Santelli vs. Huffington -- CNBC Reporter Takes on Liberal Blog Editor on Economy

Photo of Jeff Poor.
  • Bookmark and Share

Both have loyal following, but their fans are on opposite sides of the political spectrum.

CNBC's Rick Santelli rose to prominence earlier this year when he railed against President Barack Obama's policies on live TV from the floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. He's a hit with conservatives staging tea parties to protest the bailout culture in Washington throughout the country. 

Arianna Huffington, who appeared as a guest host on CNBC's March 31 "Squawk Box" has following of left-wing readers and bloggers, as the editor of the very popular Huffington Post blog. The two faced off on "Squawk Box" about how the housing crisis should be handled. Huffington asked Santelli what his thoughts were on more government assistance for underwater homeowners to prevent another round of foreclosures.

"Well, the whole country is underwater I guess," Santelli replied. "It's just a matter of where you want to point the bailout gun. I would certainly like to see some of those mortgage contracts gone through to find out where the erroneous and inaccurate and illegal contracts and separate those from the rest because I think that a lot of the information on the original mortgage contracts is not accurate and I don't think it would be very fair to put those in the same camp as other foreclosures."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Huffington pressed Santelli on the handling of banking bailouts versus a housing bailout, while Santelli held to a defense of the free market:

HUFFINGTON: But if it is a question of the value of the house going down through no fault of the owner of the house?

SANTELLI: What do you mean no fault? No fault in what regard?"

HUFFINGTON: Well, in the sense that it was not anything they did through fraud or through ...

SANTELLI: Well, who did it?

HUFFINGTON: Well, the market did it - the same way we're bailing out AIG or Citibank. Who did that, I mean the economic conditions under which we're living - are responsible for that as well as ...

SANTELLI: Did anybody complain when the prices were going up?

HUFFINGTON: But what are you saying? Are you saying you don't owe any responsibility to homeowners - only to bankers?

SANTELLI: I think we have only one responsibility - we need some good regulation and the best regulation that I think I've ever heard is failure. If you take failure out of the system, all other regulations really don't do very well.

HUFFINGTON: So, should we let some banks fail then?

SANTELLI: Some people should be renters and yes, I think some banks need to fail.

HUFFINGTON: Like Citi - like which bank would you suggest let fail?

SANTELLI:  Well, I think anybody that's insolvent, whether it's a private firm, a private entity, a family, a bank - that they should all have their constitutional right to fail. It doesn't mean there can't be lots of help and some orchestration, as it seems like the Barack administration, Obama administration is working on - I'm for that. Some type of organized bankruptcy and I think many people may need a helping hand, but I don't think it's a God-given right that everybody needs to live in a house whether they can afford it or not.

Huffington's appearance was one of several moves seen by many as CNBC pandering to the left-wing advocacy groups. The network announced March 23 former DNC chairman Howard Dean would officially be a "CNBC contributor." And Cramer, after referring to Obama's rhetoric as having heard "Lenin," changed his tune on Obama on NBC's March 24 "Today" proclaiming "the president has become pro-shareholder."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Yeah, what he said.

Exactly the truth. Let people go through bankruptcy. Let banks fail. Someone will pick up where they left off. You can't sew back on a severed head, no matter how much money your throw at it. You can only let them die and continue the cycle of life. The same goes for the cycle of business: the bad ones fail and the good ones succeed.

on bailing out..

Back in 2000 - March thru December - when the dot.com bubble was crashing; when thousands of companies began to go out of business; when millions of ordinary Americans were loosing $50K, $100K, 200K or so, in their 401K's and their children's college education accounts were heading south - where were all of these folks, like Huffington, the D's and the rest of the MSM? Where they blaming Clinton and calling for bailouts? (that was a rhetorical question).

Whether folks bought into a dot.com bubble market that time, or a housing bubble and the roaring stock market this time, and are loosing their shirts, it's still the same thing - a bad investment decision.

As an economist and

As an economist and constitutional lawyer, Santelli buried her.

I have been following CNBC almost exclusively during this crisis. I now switch off CNBC when the communists are invited, especially communist politicians. 

when nothing is risk

and its all reward - of course its all going to go to hell.  What planet do these people come from?  Sitting there with eyes squeezed shut and ears plugged singing la-la-la prentending human nature doesn't exist. 

I hope Mr Santelli continues to keep his job at CNBC.  It was nice to see him lay a little smackdown on that pinchy faced woman.

_____________________________________________________
Obama does not perform as advertised.  I'd like a refund.
Taxed Enough Already.

Great video.

Thank you.

 

Good for him!

At least someone at CNBC has the guts to speak their mind and some common sense. A little intellectual honest is refreshing in the media. 

http://franklinslocke.blogspot.com/

But there was FRAUD

Seems Ms. Huff  & Puff is missing the point. Fraud was committed by some brokers and some homeowners. We should look at the applications approved because of false income, those responsible should be held accountable.

Steve Martin with the WSJ nailed it when he said the GM bailout is all about saving the autoworkers union. GM's problem? How about greedy union bosses and greedy upper management?

Thanks for the Post

Thanks for capturinig the story.  Missed it this morning.  Santelli was great again.  My favorite was this:

SANTELLI: I think we have only one responsibility - we need some good
regulation and the best regulation that I think I've ever heard is
failure. If you take failure out of the system, all other regulations
really don't do very well.

Exactly. Common Sense 101.  Again, great.  (Linked to this from my blog at http://thelearningcurve.blogspot.com )

This new era of letting companies with bad business models continue on is crazy.  Bad companies go out of business. Good companies survive.

Zsa-Zsa, de Bore

Arianna Huffington is a fruitcake.

Huffington

Good Shahinshah, whenever this woman gets on any network in the English speaking world, they need to run subtitles on the bottom, or overdub her with a translator!

Rick Santelli is truly The Man.  If, when visiting Chicago, I ever run into him, I'm buying him a beer.  Or, better yet, I'll have a six pack of Shiner Bock with me just in case I run into him. 

The line about failure being the ultimate regulator is PRICELESS.  And it is so common sense it is horrifying to me to think that some will hear it and think it a deep, profound revelation. 

"CONSUMED DEMOCRACY RETURNS A SOCIALIST REGIME" - Slayer, "Fictional Reality", from Divine Intervention (1994)

The Scorceress as guest host

Wow, CNBC really knows how to pick a guest host. The creator of a blog, with no real economic knowledge who sounds like a peasant from Athens. Greece not Georgia.

Mr.L

Mr.L's Tavern

http://mrltavern.podomatic.com

 

huffinton

CNBC also had Huff n Puff converse with Rubini, the economist from NY.  It was comical to try to listen to them talk.  They both have accents no one can understand...having both on was hysterical.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.