Dobbs Mocks Gore for Likening Global Warming Alarmism to Civil Rights Legislation of the 1960s

Photo of Jeff Poor.

One of the latest tactics some global warming alarmists have employed is to compare their activism to struggles of the Civil Rights Era of the 1960s. Actor Edward Norton compared the "symbolic" Earth Hour of March 29 to infamous Selma's "Bloody Sunday" in an appearance on CNN's "Larry King Live," and again on NBC's "Today."

But this time, one of the movement's leaders, former Vice President Al Gore, made a similar comparison. Testifying for before a congressional committee on April 24 in Washington, D.C., Gore rated his activism to that of the civil rights movement.

"I believe this legislation has the moral significance equivalent to that of the civil rights legislation of the 1960's and the Marshall Plan of the late 1940's," Gore said. "I am here today to lend my support to one of the most important pieces of legislation ever introduced in the Congress."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

However, for CNN's "Lou Dobbs Tonight" host Lou Dobbs, there was some irony in that remark, being that Gore's father was a longtime senator from Tennessee that voted against civil rights legislation.

"Well, as you just heard Lisa [Sylvester] report, the former vice president claimed that this climate change legislation has the moral significance or equivalence of the civil rights legislation of the '60s and the Marshall Plans," Dobbs said. "Well, an interesting note - Gore's father, Senator Al Gore, Sr., like many southern Democrats at the time voted against the Civil Rights Act of 1964."

Dobbs also noted during the segment prior Earth Day prognostications in his report, all of which didn't quite come true.

"Well, Earth Day, this week, and here are some words of doom and gloom from leading scientists, academics and authors on our climate and environment associated with Earth Day," Dobbs said. "Journalists Peter Collier wrote, ‘One to two million people per year will be starving to death during the next 10 years.' Biologist Paul Ehrlich claimed that most people are going to die in ‘the greatest cataclysm of mankind.' Harvard biologist George Wall said, ‘If we don't take act now, civilization will end between 15 or 30 years.' And ecologist Kenneth Watt claiming that in 15 years, ‘Air pollution will reduce the amount of sunlight reaching earth by one- half.' I want to point out if I may that each and every one of those quotes were from the first Earth Day in 1970, nearly 40 years ago."

The CNN segment highlighted a ClimateDepot.com report that global warming skeptic Lord Christopher Monckton was denied the opportunity to testify before the House Subcommittee on Energy and the Environment.

"The House Democrats don't want Gore humiliated, so they slammed the door of the Capitol in my face," Monckton told the online magazine Climate Depot," CNN correspondent Lisa Sylvester said.

And as Climate Depot's Marc Morano explained - most Gore's doom-and-gloom forecasts are to occur in the distant future.

"If you look at Gore's testimony today, he was talking about what could, might and may happen 50 to 100 years from now," Morano said to CNN. "He was not talking about reality."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

   Someone contact

   Someone contact Gorbachev the moonbats from out of this world are indeed attacking this country.....

And The Goracle...

...that parody of a human being, is their leader.

Cap and Trade

Does anyone know just how large of a tax these democrats are looking to pile on to us over this ridiculous D Science student Al Gore's Global Warming nonsense. I know I can't count on any Libs knowing the answer, they are so pitifully uninformed its pathetic. 

Cap and Trade will destroy the economy

It is not just a tax but a socialist command and control system over which business and industry are told how much of the essential, life supporting, atmospheric trace gas, Carbon Dioxide (CO2) they can emit and at what price. The socialists will have complete control over our energy production and consumption. They can use this to bankrupt any business and industry they do not approve of, like the coal industry which produces 50% of our electricity.

'Cap and Trade' Would Bankrupt the Coal Industry (Video) (9min)
Obama: "Cap & Trade Will Cause Electricity Rates to Skyrocket" (Video) (3min)

Cap-and-Trade Could Cost Average Family $10,800 in Lost Income (US Newswire)
Duke Energy CEO: Cap-and-Trade Plan Would Raise Electric Rates 40% (The Wall Street Journal)

Cap & Trade Is Not A Market Solution (Robert P. Murphy, Ph.D. Economics)
Beware of Cap and Trade Climate Bills (The Heritage Foundation)

As usual, great post and

As usual, great post and links, PT.

This also highlights the handling of the election by the dufus Senator McCain.  This was just one of many areas that McCain could of ripped the now, bambi, first stupid liberal, but he was also FOR this same measure - cap and trade. 

The best news regarding McCain is that he is up for election in Arizona and is opposed by a Republican.  We need to get behind that candidate and ensure that he defeats McCain.  This would eliminate another "dimocrat" vote in the senate. 

Al Gore Gets Testy

Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee asked Gore:

"So is the legislation that we are discussing here today, is that something that you are going to personally benefit from?"

Gore could just not bring himself to answer "Yes".

Thanks for the link

that certifies Algore is a pompous dork who acts like he is above the fray.

Ms. Blackburn is a class act who handled herself like a servant of the people should.

Why can't there be more like her?

Pompous Ass...

answers a classy lady who is doing what more of those crooks up there should be doing.  Here is a partial transcript:

 Gore:  "...every penny that I have made, I have put right into a non-profit, "The Alliance for Climate Protection", to spread awareness of why we have to take on this challenge.  And Congresswoman, if you're...if you believe that the reason I have been working on this issue for 30 years is because of greed, you don't know me."
Blackburn: "Sir, I'm not making accusations"...and states she is trying to clarify questions that her constituents have been asking.
Gore's response:  "I understand exactly what you're doing here, congresswoman, everybody here does."

I was thinking as I listened to this, that someone needs to look into the "Alliance for Climate Protectin" thing, as I am sure this is a scam too.  Also, the list of references linked to in the Monckton link in the blog above is very good, too.  I wish I had more time for this, but I have to go cut down a tree.  Sorry, Al.  I'll hug it once it's down.

"The future is not set.  There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."

michaelyon-online.com

Re His Pompousity

Pompous Ass is the definition of Fat Al. Just because a corporation is a 'non-profit', doesn't mean that the corporation can't pay Fat Al an enormous salary complete with Wall Street-style bonuses. In cases like Al's, 'non-profit' can be meaningless or a tax dodge. Criminal organizations like ACORN are also 'non-profit'.

PS: Of course, MLK was also a Republican.

slick

This came from the Alliance for Climate Protection website:

(laugh lines, for me, in bold):  "We will be completely non–partisan in pursuing our mission."
Then, several sentences later, this:  ...The Chairman of the Board, Al Gore, has been an advocate and leader for climate action for over 30 years."
Under the "Our Mission" heading is this:  "The Alliance for Climate Protection is undertaking an unprecedented mass persuasion exercise based on scientific facts."  (it may be unprecedented, but it's not scientific.)

  It gives a list of "partners", including professional advertising types, obviously to convince the American people, in a bi-partisan way, that their selectively chosen "scientific" facts should convince everyone that we need to hand over the reins of power to the greens.
The blurb about the staff just says to me that they are carrying out an unprecedented propaganda campain: 

 "The Alliance staff is equipped with decades of top-notch experience in private sector marketing, advertising and communications as well as a deep technical, policy and institutional understanding of climate change. As professionals, they combine the discipline and focus of the commercial world with the passion of focusing on an issue critical to the future of the globe."

I wish I had the time to dig into this more deeply.  Maybe someone at NB is already on it.  I just smell a really rotten dead rat ever since I heard Mr. Pompous Ass tell the congresswoman, with his panties all in a bunch that she or her constituents should ever suggest that he might be personally benefitting from the Cap & Trade legislation, that he had donated all his proceeds to this sham group.

P.S.  Taking a break.  The trees are now on the ground.  Getting ready to cut them up into little bitty pieces.  Send them to a landfill.

 

"The future is not set.  There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."

michaelyon-online.com

Where's MLK?

We are missing one more comparison, Al Gore to Martin Luther King. Al's head is not quite swollen enough for him to make that comparison himself, but he is waiting for someone else to do it. Waiting ...

Gore is no MLK

Al Gore couldn't hold a candle to a man like Martin Luther King, Jr.  And to compare something like global warming to the civil rights movement is a massive insult to the people who lost their lives and livelihoods in that movement.

Well Kat, there a few

Well Kat, there a few comparrisons that you could make between MLK and Gore.

They both are/were on the extreme left.

As yet, no woman in their right mind would admit to having an affair with Gore.  So one up for Gore there.

Gore I would say, has borderline Communist tendencies, so this may be a push. 

However, both insist(ed) the government is the only institution that can handle the current 'problem'. 

On this I disagree.  But, that's what debate is all about, correct?

i'll compare Gore to MLK

MLK was a man willing to die for his beliefs and willing to debate them

Gore is a man willing to profit from his scam and thus no debate is allowed

"Outside of a dog a book is man's best friend,------------inside a dog it's too dark to read"   ---Groucho

botg

You just nailed it.

eye noes

but maybe the cat should stay in the bag?

better yet, go cat go

"Outside of a dog a book is man's best friend,------------inside a dog it's too dark to read"   ---Groucho

Picture

Love the picture!  :)

yes kat

luv da kittahs

"Outside of a dog a book is man's best friend,------------inside a dog it's too dark to read"   ---Groucho

Rep from Tennesee

took Gore to task yesterday on this very thing.  Sepcifically Kleiner Perkins.  He sat there and directly (and very indignantly) demanded if she was implying he doing this simply out of greed.  He then proceeded to tell the room that every cent he gets from what he's doing goes right back into NFP organizations.  He is a lying sack of crap. 

I love to help the helpless but I'm not gonna help the clueless   ~Dennis Miller

Uh, oh...Dobbs had BETTER be careful!

He could end up working for FNC real soon if he keeps speaking the truth - heaven forbid, CNN would ever WANT to speak the truth!

"Who am us, anyway?" - Firesign Theatre

AL GORE - HERO TO POMPOUS A-HOLES EVERYWHERE

If you think that "global warming" has the moral equivalence to the civil rights campaigm, then it should come as a stretch to think of yourself as the Martin Luther King of climate change.

Al Gore - Proving every day that America detests pompous pricks.

Set a precedent

 If the left goes after the Bushies' that will set a precedent for the next administration to go after bambi and co. for bankrupting this country. We will have runaway inflation and be living like a 3rd world country very soon. The dems. will get what they want ,but the people will be saying WTF.

precedent Maytag

plus his fraud for not providing a birth certificate

"Outside of a dog a book is man's best friend,------------inside a dog it's too dark to read"   ---Groucho

I'm starting to like this

I'm starting to like this Dobbs guy.

Lord Christopher Monckton Destroys Al Gore's Propaganda

If you watch this video or read his paper you can clearly see why the Democrats do not want Lord Monckton testifying next to Al Gore.

Apocalypse? No! (Video) (1hr 26min)

Global Warming Is Not Happening (PDF)

Obama: "Cap & Trade Will Cause Electricity Rates To Skyrocket"

I wasn't aware Martin Luther King, Jr.

became a gazillionaire during the Civil Rights Movement. Gore has so I see no comparison.

The global warming freaks are all wack jobs. I heard the founder of the "Voluntary Extinction Movement" on the Laura Ingraham show on Earth Day. I hope some of you heard because it was downright hilarious. Where do these people hail from?

→ Hijacking Martin

It's always something isn't it?

Homo (Barney Frank's word) marriage is the same as the struggle of Black America.

Save the planet.  Don't mind if we borrow Martin again, do ya?

It's hard to talk when you're teabagging - Anderson Cooper

So many of Gore's Claims have been debunked...

...like his CO2-temperature correlation graph derived from ice core data (which actually showed temps driving CO2, not the other way around) and the hockey stick B.S.

An actual scientist that F.U.'d this monumentally this many times would be completely washed up and a laughingstock (as should anyone who is part of Gore's oft-touted "consensus").

So why on earth does the media and congress continue to pretend this guy is some kind of credible authority on any subject?

Gore's Claims have been Debunked in a UK Court

Judge attacks nine errors in Al Gore's 'alarmist' climate change film (Daily Mail, UK)

And more thoroughly by Lord Monckton which is why they did not want him to testify...

35 Inconvenient Truths: The errors in Al Gore’s movie (Science & Public Policy Institute)

Obama: "Cap & Trade Will Cause Electricity Rates To Skyrocket"

Too funny!

Thanks PT

Thanks PT, can count on you for solid info.

What's truly amazing is

What's truly amazing is that criticism of Gore warrants any air time and qualifies as news.

That is, in saner times Gore and the other nuts wouldn't have boldly foisted their pseudo-scientific delusions on the rest of the world with so much success.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).

CARBON COMMUNISTS...

A couple of things...

If I was one of the many who marched against the racism & segregation of the civil rights era, I would be pissed. Having police beating people, having fire hoses turned on peaceful protestors, & police dogs as well was a real problem. Plus the KKK were in the mix with their special brand of terrorism, & to compair that to "global warming" or "climate change" is truly offensive.

Al Gore is the front man for what would be the greatest fraud ever committed if Gore & guys like George Soros & Maurice Strong can get crap like "cap & trade" forced on the people. The impact of this crap bill would destroy America's economy, setting the stage for a truly opprssive gov't. These people are CARBON COMMUNISTS, & should be considered enemies of the state. Man is not warming the earth, & CO2 is little more then plant food. In fact, the most prominent greenhouse gas is H2O, not CO2. Water is a bigger "threat" then carbon.

Gore should be under investigation for fraud & corrpution. The MSM should look into how damn stupid his claims are & then take him down. The MSM still kiss his fat @$$ because they feel he was screwed by the Florida recount, & will never have a hard look at his lies.

Soros should be looked at as well. I'm sure those who prosicute Nazi era war crimes should have a look at how he is reported to have COLLABORATED WITH THE NAZIS as a 14 year old...http://sweetness-light.com/archive/george-soros-on-helping-the-nazis-during-the-holocaust ...plus he's a Jew. Nice, this guy is pure evil, & should be investigated for his actions in the early 40s.

 

 

"The Fairness Doctrine = Jim Crow laws for Conservatives".  Jim Quinn from "Quinn & Rose"