Perhaps this is coming a little late with the election already underway, but the idea the current economy is as threatened as it was during the Great Depression is unfounded, according to the Nov. 4 USA Today.
"Failed banks. Panicked markets. Rising unemployment. For students of history, or people of a certain age, it all has an all-too-familiar ring. Is this another Great Depression? Not yet," John Waggoner wrote for USA Today
Soup lines, Hoovervilles and other Depression-era imagery have become commonplace in the media. Journalists have compared the current downturn to the Great Depression hundreds of times. On the networks (ABC, NBC and CBS) alone, there were 70 comparisons in the first six months of 2008. Since July 1 that number more than doubled to 157. But as Waggoner pointed out - the similarities aren't even close.
"Our economic woes dwindle in comparison. As of the end of June, the latest data available, the nation's gross domestic product was still growing at a respectable 2.8% rate. In the third quarter, it fell at an annual 0.3% rate. Unemployment in September was 6.1%. ‘We're a long way from the D-word,' says David Wyss, chief economist for Standard & Poor's. ‘It's a recession.'"
Another reason the Great Depression, Part II is not in the realm of possibility is because the government learned its lesson from the Depression. Higher taxes, tariffs and interest rates were the Hoover Administration's responses to the Depression and they ended up making things much worse. But according to Waggoner, the government has been proactive with even the smallest chance of a Depression being a possibility.
"In contrast, the government this time has been active in trying to prevent an economic meltdown, precisely because officials worried about another Great Depression. ... The $700 billion bailout bill, and the fiscal stimulus checks that went out early this year, although controversial, show that the government is willing to intervene in the financial system to keep it afloat."



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
um... DUH!
November 4, 2008 - 16:11 ET by killbill2It's not news to right minded people... Just further evidence that Obama and his MSM cohorts have led the narrative in this election and McCain has been reactionary and even capitulative. John McCain should have worried less about all the popular opinion polling and STUCK TO HIS GUNS! Yes, I am a little frustrated by how poorly the campaign was run IMHO...
...isn't Social Security still failing? How can you not drive that home to older voters? Obama wants to give 40% of the 95% a tax cut out of their FICA deductions... that's such a political homerun it's absurd...
The MSM is scenting the
November 4, 2008 - 16:11 ET by Hunter12The MSM is scenting the victory. Time to start the recovery, so Obama will have something or someone to tax.
"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last." - Sir Winston Churchill
McPaper.
November 4, 2008 - 16:13 ET by R D HelmThey are only saying this because they think Obama is going to win.
If it were the other way around, the economy would be headed for something worse than the Depression.
-Dave
I voted. Have you?
This is another "Dan Quayle
November 4, 2008 - 16:18 ET by mattmThis is another "Dan Quayle was right" moment.
But re. the Depression. The crash happened in 1929, the Depression only began after three years of "bail-out" policies of Hoover, and was worsened by the outright socialism of FDR.
Obama will turn an economic downturn (caused by Democrat policies-i.e. Fannie Mae and too much government spending) into a depression if he gets his redistributionist policies implemented.
Great Depression - HA!
November 4, 2008 - 16:16 ET by BlueCat57How about a Revolution? Any guess at the effective tax rate that the Colonies were revolting over? Try less than 5%. That's right folks all those crazy colonists were risking their lives over a measly 5% tax. Most of us pay that just in sales tax. So next time you are tempted to believe any journalist's historical comparisons do your own research. We have it so good in 21st Century America that even the One won't be able to completely destroy this country. And guess what folks, we can always throw another revolution.
That's like reading Marx to become an entrepreneur.
Just wait........
November 4, 2008 - 17:28 ET by MNotaroJust wait....people think our economy is not as bad as the Great Depression...well, not yet it isn't. But who knows what will happen if the liberal illuminati get into the White House.