Whoopi Goldberg: McCain 'Pulling Out Garbage'

Photo of Justin McCarthy.

With the McCain campaign’s new offensive on Barack Obama and his ties with William Ayers, "View" co-host Whoopi Goldberg, on the October 6 edition, suggested McCain is playing this card out of desperation and using the same failed tactics of Hillary Clinton.

Discussing Ayers, Whoopi "assume[d] that he rehabilitated himself." When Elisabeth Hasselbeck, outnumbered three to one, reminded that panel that Ayers expressed regret in 2001 that he had not done more, Sherri Shepherd wagged her finger in Elisabeth’s face lecturing "no you don’t Elisabeth." Shepherd retorted that Ayers’ remarks were not about September 11, something already known, but do they make Ayers’ lack of remorse any more defensible?

Barbara Walters, for her part, called such campaign tactics "smears" even as Elisabeth asserted that they are not smears, but true. Walters, also added that attacks on McCain’s involvement in the Keating Five scandal was a smear as well and such attacks distract us for the many challenges the United States faces.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The transcript follows.

GOLDBERG: Both campaigns have gone on the attack now. Palin has been accusing Obama of paling around with terrorists. And Obama’s accusing McCain of being involved with the Keating Five Savings and Loan scandal. Any thoughts?

WALTERS: Well, two things. The whole business about the terrorists is the relationship with-

HASSELBECK: William Ayers.

WALTERS: Which was-

HASSELBECK: Of the Weather Underground.

WALTERS: -years ago.

GOLDBERG: Forty years ago.

WALTERS: He was friendly with this man who’s life has changed. All of this was brought up during the Democratic campaign. There was, you know, there was, now it’s being rehashed and rehashed. We did it. It was discussed. That was in the past. His life has changed.

HASSELBECK: Why doesn’t it matter though?

WALTERS: Because we didn’t-

HASSELBECK: Just because it’s in the past, doesn’t- 9/11 is in the past. It’s still important.

WALTERS: Alright let me go on. I don’t also think there’s a reason to bring up the Keating Five, which is the other side. In case you don’t remember, Keating Five were five United States senators, one of whom was John McCain who was accused of corruption in 1989 igniting, it was a major political scandal having to do with the Savings and Loan. And they were accused of, I’m quoting, "improperly intervening on behalf of Charles Keating, et cetera. Now we can bring that up and dump that on John McCain now. Let’s discuss the economy for heaven’s sakes. Let’s discuss health care. Let’s discuss insurance for kids. Let’s not drag up just to discredit people on either side. [applause] There are much more important issues.

GOLDBERG: Here’s, here’s the other thing also. I mean, one of the things that, that no one has talked about is that, number one, Bill Ayers surrendered in 1980 to the federal government. He turned himself in to the feds. He, like a lot of us in a certain generation were pissed at the United States of America. Some were more radical than others. Some, some did stuff that, you know, they shouldn’t have done. And, you know, he turned himself in. He, I assume, rehabilitated himself because from 1980 to now, I don’t recall anyone saying in 2001, "oh we got to go get Bill Ayers. He’s a terrorist." I- wait no- let me just finish-

HASSELBECK: Sure, sure.

GOLDBERG: -because I know you have a lot to say. [laughter] I don’t think anyone has been looking at him as a terrorist until now. When someone’s past is in- we talked about this a little bit, so maybe yours wasn’t- maybe it was Bill. You know, there are senators and congressmen that had pasts. And at some point you have to say "forty years ago this is what you did. What are you doing now?" Because otherwise you have to say that the parents of the kids who are in his classes and the school itself and all of the faculty are carousing with the terrorists.

HASSELBECK: You know what? This terrorist-

GOLDBERG: And I don’t believe- I’m sorry- I don’t believe that, that is any better than John McCain being, having to rake over John McCain over-

WALTERS: 17 years ago.

GOLDBERG: 17 years ago. And the other thing, wait, let me just finish. And Barack Obama is not the terrorist. Let’s make sure that we’re clear [applause] that Barack Obama is not the terrorist. So linking him to people and link- we can link all of these guys to people. That’s- I’m done.

HASSELBECK: Okay, two things, one John McLean- John McCain was cleared of any charges. The ethics commission declared him- his actions cleared and his actions not improper. Number two, in terms of- and I wish Sarah Palin would come out specifically-

WALTERS: He was accused of it.

SHEPHERD: He used poor judgment.

HASSELBECK: They also found his actions were not improper.

WALTERS: He used poor judgment. It was lobbying.

HASSELBECK: Sure, but don’t you-

WALTERS: Keep in mind that both of them- can’t we get away from smears?

HASSELBECK: No, because some of these things are not-

WALTERS: Why no? Why no?

HASSELBECK: This is not about smearing. John McCain-

GOLDBERG: You don’t understand. You don’t understand.

HASSELBECK: John McCain has-

GOLDBERG: You can’t get away from smears.

HASSELBECK: I don’t believe that this is a smear. John McCain has been open about what happened with the Keating Five. And he was cleared. Number two, Barack Obama went to a party with William Ayers. And I wish Sarah Palin, when she addresses the crowds, would get specific and say not "my opponent," not "our opponent," and not "a terrorist." Barack Obama went to the house of William Ayers-

GOLDBERG: Yeah.

HASSELBECK: -who is a U.S. terrorist-

GOLDBERG: In 2002.

HASSELBECK: It doesn’t matter.

GOLDBERG: Oh my God!

HASSELBECK: After 9/11, William Ayers said he was unrepentant about his bombings and said that he wishes that he had done more.

SHEPHERD: No, no, wait, wait, no you don’t Elisabeth. When he made his comment it was about his book. It was not about 9/11. That book was about to come out. It was 40 years ago, when Obama was eight, there was a rabbi that was-

HASSELBECK: I don’t care-

WALTERS: Can I just ask you a question? You said you don’t care whether or how long, or he was friendly with him-

HASSELBECK: He has a history of this.

WALTERS: Well wait, wait, wait. Doesn’t it bother you, with everything that’s going wrong with this country, that either side is going back to smearing? Is that the way-

HASSELBECK: It’s the truth.

SHEPHERD: But Elisabeth-

GOLDBERG: The man is losing. The man is losing and he’s pulling out garbage that didn’t work for Clinton. It’s not going to work for him.

[applause]

HASSELBECK: It doesn’t matter Whoopi. Here’s the thing. This is not about winning or losing. This is what bothers me truly about Barack Obama because when I heard him back, I really thought there was hope for him. It bothers me that he’s not open. Whether you agree with Sarah Palin or not, she’s open-

SHEPHERD: Why do you say he’s not open? He did-

HASSELBECK: He used to hide, he used to hide all of his radical connections-

GOLDBERG: You know what? That’s bullshi- oh!

HASSELBECK: He obviously does not want to address.

WALTERS: He has addressed it.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hasselbeck an Angel

Right next to the abuse Sarah Palin has suffered since being named McCains running mate, comes the abuse Elizabeth Hasselback has to endure on a daily basis from a hoard of liberal bigmouths who talk out of their asses.

 I couldn't imagine having to face the likes of Rosie O'Donnell, Baa Baa WaWa, or Whoopie Goldberg every day.

Elizabeth, for what you do for the conservative cause, I salute you. There will indeed be a special place for you in Heaven.

Woopi, racist pig?

Woopi dear,

I went to see "The Color Purple". You were wonderful. Where did all that "wonderful" go? Are you another racist pig now?

And if you should read this Woopi, I took my liberal, Democrat, black friend to Paris, France with us. I am not a racist, I think you are!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (I am center, right-leaning.)

 

Yeah, but they never let her

Yeah, but they never let her finish a sentence. They declare that they don't want to "smear" anyone, and they won't LET Elizabeth make her point about Ayers, but Barbara is given free reign to expound upon the Keating 5 without being interrupted. It is pathetic. Wake up people!

conservative icons

Obama

It's out there. Good. This guy Barry is a threat to the nation. He's a left-wing radical. He and his "associates" want radical "change" for America. What do you suppose that "change" will entail? Now let Americans decide. If they want him, they've got him. If he's elected, God forbid, buyer's remorse will set in quickly. The question will then be if it is too late. Tell your "liberal" friends, however, not to be shocked at what Obama does. Caveat emptor. 

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

yea told some lefty friends of mine

If you want that marxist you can have him.... one guy then proceeds to tell me that capitalism doesnt work that we are going the way of the rest of the world, we will become socialist because it works ....I said where does it work?  I said if in fact there is somewhere that it does work its only because they dont have to defend themselves because we do that for them, that if it wasnt for us in the 40's thru the 80's that the Soviets would have just rolled over their countries.  He then goes into this diatribe that the rich dont pay their share ....that as Biden said its "patriotic to pay taxes" but when I pressed him by saying your a business man you should keep what you have earned he says of course he takes advantage of all the loop holes so that he can to reduce his tax burden .. by this time I am so dizzy and confused ... but I left the conversation smiling because my friend has no idea what awaits him and his business in the wonderful socialist world that he yearns for

 

Dark, Ask your friend

Dark,

Ask your friend this.... If he went out to dinner with 19 of his friends, and the bill came to $1,000, and ONE person paid $560 of the bill, ask him if he has the unmitigated gall to tell that person he is not paying his fair share.

The top 5% of wage earners pay 56% of all federal income taxes.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

yea i know

I am an artist and I used to manage bands so I am surrounded by liberals and very left thinking folks which is OK they are my friends and I have long believed if I only hung around those who thought like I do I would be one lonely guy.  I seldom talk politics with these friends ( I used to all the time) it just wont accomplish anything  They think I am crazy, they know my beliefs.... they cant understand by worldview because they havent allowed themselves to be open they still belive what they belived when they were young adults 20 to 30 years ago... I on the other hand understand them perfectly well because I used to think just like they do ....they either will figure things out or they wont and I really dont care .. they see the world how they wish it was I see the world as it really is

Iveseenitall: "If he's

Iveseenitall:

"If he's elected, God forbid, buyer's remorse will set in quickly"

Never happen. The left has a ready list of excuses and ways to pass the blame to someone else, and a complicit media to back them up. Haven't you noticed how Dodd, Frank, ACORN, and Obama himself have been easily able to deflect the blame for the disastrous outcome of forcing banks to make risky mortgages, to "failed Bush policies", John McCain, the republicans, capitalism, Phil Gramm, deregulation, etc ad nauseum?

Once Obama gets in office, first thing that happens is the "Fairness Doctrine" and similar measures aimed at rightwing internet blogs, already promised by Pelosi, will choke off the only two effective means of organizing and communicating that conservatives have. Once they have re-established full control over all the opinion making machinery (they already have the schools, universities, MSM and entertainment industry), you will see the indoctrination in full force. Left wing government initiatives will be reported in the press as working sensationally under the guidance of the Supreme Leader, or if they fail, it will all be the fault of the fascisti opposition, or because they just need to spend lots more money, or because the last vestiges of the greedy capitalist roaders need to be more thoroughly eradicated. Any remaining pockets of resistance will be subjected to intimidation, threats of violence, and occasional actual violence that can't easily be traced back to the ruling party.

These are the tactics of communists. 

It worked in the Soviet Union for seventy years, still works in North Korea, Cuba and China for the last 50+ years, and for shorter periods of time in Zimbabwe and Venezuela.

Obama's father - self-described communist

Obama's teenage mentor, Frank Marshall Davis - card carrying member of the Communist party

Ayers and Dohrn - self-identified communists still

Saul Alinsky - self described communist and inventor of "community organizing" in the 1960's, for the purpose of overthrowing the country, whose works were used as the textbook by Obama to train new radicals for ACORN, a primary cause of the current finacial meltdowm 

Unfortunately, the left has pre-emptively demonized anyone against communism as "McCarthyites", and the media will back them up on that as well. Watch for those smears to begin in mere days, now that McCain has finally grown a pair.

I personnally thought that when the Berlin Wall came down we were done with that hateful ideology, but it had already transferredd itself to the university faculties here in the US 50 years before that and has been self-sustaining ever since. There for the last 70 years it has been festering, gradually building its power base, turning out tons of indoctrinated followers, polluting the academic and political discourse, and now has a sympathizer in line to be POTUS.

Even if he is really not at all a believer in communism per se, Obama would be termed a "useful idiot" in the old USSR.

The focus of criticism has been deftly diverted these last two years to a strawman, that Obama is a Muslim sympathizer, a charge easily (so far) refuted. The real concern should have been the worldview and philosophy that he has been immersed in his entire life - communism.

 

 

 

 

geokster

I agree with all you've said. That's why I believe we will have buyer's remorse, particularly because we may not be able to do anything about it. I'm an old-timer and there is absolutely no question in my mind that Obama is a communist. Communism is at the heart of Black Liberation Theology and other doctrines in which he is steeped. It looks like the American people have been fooled because we took our eye off the ball after Ronald Reagan. Moreover, the American press are complicit in this, as history will prove when we look back at the downfall of a nation. Sad.

P.S. If Barry gets elected, we are looking a Democrat/Socialist/Communist rule for a long long time to come.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

It's hard not to pull out

It's hard not to pull out garbage when talking about Obama and his slimy Leftist pals.

WHOOPI IS GARBAGE

THE PHEW STINKS SO BAD. These are some of the most classless AND STUPID broads that TV has ever seen.

Now is not the time for doubt. Boycott these sleezballs at ABC and the rest of the alphabet soup gang mafia that is the liberal media.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAYNeO_JNz4

 

FIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Mr.L

Umm..WaWa...no he has not

Umm..WaWa...no he has not addressed it, the msm hasn't made him address this issue, he has just side-stepped it with a smile and a lie

We aren't all as insufferably stupid as you are, let alone left-leaning nit-wits out here.

Obama's pals have been ignored, let alone his campaign money contributions. (which now the repubs are asking the FEC to look into now, which is far too late to do now, which has been past aggravating) 

I guarantee if this was reversed with any repub they would of already been run out of town on a rail.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

Obama is full of empty promises

He is like every politician. He promises and doesn't deliver. that's what he did in Chicago.

Never does he give specifics. NEVER.

Mr.L

Walters was never that smart

"WALTERS: He was friendly with this man who’s life has changed. "

Really? He is completely unrependented of his actions and wishes he could have done more. He still preaches socialism in the U.S. and is still an outspoken supporter of the overthrow of this republic.

At least she admitted that Obama was "friendly" with Ayers and not just a neighbor. She messed up on her Obama talking points.

"the msm hasn't made him

"the msm hasn't made him address this issue, he has just side-stepped it.."

Exactly.   Ayers is like a turd in the litter box, and Ba-Ba, Whoopsi, and Joyk are like 3 brainless cats, busily trying to cover it up.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Let all facts into the light

Let all facts into the light and examine them. The light has such cleansing properties. Satan in the Garden said so much that sounded like God's word but upon inspection was pure balderdash.  So we should look at all canditates and the facts of their lives. 

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Ayers at present

What a dodge!

Please, someone who asks questions at the Town Hall Debate tomorrow night, ask Obama about whether he supports Ayers' current educational philosophy.

To wave it all off and say, "that happened years ago," they have to imply that Ayers has since changed. But that's exactly the point. He hasn't changed. His radicalism is as strong as it ever was. And Ayers has the same radical philosophy now that he had forty years ago. Obama didn't associate with the terrorist Ayers, but he certainly associated with the radical Ayers.

Terrorist Radical

"Obama didn't associate with the terrorist Ayers, but he certainly associated with the radical Ayers."

Excellent way to phrase it.  Clear and concise.  Can we write you in as a POTUS debate moderator?

Hmmmm ....

That would put me on the same pedestal of thought as Tom Brokaw and Gwen Ifill ... hmmmm ... I'm afraid I'll have to pass.

I'm sure you didn't intend to insult me ... (LOL!)

Ooops

Oops, no insult intended. LOL.  We just need to see a moderator that is clear, concise and cuts through the spin.

I guess the Truth hurts

I guess the Truth hurts Whoopsy, huh? Your messiah is finally being called out for the dangerous connections he has.

Elisabeth, please keep this up.  The Truth that you put out there is like sunlight is to a vampire to these liberals.

On a side note it is nice to see Sen. McCain is bringing up Obama, Fannie and Freddie.  NRO

Walters is a Partisan

"WALTERS: He has addressed it."

This is what bothers me about Barbara Walters.  She pretends she is this down-the-middle journalist, who does not let her personal politics get in the way of her job.  Then she spouts nonsense like this on a regular basis, giving no benefit of the doubt to anyone with an "R" after their name.  Of course, Obama has not addressed his radical friends, not in the least.  This issue has been off the table for the entire duration of the campaing to this point.  Perhaps it was mentioned briefly during a Dem party debate, when nobody is watching, but this is now the big leagues.  It is patently absurd for someone who considers herself to have the utmost of journalistic integrity to insist that Barack had addressed the issue to a satisfactory level.  Now it's all about the current issues, that's all that matters.  Rest assured, if McCain had previously hung out with racists, anti-Americans and other assorted radicals, good old Babs would not be insisting that it is all about current issues or that the past is meaningless.

Whoopie

Who care what this spook says??!!

Ayers

As recently as 2001, Bill Ayers was photographed stepping on the US flag.  What more proof is needed?  Obama should make a definitive statement on whether he approves of Ayers or not.  If Obama gets elected, don't be surprised to see Ayers as head of the Department of Education.

hahahahahahaHAHAHAHAHA!

 

Celebrities:  Is there anything they don't know?

 

 Best Regards,

 

e

 

P.S.  Does anyone actually watch that hen party?

For years, Congress has asked Hollywood types to testify

On Capitol Hill.  Why, I've never understood.  They understand basically what they've read in scripts, or have been taught by acting coaches.  That makes them experts on exactly what?  Maybe acting, but that's about it.

Getting Pesimistic

Or maybe I should be optimistic? I'm conflicted...

Rev 17:17  For God has put it into their hearts to fulfill His purpose, to be of
one mind, and to give their kingdom to the beast, until the words of
God are fulfilled.

As for the Bail-out and the financial crisis:

Rev 18:11 - 18:19

And the merchants of the earth will weep and mourn over her, for no one buys their merchandise anymore:

merchandise of gold and silver, precious stones and pearls, fine linen
and purple, silk and scarlet, every kind of citron wood, every kind of
object of ivory, every kind of object of most precious wood, bronze,
iron, and marble; and cinnamon and incense, fragrant oil and frankincense, wine and oil,
fine flour and wheat, cattle and sheep, horses and chariots, and bodies
and souls of men.

The fruit that your soul longed for has gone from you, and all the things which are rich and splendid have gone from you, and you shall find them no more at all.

The merchants of these things, who became rich by her, will stand at a distance for fear of her torment, weeping and wailing, and saying, 'Alas, alas, that great city that was clothed in fine
linen, purple, and scarlet, and adorned with gold and precious stones
and pearls!

For in one hour such great riches came to nothing.' Every shipmaster,
all who travel by ship, sailors, and as many as trade on the sea, stood
at a distance and cried out when they saw the smoke of her burning, saying, 'What is like this great city?

They threw dust on their heads and cried out, weeping and wailing, and
saying, 'Alas, alas, that great city, in which all who had ships on the
sea became rich by her wealth! For in one hour she is made desolate.

Sounds like a severe recession or maybe a depression...

You want change? Give me a dollar.

Don't Worry

c5then, my belief is that these passages from Revelations occur after the Rapture of the Church.

I believe what we are seeing now are the birth pangs of the coming tribulation.

Yes Whoopi, McCain is

Yes Whoopi, McCain is pulling out garbage, but its' Obama's garbage he's pulling out. And even Whoopi would agree that from time to time you have to take out the garbage. McCain is just doing the sanitary thing to do in a case like this.

Fuhrer Obama Hitler Youth

 

 

 

Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/  

Sorry but

McCain has not "pulled out the garbage"...if he HAD done that, he'd be pulling Ms. Goldberg off that show!

How ANYONE could take this woman seriously is beyond me!

"For years, Congress has

"For years, Congress has asked Hollywood types to testify on
Capitol Hill.  Why, I've never understood.  They understand basically
what they've read in scripts, or have been taught by acting coaches. 
That makes them experts on exactly what?  Maybe acting, but that's
about it."

*chuckle* You talkin' about Meryl Streep and her Alar apples?

How does Elizabeth get up and go to work every morning to spar with these chuckleheads? I'd have a volcanic ulcer the size of Mt. Everest.

Who in the world is the newest View host? I've never seen her before in my life.

Nice.

I'm new here. Someone else deleted my original post.  Really nice.  I'm glad someone thought it would be nice to do that.  Nice job.

Welcome aboard JimC.  

Welcome aboard JimC.   Posts don't usually get deleted here.  Sometimes you can inadvertently post a reply to the wrong thread.  I've done that many a time.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

The Dissing View

ArkieRepub

Why has no one had the guts to call these liberals what they are... political hacks? They are doing the bidding for the Democrats in a forum set up to 'look' above board discussing the 'current affairs' of the day.' A true sham. Barbara Wa Wa with her noticable irritating lisp, Whoopsi with her wigs and the new Sheperd acting all "in your face" to Hasselbeck reminds me of high school 'put-downs' in gym class. How pathetic.

The real scary thing is that there is a large audience of women who should be ashamed to have paid good money to sit and listen to the cackles of these liberal "femin-nazi's. Their obviously poorly educated are they would not sit there and soak in all the lies and half-truths of the liberal tongue waggers without so much as a whimper and applauding these "know-things" is..... unbelievable!

Obama is a liar and perverse;...we should all be afraid, very afraid of this man of whom we know so very little. He has accomplished nothing to warrant his ascent to the Oval Office.

What Liberals call garbage...

normal people call the truth.  The "Swift Boaters" told the truth about Kerry and saved us from his "Presidency".  Talk radio and Sarah Palin are telling the truth about Obama and his "radical associations".  For some reason, George Bush never joined in with the "Swift Boaters".  If he wants to win, John McCain can not afford to not talk about Obama and his "radical associations".  After all, one is known by the company he keeps.  Jim Webster

This coming from whoopie

This coming from whoopie "should I become a slave again?" goldberg.

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

Ayers is coo l- he didn't KILL anyone

What a bunch of frigging loons. All the Hollywood fools trying to differentiate this terrorist from others because someone didn't happen to walk past the garbage can that exploded. Ayers, the maniac, put a frigging bomb in a place frequented by people. The fact that no one died is luck not design.

McCain has to ask Obama outright - "Did you launch your political career in Ayers home because of what he did or in spite of what he did?" No one is going to tell me Obama didn't know Ayers was sort of a radical "celebrity" in Chicago and that's what intrigued him. The Chicago magazine from 2004 highlighting Ayers ( The cover where Ayers is stomping on the flag) is photographed like the cover of a Bob Dylan album. This radical/celebrity culture has to be brought to the light of day. Cockroaches HATE the light of day.

McCain has gota come out of his coma and press for answers.

Ayers' wife, Dohrn, lauded CHARLES MANSON.

Yea thats what we need. A President who launched his political career in the living room of two domestic terrorists, one of which lauds CHARLES MANSON. Are we in the Twilight Zone?

Obama was 8 but victim was 9 when Ayers tried to kill him

read about it at  Powerlineblog

Poopy gold digger and shaggy sheepherder

Hello !!!!!!!!!!!!  Three radical left wing nut jobs attacking the conservative............this is right in line with the view..and the very reason why i dont waste a moment of my time watching it.

Whoopi Goldberg is an insult to anyone watching. She has made it well know through and a CNN interview on the segment "Black in America" with Brown that whites racially insult her on a daily basis. She also supports the racist rev. wright and the Trinity Church.

Shepherd is just a very dense un-educated hippo that Walter drag from the sewer pipe she came up on.  She is just following Whoopi's lead because of skin color.................The sum of Obama's campaign.

Walter's on the other hand is like Oprah...........just working it, in all hope of bedding ever dick that comes swinging overhead.