Matthews Goes on Tear Against Term 'Homeland'

Photo of Geoffrey Dickens.
  • Bookmark and Share

Chris Matthews, on Thursday's Hardball, admonished one of his panelists, April Ryan of American Urban Radio Networks, for using the term "homeland," because "it sounds like Russia," and worried that use of that term could lead to calling the United States "motherland," and "fatherland," and "that's when we are getting imperial."

The discussion with Ryan and Chris Cillizza of the Washington Post, began with Matthews rationalizing President Obama's decision to send more troops into Afghanistan because "his administration is so stacked with people who are more hawkish than he is."

The following exchange was aired on the December 3, Hardball:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

CHRIS MATTHEWS: April, is this because his administration is so stacked with people who are more hawkish than he is? I go to Secretary of State Clinton. I go to General Jones, who is national security. I go to Gates. I go to everybody but the vice president and Rahm Emanuel, people tell me, is to the right of the President. Was he just out-voted here?

APRIL RYAN, AMERICAN URBAN RADIO NETWORKS: The bottom line is, when it all is said and done, at the end of the day, it's about protecting the homeland. I asked several people who are very close to many of those persons that you acknowledged. They said, look, everyone was with the President. Everyone is looking to protect the homeland. And that's the key issue, when all is said and done. And they feel in that area of this, of the world, that's where we have to be.

MATTHEWS: Yeah there's one of the words I hate most, by the way, homeland.

CHRIS CILLIZZA, WASHINGTON POST: I think he-

MATTHEWS: It sounds so vaguely, it sounds like Russia. It sounds like-

RYAN: To protect the US soil

MATTHEWS: No it's, no I don't...

RYAN: To protect the US of A.

MATTHEWS: ...because it`s one of those neo-con words I despise.

CILLIZZA: I do think though.

MATTHEWS: By the way, there shouldn't be any other bit of territory we do protect, except the homeland. It`s called the United States. That's what the Defense Department should be for!

RYAN: The good old US of A.

MATTHEWS: Defending the United States. You don't have to defend the homeland, the off-land islands, like we're Japan. We have some other space we defend. That's what got us into trouble in the first place.

CILLIZZA: I do think, Chris -- rhetoric aside though, rhetoric aside -- I do think the President, this is not an adviser's decision. I do think, if you follow his logic, what he has said publicly, he genuinely believes this. He said this in the Afghanistan speech. That this is the central front, that this, if we let this go, that this will create a real danger to America.

MATTHEWS: Okay next time. By the way, when we stop term, using terms, start using terms like the motherland and the fatherland, that's when we are getting imperial. Anyway, thank you, Chris Cillizza. Thank you, April. I don't think you are an imperialist. I think you get caught in that language trap!

—Geoffrey Dickens is the senior news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Outvoted?

Isn't there one vote--his? Except for that pesky old Congress. He has gotten on that homeland thing before--to say it's a side issue is to exaggerate it. I name things for a living--yes, it's stupid and jarring. Big deal, what isn't these days?

 

Proof That Tinglebell is a Nut Job!

He and his treasonous cohorts are pimping Obama, the Lenin of their movement, and yet he has a problem with the Communist terminology?

He IS a Communist!

sorry, but this clown is a bit late!

Just who and what does this idiot think the one whose butt he kisses daily is?   Look up Nazi......socialism.....maybe a light will come on "tingler"!!!

Ha ha ha -- Matthews got it so wrong!

Ha ha ha -- Matthews got it so wrong! It was the Nazis who used the term first. We brought it back a few years ago to help keep us on our toes (not like torture, though!) against those who would do us harm, that is, all those other countries out there. Russia -- ha! Without the idea of Homeland, how can we possibly have the isolation and fear we need to protect us?

Well that explains why

Well that explains why lefties hate the "Heartland". 

"DumbAssity of Dope"

Heart(land) attack

Lefties hate the heartland because they are elitist communists. They want what is good only for the majority, not for the strong people who earn it by pulling up their bootstraps through smart investments and good connections. Lefties should all move to the "Brainland" and let the rest of us live in peace in the paradise of a free-market Homeland.

UV Rae---

Unless all of your posts are done tongue-in-cheek style, or I am just completely misreading them, what you say makes me wonder if you live under a bridge somewhere.

If I am wrong, let me know how so.

If so,  I shall certainly apologize.

MD

"There is no distinctly American criminal class - except Congress."

Mark Twain (1835-1910)  

Holy Crap

Didn't we have this inane conversation when the entity was created. Is Matthews in a time warp?

UV Rae---

Why do you think we need isolation and fear to protect us?

And how does Homeland Security relate to that?

Where does (not like torture, though!) fit in?

You shootin' zingers at the Bush Administration?

Just curious.

There has been a new administration (of sorts) in D.C. for several months now.

MD

"There is no distinctly American criminal class - except Congress."

Mark Twain (1835-1910)

A pun on stressful positions

No zingers against George Bush. My "Not like torture, though" comment
was referencing the new administration I guess - since they "say" they
are different from the last administration- (same foreign policies,
same unwavering support of business as usual, and more) , but also was
a pun on the idea of staying on one's toes - which is a stress position
considered tortured by some of the "compassionate" persuasion.
We are "protected" from others by not becoming them. The only way to not be them is to draw that distinction, to insulate, isolate (strong borders and immigration laws), refuse and deny ourselves from ever being drawn into their cultural relativity morass. Otherwise, we would all just be citizens of "their world" as well. Don't you agree? It's the only way to keep what we have worked hard for, our culture and who we are as a people.

Who's Chris Matthews?

Can't we focus our attention on what is being said by people who actually earn respect in our society?

This unknown Chris Matthews guy is a waste of everybody's time.

Yeah, Chrissy, let's not

Yeah, Chrissy, let's not adopt the supposed language of totalitarian regimes, let's just implement the policies of totalitarian regimes...while we pretend to be a representative republic and a free people.

 

Tingles: "Alaska and Hawaii, you're on your own"

Same goes for you, American Samoa, Canal Zone, Guam, Midway, Marianas, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands.  

"You don't have to defend the homeland, the off-land islands, like we're Japan." Chavez would be very interested in the USVI, I think.

This has been one helluva week for Tingles, starting with the enemy camp debacle.

ryan was the reporter who...

got up in Gibbs' face yesterday about the party planner partying instead of doing her job, i.e., checking people's names off the guest list. Nice work, April. And, yes, tingle, this is land is our land, the land of the free and the home of the brave...

Playtime For Tingles

Hey Chris! You're a poor excuse for an American or a human being. Now go play in traffic!

Matthews has lost it. I expect him to fade away soon...

along with fellow hater Olbermann. They are already on the lowest rated cable net.

 

"Democrats; Breeding voters like farm animals since 1962"

I'm pretty sure I've heard

I'm pretty sure I've heard Matthews's hero use the term "homeland" before, and not just when referencing the Cabinet department with the word in its name.

crap

what do we do with the Department Of Homeland Security now?

cm5050

It'll now be:

Department of Don't Worry We're Just Like You 2nd and 3rd World Nations (No Better, We Swear!) Security.

:p 

 

"Collective"? 

"Collective"?  "Commune"?  

Since when does Tingles have anything against the Socialist Workers Paradise that once existed in Mother Russia?

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

how this

Graceland, Disneyland,Toyland, Zombieland, Carland, Futureland you gotta be careful because they could promote the use of the term the mother or fatherland.

Maybe po' liddle Chrithy doesn'th have homeland he's an alien from another world.

Matthews should do some studying before he opens his trap.  Imperialism is not Communism, Socialism or Federalism.  It is reflective of an Empire controlled by Royalty.  Oh my, King Obama and the American Empire.

Here's a fact that's worth the knowing, So treasure and mark it well.  When the mind is through with growing, the the head begins to swell.             Sir Nosmo King

When teh "Homeland"

When teh "Homeland" termology first came up I was startled by the use.  For me it brings up totolatarin societies trying to suppress its peoples; I still have problems with it but what do you use?

The mere fact that Hillary

The mere fact that Hillary Clinton is one of the most Hawkish members of this administration should tell us all we need to know

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.