NBC News went out of its way this time to show how the American public relies on government Dec. 10 by focusing on the public library in it's "Hard Times" series.
The broadcast examined the hardships public libraries are facing in the economic downturn - at a time when people are flocking to libraries instead of the local bookstore.
"These tough economic times, as we have been saying, have forced a lot of people to find new ways of doing things to save money," "Nightly News" anchor Brian Williams said. "And listen to this next one - with money so tight, the costs of books has people turning to a place where you can actually get books free, then return them for the next user. The library business, it seems, is booming. But now they could use some help in this economy."
NBC correspondent Chris Jansing interviewed a librarian that detected an uptick in "wild" behavior at one library - which Jansing deemed a result of the economic downturn.
"Wild is not a word you usually associate with libraries, but the economic downturn has made them wildly popular," Jansing said.
A Google News search indicates library usage is way up all across the country and NBC attributed that to the lackluster economy. However, Jansing also complained that in some localities the governments have had to cut library funding. No free-market solutions to the funding problems were presented in the segment such as private donations from library users.
"But just as use of libraries is way up, many of their budgets are way down, slashed by local governments caught in the economic downturn," Jansing said. "So some are being forced to cut hours, staff and in some cases - close branches altogether."
According to Jansing, in Philadelphia, there are plans to shut 11 of 54 branches of their library - which was met with an emotional outburst by one resident.
"I can't believe anybody is going to close this damn thing down," said one grown man in tears over a library closing Philadelphia.
According to the American Library Association, most libraries are funded on the local and state level, but they do receive funding from the federal government. The majority of appropriated federal library program funds are distributed through the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) to each state. The IMLS requested $271.2 million in funding from the federal government for fiscal year 2008 - a nearly 10 percent increase from just two years before.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Confused
December 11, 2008 - 11:09 ET by iveseenitallI'm confused. I went to a local restaurant on a weeknight recently. It was packed. But my wife went Christmas (can I say that?) shopping and the stores were empty. I guess people have so much "stuff" right now, but their bellies always need to be filled (and most boomers don't know how to cook). As for libraries, maybe it is a good thing that people are returning to some simple pleasures, unless they ruin them too. Then again, it's not for books, but for free videos. Pretty soon they'll be asking for latte machines at the checkout desks. I hope they stay away and leave intelligent folks alone.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
You haven't been to the library lately have you?
December 11, 2008 - 11:12 ET by PamThey have them in my area of MI! :) Once Barnes and Nobles put Starbucks in, it was the natural order of things to come..
On another note about the library..My neice lives across the street from our main library and she buys her internet from them..she goes and uses her computer but spends hours reading...so they are taking in money from sources other than government..
Privatization Anyone?
December 11, 2008 - 11:07 ET by PopularTechPrivatize the libraries and I guarantee many of these will not have to be closed. Libraries pay no taxes, have a limited staff so their major cost is what? Utilities? Only government could screw something like this up.
Carbon Dioxide (CO2) is Not Pollution
King Co. Lib Yearly
December 12, 2008 - 00:35 ET by katainkentKing Co. Lib Yearly Budget - 60% of budget goes to Salary and Benefits
somewhat amusing is that on average we see about 3 employees each time we visit our local library and interact with none of them. Its a completely automated lookup and check out system.
"part of what I'm hoping to introduce as the next president is a new ethic of [government enforced] responsibility" - B. Obama
Lord!
December 11, 2008 - 11:08 ET by heldmyw"Economic Downturn Causes Budgetary Belt-Tightening". This should be about as interesting as "Sun Rises in East: Sky Blue".
Yet, the friggin' MSM acts as though there were volcanoes erupting and vampire leeches arising from the sewers.
What a pack of hysterical nitwits. No wonder they're dying.
Absurd
December 11, 2008 - 11:15 ET by jiminjerseyOkay. Has anyone actually been in a library lately?
They aren't just for reading or research anymore. You can get the latest music CD's, the latest movies and TV series on DVD and use the internet. They have meeting rooms and big screen TV's as well.
This is all very nice. But is it necessary? If we are broke then perhaps we should start acting like it.
Libraries
December 11, 2008 - 11:32 ET by 10ksnookerWomen and children hurt worst.
I happened to have been at the local library yesterday, they got there December shipment of free DVDs, and the line was long. Everybody was trying to get the 'Dark Knight'. Rats, missed it by that much.
Around our area the recession is going just fine, locally we choose not to participate.
we go to the library almost every week
December 11, 2008 - 12:07 ET by katainkentusually there are about 30-40 people there. 20 people on the computers using the internet chat, 5-10 people looking for books or studying and our family of five. Thus far we havent noticed an upswing in people actually looking for books.
We have no local book stores.
Two libraries in our area were recently renovated. Our county system is a good system ($85m/yr) and is funded almost entirely by property taxes (96%).
"part of what I'm hoping to introduce as the next president is a new ethic of [government enforced] responsibility" - B. Obama
"And listen to this one..."
December 11, 2008 - 12:31 ET by SickofLibsThere's get actually a place you can get books for free, and then return them for the next user?
Brian, thanks so much for bringing this fantastic new idea to our attention.
All Liberals are Deranged.
December 11, 2008 - 12:36 ET by CrashWhat the hell is it with that guy who's sobbing like he just had a lobotomy with a rusty railroad spike!? I always thought that liberals were daft ...
Instead of closing down libraries. How about shutting down the computer porn wing and hitting the books?
"A man with an experience is never at the mercy of a man with an argument." Hilmar von Campe
Where do you start?
December 11, 2008 - 12:39 ET by BlueCat57To begin with, who put Blockbuster out of business? Local libraries.
Who put the local bookstore out of business? Local libraries.
The local library is no longer needed to fill its original purpose of supplying books and other media, which were once scarce and expensive.
All forms of media are now affordable to all, even the poor. I have two closets full of childrens books that I can't even give away because everyone we know already has them or has so many they don't want any more. Used book stores are stuffed full of books that won't sell. New book stores have thousands of titles that they have to carry but will never sell.
The whole concept of the public library needs a radical rethinking. But no one will touch this sacred cow.
My biggest complaint about my local library? Most librarians are liberals and they don't carry the conservative and Christian books I want so I end up buying those (used if I can) from an online bookstore. Then they end up sitting in my house gathering dust because I can't even donate them to the library to put into circulation.
I could rant on but I need to run and pick up the DVDs I requested from the library so I don't have to pay for cable or watch commercials on TV.
Find a small-town library, BlueCat
December 11, 2008 - 23:13 ET by Scout FinchMost libraries tend to cater to their local residents, since they are the ones primarily footing the operational funds. The small library I work at has a wide array of Christian fiction, western paperbacks, old fashioned family DVDs, and filters on the computers. We carry the latest books from Bill O'Reilly and Mike Huckabee and others. It may please you to know that our old, worn copy of Ayn Rand's "Atlas Shrugged" has had it's clear plastic cover replaced and spiffed up since it's become a popular book again.
Sure, we also carry liberal authors and book titles, along with most of the Judy Blume "classics", because we try to please everyone. We also are in a system that can easily interloan any title any patron desires. But we promote a family-friendly atmosphere in our library. We even have a Christmas tree by the reading chairs, and we don't call it a "Holiday" tree!
I'd also like to add that in these times of lay-offs and unemployment, our patrons depend on us for computer access for filing unemployment claims, uploading resumes to online job search sites, and books on skills and testing/training for different job opportunities.
Makes Sense
December 11, 2008 - 12:41 ET by MillerTimeWarpI live in a small upstate NY town. They have just finished renovating the old library. They spent 18million (yes the m word) on this project. They even have a robotic book return system. They justify the cost of this thing - it will allow a human that used to collect the returned books to spend her time more wisely by answering questions from the public. As in "Where can I find the free stuff".
All in all I dont blame the library for anything. The nearest Barnes and Noble is 25 miles away. The local mom and pop book store has about 30 books. Most of those are by local writers....how many books do we need about the Adirondacks ?
Golden Palaces
December 11, 2008 - 16:12 ET by BlueCat57$18 million!! Wow! I thought the $3 mil for a new library in our town of 3,000 was a lot. I don't imagine that more than 20 or 30 people a day use the place. My suggestion, which was turned down, was to give everyone in town $100 a year and tell them to buy books, read them, and then exchange them with their neighbors.
Death of the Public Library
December 11, 2008 - 16:57 ET by Jonah JohansenI recently left a job of 14 years at a medium size public library.
I watched the professional librarians slowly destroy that library.
There is a pervasive mentality which dominates the whole field.
They no longer see the library as an educational, cultural institution; they
see it first as a social service and second as a kind of "Fort Apache"
fighting off the book burning know-nothing Christian Conservatives.
Anyone who criticizes libraries or librarians are immediately denounced as
Nazis.
The logic which dominates the whole library community is that
the library should provide what ever the public wants for free and at all costs do not impose your values, instead of buying a copy a multipart historical documentry you buy 5 copie of th new Adam Sandler comedy the kids who want to use the computers to do their homework or use the Encyclopedia program will just have to wait for all the game players and rap video viewers to finish up.
If the public wants free DVDs of popular recent movies so be it, if they
want free internet access for e-mail, chatting, MySpace and porn give them what
they want.
If the public wants bestsellers buy multiple copies. I watched
them buy something like 50 copies of new Harry Potter books to manage the initial
rush of requests. The first day of release the parking lot is full of
Lexus Suvs and BMWs, filled with upper middle class parents and kids picking up
there tax payer supported $15 perk. A month or two later 40 of those 50
books are removed from the collection.
At least half the people using the
public computers have their own computers at home, for whatever reason they
would prefer to sponge off the taxpayer.Instead of them paying 70 cents a day for broadband they would rather have the taxpayer pay 20 times that amount to provide it for them free. I did the math on our regular everyday heavy users and it would have been cheaper for the library in the long run to give them a new computer and pay for their internet.
The dirty secret the con-game is how these librarians justify
their actions by quoting usage statistics. "We are seeing a 10%
increase in teens using public libraries" People hearing this think
"Oh, wonderful young people reading more...that wonderful library is
helping educate our kids" In reality book checkouts are
down significantly, it is teens playing games on the computer or
uploading dirty pictures or rap music links to their MySpace pages which is
responsible for the higher numbers.
Local governments keep allocating money to these freeloader
magnets in the mistaken idea that more library use is an unquestioned good.
You could easily double the usage of public library by simply completing the
current trend. Fill half the library with X-Boxes and Play stations and the
other half with new release DVDs.
Thank you Scout Finch for
December 12, 2008 - 00:21 ET by suzycreamcheeseThank you Scout Finch for your positive post about libraries. I had no idea so many people had such negative opinions about public libraries.
I've been working at a library since 1989. I work in the largest library (4 floors) in my southern state. Perhaps southern libraries are different? Yes, a lot of our librarians are liberals, but they believe in buying materials to please all of the population. We buy just as many conservative nonfiction books as we do liberal. We have a collection committee that decides a fair criteria for choosing materials.
Who can buy all the books or movies they desire to read or watch and have a place to store them in their homes? I'm an avid reader and only buy books for my collection that are special to me. Others that I want to just read I check out from my library and return them. What could be better than that?
We do have a lot of computers for people in our society that can't afford them or Internet access. That's a bad thing? We have a ton of kids doing reports after school; people looking for jobs; people doing research; and we also have people playing games. Our mission statement includes entertainment for the public as well as educational materials. We kick porn users out of the library. It is illegal in our state for people to access porn in public. We are concerned about what our young people might be exposed to in our library. We try to filter porn, but filters aren't always 100% effective. Hey, we're not San Francisco.
Our library has an excellent southern history department that has been praised by people all over the world who visit for research purposes. We also have an entire department dedicated to government documents.
We have seen some funding cut, but overall we still have a large budget for salaries and purchasing materials.
liberal librarians
December 12, 2008 - 01:22 ET by JerYes, a lot of our librarians are liberals, but they believe in buying materials to please all of the population.
I'm sure you have violated a NewsBusters regulation by making this blatantly heretical statement. Hopefully, you'll just get a warning citation. ;-)
Seriously Miss creamcheese, thanks for your admirable work as well as your very encouraging report.
Jer
Lucky you, suzycreamcheese
December 12, 2008 - 01:29 ET by Scout FinchWe have seen some funding cut, but overall we still have a large budget for salaries and purchasing materials.
We'll be begging for a millage increase soon, or our operational funds will be depleted. I'll be using our computers to upload my resume and search for employment!
We kick porn users out of
December 12, 2008 - 01:44 ET by Jack BauerGood. I used to be a librarian, it was my first job. And I am a frequent user of libraries.
Unless it's a national library (Congress, British) even the biggest library cannot carry all books puiblished.
Therefore why should libraries carry pornography in a limited space?
Anyone who argues this is is a "free speech" issue is sadly misinformed.
<i>somewhat amusing is that
December 12, 2008 - 11:29 ET by suzycreamcheesesomewhat amusing is that on average we see about 3 employees each time
we visit our local library and interact with none of them. Its a
completely automated lookup and check out system.
There is a lot of library work that goes on behind the scenes. We have some automated check out machines for independent people who aren't afraid of technology. Everyone else appreciates the human contact and full service of our circulation staff.
And I believe in the "give a man a fish/teach a man to fish" philosophy of library use. We have catalogs on computers and people appreciate most of the time being shown how to search for materials and information themselves. So, I don't see a downside to any automated system.
Jer, I wouldn't want to get kicked off my favorite site for coming to the defense of a *gulp* liberal. But I call them as I see them. People tend to think of all librarians as those nutty west/east coast hippies who push Heather Has Two Mommies on preschoolers and who defend the rights of pedophiles to access porn in front of patrons. That's not true for most libraries in this country.