CBS 'Global Warming Special' Host Likened Warming Skeptics to Holocaust Deniers

Photo of Jeff Poor.

While most of the country was watching the Green Bay Packers play the New York Giants, CBS aired an hour-long, severely one-sided special about the threat of global warming.

The special was hosted by CBS's Scott Pelley. In January 2007, Pelley was asked why he refused to include global warming skeptics in his reporting. He responded, "If I do an interview with [Holocaust survivor] Elie Wiesel, am I required as a journalist to find a Holocaust denier?"

The January 20 CBS special attacked the Bush White House for not being willing to sign the Kyoto Protocol after he was elected - furthering the common misconception that Bush has been alone in his opposition to it, as the Senate actually voted 95 to 0 to reject Kyoto earlier.

Pelley took a very conspiratorial tone.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

"Dozens of federal agencies report science, and much of it is edited at the White House before it's sent to Congress and the public," Pelley said. "It appears that climate science is edited with a heavy hand. These drafts of climate reports were co-written by Rick Piltz for the federal climate change science program. But Piltz says his work was edited by the White House to make global warming seem less threatening."

The White House declined comment, and Pelley didn't include anyone else to answer allegations or scientific claims.

Pelley's hour-long special didn't offer a single scientist who was skeptical of these catastrophic global warming claims. However, a report released by the U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works (EPW) Committee December 20 has revealed more than 400 prominent scientists questioning the hype.

The special also warned of cataclysmic consequences if global warming wasn't addressed.

"Tremendous redistribution in where one would be able to have agriculture, tremendous changes in storm patterns. You could very well see sea level rises on the order of several feet and perhaps even several tens of feet," Paul Mayewski, director of the Climate Change Institute at the University of Maine, said. "If sea level were to rise it would be tremendous changes, immense migrations."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Alarmists

Really, I call the anthropomorphic global warming adherents: alarmists.  These chicken littles are yelling "fire" on a crowded earth.

Alarmists love calling skeptics deniers

If they could prove what they preach via the scientific method there would be nothing to argue about, instead they try to silence anyone skeptical of doomsday due to CO2:

Global Warming Ad Hominem Attacks Show Alarmist Believers' Desperation (Heartland Institute)
Global Warming Denial = Holocaust Denial? (FrontPage Magazine)
Global Warming Smear Targets (David R. Legates, The Marshall Institute)
Hooey Denier Deniers (RealClearPolitics)
Ignorance Is Strength, Dissent Is Treason (The National Review)
Newsweek: Alarmed by Deniers (The American Spectator)
- Greenhouse Simplicities (Newsweek)
Newsweek: Global-Warming Skeptics Are Like Moon-Landing Deniers (Business and Media Institute)
Nuremberg-Style Trials Proposed For Global Warming Skeptics (US Senate Environment & Public Works Committee)
Public 'in denial' about climate change (The Daily Telegraph, UK)
Scientists threatened for 'climate denial' (The Daily Telegraph, UK)

The Anti "Man-Made" Global Warming Resource

I got my Global Warming

I got my Global Warming Skeptic discount credit card in the mail from Shell just last Saturday! And I expect cards from Exxon and BP any day now! It's ten percent off the price at the pump just for being part of the conspiracy to deny global warming. Not to mention the free oil change four times a year and the coffee mug too. All I have to do is sign a few on-line petitions and send in a few form letters to the local news rag. It pays to be a global warming skeptic!

Damn, you get all that??

Damn, you get all that?? Where do I sign up?

Global Warming Farce

So following Pelley's reasoning, if he did a story about Holocaust deniers, he would not have to interview any survivors, like Elie Wiesel, who might cast doubt on the believability of his story.

Classic liberal reasoning.. The story iswhat matters...not the facts.

And

If he did a piece on global warming skeptics, I bet he would have at least a dozen or so GW propagandists ready to argue.  That there, to me, be the bias.

Holocaust = Science?

Pelley's analogy doesn't make sense since I don't recall scientists ever debating the Holocaust. The only deniers I ever hear about seem to be anti-semitic muslims.

 

 

 

GW is like a god that

GW is like a god that demands sacrifices. in this instance, capitalism is the thing that must be sacrificed to assuage the angry god GW.

For now. If one gets deep

For now. If one gets deep into the environmental religion, it's humanity itself that is a yeast infection in the vagina of Mother Gaia. I tried reading one of the faith's recent "testaments" The World Without Us by Alan Weisman. But I got tired of reading chapters that start, for example, with such lines as "When humans depart, among the immediate beneficiaries of our absence will be mosquitos."

Geez, I thought

I was a buffet for mosquitoes. Besides I thought we only endangered ocean life like whales and dolphins etc. Would you like to start a "Save the Mosquitoes" campaign? I bet the libs would jump all over it!

Ban Hydrogen Dioxide!

Yep, just like when Penn and Teller had some folks go around with a petition at some enviro tree hugging festival-- the content of the petition? Banning Hydrogen Dioxide.

The petitioners would say true but misleading stuff like, "Millions of people have died when they inhaled hydrogen dioxide. It's colorless, odorless, and it can be deadly."

Great stuff. I think you can find it on YouTube.

[BTW, The chemical symbol for Hydrogen Dioxide is H20.]

It's actually called

It's actually called Dihydrogen Monoxide. Hydrogen dioxide is H2O2

Here is the Penn/Teller video

Great Vid...

Thanks for sharing...

For the nonbelievers of DHMO, take that hose & put it into the car, attach the other end to the outside DHMO outlet located on the side of most houses, turn on, get back into car, breathe in...

Syrius

 

 

isn't h2o2

isn't h2o2 Hydrogen Peroxide, the stuff to clean wounds??

I may be wrong

and I LOVE that Penn and Teller bit, my favorite one is the guy who says " Yea I've heard of that"  trying to sound worldly and "smart"

 

"Get off the phone you big dope!!!!!!!!!!" Mark Levin

"I was a buffet for

"I was a buffet for mosquitoes. Besides I thought we only endangered
ocean life like whales and dolphins etc. Would you like to start a
"Save the Mosquitoes" campaign? I bet the libs would jump all over it!"

They already have. Why do you think they prefer nets over DDT?

"If I do an interview with

"If I do an interview with [Holocaust survivor] Elie Wiesel, am I required as a journalist to find a Holocaust denier?"

How do you compare an historical, documented event to speculating about future weather events?  No you don't have to interview a holocaust denier but yes you do have to interview a scientist who supports the other side of an unproven and greatly debated hypothesis.

You said it, brother.

You said it, brother.

media bias denier

“…you don't have to interview a holocaust denier but yes you
do have to interview a scientist who supports the other side of an unproven and
greatly debated hypothesis.”

No you don’t! You do
not have to interview [someone] who supports the other side of an unproven and
greatly debated hypothesis, if you are a biased media bias denier!

 

Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.

Bingo. But that's logical.

Bingo. But that's logical. Don't try logic with a liberal. They look at you like a dog does when he hears a sound he can't figure out from which direction it's coming.

Then they just get ticked off and rant something to see if they can throw you off your thoughts, or ask a question with a question to see if they can get the conversation going in a direction they can comprehend better.

These GW twits have a lot

These GW twits have a lot of nerve...they really do.

Eleven below here...just went to get some wood....

GW my arse...well I am a denier. 

Along with many other TV shows

I have stopped watching 60 minutes, and I turn it off quicker if Scott Pelley is the one presenting the story. I know it will be ONE SIDED and he attempts to put my beliefs and those I agree with in as bad a light as possible. When I think back over the rare story I have heard he is so blatently anti-American it isn't even funny. Or do I mean liberal? Hmmm...

And just how did he get to

And just how did he get to the Artic (or where ever he was) anyway? I am sure that CBS has some stock footage of icebergs laying around so he didn't have to generate tons and tons of Co2 to get there!
Nortonalec

No, No

THEY are so important all the GWing "rules" do not apply to them, please, what are you thinking?

Well I find it ironic they

Well I find it ironic they air this while most of the country was watching a football game where the temperature was 2 below and it was colder in Green Bay than it was in Alaska.

 

Do you realize how much it costs to run for office? More than any honest man could afford. -Montgomery Burns

This is not new. A couple

This is not new. A couple of years ago, AGW advocates convinced many in the MSM that it was "irresponsible" to present the other side of the argument.

And they haven't been deterred by their failure to get centrally-controlled thermostats in homes in California. These people just regroup and come at things from a different angle.

Since the 70's they have gone from "acid rain" to "global warming" to "climate change" and now their newest angle is "Carbon Footprint" as the way to control lives. The last paragraph is the money quote:


“Carbon footprint” is code for limitless government intrusion into every detail of your life. Nothing is beyond the reach of a government determined to reduce your carbon footprint in the name of the environment. To these people, nothing is sacred, nothing is private, nothing is truly yours.

 

Another poor excuse

...from the corporate communist corrupt press and yet another example of what I call enviro-fascism--that's saying the Earth is far better than anything else and anyone who says otherwise is punished. Of course the leftist enviro movement has far deep roots in socialism, but you won't hear that in the new CCCP.

You know, people ask me what

You know, people ask me what I like to watch on TV, and I always tell them that I simply don't watch TV. And I really don't, because TV is a easy way for others to manipulate how you think. And I would rather not put up with that burden. Nor, I like to think, would other people who recognize it.

That's why you wear the

That's why you wear the tinfoil hat.

...duh.

If that comment was

I should probably inform you that I am not what they call a "Paultard." :)

(signature):
You know, people ask me what I like to watch on TV, and I always tell
them that I simply don't watch TV. And I really don't, because TV is a
easy way for others to manipulate how you think. And I would rather not
put up wi

George F. Will

I love how George Will ended today's column on "John McCain - He's a Democrat," as it relates to the Global Warming debate.

"Interesting, is it not, that no one considers it necessary to insist that 'the debate has ended' about whether the Earth is round. People only insist that a debate stop when they are afraid of what might be learned if it continues. "

*****

"There are no stupid questions. Only stupid people who ask questions." - Chris Berman 

Scottie Pelley should read the New York Times

Why is it when the Times and Boston Globe state there is nothing that can be done about global warming and the world should instead prepare how to deal with climate change..........that they are not on Pelley's conspiratory list as they call Al Gore a huckster for profit.

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

They almost got one thing right

There's no doubt "tremendous redistribution" is an issue associated with global warming or climate change or whatever the term du jour is.

Of course it's the tremendous redistribution of wealth proposed to be spent chasing this phantom menace that's really the issue.

Of course it's the


Of course it's the tremendous redistribution of wealth proposed to be spent chasing this phantom menace that's really the issue.

masslib...not only money, it's about "control"....see my comment above for a link to "Carbon Footprint". It's a good article about how the CF angle gives government control over virtually everything.

Wow, The Convienient Lie: Sequel

This is just sad that our media has gotten so hyped about global warming, a non-existent, natural condition that occurs every 500 years. What happened in 1500? The earth warmed. What happened in 2000? The earth warmed. TO AL GORE: Do some ACTUAL research.

Tonight, a stupid green report will be on NBC 30, Connecticut's Liberal News Leader, the green reports are so dumb and such a waste of money. The reason why they are there is just because there isn't any real news going on in Connecticut.

I forced myself to watch

I forced myself to watch this crap last night. I found myself screaming multi-syllable curse words at the TV! But I felt I had to be informed. It is unbelievable how far these socialists will go.

My favorite part was the Hansen interview. For a guy who claims the President and NASA is censoring him, he sure gets to talk a lot! Also kudos to Scott for conjuring up images of the old Soviet Union, by saying Hanson was only allowed to speak with someone from NASA in the room. What a crock of $hit!

Yep...I saw this Baloney program..Briefly

The Guy had to go to Chile, to find a melting Glacier......(it was too Cold to go all the way to Anartica)....and the Glacier has been melting since the late 1800's. 

The guy was so high level, non Specific, and Non Scientific......but he was Emotional and was predicting the future.   Another weather diety.

"Barack Obama is a Powerful Speaker—And so is My Bose Bass Amp"  Doug Giles

Meet the New Dan Rather.

In Pelley's defense, why should he have to prove science fiction?

In science we are required to prove both the positive and the negative. AWG has yet to do this and NASA still cannot lift or land the shuttle with 100% certainty ... weather's a bitch for scientists to predict a day ahead of the big show.

Pelley-smelly

"It appears that climate science is edited with a heavy hand."

Well, at least he said "appears". He is such a smartass.

Earth's out of balance, hmm

One of the scientists interviewed said the Earth was out of balance (climate-wise).

How can that even be remotely consider a problem?  The Earth is always out of "balance".  If the climate was "balanced" wouldn't it be like living in a climate-controlled home?  Where there is no weather because everything is "in balance", no rain, no storms, no wind.

As for "balance" what about the bazillion inputs to the Earth's climate everyday? From belching volcanoes to cosmic rays to insolation to the oceans?  Somehow some barely noticable trace gas has risen in its concentration (from 280ppm to 380ppm, a mere 100ppm rise) and now the climate is out of balance!?

When I heard that I knew that the scientist who said it was a nut job.

 

 

The earth warms, the earth cools.

It always has, and it always will. What people like this jackass are doing is pure fascism. Like, "the debate is over" from the Owl Gore. Oh really? I thought liberals were all for diversity of opinions and "discussing dissenting opinions" and other "liberal" topics. What happened?

One other thing these buttplugs on the Jim Jones Global Walarmist Cult Freak left can't get straight is that many Conservatives believe GW may be real, but human activity has little to nothing to do with it - as in a correlation to solar activity. Funny how you never see global warming freakshow rallies in January, eh?

By the way, didn't we just have two complete years of NO hurricane activity when both years (2006, 2007) were forecasted to be above average and some big ones were to hit US shores? We can't even get THAT accurate yet we are to know for a fact we are causing GW? I don't think so. Tell these stupid GW anti-capitalist liberals to piss off.

I do believe they have

I do believe they have interviewed a Holocaust denier with Ahmanutjob. So YES, you have to interview a "global warming denier" whatever that means. I prefer the term "realist" or "non-fearmonger."

The Rocky Mountain Collegian: Illustrating Idiocy

Cold and Heat Shall Not Cease

Temperature fluctuations are part of the natural cycles God built into the earth.

Genesis 8:22

While the earth remaineth, seedtime and harvest, and COLD AND HEAT, and summer and winter, and day and night shall not cease [i.e."global" warming is NOT going to bring global catastrophe to the earth as Al Gore claims].

Also, the shields of the earth are not Man's OR Al Gore's ... they're God's (i.e. HE takes care of any "global" environmental issues, not Man or Mr. Manbearpig).

Psalms 47:9

The princes of the people are gathered together, even the people of the God of Abraham: FOR THE SHIELDS OF THE EARTH BELONG UNTO GOD : He is greatly exalted.

The earth isn't going to overheat, we're not going to get hit by some giant asteroid, we're not going to have global flooding, we're not going to be wiped out by nuclear war, we're not going to have another ice age, etc. etc. ... THE SHIELDS OF THE EARTH ARE THE LORD'S.

CBS and AGW

I watched this show, kink of kooky. They are, of course, trying to tie any thing skeptical on Exxon.

My favorite part shows the "reporter" in Greenland talking about the melting ice sheets. They don't say anything about the ice that is covered with some type of dark colored particulate matter (soot from China?). I thought that dark colored material absorbs heat and it on ice, would cause melting.

Speaking of melting ice caps, check out these stories on vocanic actitivty in Greenland and the Anctartic. (Exxon must be at it again)

http://www.medindia....

http://www.iht.com/a...

But Antarctica is Not Melting


Antarctica - Antarctic ice sheet thickening, researcher says (Associated Press)
Antarctica - Antarctic Sea Ice at Record High (The Reference Frame)
Antarctica - Antarctic Sea Ice Increases over Past Two Decades (Space.com)
Antarctica - Antarctic Temperatures Disagree With Climate Model Predictions (Science Daily)
Antarctica - East Antarctica's surface slowly rising (The New York Times)
Antarctica - Ice Core 'Dipstick' Indicates West Antarctic Ice Has Thinned Less Than Believed (Science Daily)
Antarctica - Ice 'thickens' in West Antarctica (BBC)
Antarctica - No Major Changes Seen In Stability Of Antarctic Ice Sheet (Science Daily)
Antarctica - Pondering A Climate Conundrum In Antarctica; Unique, Distinct Cooling Trend Discovered On Earth's Southernmost Continent (Science Daily)
Antarctica - Researchers find Antarctic ice is thickening (USA Today)
Antarctica - Satellites Show Overall Increases In Antarctic Sea Ice Cover (NASA)
Antarctica - Scientists Detect Thickening Of West Antarctic Ice Sheet (Science Daily)
Antarctica - Scientists Rule Out One Threat Of Antarctic Collapse (Science Daily)
Antarctica - Snowfall-Driven Growth in East Antarctic Ice Sheet Mitigates Recent Sea-Level Rise (Science)
Antarctica - Study: Antarctic Ice Sheet Is Thickening, Not Thinning (ABC News)
Antarctica - The Antarctic Ice Sheet is Growing Thicker (Not by Fire but by Ice)

As for Greenland...

Greenland - Current Melting of Greenland's Ice Mimics 1920s-1940s Event (Science Daily)
Greenland - Dramatic Ice loss in the Greenland seas in 1817 (A History of the Royal Society Archive)
Greenland - ERS altimeter survey shows growth of Greenland Ice Sheet interior (ESA - European Space Agency)
Greenland - Fossil DNA Proves Greenland Once Had Lush Forests; Ice Sheet Is Surprisingly Stable (Science Daily)
Greenland - Greenland's Glaciers Have Been Receding for 100 Years (University of Aarhus, Denmark)
Greenland - Greenland Ice Sheet Changes Are Normal; No Evidence Of Long-Term Climate Changes (Science Daily)
Greenland - Greenland Temperatures Coldest in 60 Years (The Heartland Institute)
Greenland - Heat From Earth's Magma Contributing To Melting Of Greenland Ice (Science Daily)
Greenland - Is Greenland really melting? (Patrick J. Michaels, Ph.D. Ecological Climatology)
Greenland - Latest Scientific Studies Refute Fears of Greenland Melt (US Senate Environment & Public Works Committee)
Greenland - Letter to the Editor: Greenland Ice Gain Since World War II (The Heartland Institute)
Greenland - Magma may be melting Greenland Ice (MSNBC)
Greenland - Recent cooling in coastal southern Greenland and relation with the North Atlantic Oscillation (American Geophysical Union)
Greenland - Study Shows Greenland’s Ice Growing (CO2 Science)
Greenland - The Cold Truth about Greenland (Patrick J. Michaels, Ph.D. Ecological Climatology)

Huckabee: Raising Taxes OK
The Anti "Man-Made" Global Warming Resource

And the truth shall make you free ...

... nice work, PopularTech.

These global warming antichrists want to bind everyone with their insane doctrine and science falsely so called, yet the truth shall set men free from this ecomilitant and ungodly religion.

1 Timothy 6:20-21

(20) O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and oppositions of science falsely so called:

(21) Which some professing have erred concerning the faith. Grace be with thee. Amen.

John 8:31-32

(31) Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, "If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed;

(32) And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."

Sci-Fi 101

At another site we had a discussion about AGW. No matter how many links, citations or proven science we showed the crazed IPCC socialists, they always claimed it wasn't real proof. They would often ask if "[we] were climatologist" or start tossing around the buzzwords Halliburton or Fascist. If the IPCC report stood for Inter-corporational instead of Inter-governmental, the socialist* would be crying foul. 

*By socialist, I mean liberal, anti-capitalist, communist, & leftist in the worst possible way. 

Problem with the Greenland

Problem with the Greenland ice sheets "retreating".  The glaciers that supposedly never retreated. They're now finding branches and other organic matter under them. Branches which unfortunately can be and have been C-14 dated to the medieval warm period.

Contrary to the reports of the demise of the medieval warm period. The MWP is still alive and well.  

"There is a clear attempt to establish truth not by scientific methods but by perpetual repetition."
- Richard S. Lindzen, Ph.D. Professor of Meteorology, MIT

Pelley should where a big

Pelley should where a big ol' safety helmet when he does these reports and we'd take him more seriously.

Has anyone seen

this article on Fox http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,324446,00.html It states "Sweden to study belching cows". What a farce.

The Big Lie

It's actually appropriate that Pelley use the holocaust analogy because the alarmist tactics come directly from Mein Kampf:

“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.” -- Joseph Goebbels, propaganda minister for Adolph Hitler

Now repeat after me: 

Carbon dioxide will scorch the Earth, the planet will warm uncontrollably, it will cause massive droughts, pestilence and disease will spread and our luxurious oceanfront homes will be flooded.  We must cut carbon, we must cut carbon, we must cut carbon ....

And then wealth and prosperity can be repealed.

   - Does Al Gore seriously think that we should reduce the U.S. standard of living until developing countries catch up with us economically? -- Ed Koch, former mayor of New York City

There are clearly people on

There are clearly people on this site who know a thing or two about science. Alas, I am not one of them. To that end, I wish to put forth the following anecdotal evidence that global warming is a big steaming pile of bullpie.

When I started my car this morning, it was 7 degress F. The temperature rose to a balmy 18 with a wind chill back around 7.

The moment I see penguins in my backyard or I'm able to grow oranges in Pennsylvania, then I'll buy into gloabl warming.

By the way, wasn't the football game that preceded this nonsense experiencing rather frigid temperatures, too?

Common Sense Trumps Intellectual Stupidity ...

... every time.

Tell Canada, Alaska, Greenland, Iceland, Norway, Finland, Siberia, or Antarctica that there's "global" warming ... they're going to scream, "WE NEED IT!!! BRING IT ON!!! DUMP AS MUCH FRICKIN' CARBON IN THE ATMOSPHERE AS YOU CAN!!! IT'S FLIPPIN' -70 DEGREES FOR GOD'S SAKE!!!

"Global" warming is the biggest white elephant in human history ... to the tune of TRILLIONS of taxpayer dollars.

Holy Shinto ... We NEED Global Warming

Ever spent a winter in Chicago?

Or New England? or Canada? or Siberia?

My God, man ... we NEED global warming to save the planet from the global disaster of "global freezing".

If these global warming idiots did the same thing with the numbers from FREEZING weather as they do with the numbers from WARM weather ... you could build a doomsday scenario for global catastrophe from global COOLING.

Cherry-pick your cold temperatures, have weather stations put their thermometers in the shade instead of on brick walls exposed to 10 hours of direct sunlight, create computer models that "prove" global cooling and the threat of the next ice age, get a Democrat who could barely maintain a 'C' in basic science to become the messiah for your cause, and then create billions of dollars in government funding to keep your religion operating into perpetuity.