MSNBC Uses Cancer Survivor to Promote ‘Success’ of ObamaCare
Now that the Supreme Court has ruled ObamaCare constitutional, MSNBC has redoubled its efforts at promoting the president's signature legislative accomplishment to its audience. On Friday’s 2 p.m. Eastern NewsNation program, guest-host Thomas Roberts brought on a cancer survivor to fawn over Obama.
Natoma Canfield, who thankfully is cancer-free, was prompted by Roberts from every angle to praise Obama and go on at length about how much credit she gives to Obama for saving her life. Thomas then followed this up by telling his audience how Canfield is "one of the millions of Americans who have already benefitted from this law." [Video coming soon. MP3 audio here.]
Roberts went on to ask the following:
What goes through your mind, though, when you hear people on the right? People out there across this country that may not understand exactly what the Affordable Care Act does, and they want to repeal it. They're angry about it. What is your message to them?
Roberts guided the interview to a position where he could lay out his usual smear on conservatives. Acting as a surrogate for the DNC, Thomas asked Canfield if Democrats "need to be on the front lines of trying to explain this better so that Americans can understand" the law, seeing how Republicans had a "policy of fear," trying "scare people into not wanting" it.
See relevant transcript below.
MSNBC
News Nation
06/29/20122:16 p.m. EDT
THOMAS ROBERTS: President Obama there sharing the personal emotional story of a woman who benefited from his health care law. The president says he's carried Natoma Canfield’s story with him every day of this fight to pass the law and then yesterday the Ohio woman was solidified as a national symbol of this president's signature legislative achievement. Natoma Canfield joins me now to talk more about this. It's great to have you with us and we first heard your story when the president invited your sister to introduce him at a health care event two years ago. You were too ill to make it at that time. Let’s start out with update us all on your condition now. How are you doing?
NATOMA CANFIELD: I'm doing fine, thank you. The cancer is gone. And I'm just recovering now. It's going to take a long time, but I'm doing well, thanks.
ROBERTS: Natoma, you are certainly a fighter. It has to be certainly a validation and an inspiration to you to hear that your letter that you wrote to the president appears framed on his wall. And I want to read part of it to everybody here you say, in that letter, that I need your health reform bill to help me. And how much credit do you give the president's law for your improved health, for the improved life situation that you've seen?
CANFIELD: Oh, I give him a lot of credit.
THOMAS: Natoma, specifically, explain to all of us, how did it change for you? The outlook, at least, for hope, to recover from what you were facing.
CANFIELD: Well, it was a very uplifting experience, to receive both of his letters. And to know that my letter had been heard. So -- those things were very important.
THOMAS: Natoma, you're one of the millions of Americans who have already benefitted from this law. What goes through your mind, though, when you hear people on the right. People out there across this country that may not understand exactly what the Affordable Care Act does, and they want to repeal it. They're angry about it. What is your message to them?
CANFIELD: Well, first of all, I hope they never firsthand understand how important it is. To be able to have insurance if you've been laid off from a job or something like that. That you can afford. Or you've had a pre-existing condition. But I think that, I guess my message is, that it's going to help a lot of people. And I think people need to look at it and give it a chance.
THOMAS: For people that may not have an opportunity, certainly, to walk a mile in your shoes, and the medical heartbreak that you've gone through with the diagnosis and the battle that you've waged since then do you think that the president, do you think that Democrats, need to be on the front lines of trying to explain this better so that Americans can understand more so that there's not a policy of fear that's coming out of this as we've been hearing so much over the last couple of years, trying to scare people into not wanting this?
CANFIELD: I think that explanations are always good. People have to listen, also.
ROBERTS: If you had the president's ear, which I think you did after he got the ruling coming down. What did you say to him? He called you. Correct?
CANFIELD: Yes, he did.
THOMAS: Would you mind sharing with us what you guys discussed?
CANFIELD: He asked how I was. And I told him what a wonderful president I thought he was. And he asked about my sister Connie who had introduced him, and said to say hi to her and he asked if I'd gotten an pen from the signing of the health care bill, which we hadn't. They were all gone by the time my brother and sister went up there, and then he told me that I was welcomed anytime to come and see my letter on his wall.
THOMAS: Well, Natoma, I'm sure if somebody's watching at the White House right now they can find a pen and get it sent it to you. May not be from that signing bill, but they can find you a pen lying around the White House. Certainly an inspiration as the president said your letter was to him. And you are an inspiration certainly to those with this diagnosis of cancer and the fight that it takes to come back. We wish you the best of luck. The best of health as you move forward. Thank you.
CANFIELD: Thank you.
- Jeffrey Meyer's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
Oh that is hilarious
Submitted by jon_torlin on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 4:16pm.
What success, nothing in it gets implemented(except the taxes) until 2014/2015, so there's no way in hell this would have helped that cancer survivor. She's crediting the wrong person and the wrong thing.
And someone should tell her that health care will never prevent anyone from dying.
Sorry, I don't care if she's a cancer survivor or not, Canfield is a first class idiot.
-Jon
What, Tommy Bobby couldn't find an AIDS patient?
Submitted by SickofLibs on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 4:16pm.
He's gonna catch flack for this, mark my words.
Jeffrey. Any clue as to how ObamaCare helped Ms Canfield?
Submitted by Gary Hall on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 4:17pm.
Perhaps it was explained earlier in the interview, but one should be curious as to how -- of if - Ms. Canfield actually benefited from ObamaCare?
Note:
Roberts: The president says he's carried Natoma Canfield’s story with him every day of this fight to pass the law
"Every day?"
Well, Obama's been carrying Natoma's story since early in 2009 - since before ObamaCare came up for a vote? Since before ObamaCare was signed into law? Long before most, if not any, of it's provisions became effective?
Just when was she diagnosed with cancer? And just how, and how, did she get treated for, cured, and declared "cancer free?"
What story has Obama been carrying around with him?
Her story is indeed a tough one. Fox News gives the history, here, however, I see nothing in the story which indicates that there is anything from ObamaCare that has aided her, in any way.
It appears that she lost her health insurance policy (must have been some little fringe company, from the description) because the rates kept going up. Now, it sounds like the hospital thinks she may qualify for financial aid.
Is the entire premise of the story fabricated?
(;~/ gary
"seeing how Republicans had a
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 5:30pm.
"seeing how Republicans had a "policy of fear," trying "scare people into not wanting" it."
That's hilarious, scare tactics are exactly what was used to PASS Obamacare. "People are dropping dead on every street corner due to lack of health insurance!!! You're next!!!" The Dems had liberals worked into such a tizzy they would have voted for martial law if they were told to.
Even now, if you make the mistake of mentioning Obamacare to a liberal they will get a glazed look in their eye and start fervently repeating left-wing talking points about the CRISIS. This is the way the Dems get people to give them control over things, by creating a crisis. If anyone has a contrary view, the Dems accuse THEM of scare tactics.
Pelosi
Submitted by Jimbo on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 5:40pm.
The height of Liberal Hypocrisy came yesterday during the Holder debate when Pelosi was on the floor with fire in her crazy eyes as she condemned the Republicans for forcing the legislation through the House without time to reflect on it. And I'm convinced that the crazy SOB was sincere and drew no correlation to her own actions with the healthcare bill.
My favorite quote on Pelosi
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:12pm.
My favorite quote on Pelosi came from Dennis Miller:
"She can look you in the eyes and tell you she's not looking you in the eyes."
Pelosi
Submitted by Jimbo on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:28pm.
She is bizarre to say the least. It was painful to watch her yesterday but it was like the proverbial train wreck and I just couldn't look away.
She claims to be highly bi-partisan yet continued to refer to the Republicans as "them" and "they". It was as if the Republicans were a collective piece of dog crap pilled up inthe corner of the house floor, even though they were sitting right in front of her. If she couldn't bring herself to address them civilly, she could have at least addressed them directly by using the term "you". Very juvenile and disrespectful, but I'm not at all surprised.
Pelosi is what you get when
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:45pm.
Pelosi is what you get when you have one of the most liberal districts in the nation. She has never had to have ANY accountability at all, she is just automatically re-elected by a huge margin. She went off the rails long ago. The only place she could be considered bi-partisan is in the far-left district from whence she was spawned.
3rd in line
Submitted by Jimbo on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:54pm.
I know. When Pelosi was Speaker of the House, I recall questioning how someone who was elected to her office by less than 100,000 people from the most liberal moon bat district in the nation could find herself 3rd in line for the Presidency. Something is wrong with the system. In this day and age where third in line isn't as far fetched as it once was, there should be some mechanism in place where the people have a say about who sits in the high chair (pun intended).
Each congressional election, the house should put up two or three names that can be voted on by the country. Registered Democrats could vote for their choice which would kick in if they win the majority, and the same for Republicans.
Right, we keep hearing about
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 7:10pm.
Right, we keep hearing about how the right has gone further and further to the right (a favorite left talking point) but then you have an extremist like Pelosi put up as Speaker. She was carrying a giant gavel to the signing of Obamacare, baiting her opponents, and we're supposed to believe it's the right that has gone extreme?
Hasn't even gone into effect
Submitted by RR GOP on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:44pm.
Hasn't even gone into effect yet! When it does, though, they'll keep rolling out these testimonials. For every 4 people that die due to inefficient health care, the LSM will parade around the 1 that got lucky.
"Under Capitalism, man exploits man. Under Communism it's just the opposite."
"All that Communism needs to make it successful is for someone to feed and clothe it."
Joe Blow
Submitted by Jimbo on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 6:48pm.
That's an age old con game. How often do you hear Obama say, I talked to Joe Blow and he benefited from ABC initiative. He mentions Joe Blow because he was the only one who he could find that benefited! And I often wonder if Joe Blow even exists. If it's true, have him come up and tell his own story.
The 4 people who did die due
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 7:31pm.
The 4 people who did die due to inefficient health care will be attacked and have dirt dug up on them for making the government look bad. If they know what's good for them will just, what's the phrase? "Die quickly."
Oh, they say they were too
Submitted by RR GOP on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 7:39pm.
Oh, they say they were too fat or old and useless anyway...ate too many Twinkies (if they're still around years from now), drank too many sodas (if they're still around years from now), smoked too much (if cigarettes are still around years from now), and so on.
They'll NEVER blame the government bureaucracy and their monopolistic, money-grubbing, crony-Capitalist buddies who do really believe in eugenics and Socialism (hey, get over the idea that Commies have to be poor if that's what you still think).
"Under Capitalism, man exploits man. Under Communism it's just the opposite."
"All that Communism needs to make it successful is for someone to feed and clothe it."
Just Wait
Submitted by tcm14 on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 8:02pm.
By the time the govt and the MSM have gotten done spinning govt rationing of health care, they will be telling you it is positively PATRIOTIC to go to an early death to save the govt a few bucks. Just like it is "patriotic" now to pay higher taxes.
Geez, you're right...I had
Submitted by RR GOP on Fri, 06/29/2012 - 8:08pm.
Geez, you're right...I had never thought of that!
"Under Capitalism, man exploits man. Under Communism it's just the opposite."
"All that Communism needs to make it successful is for someone to feed and clothe it."