NBC's coverage of a new bill that restricts credit card companies has been riddled with contradictions - first attacking companies for taking advantage of young people, then admitting students need to build credit.
On May 14 "Nightly News" anchor Brian Williams said, "graduates enter the world with awful credit card debt" and then reporter Lisa Myers demonized credit card companies for student debt and praised possible government intervention.
The House passed a bill on May 20 to restrict credit card companies which would make it very difficult for consumers under 21 to obtain a credit card unless they have a parent co-sign the card or prove they can pay.
That will make things difficult for college students who need to establish a line of credit to rent an apartment, buy an airline ticket or purchase a car. That was ignored by NBC "Nightly News" May 19 and CBS "Early Show" on May 20. "Good Morning America" didn't report the credit card story at all on May 20.
Ironically, a "Money 911" segment on NBC's "Today" included personal finance expert and author David Bach. He suggested that a young woman who called in should get a credit card to establish a line of credit.
Bach said, "The reason you don't have a higher credit score is that you're young and you don't actually have a credit line. So yes, we're gonna shock you right now, you should go open up a credit card account." He continued to say that setting a card up to pay one bill automatically will create a history of on time bill payments that will increase her credit score.
The new restrictions will hamper this process.
While "The Early Show" noted the age restrictions missed by "Today," they did not examine the consequences. CBS did quote a proponent of the measure - Sen. Chuck Shumer, D-N.Y. - who said, "For consumers across the country, who are drowning in credit card debt, a lifeboat has just arrived."
Cato Institute's Mark A. Calabria criticized the bill on May 11 saying, "Congress should also further examine the wisdom of restricting credit to college students under the age of 21. Outside of the obvious age discrimination, why treat adults between the ages of 18 and 21 any differently from those above 21?"
Calabria was included NBC "Nightly News" May 19 but was only quoted saying, "Even if I thought that this was the best bill possible; I think the timing is absolutely wrong."
Network criticism of the credit card bill has focused on rate hikes and fees that may be put into place until the law takes effect in nine months. That glossed over the unintended impact on the credit of young adults.



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Restrict Credit Cards to those Over 21?
May 20, 2009 - 16:49 ET by allanfI thought you had to be over 18 to sign a contract in most states. Lot's of students used credit responsibly and student credit cards are no worse than student loans. So now an 18 year old can sign up for a loan but not a credit card? /
Such restrictions on contracts are a state perogative not a Federal one. This one might violate the equal protection clause.
Yep another law....
May 20, 2009 - 17:03 ET by NavyBuckeyeman our youth can join the military (like myself) and die for your country but you can't drink a beer legally and now you cant even establish your credit..
Hello, I'm Private Eighteen year old...can I get a credit card please....I do have a job...
Government "NO!!!!!"
Two minutes later
Bam....your dead.....
So glad I signed up to defend this "Land of the Free"
"You see Obama is going to tax those not payin taxes...those making
over 97,000 dollars ayear. Once you make that much you don't pay
taxes...he's going to make them pay. And I will finally get a break." -My mom who is on welfare and foodst
so what industry is next for Big O Gov to interfere with?
May 20, 2009 - 17:59 ET by UndercoverConservativeMore involvement with fast food? Or taking over the baby formula industry and forcing changes there? I know! Cable and Satellite Television! Force cheap rates so all can get the 24/7 MSM love fest!
WWW.GS2AC.COM. 2nd Amendment Grass Roots Action in the Bay Area, CA. We're not all "Breakfast Cereal" folks here! :)
→ Even worse UC
May 20, 2009 - 18:08 ET by Cool ArrowHe could drive down Big Pharma and the Hospital System to the point of bailout.
"I was fighting a war in Iraq!" - Nancy Lugosi
Uh...CoolArrow...
May 20, 2009 - 20:11 ET by c5thenThey refer to that as "healthcare reform".
Hey, I got the wrong "CHANGE"!
www.loyaltoliberty.com
→ Like . . DUH!
May 20, 2009 - 20:26 ET by Cool ArrowI forgot they already have that one tackled behind the scenes.
"I was fighting a war in Iraq!" - Nancy Lugosi
The present credit card
May 21, 2009 - 01:15 ET by jdhawkThe present credit card regime is designed to penalize, wait for it, those who either don't pay on time or at all. The important aspect of this new "law" is that now those that pay their bills on time will be penalized.
Now: Do you pay your credit card bill on time? Great, you get the lowest interest rates, or perks like cash back, or frequent flyer miles, etc., some or all of the above. You don't pay your bill on time? Your are billed for penalities and your interest rate goes up.
After Bill Goes in Affect: Do you pay your credit bill on time? To bad, we are so pinched no lower interest rates, no perks and you are charged interest from the first day that you charge your card. No more 25 day grace period. You don't pay your bill on time? Well, that's alright. We'll keep your interest rate as is and no penalty fees will be assessed. Yeah, those that are paying on time are paying up for your lack of responsibility.
The above scenario is just one of many engineered by this president. Do you buy a car and make the payments on time? Well, no problem. Thanks, buddy. Your taxes are helping keep the inefficient car companies afloat. Do you buy your own house and make the payments on time? Well, no problem. Thanks, buddy. Your taxes are paying for those who don't. Do you pay for health insurance? No problem. Thanks, buddy. Your taxes are paying for a boatload more people than previous that don't pay, aren't ever going to pay, and demand that health care be provided as a "right."
The above is the bambi, first stupid liberal screw job of hard working responsible Americans. Had enough, yet?