On the Wednesday night edition of MSNBC's "Hardball" Chris Matthews and David Shuster continued to use the Larry Craig scandal to bury the GOP and while Matthews declared "the downfall of" Bush's party was "driven by every movement of the body politic" it was his colleague Shuster who outdid him when, after running down a litany of GOP troubles ranging from Craig to the resignation of Alberto Gonzales, charged: "It all adds moral insult to the injuries being suffered today by the victims of Hurricane Katrina."
Not only did Shuster, mock the President's return to New Orleans on the two-year anniversary of Katrina, as he noted: "The memories of an incompetent administration divorced from reality are still hard to forget," he also took umbrage with a harmless prank of Karl Rove as he concluded his long-winded rant this way:
"In Washington White House staffers unveiled that they cared about wrapping up Karl Rove's car in plastic. The prank, while perhaps funny to them, provided fresh field for critics who see a White House that is caught up in its own cozy world. The White House did offer a statement today on the Larry Craig sex scandal. A presidential spokesman expressed disappointment but refused to say whether Craig should keep his job. That means the White House is trying to stay detached from Senator Craig in much the same way the White House has tried to stay removed from the lingering Gulf Coast problems since Hurricane Katrina. I'm David Shuster for Hardball in Washington."
The following is Chris Matthews' introduction at the top of the show, followed by the entire Shuster piece as they occurred on the August 29th edition of "Hardball":
Chris Matthews: "Good evening, I'm Chris Matthews. Welcome to Hardball. Our top story, obviously, tonight President Bush resides in a political bunker. The downfall of his party driven by every movement of the body politic. Just 48 hours ago he gave up his pal, Alberto Gonzales to the political wolves. Yesterday he watched in awe as yet another warrior of the cultural right was caught in the spotlight of illegal, sexual misconduct. Misconduct, against which his party has mounted a chest-thumping, full-throated campaign, a campaign of words, that once again, has not been underwritten by actions. Even their holiest colleagues are now forced to acknowledge that the public indecency of Senator Craig has exposed the sub-prime Republican morality of those who have dared to rate themselves as culturally conservative?"
...
Matthews: "But we begin tonight with Hardball's David Shuster and his report on the tough times now facing the Grand Old Party."
David Shuster: "In the midst of a horrific week for his White House and his party, today in New Orleans, President Bush tried to show a happy face while staring at another challenge, the two year anniversary of the destruction from Katrina."
George W. Bush: "Hurricane Katrina broke through the levees, it broke a lot of hearts, it destroyed buildings but it didn't affect the spirit of a lot of citizens."
Shuster: "On that point the President is correct. Two years ago residents, stuck for days at the New Orleans convention center, were so angry at the lack of any government response that their spirited cries haunted the nation and sent the President's approval ratings tumbling. And while the White House is trying to put the focus on the ongoing recovery, thousands of Gulf Coast residents still live in FEMA trailers, large parts of New Orleans are still uninhabitable and the memories of an incompetent administration divorced from reality are still hard to forget."
Bush: "And Brownie, you're doing a heckuva job."
Shuster: "On top of the awkwardness today in remembering Katrina, the President's week began when he saw his longtime friend, Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, driven out of town over a spate of scandals."
Bush: "It's sad that we live in a time when a talented and honorable person, like Alberto Gonzales, is impeded from doing important work because his good name was dragged through the mud for political reasons."
Shuster: "The politics, however, that fueled the U.S. attorney scandal came from the White House. And few Democrats or Republicans believe, this year, that Gonzales was talented or honorable."
Alberto Gonzales: "I'm ultimately accountable and responsible for what happens within the department but that is, in essence, what I knew about the process, was not involved in seeing any memos. Was not involved in any discussions about what was going on."
Shuster: "Gonzales, eventually retracted that statement and a dozen others. But President Bush seemed oblivious."
Bush: "I haven't seen Congress say he's done anything wrong."
Shuster: "However, nearly everyone else paying attention, did, when Gonzales testified."
Sen. Arlen Specter(R): "I do not find your testimony credible, candidly."
Sen. Diane Feinstein(D): "I have never seen an attorney general so contemptuous of Congress."
Rep. Jay Inslee(D): "If you count the number of times this attorney general has refused to shoot straight with the U.S. Congress, it has to set a congressional record."
Shuster: "On Tuesday the President and his party suffered a huge embarrassment when court documents revealed that full-throated conservative Senator Larry Craig was arrested for his behavior towards another man, an undercover cop in this airport men's room."
Sen. Larry Craig: "Let me be clear. I am not gay, I never have been gay. I did nothing wrong at the Minneapolis airport."
Shuster: "The Republican blamed the Idaho media, gay groups and the police for his arrest, for his guilty plea and for not telling anybody about it for months. The problem, among others, is that the GOP campaigns as the party of family values and Senator Craig's bathroom bust underscores the hypocrisy. Never mind Craig and his old attacks on President Clinton."
Sen. Craig from 1999: "The American people already know that Bill Clinton is a bad boy, a naughty boy."
Shuster: "There is former Republican Congressman Mark Foley, who built his social life on male pages. Conservative pastor Ted Haggard, who had trysts with a male prostitute. Republican Senator David Vitter, who campaigned as a family man but later acknowledged encounters with a woman who police described as a prostitute. It all adds moral insult to the injuries being suffered today by the victims of Hurricane Katrina. But as the President was finishing his solemn speech this morning."
Bush: "We, we care deeply about the folks in this part of the world."
Shuster: "In Washington White House staffers unveiled that they cared about wrapping up Karl Rove's car in plastic. The prank, while perhaps funny to them, provided fresh field for critics who see a White House that is caught up in its own cozy world. The White House did offer a statement today on the Larry Craig sex scandal. A presidential spokesman expressed disappointment but refused to say whether Craig should keep his job. That means the White House is trying to stay detached from Senator Craig in much the same way the White House has tried to stay removed from the lingering Gulf Coast problems since Hurricane Katrina. I'm David Shuster for Hardball in Washington."
—Geoffrey Dickens is the senior news analyst at the Media Research Center.





David Shuster: "In the midst of a horrific week for his White House and his party, today in New Orleans, President Bush tried to show a happy face while staring at another challenge, the two year anniversary of the destruction from Katrina."














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Would someone please
August 29, 2007 - 18:06 ET by motherbeltWould someone please explain how the Craig incident "adds moral insult to the injuries being suffered today by the victims of Hurricane Katrina."??????????????????
I'm verklempt.
Hardball is nothing but a
August 29, 2007 - 18:19 ET by Chris NormanHardball is nothing but a playground for childish Democrats and liberal reporters. They should rename it "The Sandbox" or "The Political Playpen". I can just picture Matthews in a baby bonnet and diapers, shaking his rattle and screeching.
The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.
- Arabian Proverb
ROFLMA
August 30, 2007 - 10:48 ET by TruthMongerholy liberal leap of logic batman:)!
i hope matthews didn't pull a muscle:)
the things the DNC makes this guy try to pull of on live tv...
Didn't ya know who lives in NO!!
August 29, 2007 - 18:12 ET by PawpawNDidn't ya know that many gays reside in New Orleans and they're hurt from the fact he wasn't doing a jazz tap in the bathroom, but a waltz!!
"That means the White
August 29, 2007 - 18:08 ET by Chris Norman"That means the White House is trying to stay detached from Senator Craig in much the same way the White House has tried to stay removed from the lingering Gulf Coast problems since Hurricane Katrina"
Oh, for Pete's sake. Talk about a rickety, stretched comparison to get in an unrelated insult. Shuster is supposed to be a straight news reporter? How?
The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.
- Arabian Proverb
Good question Chris Norman
August 29, 2007 - 21:48 ET by SportPoliticsI don't believe Shuster is a straight reporter, I believe he is as queer as a 3 dollar bill.
an aside
August 30, 2007 - 02:29 ET by AjtlawyerIf the global warmists are right, why are we trying to rebuild New Orleans anyway? The city was already below sea-level and Gore says the sea level is only getting higher. You'd think the GW crowd would be railing against any effort to rebuild and repopulate the Big Easy because the whole thing is supposedly going to be underwater again by the end of the century.
And, even if GW isn't true, and I don't believe it is, not in the manner that Gore & Co. tout it to be, it seems to be stupid in any event to be trying to rebuild a city that is below sea level in a region that will, as sure as God made the State of Louisiana, be hit by another huge hurricane some day.
Old adage
August 30, 2007 - 08:02 ET by JDWLib play book mandates the advancement of deleterious issues. It was not long ago that sen Clinton was promoting the funding in order to assist illegals. Today the emphasis is not centered on building a community around business yet just the opposite.
Public assistance, both physical and monetary, has been overwhelming. Other states suffering similar problems are reconstructing and not looking back (the news media will not recognize Florida). New Orleans is now expecting funding to cover long term problems, why waste the money today?
JDW
News media: Scoreboard for terrorists
The subtle spread of lies
August 29, 2007 - 18:37 ET by SportPoliticsSchuster hits a subtly home run with this one
" ... that the public indecency of Senator Craig has exposed ...."
Well I guess he should have just said Senator Craig exposed himself in public and has pled guilty to indecent exposure. Noone hearing Schuster's commentary could think anything else, and of course that's exactly what he wants.
It's just amazing how they keep their subtle lies going, and of course most of the GOP in this case thinks exactly what Schuster wants them to, with his subtle remarks.
What?
August 29, 2007 - 18:14 ET by Felicity RandJust when you think Chrissy has reached the peak of insanity he pulls out a ladder.
Continuing to view the residents of NO as victims only prolongs their victimhood. It is disgusting that the Dims use Katrina as political hay.
Blame Game
August 29, 2007 - 18:18 ET by Daniel BakerThe Blame game that reporters play after every disaster is immoral. They act like those in authority should have the perfectness of God.
or that some unnamed and,
August 29, 2007 - 18:22 ET by Chris Normanor that some unnamed and, as yet, unelected liberal president could reach that perfection.
The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.
- Arabian Proverb
Well, Chris, you know that
August 29, 2007 - 19:10 ET by drillanwrWell, Chris, you know that had Kerry/Edwards been elected in `04, not only would Christopher Reeves have walked again ... but Kerry would have risen him from the dead ... Democrats promise everything, but deliver very little if anything.
New Orleans Own Moral Insults
August 29, 2007 - 18:20 ET by PawpawNAnything anyone did in his rant can be had in NO for free. NO was & is the moral cesspool. This is where they have huge GAY PARADE, women flash you all the time, more prostitution than in Vegas, and what you catch there doesn't stay there! They showed stats today about how much murder and other crime is up in NO after reconstruction has started. Seems Mayor Ray N{L}agin behind has not done anything to help. Anyone check the trail of the monies sent to NO & the dishonorable Mayor!! I'd love to see that!
Gay bashing?
August 29, 2007 - 18:26 ET by Mica the MagnificentWhy does Shuster refer to Senator Larry Craig as a 'full throated conservative?'
Craig claims he's not gay, but Shuster looks like he's enjoying a little gay-bashing.
Does Shuster refer to heterosexual liberal women as 'spread-legged democrats?'
Never thought I'd say this...
August 29, 2007 - 18:38 ET by c5thenDailyKOS has better and more logical thoughts on their site than Hardball just exhibited in that joke of a story. If the sourse of the story hadn't been published, I'd have bet it was from "The Onion" or a similar site.
When are Chrissy and company going to start drooling and foaming at the mouth while laughing hysterically?
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic
It all adds moral insult to
August 29, 2007 - 18:49 ET by SMGalbraithIt all adds moral insult to the injuries being suffered today by the victims of Hurricane Katrina."
This is just risible. Any resemblance to professional reporting is a coincidence.
How does an event in a Minnesota airport bathroom in June add anything - much less "moral insult" (whatever the hell that is) - to "injuries being suffered" by people who went through a hurricane? Hurricane victims and a senator soliciting sex in a airport restroom are connected?
Adds moral insult? To who? How?
What is moral insult anyway?
Furthermore (ugh), how exactly does a "moral insult" add to injuries? That makes no sense. His metaphors are so twisted and confused that the statement grammatically makes no sense.
This has to be about the most tendentious - and asinine - statement from the absurd Shuster since he was reporting on the Plame matter.
SMG
Personally, I think Chrissy
August 29, 2007 - 19:17 ET by drillanwrPersonally, I think Chrissy and Davy are turned on by the whole Craig story, and were using code-speak to communicate how hot they were to each other ...
Sorry. They walked right into that one.
Anybody have info on how Matthews (MSM) handled the whole Barney Frank and boyfriend gay prostitution in their basement scandel several years ago? Or how about the democrat Gerry Studds homosexual relationship with a young congressional page?
You think this is bad, some
August 29, 2007 - 19:18 ET by MightyMouthYou think this is bad, some dipsh*t filling in for BOR just had a liberal nutcase on and both circle jerked each other about the familiar "no leadership from Bush" rant of the left about Katrina.
I swear Fox News is getting more and more intolerable!
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
Geoffrey...I'll get you
August 29, 2007 - 20:57 ET by superconGeoffrey...I'll get you for this!How dare you post that ranting jackass on these hallowed pages.If I was ever captured by an enemy force the only way they could get me to talk would be to make me watch HardBall.The guy is an insufferable blowhard and now I'm pissed off.His little sock puppet Shuster is no better.
If the show HardBall isn't absolute proof that MSNBC doesn't give a damn about ratings or profit but exists merely as a DNC tool then I don't know what is.
Victory in Iraq.
Newt for President.
This is what a real
August 29, 2007 - 21:10 ET by MidAmericaThis is what a real sex scandal looks like.
Is it just me or does this
August 29, 2007 - 21:18 ET by jdhawkIs it just me or does this guy, Matthews, look like he is constipated and in the process of desperately trying to "pinch one off?"
Meanwhile, hasn't NBC pulled the plug on MSNBC? If so, what is Slim Ball still doing on TV? Besides this blog, did anyone ever actually watch it?
LMAO!
August 29, 2007 - 21:19 ET by drillanwrI thought the same thing about the picture ... Only maybe he's taking one for the MSNBC team ...
The real moral insult
August 29, 2007 - 21:32 ET by mlongThe real moral insult to the "Katrina Victims" was...
The Dem. Senator who diverted funds for the levees..
The Dem, Gov who wouldn't issue a evacuation order or make proper requests to the Federal Government for help...
The Dem. Mayor of N.O. who stuck his people in the Superdome even though he had a fleet of school buses that could have taken them out of harms way...
The decades of corrupt and incompetent leaders of the state and the city(Dems) who mismanage and ignored the problems...
And finally the people of N.O. themselves who put up with this type of Government for decades.
*********** John Edwards '08 ***********
"More woman than Hillary,more black than Obama!"
And finally the people of
August 30, 2007 - 16:56 ET by FlashmanLet's not forget they re-elected the same incompetent fools. Talk about your battered wife syndrome.
Alka Seltzer, please
August 29, 2007 - 22:58 ET by krismcsherryBecause of the way it's reported:
I'm tired of hearing about freakin' Katrina...ad nauseum.
From the Craig affair to "moral insult"? Talk about the exploitation of the suffering of others (the Katrina victims, not Craig).
Hardball's reporters are moral and ethical airheads.
It could be the "Moral
August 30, 2007 - 14:52 ET by BuffNBoneIt could be the "Moral Insult" stems from the possibility they had all this slam GWB stuff lined up for the Katrina 2 year anniversary and they had to preempt themselves with this other juicy titbit.
"Fighters are fun but bombers make policy"