CBS Finds Unique Culprit in Subprime Hardship Story – Race

Photo of Jeff Poor.
  • Bookmark and Share

Fall behind on your mortgage? These days it's anyone's fault but your own according to the mainstream media.

The March 9 "CBS Evening News" found another way to fault home lenders instead of one borrower who took on an ill-planned mortgage that was more than he could pay: the race card.

"[Michael] Wiggins, a city bus driver, was one of millions of Americans caught in the subprime mortgage crisis," CBS correspondent Randall Pinkston said. "His mortgage lenders' network loan gave him an 11-percent interest rate with a payment of $3,900 a month. But that jumped to $4,200 a month because of delinquency fees and penalties. Knowing he was sinking fast, Wiggins looked for refinancing at commercial banks."

This time, instead of blaming the borrower who got in over his head, Pinkston played the race card and suggested the color of Wiggins' skin was to blame for the type of mortgage the bank sold him.

"Some community bankers believe there is a racial component to the subprime mortgage crisis, a belief supported by the Federal Reserve report which shows that 55 percent of black borrowers versus 17 percent of whites were steered to subprime loans, even when they qualified for lower interest rates," Pinkston said

Hard-luck mortgage stories that suggest the borrower should be held responsible for taking on more than he or she could afford are few and far between. Instead, the media focus heavily on worst-case scenarios, using extreme situations to make businesses - in this case mortgage lenders - look bad.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

CBS Network...

By watching this network, you can not only SeeBS, but hear it as well!

»→ $3900 a month mortgage?

How does a bus driver make $12,000 per month?

No way should a person try to take on a mortgage more than 1/3 of monthly income.

This isn't a race thing.

♣ a seal

Pay for a bus driver

 That's just what I was thinking.  Perhaps my hubby should quit the Army and become a bus driver, if they are making that much dough. 

 Just kidding, I don't think he would go for it.  Not as patriotic, and I am sure they frown on bus drivers carrying weapons. :)

Nebraskans for War: Peace through Strength

 Oh, and how the heck is a

 Oh, and how the heck is a jump of $300 a month for a mortgage payment going to be breaking him off if he's pulling down enough money to pay a $3900 monthly payment?  That's just not right.

Nebraskans for War: Peace through Strength

Surprised it took them this long.

I've been waiting for this. Of course, if these same "sub-prime" (read: "under-qualified") borrowers had been denied loans, that also would have been "racist." You can't win against the race card.

Note, too, that the extra $300/month was in "delinquency fees and penalties." Gee, maybe this bus driver really couldn't afford a $3900 mortgage payment! But of course, not giving it to him would have been RACIST!

I am SO tired of this kind of crap. There is REAL racism out there, but stuff like this just makes me suspicious whenever anyone claims to be a victim of racism. The term is tossed around to the point that it's almost lost all credibility.

delete double

delete double

Here is a chart with

Here is a chart with average bus driver salaries nationwide. Even at 20 years experience, it tops out at $67,500. Let's say this guy made the max....that is $5625 a month (before taxes).

What on earth gave him the idea that he could afford a $3900 mortgage????????????

The mind boggles.

»→ Whose tagline is it anyway

I forget who has the great tagline:

There's no sense in being stupid if you can't prove it.

This bus driver should be very proud of his ability to prove it. 

♣ a seal

I believe that would be Fast

I believe that would be Fast Ed, Cool.

»→ Thanks Indiana Joe

And thanks to Fast Ed's Dad for those words of wisdom.

♣ a seal

Much more than 1/3 of net

That's 1/3 of his gross.  But the $3,900 is net money.  That probably closer to 1/2 of his net.

Good grief, again.

I don't buy this story at all.

sean robins
www.seanrobins.com

To the list of life's

To the list of life's certainties of death and taxes, a new certainty can be added: no matter the issue, sooner or later, the MSM will play the race card...

Racism

Does this mean that the Blacks cannot make reasoned decisions? Is CBS implying that Blacks are easily steered and that the evil mortgage folks know this and are targeting these easily steered sheep. In other words these people are so stupid that the Government has to make sure they don't hurt themselves. That the government has too make sure they all are dependent on, what else, the government. Sounds like Katrina all over again too me. I can just hear the mortgage industry rubbing their hands and cackling as they send more black folks into bankruptcy.

Definition of terms...

MSM is not what you think its, MSM = Mostly Slanted Media.

OHH PUKE NOT AGAIN...

Oh here we go yet again with the infamous race card, gee let me take a wild guess everything is whiteys fault. I say that everything should be based on percentages including the distribution of wellfare. Once a person reaches the quota for his or her race all wellfare should be cut off.

They have it wrong

The reason these borrowers even got onto the road toward subprime mortgages is because these banks and mortgage companies were being accused of racism by denying mortgages to lower income people and taken to court.

This just in : Michelle

This just in : Michelle Obama agrees with Randall Pinkston---and she's surely not proud of the way whitey is acting here.

And I thought all money was "green"--silly me

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

Now it's RACIST to give minorities loans!

The National Council of La Raza takes it one step further. The group argues that giving subprime loans to minorities is itself an act of discrimination. Talk about Orwellian double-speak! From an article I co-wrote for Capital Research Center:

Activists also allege that subprime lenders deliberately victimize racial minorities, women, and the elderly, tricking them into accepting grossly unfavorable loan terms.
For example, the National Council of La Raza (“The Race,” in Spanish), argues that subprime loans to racial minorities violate their civil rights. Earlier this year a coalition of racial preference groups demanded that subprime mortgage lenders slap a six-month moratorium on foreclosures, arguing that lenders should have known better than to lend money to people with bad credit, many of whom are minorities. The coalition said subprime mortgages are “reckless and unaffordable,” and they warned that lenders, realtors and investors who bought up subprime loans could be sued under a federal law that forbids housing discrimination.
It was the lenders’ responsibility to “match families to the sustainable loans that they should have gotten in the first place,” said Janet Murguia, president of La Raza. Pointing to 2005 data that show subprime loans with high interest rates comprised more than 50% of all mortgages taken by African-Americans and 40% of Latino borrowers, compared to 19% of white borrowers, she raised the specter of racism. Murguia failed to mention that without a subprime market many members of racial minority groups would have remained renters, unable to buy a home.

[Emphasis added.] From pages 2 and 3 of the article at http://www.capitalre...

Matthew Vadum is Editor of Organization Trends and Foundation Watch, two monthly newsletters published by

OK Then...

It's racism when minorities can't get credit and it's racism when they can. Draw to the only conclusion...everyone other than minorities are racists.

The National Council of LaRaza huh? I'm still waiting for someone to start-up the National Association of White People.  I'd join just to spite those racist bastards of LaRaza and the NAACP. If it weren't for them, the word would probably disappear from our language.

It's racist to not give

It's racist to not give loans to minorities; it's racist to give loans to minorities. I guess it's just racist to not tailor loans to individual needs.

Those lousy racist mortgage lenders!! They should ahve just figured out what those people could afford, and agreed to settle for that amount of payment every month.

Any day now Obama will come out with an addendum to his plan...along with a "living wage," free health care, college for every kid, and a comfy retirement, he will add in  "an affordably morgaged house for every family."  

 

Caucasian lenders only?

Why must we assume all mortgage lenders are white?

How many black mortage lenders gave loans to other blacks?

Just asking that question makes you a racist, Mica. Come along! - PC police are watching

Mica, you have to know that

Mica, you have to know that even if a black lender refuses to give a loan, or gives a subprime loan to a black buyer, that is still racist, because he is discriminatig against the black buyer in the first instance, or deliberately saddling him with an untenable loan in the second...his color doesn't matter.

Tracing it back to the roots Mother

What Shelby Steele labeled as the “politics of difference” in a 1993 (concept first published in 1992) eye-opening article in USA Today. That sow has grown so obese, I’m not sure it’s possible to put the hog back in the pen.

Excerpt - “The black power movement encouraged a permanent state of rage and victimhood. An even greater failing was that it rejoined race and power–the very “marriage” that civil rights legislation had been designed to break up. The leaders of the original movement said, “Anytime you make race a source of power you are going to guarantee suffering, misery, and inequity.” Black power leaders declared: “Were going to have power because were black”.”

“Is there any conceivable difference between black and white power? When you demand power based on the color of your skin, aren’t you saying that equality and justice are impossible? Somebody is going to be in, someone else out. Somebody is going to win or lose, and race again is a source of advantage for some and disadvantage for others. Ultimately, black power was not about equality or justice, but, as its name suggests, about power.”

“When blacks began to demand entitlements based on their race, feminists soon responded with enthusiasm, “We’ve been oppressed, too!” Hispanics maintained, “Were not going to let this bus pass us by,” and Asians stated, “We’re not going to be left out either.” Eskimos and Native Americans quickly hopped on the bandwagon, as did gays, lesbians, the disabled, and other self-defined minorities.”

“By the 1970s, the marriage of race and power was firmly established again. Equality was out; the “politics of difference” was in. From then on, people would rally around the single quality that makes them different and pursue power based on that characteristic. It is a very simple formula. All you have to do is identify that quality, whatever it may be, with victimization, which is itself, after all, a tremendous source of moral power.”

“The politics of difference demanded shifting the entire basis of entitlement in America. Historically, it was based on the rights of citizenship elaborated in the Declaration of Independence and the US. Constitution. This was the kind of entitlement the original civil rights movement leaders claimed for blacks–recognition of their rights as American citizens to equal treatment under the law. They did not insist, “We deserve rights and entitlements because we are black,” but “We deserve them because we are citizens of the United States and like all other citizens are due these rights.” The politics of difference changed all that. Blacks and other minorities began demanding entitlement solely based on their history of oppression, their race, sex, ethnicity, or whatever quality that allegedly made them victims.”

The above link is worth chasing to understand the process of victim production.  Sorry for the length of the above post but it's nice to recall the origin of the politics of racism, sexism, genderism and all the other isms that have made most Americans victims....at least in their own minds. 

Shelby Steele is an amazing

Shelby Steele is an amazing mind and an amazing writer. I don't have time to read that whole thing right now...I didn't realize it was 5 pages ...but I will bookmark it and get back to it.

PS Do you have a link to the USA Today article? I can't seem to find "opinion" on the USA homepage

 

DUCT TAPE ALERT!!!

It was the lenders’ responsibility to “match families to the sustainable
loans that they should have gotten in the first place,” said Janet
Murguia, president of La Raza

And if they said to the borrower, you can't afford this house, you can only afford that house, they would be accused of discrimination, of redlining, etc.

See, I was right in my other comment. The lenders should just agree to accept whatever those borrowers could afford.

lenders, realtors and investors who bought up subprime loans could
be sued under a federal law that forbids housing discrimination.

And now they can be accused of discrimination for GIVING these people loans????

Talk about Bizarro World.... 

Let's see... minorities are more likely to need subprime loans because of bad credit....Maybe they should just sue the major credit bureaus for giving minorities bad credit ratings in disproportionate numbers....

Oh great, something else they haven't thought of yet....

Good think I replenished my supply of duct tape over the weekend!!

 

mb,

Maybe they should just sue the major credit bureaus for giving minorities bad credit ratings in disproportionate numbers....

Honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if this actually happens.

Theme for Election '08: I want my mommy!

I know, RD...I'm afraid that

I know, RD...I'm afraid that now that I've said it, it will actually happen! LOL

Responsible Lending ???

Try forced lending.  Just imagine this scene: Mr. Wiggins walks into the bank a few years ago looking for a mortgage and they tell him, "Sorry, you don't qualify for an amount that high.  We suggest you look for a less expensive home."  The next day, the Reverends Al and Jesse would be dancing in the street in front of the bank making racism accusations against the bank and Nancy Pelosi would be on CNN explaining how the Bush tax cuts for the rich have made it impossible for Mr. Wiggins to get a loan.

The bank is screwed one way or the other.  In retrospect, the bank should have tossed Mr. Wiggins to the curb at loan application time and fought a racism lawsuit then.  Now the bank has the racism lawsuit AND a foreclosed piece of property in their inventory.

The real trouble

ADDI 2003, google it.

Crock of BS is at it again....

when I think bus driver I'm reminded how nice Ralph Kramden's digs were on Chauncy Street! Boy, Bus Drivers have sure come a long way!

Saw this link on Hot Air a couple of weeks ago, check it out for a most excellent sub prime primer.

http://hotair.com/ar...

 

This town needs an enema! - The Joker

White Guilt

Shelby Steele has written a gem on race.

Check it out, it is spot on.

 

Bus Driver - How much does he make?

I'm all ferklempt!

A City bus driver?  What city?  How the heck much money does he make?

According to my calculations, if he was paying $3,900 per month - assuming it includes moderate property taxes, a typical 30 years, and 11% (good grief!) - the amount of his loan principal was approximately $360,000.

What city pays bus drivers enough to support a $360,000 home, and $3,900 (original) monthly payments?

And if he makes enough to have made the $3,900 payments to start with, he's not your typical "sub-prime" buyer with no credit, and no means.

But a "city bus driver"?  I can't get that part of his CV out of my head.  This is another load of CBS bushwa! 

sean robins
www.seanrobins.com