Another Fishy Tale: 'Nightly News' Jumps Onboard with Mercury- in- Fish Hysteria

Photo of Jeff Poor.

Here we go again - another media hit on the dangers of fish consumption due to the possible threat that mercury may have on pregnant women.

A segment on the Dec. 30 "NBC Nightly News" warned viewers to exercise caution when consuming fish because of the potential side effects it may have on newborn children.

"There's no question that fish is healthy," NBC chief science correspondent Robert Bazell said. "But toxic mercury, mostly from coal-fired power plants makes it way into the ocean, where it can end up in the meat of certain fish."

Bazell's report even singled out certain fish that were deemed unsafe and those that were considered safe for viewers.

"So the key is knowing which fish is safest," Bazell said. "Those with high levels of mercury include swordfish, king mackerel and tile fish. Seafood with low levels of mercury include salmon, cod, shrimp, trout and most small fish."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

But according to the National Fisheries Institute (NFI), those suspect fish account for a very small portion of overall seafood consumption. By omitting that detail, the threat of mercury contamination is exaggerated, as the NFI's "AboutSeafood" blog pointed out.

"The fact of the matter remains that the four fish FDA believes pregnant women should avoid -- shark, swordfish, tile fish and king mackerel -- account for less than one percent of all seafood consumed in the U.S. every year. But by obscuring the fact that very few people actually eat those fish, activists have managed to scare consumers away from eating seafood at all," a December 2008 post reads.

If women are apprehensive about fish consumption because of the warnings broadcasted on "Nightly News" and other included in other media outlets, they could be depriving themselves of important nutrients.

"Women in the U.S. eat less than two ounces of seafood per week, which means they are denying themselves an important source of Omega 3 fatty acids that are known to encourage cognitive development in fetuses and help protect against heart disease," the blog continued.

Over the past several months, the fish industry has been under fire from various media reports because of the potential for mercury contamination, which have relied heavily on environmental activist groups for their sourcing according to the NFI.

A Dec. 23 New York Times editorial questioned if fish were safe to eat. An Oct. 14 Reuters story relied completely on data put out by Greenpeace and that the environmental group even used in a Web ad. On CNN's Dec. 16 "Lou Dobbs Tonight," a report raised the possibility the outgoing Bush administration was trying to dupe the public when the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) increased its recommendations of fish consumption because it conflicted with the environmental agenda.

Also, at the top of the "Nightly News" segment, anchor Lester Holt used actor Jeremy Piven to introduce the report by Bazell. The actor resigned from a starring role in a Broadway play claiming mercury poisoning from sushi.

"You may have heard the recent story about actor Jeremy Piven abruptly quitting a starring role on Broadway claiming he was terribly ill from mercury poisoning," Holt said. "He blamed it on a constant diet of sushi. While his diet may not be typical of most Americans, it is the latest in a long-running controversy over how much fish we should eat - a question that applies most urgently to pregnant women and nursing mothers."

However, as AboutSeafood.com pointed out, the checkered background of the physician that diagnosed Piven with mercury-related ailment raised questions about Piven's illness.

"Well, he too has been called ‘fishy,' the former body builder turned celebrity physician and motivational speaker has been a pitch man for muscle-building health supplements and has reportedly been hauled into court four times for allegedly faking lab results so companies that paid him could promote ephedra as a diet supplement," the blog said. It also pointed out that "Nightly News" was just picking up where environmental groups left off.

"And today environmental lobbying groups latched on to the story and are trying to make hay with it but they are quickly finding that they may have hitched their cart to the wrong horse," the blog continued. "As it turns out the play's investors aren't buying the diagnosis and may call in their own doctor to get a ‘second opinion.'"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Maybe they can do a segment...

on cars with gas tanks that explode on impact too.

 Ok, questionable

 

Ok, questionable trace amount of mercury on your dinner table is bad, but guaranteed toxic amount of mercury in every light fixture in your home is good. Does the media ever step back and look at how stupid they are?

  

Doh!

I know you might find this a little hard to swallow, but, until further results are in, I would only recommend eating incandescent lightbulbs.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

Phosphor Alert!

Phosphor Alert!  Most incandescent lightbulbs have a phosphor coating on their internal surface.

On Edit:  I recommend that you only eat the clear bulbs.

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

Hay, "smart" people.

Hay, "smart" people, listen up:  Mercury exists in the oceans naturally, just as it has since the oceans formed. The amount of mercury released by coal-burning power plants is minuscule when compared to the levels that naturally occur in the oceans.

Where do you think the mercury in coal came from, anyways? Did it just magically appear when the coal was buried for millions of years?  No, it came from the ancient OCEAN SEDIMENTS that the plants grew in and used as a source of nutrients before they died and were transformed into coal.  Duh!

Mankind has been eating fish from the oceans for tens of thousands of years (if not longer), yet, despite the supposedly high levels of mercury that are found in fish, levels that have also existed since fist first swam in the oceans, mankind, even the "unborn" variety of mankind, not only survived, they THRIVED on the protein and nutrients that seafood provides! 

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

hootie-hoot

cobra man

yes but we must use CFLs to fight climate change and move all the mercury to our landfills      

----- Radical  Liberal

Full circle

Someday, several millions of years from now, an intelligent walking fish will dig up our landfills and burn the "coal" that is trapped there and release that mercury back into the atmosphere and, eventually, back into the oceans, thus completing a cycle that has existed for billions of years. 

I wonder if, millions of years from now, some "environmentalist" walking fish will complain about the "toxic" mercury that they will be eating from the funny looking naked bipeds that the walking fish use as a food source?

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

Obviously

this is just a story to state the evils of coal power.  The Chosen One has already said he is going to kill coal power, I suspect the evils of coal power to be laid out often over the next few years.

be alert also

The sun produces massive amounts of  lethal radiation.

 

So does Granite

So does Granite, although not nearly as much as the Sun.

Obama: My job is above my pay grade

2nd degree burns!

  I will take my chances with teh fish. 

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

I will take my chances with

I will take my chances with teh fish.

Ohh no it has affected you already. using teh instead of the.  A sure sign of troubles ahaead. 

 Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

More fish for me!

As usual, the enviro-whackos get it all wrong.

The fish in question (??) are the large pelagic species...in layman's terms, the top ocean-going predators in the food chain with fins.  Mercury does accumulate, but I think you'd have to eat a whole bluefin tuna, which you couldn't do in a week even if you were a world champion food-stuffer.

The more troublesome thing about seafood, which fortunately we don't see here in the first world, is ciguetera posoining, which can be fatal after one exposure, and can also cause a lifetime of neurological problems.  It is an accumulation of coral reef toxins, found in the largest predators on the reef (and generally not in the pelagic species as they usually feed off-shore). 

In the islands, many of the locals eat barracuda.  Which is a fine eating fish.....but the question one must ask is....where was it caught?  If it was caught on the grass flats (a juvenile fish)....enjoy your meal.  But if caught on a reef, pass.    Personally, I never eat a barracuda I haven't caught myself.

As for the rest of this article....I have to laugh.  But if that means lower prices at my fish-mongers, all the better, and another reason to mark this year as better than average.

 

What about

What about mercury-in-lightbulb hysteria?

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

Mercury laden fish give me constipation or sometimes colic.

  I usually treat it with azogue pills I pick up in Mexico. 

Sincerely,

a Veteran of a 1000 psychic wars.

What I got from this

What I got from this story:

Don't eat the NBC News fish - it's toxic!

Make a resolution for 2009 that whenever the drive by media attempts to come into your home or office that you turn them off or throw them in the trash can as the case may be.  

This is the way you handle toxic waste . . .

Happy New Year!

 

 

here's something you'll love....

when we were kids (late 60's early 70's) we used to play with liquid mercury. from thermometers, old thermostats, silent light switches etc. used to dip pennies in it to turn them silver....is that not crazy!!!. roll it around in the palms of our hands...now we find out that parts per million are harmful.granted  we weren't ingesting it....