Dobbs Claims Salmonella Outbreak 'Sufficient Reason to Impeach a President'

Photo of Jeff Poor.

CNN's Lou Dobbs is known for his fiery protectionist rants, but now he's calling for an extreme response in the wake of the Food and Drug Administration's inability to prevent a salmonella outbreak.

The "Lou Dobbs Tonight" host placed the blame squarely on President George W. Bush, calling for his impeachment on the June 19 broadcast. Contaminated tomatoes from an unknown source or sources have sickened 383 people since April, according to the Associated Press.

"You know, I have heard a lot of reasons over the years as to why George W. Bush should be impeached," Dobbs said. "For them to leave the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in this state, its leadership in this sorry condition and to have no capacity apparently or will to protect the American consumer - that is alone to me sufficient reason to impeach a president who has made this agency possible and has ripped its guts out in its ability to protect the American consumer."

"It's insane what's going on here," said a visibly angry Dobbs. "Is there any sense of embarrassment on the part of the leadership of that agency?"

On June 18, Dobbs called the FDA "excessively intellectually challenged."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Damn, by this standard we

Damn, by this standard we should be able to impeach all members of congress for the yearly flu outbreak and the Supreme Court for an unpaid parking ticket....

Standards, we don't need no

Standards, we don't need no stinkin standards.  All we got to do is feel it is right. 

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

The phrase 'People would

The phrase 'People would rather feel good than be right' came to me the other day and your post brought it back to mind and it seems to fit so many situations anymore. And the list seems to grow each day. The liberals just keep getting farther and farther from reality.

Yeah, why wait for facts.

So, we don't know the origin of the tomatoes, or at what point in the delivery chain the salmonella was introduced, but we should still impeach the president?

If we impeached a president every time someone got sick from salmonella in this country, Inauguration Day would become Inauguration/Impeachment Day.

The only thing that should

The only thing that should be considered impeached is any reputation Lou Dobs may have once enjoyed as a serious commentator.

Presidents aren't gods

Lou, we elect Presidents, not gods.  Even if your complaints about the FDA are accurate, that 's no guarantee that this outbreak wouldn't have happened.  If you expect the Chief Executive to be able to protect us from everything that might go wrong, your expectations are far too high. 

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Maybe if the Obamessiah were

Maybe if the Obamessiah were to bless the tomatoes. . .

Oh, just think....no

Oh, just think....no salmonella outbreaks after January 2009! Obammy, my government mammy!

Oh Lou - why so upset

Now you Lou you - just relax a little bit.

Hey Lou - correct me if I'm wrong but weren't you a red head last week, a grey head the week before - and now YOU'RE BLOND..

What's up Louie ????

Good Grief

Lou, you need to take a day or two off and get your tin foil hat polished up.

I ate some bad guacamole a

I ate some bad guacamole a few years ago and the thought of writing my congressman to impeach the president never occured to me.

1/10,000th of 1% of the

1/10,000th of 1% of the population gets sick from some bad tomatoes and we need to impeach the President? 

By that standard shouldn't ever member of Congress who is coddling to illegal immigrants also be impeached/recalled?  How many people in this country have died at the hands of an illegal immigrant.  My guess is it is more than 383.

Obama '08 - He has the Wright stuff...and that is WRONG for America !!!" 

Can someone please tell me

Can someone please tell me how you get bacteria inside a tomato?  If it is on the outside, can you tell me how it doesn't get washed off?

I read that salmonella is caused by fecal material contact with food.

Now stay with me here. . .

Can't we just wash the sh_t off our tomatoes before we eat them? and all live happily ever after?

Do we need to impeach a president?

Get a Tomato Czar?

Distribute training materials for tomato washing?

Start a new safer tomato entitlement program?

  "Start a new safer

 

"Start a new safer tomato entitlement program?"

With oversight from the Dept of Homeland Security of course.

 

 45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goals.htm

Tax credits for growing your

Tax credits for growing your own tomatoes! 

Start distributing condoms

Start distributing condoms to tomatoes. That "abstinence only" policy ain't working.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq to derail the impeachment vote: “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Dobbs Claims Salmonella

Dobbs Claims Salmonella Outbreak 'Sufficient Reason to Impeach a President'

(sigh)

Did Bush commit treason? No. Did Bush bribe anybody? No. Did Bush commit a felony (high crime)? No. Did Bush commit a misdemeanor? No.

Therefore, Bush's actions do not pass the impeachment test.

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

Grrr...quit trying to use

Grrr...quit trying to use reason when dealing with a liberal!

Lou Dobbs - NJ's resident idiot

The thing that bothers me most about this story is that this idiot is thinking about running for Governor of New Jersey.
The thing that bothers me about that is that the IDIOTS in this state would probably elect him!!!!

True SouthJersey, but look what we got now!

I consider myself a conservative, but the Dims couldn't even replace the 83 year old cadaver with a real candidate on June 3rd.

Once again Lou's bluster misses the point.

Who believes after a week or two the FDA hasn't figured out where the tainted tomatoes came from?  The problem that I see is the cover-up LIE that is hurting growers and purveyors of tomatoes across the country while somebody's amigo is protected.

Crawford, Texas... Of Course!!!

That darn Karl Rove protecting the President's tomato growing friends at home. How could I have missed that? </sarc>

As far as I am concerned

As far as I am concerned Dobb's has gone off his rocker...

I cannot listen to him anymore...I heard this insane rant yesterday when my husband was listening...I told my other half...the man is nuts...he goes on these daily tirades against Pres. Bush and the FDA where he would drive anybody with brains nuts...I turned it...I also am sick of hearing how approx. 280 people are sick from tomatoes out of what here, over 300 million...did it ever occur to Lou baby that people are not taking proper care with the tomatoes...you know, like washing them, being able to tell if they are rotten, keeping them refrigerated ect...

I clicked him off to Beck while I was complaining... 

Enough already...he does okay on illegal immigration, but I think his narcisstic view of his importance has gone beyond reality. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson

As far as I know...

...no one has died from salmonella.

That is not true, however, of the Branch Davidians in Waco.

And I don't recall too many people calling for Clinton's impeachment over the death of 80 or so American citizens at the hands of his Justice Department and ATF.

Note:  I am no defender of David Koresh, justing pointing out a slight inconsistency on the party of Louie.

 

Well, plenty of Libertarians did.

Consistently, from the beginning, and with very little help from others even though they (ok, we) had a very damn good case, for a variety of reasons.
JMR

The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.

Point taken

I really meant to say that I don't remember Dobbs or any of the usual MSM suspects calling for Clinton to be impeached.

You are correct! Wash your

You are correct! Wash your stinkin' veggies & fruit before you eat them and you won't get salmonella.

Dobbs is an idiot

Many years ago, Lou Dobbs was a first rate business reporter. Then he discovered, I suppose, the best way to make hay would be to be a intellectually dishonest shrieking protectionist. Now THIS?

I would say Mr. Dobbs lost any respect I had for him, but one cannot lose what one does not have to begin with.

Res tantum valet quantum vendi potest.

Yep Unsane...I listened to

Yep Unsane...I listened to him also on the CNN business report, Cafferty too...I enjoyed them back then....they are both beyond help now.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson

Is this a joke?

This is a joke, right?   I have a mental image of George Bush sitting in the middle of 80 acres of tomatoes cleaning and shining them one at a time.    There is not enough tin foil in the world for the size of hat Lou Dobbs needs.  

Course correction

Well, since that Congressional committee had to admit that "Bush lied, people died" wasn't true, those afflicted with BDS need another route on their road to impeachment.

No one said it had to be a good route.

End of thread?

Sorry to do this as it may end this funny thread.   But who all remembers the movie and the three great sequels of "The Attack of the Killer Tomatoes" movie?    http://killertomatoe... . Run one of these trailers after Dobbs tonight on CNN and he's gone.  A single tomato got Dan Quayle.  The same can happen to Lou Dobbs.  Beware: listen to the theme song for more than 60 seconds and it will be with you for days. 

LOL...I listened wOtm...I'm

LOL...I listened wOtm...I'm still chucklin' to myself...I really wished somebody could somehow insert that theme song on before Dobb's speaks at the beginning of his show...and the end of it.

Comedy Central indeed.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson

Radiate the tomatoes

I seem to remember proposals over the years, and again recently with an E-Coli scare, proposals for irradiation of foods, including vegatibles to kill dangerous bacteria. I would then assume, that the left would be opposed to such - after all millions of radical leftists remain fearfull of what microwave ovens do to food when reheating them, and refuse to use them.

you're right

The tinfoil hat brigade 'forced' Congress to stop the irratiation of produce. While it won't kill everything, it would have added one more safety feature to our food chain. Perish the thought (pardon the pun, couldn't help it :-)

You know what? I think

You know what?

I think all of this started when we started cracking down on illegal immigration.

The Americans we have picking tomatoes now obviously don't want to do these jobs, so they are not taking care in the proper picking of the produce.

OK, enough sarcasm, now the bad news.

Mark my words: The MSM will bring up this issue claiming that corners were cut in food safety because labor costs have gone up due to the shortage of illegals.

Whatever, Whenever, and Forever

It will be Bush's fault. These people are truly nuts. Do they even think before talking or writing? How in the world is one man supposed to prevent any harm to any person at all times. It just goes to show you how the U.S has turned into a "its got to be someone elses fault and I deserve a settlement" society. Thanks again trial lawyers.

MSD... Yep..one of the

MSD...

Yep..one of the biggest leftist backers, along with the greenies and Dept. of Education....and the rest of the unions...

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson

Let em do it!

Let these idiots set the standard for a president and then lets apply that standard to the next Democrat in office. During Clinton's term planes were falling out of the sky due to underfunded FAA oversight, Apples were making people sick, E-coli outbreaks were happening every other week, 2 separate terrorist attacks on our soil happened- WTC and OK city bombing, it took years for some (15 years) to get power restored in some areas where hurricanes hit, trains carrying civilians were being bombed through our alliance with Nato, Chinese toys had just as much lead in them then yet no one was checking, and where was the outcry to impeach Clinton for these actions? Where were the news stories, where were the hot under the collar opinion commentators screaming that Clinton was an incompetent idiot every time something happened?

http://digg.com/odd_...

 

Lou Dobbs left CNN to form

Lou Dobbs left CNN to form Space.com, the Internet web site about all things space. 

When he returned to CNN, he brought plenty of space with him - between his ears . . .

 

jd... Yeah, I remember

jd...

Yeah, I remember when he announced all of this...I was seriously thinking of buying some stock of his on the dot.coms if memory serves me right, that Space.com was supposed to be on if it came to be...I remember when he said he was quitting CNN, he was even on Imus talking about all of this I'm pretty sure.

He lost a ton of money...Fox was making it big in viewership since/meantime...CNN rehired him for the CNN show he is on now....and wow! I wonder if he has recovered?

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Wilson

I live in Florida...the news

I live in Florida...the news here is saying it isn't at the farm level but at the distribution or processing level (according to the FDA). They are also checking in Mexico. This will cost the Florida growers millions in revenue.