about Editor & Publisher's list is that it includes the newspapers of both West Virginia University (my alma mater) and Marshall University at the other end of my home state. Two college papers from one of the smallest states in the union, and we're supposed to believe this is a fair sampling of American academia?
In the big media scheme of things, it doesn't matter much which way college papers break in a presidential election. Political endorsements by major metropolitan dailies carry little weight today, if they ever did, so endorsements by obscure college papers pack no punch at all.
That's especially true when polling indicates that the much-vaunted youth vote of 2008 probably won't be much greater than it was in 2004 or any other presidential year.
But it's not too much to ask that Editor & Publisher broaden its intellectual horizons beyond the likes of The Crimson at Harvard University, the Columbia Daily Spectator, the Daily Northwestern and the Daily Californian in Berkeley in order to offer some balance in its reporting of college endorsements.
There are plenty of conservative academic institutions in this country, and they have newspapers, too. Odds are good that they're not backing Obama.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
So, Hillsdale College
November 1, 2008 - 22:20 ET by Scout FinchAnd Hope College, both conservative and well-known colleges here in Michigan, endorsed for Obama?
Ah, I don't think so. Biased reporting. Using only the "facts" that fit the template.
63-2
November 1, 2008 - 22:28 ET by delmarThe Weekly Murmur at Delmar's College of Political Knowledge has just endorsed Senator McCain.
63-4
November 2, 2008 - 10:14 ET by ThisnThatOklahoma State has a strong "McCain is going to win" endorsement in it's 31 October version.
And check out this opinion from the University of Houston, 24 October.
But the real point is the intimidation factor on the majority of U.S. campuses today. How many stories have we heard of campus communists destroying copies of any conservative publication (Bucknell Mar 2008, Georgia Guarddog, Oct 2006, Brown Mar 2008, University of MN Deluth Feb 2007? And harrassing the newroom staff (here, here, and here)? Just like the "fairness" doctrine, liberals can't compete on ideas alone -- they have to be backed up by muscle, with protection from trial lawyers to win.
___________________________________
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber
Yay!
November 1, 2008 - 22:34 ET by Saint ZeroGo Rebs!
I doubt Miss. State went Obama, either.
Zero, it was hard to
November 2, 2008 - 10:25 ET by ThisnThatZero, it was hard to determine just by looking at their recent opinion pieces. However, there was a "student vote for Obama" election, of sorts. Here's the gist:
Just look at the sponsors -- and tell me, if you're a conservative on campus, and you saw these sponsors -- would you even bother? And yet, THE WINNER IS ---- duh!
___________________________________
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber
}:- Horns comin' back
November 1, 2008 - 22:38 ET by Cool ArrowTech still holding on, but here come the Longhorns
It slipped my beer goggles mind
November 1, 2008 - 23:15 ET by sccSuzy C. After I had a couple beers, I sat done to read the gossip in my college rag. I got so engrossed in the gossip that I realized that the polls had closed.
Sorry Dude Obama !!!!!!
The word "King" kinda says
November 1, 2008 - 23:18 ET by Clear thinkerThe word "King" kinda says it all.
Obama’s Civilian National Security Force
Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/
Many problems re: youth vote & college newspaper endorsements
November 1, 2008 - 23:26 ET by Alfred J. LemireSo many unasked and thus unanswered questions make evaluations of the "youth vote" difficult. How many of the likely voters are still in schools, colleges, and universities? How many are blacks? Those whoa re still in schools are subject to almost surely intense propaganda from faculties. I have visited a well-known Ivy college during an election season and was struck at the uniformly leftist cast of visiting speakers and pro-Democrat signs and posters on office walls. Once, when I was in Carlisle, Pa., for a backpackers' meeting, the high school classrooms where we met had only Clinton-Gore signs. Dole-Kemp? Nowhere to be seen.
The incentive for blacks to vote is obvious. Catholics had a similar incentive in 1960, but media propaganda pushing them to vote for JFK on that basis was notable by its absence. This time, the propaganda for people to vote for Obama because he is black (or apparently so, since he is mixed-race) is intense. An AP story telling that one-third of white Democrats were less likely to vote for Obama for racial reasons. The survey questions, which the AP made available, showed that negatives applied to blacks did not apply to Obama himself. E.g., judgments that blacks were lazy, violent, and irresponsible could not apply to Obama. (Oddly, the survey never asked respondents whether such terms applied to Obama.)
Further, AP writers ignored another question, which showed that, of all respondents, 6% were less likely to vote for Obama for racial reasons, 6% were more likely, and 82% did not care. So the story and a "model" showing that Obama was set to lose 6% of voters for racial reasons amounted to propaganda, not fair analysis of the facts in the AP's own survey. As should be obvious to anyone with eyes, countervailing forces will push many voters to prefer Obama. Understandable, no doubt, but the existence of those pressures ought to be reported.
As to the endorsements, one has to wonder whether it is suitable for newspapers in educational establishments, many of them recipients of federal and state funds, directly or indirectly, should be in the endorsement business. People do not choose to buy the newspapers. Colleges do not sponsor competing newspapers, to the best of my knowledge. A few educational institutions may be free of government funding entanglements, but one wonders whether any one of the endorsing newspapers is associated with such a university.
But the press has behaved with shocking corruption in this election cycle; one can expect lots more corruption elsewhere in our society. The schools, colleges, and universities will continue. As to the news media, one ought to remind them of the proof of their corrupt coverage of this election. The U.S. fourth estate has damaged its credibility irreparably. Only massive reform, starting in the colleges and ending in the news media, can restore the trust of most Americans, a reform that will not occur.
Have you ever heard of NPR, Al?
November 1, 2008 - 23:43 ET by Scout FinchAs to the endorsements, one has to wonder whether it is suitable for
newspapers in educational establishments, many of them recipients of
federal and state funds, directly or indirectly, should be in the
endorsement business.
At least one college isn't represented
November 2, 2008 - 00:41 ET by cr_uvaMy alma mater, the University of Virginia, is not among these schools. However, it is not unusual for the Cavalier Daily, UVa's primary school paper, to not endorse someone before Election Day. It will add its endorsement on Election Day, but there is not much hope there. Knowing many of the writers there of the past, it seems likely that the vote will go at least to 64-1.
My college newspaper, The
November 2, 2008 - 01:16 ET by Damian GMy college newspaper, The Delphian, posted the cases for both candidates, since, as the only student periodical on campus, it would be inappropriate to endorse someone without a counterargument.
Also, I wrote the McCain side.
When I look back at how
November 2, 2008 - 01:19 ET by mostlymoderateWhen I look back at how stupid I was in college, how wrong I was about mostly everything, how irresponsible, ignorant and undisciplined I was back then, it is no surprise that many college kids will vote for Hussein.
The Rocky Mountain
November 2, 2008 - 02:39 ET by wiwfThe Rocky Mountain Collegian should be there too, given all the horrendous editorials they put out slamming McCain with their ageism, racism, and sexism.
The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy
Bethune Cookman
November 2, 2008 - 08:34 ET by KarlaI found it interesting our local channel(WFTV of Barbara West fame or infamy depending) reported last week that the students at Bethune Cookman had a march to the polls day where 3,000 students marched and others were bussed to the polls so they would not have to wait online in order to vote. I believe they had the day off to vote???????
While I love that young people and all people are involved this election I wonder????
Even with early voting you cannot help but wonder if they are voting early because when they see the lines as 1st time voters they are unaware that on Election day there will be about 6,000 polling places open and therefore no or fewer lines.
School papers
November 2, 2008 - 21:38 ET by UnsaneWhile I attended a fairly conservative campus for my bachelor's, the one I am at now has a student body that worships either Obama or Ron Paul as Shahinshah. I seriously doubt that the school paper of the school that I attend, that recently featured a column that blasted the United States as "fascist" (oh, what a surprise), will endorse anyone other than Obama for Shahinshah.
I can't say I am terribly surprised by this. Yes, I know that there are more than 64 colleges and universities in the United States. But let's face it: most, if not all, are hopelessly beholden to Leftist ideology.
Whoever casts a vote for Obama-Biden is nothing more than a common thief. Whoever fails to vote against them is nothing more than a moral coward.