Is it okay to vote against a candidate because of his race? The answer to the question is no. It is, in fact, the only acceptable answer. But I ask the question because it raises an important point about the media, the Democrats, and Barack Obama himself.
We are, each year, treated to national media reports on race relations in this country and they invariably discuss white America coming to terms with other races in this country. Very, very rarely does the media ever report on other races coming to terms with white America.
It is not really relevant, frankly, to point out that most black voters are going to vote in droves for Barack Obama. Regardless of his race, black voters would vote for the Democrat. But when you read about Congressman Steve Cohen's race in Tennessee's Ninth Congressional District, you really are confronted by both racism and anti-Semitism in a way we rarely think about in this country. And the media is silent. Barack Obama is silent.
Steve Cohen just might lose his re-election not because he has been ineffective in representing his district, but because he is white. And a number of black members of Congress are happy about that.
The media's attention to this race is in direct contrast to Harold Ford, Jr. in 2006. The Republican Party ran an ad in Tennessee in which a white blonde lady ends the ad saying she met Harold at the Playboy mansion. The Ford camp immediately decried the ad as racist and the media nodded their head, likewise decrying the ad as racist. In fact, the hyperbolic scream of "racism" against the ad probably helped Corker more than the ad itself by hacking off voters who saw no racism in the ad. The voters, in fact, knew it was slamming Ford for his bachelor ways, hanging out with Playboy bunnies instead of representing his district.
What is happening to Steve Cohen is real racism and there are no prominent national media stories about it. Let me be clear here: Steve Cohen and I disagree on probably 99% of all issues. The point, though, is that the national media is all too willing to run stories of racism involving Republicans and then run as fast as they can in the other direction when the racism involves not just Democrats, but reverse racism.
In 2006, Steve Cohen won Harold Ford's seat in Memphis in a bitter contested race. Cohen beat Nikki Tinker barely. During the race, Cohen hacked off black ministers for supporting gay rights legislation and opposing school prayer. But what angered people in the district more was that a black congressman could potentially be replaced by not just a white man, but a Jew too. The anti-Semitism has resurfaced this year. Black ministers (started by one who is not even in district) have passed out fliers that say "Steve Cohen and the JEWS HATE Jesus." Nikki Tinker has refused to denounce the fliers.
Last year, some black ministers caused a stir against Cohen because he supported federal hate crimes legislation that included gay rights. Robert Poindexter, one of the angered ministers, gave away the game saying, "He's not black and he can't represent me, that's just the bottom line."
In fact, Nikki Tinker's campaign is openly courting the race issue by saying the Tennessee delegation, which is all white, needs "diversity." She is finding support with black members of Congress who denied Steve Cohen membership in the Congressional Black Caucus after his 2006 victory. Stephanie Tubbs Jones (D-OH), according to Congressman Cohen, is actively helping Nikki Tinker because they are both black and female. Tubbs Jones coyly claims it is because Tinker is a sorority sister in Delta Sigma Theta, a black sorority.
But it's not just Tubbs Jones. As Chris Bodenner points out, of the 42 members of the Congressional Black Caucus, only Charlie Rangel, John Conyers, and Jesse Jackson, Jr. have been willing to support Congressman Cohen. All 42, however, signed on to Congressman Cohen's successfully passed resolution apologizing for slavery and Jim Crow laws.
And where is Barack Obama? Steve Cohen got on board early with Obama's campaign. Nikki Tinker only did after Hillary was toast. Neither campaign thinks Obama will weigh in, but why not?
In Georgia, Obama gladly taped a radio commercial for Congressman John Barrow in the 12th Congressional District. Barrow looks conservative next to Cohen. In fact, Barrow, a Blue Dog Democrat, was opposed by most left-wing organization in his primary challenge by Regina Thomas, a prominent black state senator for Savannah. Seventy percent of the ballots in the Democratic primary in Georgia-12 are generally cast by black voters; yet, Barack Obama was willing to weigh in for the white guy.
In Tennessee-9, Barack Obama has remained silent. He could, of course, practice what he preaches. He could transcend race and help the healing. Barack Obama could weigh in publicly for Steve Cohen. Barack Obama could denounce the anti-semitism and racism (and blatant sexism) being hurled toward a sitting congressman.
Barack Obama cannot say this is a matter for the voters of Tennessee. He established a precedent in Georgia in a race that had no strong racist attacks against the white incumbent Congressman.
So why be silent now? And why is the media silent? The only major national media organization to look into this issue has been the Washington Post, and then only via an online blog.
Either the media and Barack Obama really care about this issue, or they use it just as a political weapon against Republicans. The silence is deafening.
Erick Erickson is editor-in-chief of RedState.com. The preceding is cross-posted at that site here.
—Erick Erickson is the managing editor at RedState.com


















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
"He's not black and he can't represent me.
July 30, 2008 - 16:00 ET by donsalimanNow if I said Obama can't represent me because he is not white, I would be called a racist, so why can Robert Poindexter say He is not black and he can't represent me.
Double standards, you bet it is.
I then say, Robert Poindexter is a racist.
fed up
July 30, 2008 - 16:15 ET by jakotaThe Center and Right in this country are about to get feed up completely with having Obama glorified, stuffed down our throats 24/7 by the MSM and then being race baited at every turn.
It soon won't matter what stances he takes on anything, we'll just be fed up with everything Obama.
Here is more race baiting
July 31, 2008 - 05:35 ET by DontFeedTheTrollsHere is more race baiting by our favorite candidate.
D
Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.
This is just
July 31, 2008 - 09:19 ET by motherbeltThis is just outrageous.
Obama and his sycophants continue to try to get mileage out of predicting that McCain and Republicans will use race-based attacks.
This is mud-slinging by Obama, plain and simple, but you will never hear the MSM call it that. What else can you call accusing one's opponents of planning vicious attacks, without a shred of evidence that that is their intent?
Obama's theme song
Lemme get this straight
July 30, 2008 - 16:27 ET by americaneagleIs this a situation where two Democrats are bloodying each other? Because if it is, then I can understand why Obama would not want to weigh in on this issue. If Cohen is in as much trouble as you are asserting, then why would Obama want to link himself to a sinking ship in Tennessee 9? Taping a commercial for a Democrat against a Republican is what he should be doing, in order to create a coattails effect for the Democrat; but it doesn't profit his campaign anything to take sides in a Democrat vs. Democrat fight.
As for the idea that race shouldn't be the reason to vote for or against anyone, I say who cares? I don't give a rip why anyone chooses to vote for Candidate A over Candidate S...all that matters is how many votes are cast for each candidate in the end!
Finally, why are you surprised that the Congressional Black Caucus didn't admit a white politician to their ranks? Heck, JC Watts was black and he couldn't get in!
Seriously though, I think that the idea that Barack Obama would ever inject himself into this race is crazy, since he gets nothing from it. If he supports the white guy, he pisses off the black voters in the district and if he openly supports the black lady he gets linked with the percieved racism of her other supporters. The best political course for Obama is to stay out of it, since it doesn't really concern him.
Geee. your so wise.I guess
July 30, 2008 - 19:31 ET by obxrayGeee. your so wise.I guess its good to have no principles.
Umm..Okay...
July 30, 2008 - 19:48 ET by americaneagleFirst, that should be "YOU'RE", not "your". I thought they cleared that up in about 1st grade...but maybe I was wrong.
And what do my personal principles have to do with anything? I never said anything that shed any light on my principles, I just commented on how the Obama camp probably sees things. And like I said, jumping into a Democrat vs. Democrat fight (if that is what it is) doesn't get anything accomplished for Obama. He is not going to wade into this fight, because he isn't going to get any good press out of it. Obama is running for the office of President, not Democratic Referee and trying to straighten this mess out only obscures what he's striving for. And honestly, how many big time politicians are creatures of principle? Nearly every one of them will support a cause they do not beleve in if they think it will bring them more votes and more power.
But hey, if casting aspersions on my principles, or alleged lack thereof, makes you feel better...knock yourself out!
Tanks fur coricting mee
July 30, 2008 - 20:34 ET by obxrayTanks fur coricting mee jeniuss..uh i wuz reffuring two de politishshuns precebuls.sawe i difinet yu.
First off, I'm replying to
July 30, 2008 - 20:21 ET by Indiana JoeFirst off, I'm replying to this post, rather than your later one, to address the points you raise. But, I think the other poster was maybe talking about Obama's lack of principles, since your defense of him is based purely on political expediency. Also, insulting someone over a slight (and sadly common) grammar mistake doesn't do much to make you look good, or, for that matter, principled.
Now, then: Obama is supposed to be the candidate that "transcends" race. This is a perfect opportunity for him to put his money where his mouth is. If nothing else, it shouldn't be too much to expect him to decry the racism and anti-semitism being displayed in this race. As mentioned, he's already become involved in another congressional race, so the argument that "he doesn't have a dog in this fight" really doesn't wash. He can keep his head down, and play it safe, but that basically gives the lie to his "different kind of politician" disguise.
And Cohen represents a majority black district. Is the CBC in business to pursue laws that are helpful to blacks? Don't they want input from black constituents? Or are they just a black version of a "good-ole-boys" club? If the former, then a representative of those black constituents should be welcome. If the latter, then they're just like the old "whites-only" country clubs, not exactly a comparison of which to be proud.
As to whether you care if an election is decided on the basis of race; if you can't see a problem with that, how "divisive" that is, how much it goes against modern sensibilities, how wrong it is for whites not to vote for a black man (and the automatic assumption that it must be for racist reasons), and you still think that voting based on race is okay... well, I guess I can't explain it to you.
But surely you understand the term "double-standard."
Thank you Indiana Joe .
July 30, 2008 - 20:39 ET by obxrayThank you Indiana Joe .
Good points, Indy.... I
July 31, 2008 - 09:24 ET by motherbeltGood points, Indy....
I think americaneagle would have a different perspective if he/she thought that people were not voting for Obama because he is black.
While the results of the election would be the same, I'm sure americaneagle would be in high dudgeon over what it said about our country.
Obama's theme song
Obama
July 30, 2008 - 17:01 ET by iveseenitallEvery time Obama speaks about "race" in America it is in dergatory terms about whites. He, as most other negroes, believes that blacks continue to be victims, no matter what is done for them. He just made a speech in which he implied as much about all "minorities". He and his wife have been totally indoctrinated in "liberal"/socialist pap concerning this matter. Never will they admit to reverse racism. And most other colored people will not admit to it either. Nonetheless, it exists. It has become institutionalized through Affirmative Action Programs, from which the Obamas have benefitted. But taking from one to give to another causes resentment, of which there is now plenty among whites. Futhermore, many negroes are not only anti-white, they are virulently anti-gay. They are what the libs would term "racists" and "homophobes". Interesting.These factors play into the Cohen situation..
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
I haven't seen McCain
July 30, 2008 - 16:30 ET by Biff McCainI haven't seen McCain denounce Rush Limbaugh's playing of the racist song "Barack the Magic Negro."
He played it 20 times one week; I don't know how the FCC allowed such a hate filled song.
Then you wander why a listener shot up a church filled with people he was taught to hate.
I know how to win wars!
Still clinging to that last
July 30, 2008 - 17:04 ET by ckc1227Still clinging to that last brain cell I see.
That again?
July 30, 2008 - 17:06 ET by americaneagleFor the 7,599,616th time: Barack The Magic Negro was a phrase coined by a black liberal columnist for the LA Times. Rush Limbaugh picked up on it and had Paul Shanklin do a delicioulsy funny satirical song that actually mocked Al Sharpron and his envy of Obama's position on the political scene. There is nothing "racist" about the parody...unless the word Negro has suddenly morphed into one of the "Unspeakable Words" now.
Please, let this lame excuse for an argument or moral equivalence go, and get something new, okay? This dog just won't hunt!
Howdy ae.... Biffy's
July 30, 2008 - 17:11 ET by bigtimerHowdy ae....
Biffy's doing his job and trolling, he knows very well the info. you posted.
I saw his post earlier and hoped nobody would respond....
Although at times it is hard not to...I myself have done so more than once or twice...lol.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Shanklin and Limbaugh are racist
July 30, 2008 - 17:44 ET by Biff McCainLA Times explained the term, Limbaugh's Shanklin used it in a racist
way -- no different than using the "n' word because Mark Twain used it.
Shanklin and Limbaugh are racist, Twain and the LA Times are not.
I know how to win wars!
...and you biffy are one
July 30, 2008 - 17:47 ET by bigtimer...and you Biffy are one twisted cookie.
Now go get a nice glass of milk and dip yourself.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Oh, I get it....having
July 30, 2008 - 18:48 ET by motherbeltOh, I get it....having Sharpton call Obama a Negro is what makes it racist.
Thanks for clearing that up, Biff.
Obama's theme song
That is not a racist song.
July 30, 2008 - 17:55 ET by mostlymoderateThat is not a racist song. If you look to history, we used to prefer calling African American's "colored". Then, the NAACP demanded they be called "negro". Then they changed it to "black". Then they changed it to "person of color". Then they changed it to "African American". Next week it will be something else.
The "Kings color" will be
July 30, 2008 - 18:56 ET by Clear thinkerThe "Kings color" will be next.
45 Communist Goals for America http://www.nationmakers.com/com_goals.htm
Oh yeah, Biff
July 30, 2008 - 17:11 ET by americaneagleWe conservatives don't "wander" about other people's actions, but we do W-O-N-D-E-R about them! And just for clarification: did the shooter in Knoxville blame a teacher for shooting up a church full of people he didn't really know? Is that a new part of the NEA's approved curriculum..."How to murder innocents"? Oh wait, they already support that with their unwavering support of "abortion rights."
I haven't seen McCain
July 30, 2008 - 19:33 ET by obxrayI haven't seen McCain denounce Rush Limbaugh's playing of the racist song "Barack the Magic Negro."YOU BIG DUFFIS.Rush was mocking the LA TIMES.....Stupid fool!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have never owned slaves
July 30, 2008 - 16:31 ET by bigpapaor denied anyone anything based on their race or gender.
Yet I KNOW that I am EVIL and represent all that is wrong with this country.
I am a white male.
.NOBAMA 08 !!!
Racist word
July 30, 2008 - 16:48 ET by iveseenitallBut I'll bet you've used the "N" word, you, you...white male. Jail time for you, buddy.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
In my view, the deep racism
July 30, 2008 - 16:43 ET by mattmIn my view, the deep racism which exists within the Black community is an outgrowth of their association with the Democratic Party.
By entrusting their fate to the Jim Crow Democrats and the government programs they push, rather than relying on their own initiative, blacks (like any other people who place themselves under the power of others) have become new slaves of new masters who require only their vote, in exchange for government largesse.
To continue receiving this largesse, they had to continue identifying themselves by the color of their skin rather than by the content of their character, thereby making it easy to become racist in their thinking.
WOW!!
July 30, 2008 - 16:54 ET by MrShyMattm, really perfectly said! I need to store this post somewhere. Eloquent and spot-on. Especially the last paragraph...
"To continue receiving this largesse, they had to continue identifying themselves by the color of their skin rather than by the content of their character, thereby making it easy to become racist in their thinking."
Nice!
* * * SOCKS THE CAT '08 * * *
For REAL Change
Decades
July 30, 2008 - 16:58 ET by iveseenitallRight on,Mattm. Since the 60's the educational system, the media. and the government have been indoctrinating both whites and blacks about real or imagined "racism". And they continue to divide rather than unite America on this issue. The "liberals" want to see America fail in its war on racism, just as they want America to fail in Iraq. It's disgusting, but it's their bread and butter.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
In my view, the deep
July 30, 2008 - 18:16 ET by general companyIn my view, the deep racism which exists within the Black community is an outgrowth of their association with the Democratic Party.
In a lot of repects I think you are correct, coupled with all peoples being more comforteable with their peers. Everyone is some kinda racist, I hate Alabama football players, wellwhen they beat LSU I do. : ]
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
In my view, the deep
July 30, 2008 - 18:17 ET by general companyIn my view, the deep racism which exists within the Black community is an outgrowth of their association with the Democratic Party.
In a lot of repects I think you are correct, coupled with all peoples being more comforteable with their peers. Everyone is somekinda racist, I hate Alabama football players, well when they beat LSU I do. : ]
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
I agree, matt. And Mr.
July 30, 2008 - 18:54 ET by motherbeltI agree, matt.
And Mr. Erikson, the only thing I disagree with you on is your use of the term "reverse racism."
IMO, there is only racism. No "reverse." Blacks looking down on whites, or defending others just because they are black is racism, period. How about black racism agains Hispanics? or Asians? Is that "reverse" racism?
All racism is equally abhorrent.
Obama's theme song
"During the race, Cohen
July 30, 2008 - 17:07 ET by ckc1227"During the race, Cohen hacked off black ministers for supporting gay rights legislation"
Yet I bet these same black ministers are behind Obama 100% despite his own support of gay rights legislation.
The Democrats, liberals and
July 30, 2008 - 17:51 ET by mostlymoderateThe Democrats, liberals and the mainstream media have turned being BLACK into a political issue. In fact, they have turned being black into a special-interest issue. That is only ONE of the reasons I refuse to vote for a guy like Barack Obama. If Barack was a republican and he wasn't treated like the "golden child" then I might vote for him.
Yep... I just heard at
July 30, 2008 - 17:57 ET by bigtimerYep...
I just heard at the very end of Matthews show with the Barnicle in the seat a black gal, I cannot think of her name, she is a regular now and then on msnbc...say that Obama is the first african american to run for President...
Nobody corrected her...nobody.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
That is hilarious!! (and sad
July 30, 2008 - 17:59 ET by mostlymoderateThat is hilarious!! (and sad at the same time).
mm..Yeah, it is....on
July 30, 2008 - 18:04 ET by bigtimermm..
Yeah, it is....on the other hand I do think the silence or non-correction was or had to be purposely...you can't tell me not one person on that panel, there were about four and Barnicle...didn't notice that...they all cannot be that simple....
..can they?
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
If they are blinded by
July 30, 2008 - 18:09 ET by mostlymoderateIf they are blinded by Obama-Fever then they COULD be that simple. Reminds me of the kool-aid effect.
I'm sure Nancy Pelosi is
July 30, 2008 - 19:14 ET by Jack BauerI'm sure Nancy Pelosi is already working on the Voting Fairness Doctrine Machine.
It's a elxtronic device that is attached to every voting machine.
What it does is read a person's "brainwaves" and if it detects "racism" within the voters decision on which candidate to vote for, that persons' vote will be constitutionally invalidated.
Of course, it is an "affirmative action" device so certain groups are excluded from scrutiny.
Hell folks, you can only take this democracy thing so far.
Jack... Yep... Why
July 30, 2008 - 19:20 ET by bigtimerJack...
Yep...
Why don't you know by now, hasn't it been breaking news on T.V. yet?
Nancy Pelosi is the new sheriff in town...why the Fearless Leader Reid announced as such on the Senate floor this morning!
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Double standard on race-based voting
July 30, 2008 - 20:10 ET by Dagny TaggartI would like to point out that there is no such thing as "reverse racism". To use such a term means acceptance of the outrageous lie that whites are racist, and no-one else is.
Racism is racism, no matter who is doing the hating.
The exact reason I hated the
July 30, 2008 - 20:27 ET by Indiana JoeThe exact reason I hated the term "compassionate conservative" from the moment I heard it. It implies a "different" conservative from most (i.e., "uncompassionate").
Agreed, Danny....I
July 31, 2008 - 09:30 ET by motherbeltAgreed, Danny....I commented the same above. There is only racism. The example I used was: would black racism against Hispanics or Asians be called "reverse racism" or is it simply racism?
Obama's theme song
>>>It is not really
July 30, 2008 - 23:06 ET by seanrobins>>>It is not really relevant, frankly, to point out that most black voters are going to vote in droves for Barack Obama. Regardless of his race, black voters would vote for the Democrat
Ahhh, but you employing a bit of sleight of hand here. You try and distract us from the unspoken "because he is black" by stating that blacks would have voted for BHO anyway "because he is Democrat"
But this does not eliminate the unspoken "because he is black" for several reasons:
First, Obama's candidacy is all about his being black. His candidacy screams "I am black" day in and day out. The most frequently used descriptor for Obama is "black" (or occasionally African-American). He is the first "black" candidate.
Second, the "because he is Democrat" is meaningless in the context of the Democrat primary season. Hillary was a Democrat, but that did not suffice to get the approbation of 97 or so percent of the black Democrat primary votes. African-Americans voted for BHO rather than Hillary - no same person could dispute - because he was Black. Not because he was a good candidate. Not because he had good positions on issues. Not because of what he has done or accomplished throughout his career. (We know - or knew - about none of that) It was "because he was black"
Relevant: Yes. Because if it is acceptable to vote FOR someone because they are black, it is and should be acceptable to determine how to counteract that "impulse" Because, voting for someone BECAUSE they are Black (or Latino, or white, or female, and so on) and only because they are Black, is and should be unacceptable.
Finally, one more observation. When someone votes for Obama solely BECAUSE he is Black (leave out the Democrat "because"), means that that person is NOT voting for John McCain, at least to a similar degree, because McCain is WHITE.
Is this now acceptable?
sean robins
blog.seanrobins.com
"...Congressman Cohen's
July 31, 2008 - 05:54 ET by Killgrave"...Congressman Cohen's successfully passed resolution apologizing for slavery and Jim Crow laws."
I know this post is addressing a blatant double-standard, but the above item really frosts me.
I'm actually 100% in favor of this Cohen guy getting railroaded by black racism. I can't imagine any more "poetic justice" than that. It's very similar to white female liberals who are now getting squeezed out of academia because of skin color quotas.
Karma's a b*tch, ain't it?
"some say" 90% of blacks
July 31, 2008 - 08:49 ET by athoughtor2"some say" 90% of blacks are going to vote for Obama....no problem... but 70% of whites are voting for McCain....they are labled as racisits....
Obama keeps saying in his speeches that the republicans will tell you I don't look like the other presidents....they will do this and say that to scare you about me. But they haven't. so who is envoking race into this election?
the only thing they have said about him is in regards to his lack of experience, his flip flops on key issues and his voting record. I have not seen one mention that said "oh by the way he's 1/2 black, so don't vote him."
Obama's bus
July 31, 2008 - 09:05 ET by Cool ArrowWhole lot of people kicking around under Obama's bus, aren't there?
Ludicris and Jeremiah are down there writing some new rhymes
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
I don't think Ludicris is
July 31, 2008 - 09:36 ET by athoughtor2I don't think Ludicris is quite there yet...I think he has at least 2 more strikes before Obama will acually throw him under....
Hannity pegged this last night, the only 2 minutes i watched. a dem strategist said Obama should denounce Ludicris for political expedience b/c it will be a distraction to the campaign...Hannity said he should denounce it out of principle and morals. it should be denounced b/c it's just plain wrong.
The only way Obama can
July 31, 2008 - 09:32 ET by motherbeltThe only way Obama can score points on the "racism" issue is to accuse them of planning racist attacks in the future, since he can't point to a single racist attack that has occurred.
Unlike his snide jabs at McCain's age.
Obama's theme song